Considering Immunotherapy for My Mom’s Liver Cancer: A Tough Decision
My mother, aged 60, has been diagnosed with primary biliary cholangitis (PBC) and has endured cirrhosis for the past decade. Two years ago, she was identified with hepatocellular carcinoma. Initially, she received ablation treatments until a solitary metastasis was detected in her lung last October, which was successfully surgically removed. While there have been no further metastases since that surgery, her tumor markers have remained elevated, leading her oncologist to prescribe Sorafenib, a tyrosine kinase inhibitor. Unfortunately, despite three months of this treatment, her liver tumor has continued to expand. The next potential avenue of treatment proposed is immunotherapy. At first, her doctor expressed concerns regarding her eligibility for this approach due to the fact that her cirrhosis stems from an autoimmune condition, which increases the risk of developing hepatitis in response to immunotherapy. Given that immunotherapy may be her only remaining option, we are contemplating this course of action. However, I find myself uncertain about the best path forward. Should we allow the cancer to progress when her liver function is severely compromised, even though she manages to carry out her daily activities? Or should we proceed with immunotherapy, despite the risk of rapid deterioration due to fulminant hepatitis that may arise, potentially shortening her life even more than the cancer could?
Answers (1)
2/12/2026, 12:31:53 AM
OpenHealth AI
This is indeed a difficult situation for your mother and your family. It's understandable to feel uncertain when faced with tough decisions about cancer treatment, particularly considering her complicated medical history. Let's break down the situation and explore your options.
Key Points
- Current Health Status: Your mother has primary biliary cholangitis, cirrhosis, and a history of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Although she has managed daily activities, her liver function is compromised.
- Current Treatment: Sorafenib has not been effective as her liver tumor continues to progress.
- Immunotherapy Risks vs. Benefits: Immunotherapy could potentially help combat the cancer, but it carries risks due to her cirrhosis and autoimmune background.
Explanation
Your mother's situation involves balancing the risks and benefits of potential treatments. Since her current treatment isn't working, and there’s a risk of cancer progression, exploring immunotherapy could be a valid option. However, her underlying liver condition increases the potential for adverse reactions, including hepatitis, which can negatively impact her quality of life and overall survival.
Next Steps
-
Discuss with Oncologist: Arrange a thorough meeting with her oncologist to discuss the likelihood of success with immunotherapy given her liver condition. Ask about alternative treatments or clinical trials that may be available and more suitable for her situation.
-
Evaluate Liver Function: Ensure that her liver function is closely monitored through tests like liver function tests (LFTs) or imaging studies. Understanding her current liver status is critical for weighing treatment options.
-
Seek a Second Opinion: Consider consulting another specialist, particularly at a comprehensive cancer center, which can offer fresh insights and treatment alternatives.
-
Holistic Support: Explore supportive measures, including nutritional support and palliative care options, to manage her symptoms and maintain her quality of life while you make this decision.
-
Family Discussion: Bring the family together to discuss your mother's wishes and preferences regarding her treatment and overall goals of care.
-
Document Concerns: Keep a record of her symptoms, treatment responses, and any side effects, which can provide valuable information during consultations.
By taking these steps systematically, you can better navigate this challenging decision-making process for your mother's care while ensuring that her needs and preferences are at the forefront.
