Understanding the Concept of 'Relative Rest' for Injuries
Profile: 31F, 5'6", 130 lbs - active athlete Currently managing pain with Advil and Tylenol as needed, and although I have been prescribed Flexiril for muscle spasms and sleep, I am opting not to take it. Two weeks ago, I experienced a recurrence of my rotator cuff injury on my dominant arm. After visiting a walk-in orthopedic clinic, the doctor recommended that I minimize movement of my shoulder and scheduled me for an MRI; I’m just awaiting a follow-up appointment next week. Fortunately, the initial MRI results did not indicate any tears. The MRI findings mentioned "bursal surface tendinosis in the supraspinatus tendon at its insertion." My initial injury, which dates back to May 2025, occurred in a car accident when a taxi rolled towards me, prompting a desperate attempt to push it away. At that time, the injury was initially diagnosed as bicep tendinitis, and physical therapy did not yield successful results. Now, I am eager to understand what relative rest actually entails in practical terms. During the mornings, I experience no pain when at rest, but gentle movements are moderately uncomfortable, rating about 2 out of 10 on the pain scale. Lifting a gallon of milk, reaching overhead, or performing repetitive actions—such as washing my other armpit—exacerbate the pain to about 5 or 6 out of 10, though this discomfort lessens after 5 to 10 minutes. My shoulder, arm, and hand are persistently uncomfortable, to the extent that it disrupts my sleep unless I am exceptionally cautious throughout the day. For context, when I broke my back a few years ago, I rated that pain at an 8 out of 10 while in tears. As an equestrian athlete managing my own farm, I typically engage in 2 to 4 hours of physical labor daily, which involves lifting and carrying heavy objects as well as various repetitive actions. At present, however, I am unable to partake in those activities. Thanks for taking the time to read my situation!
Answers (1)
2/6/2026, 8:40:50 PM
OpenHealth AI
Thank you for sharing the details of your situation. It sounds like you’re managing a challenging rotator cuff injury while trying to remain active, which can be tough. Let’s break down the concept of 'relative rest' and how it can help with your recovery.
Main Points:
- Relative rest means to modify activities rather than completely stop them, allowing your shoulder to heal while still maintaining some movement.
- Pain management and avoiding activities that exacerbate your symptoms are key to this process.
Explanation: Relative rest doesn’t mean bed rest, but rather finding a balance in your activities to help alleviate pain and encourage healing. Since gentle movement causes only mild discomfort (2/10), keeping your shoulder mobile within a pain-free range can actually be beneficial. The goal is to avoid anything that might worsen your pain (like heavy lifting or repetitive overhead movements) while still engaging in light, non-painful activities.
Given your specific situation with the rotator cuff and the MRI findings, it's essential to prioritize activities that do not cause significant strain on your shoulder. Here’s how you can approach 'relative rest':
-
Identify Pain-Free Movements: Start by identifying movements that do not pain and maintain those as part of your daily routine. This might include gentle stretching or isometric exercises (like holding your arm in a position without moving it actively) to maintain strength without strain.
-
Modify Daily Activities: Since lifting heavy objects aggravates your symptoms, try to find alternative methods to manage tasks like lifting or carrying to reduce strain on your shoulder. For example, consider using a scoop or a lift assist for heavy items rather than lifting them directly.
-
Incorporate Gentle Exercise: While waiting for your follow-up appointment, consider gentle, low-impact exercises that don’t put strain on your shoulder, such as walking or using a stationary bike, which can help maintain your fitness level without aggravating your injury.
-
Time Management for Rest: To accommodate your condition, plan your activities that involve light physical labor when you’re feeling your best during the day, followed by periods of rest afterward. Use heat or ice as needed to manage discomfort after activities.
-
Monitor Your Progress: Keep track of what movements improve or worsen your symptoms. This will help you identify strategies that work best for your recovery.
Next Steps:
- Implement light range-of-motion exercises and gradually integrate low-impact activities.
- Modify daily tasks to reduce strain on your shoulder.
- Use pain management techniques such as ice or heat therapy appropriately.
- Maintain flexibility by adjusting your physical labor activities around your shoulder's comfort levels.
- Prepare to discuss your observations and any escalating concerns at your upcoming follow-up appointment.
It's great that you're taking proactive steps in your recovery. Listening to your body and adjusting your activities accordingly can lead to better outcomes while you await your next medical evaluation. If you have questions or need further clarification, feel free to ask!
Related Questions
Hard Lump Below Adam's Apple: Seeking Insights
A 33-year-old male has discovered a firm bump located just beneath his Adam's Apple. After consulting a physician, he underwent an ultrasound examination. The results indicated no abnormalities in the thyroid and did not reveal any nodules. However, the ultrasound did identify a benign lymph node in level II, which could be swollen due to an illness that he is currently experiencing. He first noticed this lump a week prior and describes its texture as similar to cartilage. He wonders whether this protrusion could be displaced cartilage that he's detecting, possibly from the thyroid cartilage, as it seems misaligned from the center line of his neck.