Related Questions
Seeking Clarity on My Health Issues
I’m feeling increasingly frustrated as my doctor hasn’t returned my messages regarding my test results. Recently, I was admitted to the hospital due to a puzzling fever that persisted for 15 days, along with symptoms including severe fatigue, rashes on my arms and legs, increased liver function tests, and elevated inflammatory markers. I also experienced blood and protein in my urine, along with mesenteric lymphadenopathy. Despite extensive testing, all analyses from the rheumatology department came back negative, and blood cultures revealed no growth. My complete blood count (CBC) was normal, and there were no bacteria found in my urine. The results I finally received are as follows: - Positive result for Cytomegalovirus (CMV) - Positive Hepatitis B IgM antibody (which is confusing because my previous tests just one day prior were negative, and I have consistently tested negative before this) - Hepatitis B antigen is negative - Both Hepatitis B e antigen and antibody are negative - Hepatitis B DNA was not detected So, what does this all mean? Is the CMV infection the cause of my illness, or could Hepatitis B be playing a role, and could it be a false positive? I am still feeling awful and am in need of help. **Details:** - Age: 30 - Gender: Female - Height: 5'2" - Weight: 175 lbs - Ethnicity: White - Duration of symptoms: 4 weeks - Location: Kentucky - Current medications: None - Previous medical history: Gallbladder removed one year ago.
Concerned About Rabies Symptoms
Hello, I'm an 18-year-old guy feeling quite anxious about the possibility of rabies. Around nine months ago, I had a startling encounter with a bat on my front porch when returning from track practice. I distinctly recall that I don’t believe I was bitten or scratched, but the sudden scare had me worried. I came across information suggesting that sometimes bite or scratch marks may go unnoticed, which contributed to my anxiety regarding rabies for several weeks after the incident. As time passed, I managed to push the worry aside; however, this past week, after a significant interval, I've started experiencing debilitating headaches in the back of my head and neck, along with occasional disorientation. I also learned that rabies symptoms can sometimes take almost a year to manifest, heightening my fears. Although the headaches aren’t persistent and mainly occur at night, I had recently dealt with flu-like symptoms, which could be the real cause of my discomfort. I tend to struggle with anxiety over my health, and the idea of dying from something seemingly trivial overwhelms me. I wanted to reach out to the Reddit community to see if my current experiences might indicate the onset of rabies and whether I should be genuinely concerned. Thank you for your time. P.S. I don’t typically suffer from headaches, which is why their sudden appearance has me particularly alarmed. They are mild and dull in nature. To the best of my knowledge, I’m not experiencing any other symptoms associated with rabies.
Understanding Heterogeneous Regions in the Placenta
Greetings! I’m a 38-year-old woman with a past experience of losing a pregnancy at 24 weeks due to chronic placental abruption stemming from an infection. I currently have a cerclage placed and am thrilled to share that I’m pregnant again. During my latest check-up at 14 weeks, the medical team expressed some concerns about a specific area in my placenta, describing it as heterogeneous. This region measures roughly 4 cm by 2 cm by 1 cm. Has anyone encountered something similar? Initially, I suspected it might be a subchorionic hematoma when the ultrasound technician was evaluating it, but the maternal-fetal medicine specialist referred to it as a "heterogeneous area in my placenta." The information I’ve found online has left me quite anxious. I have plenty of images if that would be beneficial for context. Your insights would be much appreciated!
Inquiry About Proctitis Treatment
I'm a 37-year-old male, standing at 5'5", currently undergoing treatment with mesalamine 1000 mg in suppository form. I was recently diagnosed with proctitis a few weeks back. Since starting the mesalamine, my bleeding has ceased, which is certainly a positive development. However, I've noticed that some days my condition seems to worsen, accompanied by symptoms such as brain fog and abdominal discomfort. Should I continue with the mesalamine for another month despite these fluctuations, or is there a risk that the bleeding could return if I discontinue too soon?
Understanding Alpha Gal Syndrome
Could I be experiencing Alpha Gal Syndrome? Previous tests have confirmed I do not carry allergies to Alpha Gal, beef, or pork. However, I do have a class 3 allergy to tomatoes, along with class 1 sensitivities to both milk and lamb. My allergist suggested that it’s possible to have Alpha Gal and still test negative for it. Is this a legitimate concern? Additionally, I deal with Autonomic Dysfunction, and for the past year, I have experienced spontaneous hives and episodes of flushing. Last year, I underwent tests in May and August after a tick bite in May, and both results indicated negativity for the allergies in question. I am a 27-year-old woman weighing 142 pounds.