Concerns About My 15-Month-Old Daughter's Bowed Legs
I have a 15-month-old daughter who weighs 10 kg and has recently started walking. However, she walks with a noticeable bowing of her legs. While I've been informed that this condition is common and often resolves itself over time, a family friend who is a physician suggested that we might want to seek advice from a specialist. Given our financial constraints, I would appreciate guidance on whether it's truly necessary to consult a specialist regarding this issue.
Struggling with Kidney Stones and Waiting for Surgery
I’m a 33-year-old woman, standing at 5 feet 5 inches and weighing around 200 pounds. On December 23rd, I experienced an episode of excruciating pain that was completely unprecedented for me. It culminated in a bout of vomiting, after which the pain surprisingly subsided. Given the intensity of my discomfort, I made the decision to visit the emergency room. After examination, it was revealed that a 9mm stone was blocking one of my kidneys, leading to a urinary infection. I was hospitalized for three days, during which I received intravenous antibiotics. They performed a minor procedure to insert a kidney stent, and I was informed that they intended to break down the stone, but that procedure did not take place. Fast forward to the present; I still have that same stent in place. I have been on a prolonged waiting list for surgery to eliminate both the stent and the stone. During this waiting period, I tested positive for a urinary tract infection and was prescribed various antibiotics. Unfortunately, the infection keeps recurring despite urine tests, prompting my urologist to recommend levofloxacin. I am quite anxious about the potential side effects of levofloxacin. Additionally, it seems my surgeon is postponing my stone removal and instead opting just to change the stents. Throughout this ordeal, I have been in excruciating pain, severely impacting my work and overall quality of life. I often find myself spending time in the bathroom, struggling to urinate, or crying from the relentless pain. I rarely leave the house aside from work due to my constant need for a bathroom. Nights are particularly difficult, as sleeping is nearly impossible because of the discomfort caused by the stent and the never-ending urge to go. I feel lost and overwhelmed, and I seriously doubt I can endure this situation for two more months without significant relief.
Persistent White Spots on Tonsils: Seeking Insights
A 24-year-old female, currently using the contraceptive pill Lo Loestrin Fe, maintains a regimen of various vitamins and supplements. These include vitamin D, Elderberry, a multivitamin containing iron to address mild anemia, and a vaginal probiotic. She abstains from alcohol and tobacco. Lately, she has been experiencing recurring white spots on her tonsils. These occurrences started in May 2025 and have resurfaced in November 2025, followed by another bout in January 2026 and again in February 2026. Prior to May 2025, she had never encountered this issue. Despite undergoing tests for mononucleosis, strep throat, COVID-19, and several sexually transmitted infections, all results have returned negative. Medical professionals have suggested that the condition is likely viral in nature. Typically, she does not experience significant symptoms aside from a mild sore throat. She is now seeking possible explanations or insights into her condition.
Persistent Pain in the Neck and Shoulder Region
Hello, I'm a 35-year-old woman dealing with persistent pain in my neck and right shoulder since 2015. I experience two distinct types of discomfort: 1. An intense, sharp pain that strikes suddenly on the outer part of my shoulder. This pain is debilitating; I can't grip anything when it occurs, and I must tense my muscles and apply firm pressure to the area to alleviate it. 2. A dull ache that radiates from the right side of my neck down through my bicep and into my wrist. This discomfort can linger for several days. While ibuprofen offers some relief, it's not very effective. During severe episodes, I find it hard to concentrate, often relegating myself to bed. The sensation can be likened to hot water cascading over my skin. Interestingly, I dislocated my shoulder when I was five, though my parents can't recall which side, and my medical records don't clarify it. I notice that these pain episodes tend to arise under specific circumstances: 1. At the start of my menstrual period, 2. Mid-cycle during ovulation, 3. Following intense emotional moments, like crying. In the past, I experienced periods where the discomfort vanished: 1. While using the progesterone-only contraceptive pill, 2. Throughout my pregnancy and for several months afterward, 3. For a couple of years in between, although I'm uncertain about the cause. After consulting a pain specialist, I underwent an x-ray and MRI, which showed no abnormalities. He suggested that I might have thoracic outlet syndrome and prescribed nortriptyline, which significantly reduced my pain. However, I halted the medication during my pregnancy, and now the discomfort is reemerging. I have concerns about the compatibility of nortriptyline with venlafaxine, which I am currently taking. I'm feeling uncertain about whether thoracic outlet syndrome is indeed the correct diagnosis or if there are alternative explanations. The relationship between my symptoms and hormonal as well as emotional triggers adds to my confusion. I'd prefer to find a permanent solution rather than rely on pain medication for the long term. Thank you for any insights you can provide!