Persistent Pain in the Neck and Shoulder Region
Hello, I'm a 35-year-old woman dealing with persistent pain in my neck and right shoulder since 2015. I experience two distinct types of discomfort: 1. An intense, sharp pain that strikes suddenly on the outer part of my shoulder. This pain is debilitating; I can't grip anything when it occurs, and I must tense my muscles and apply firm pressure to the area to alleviate it. 2. A dull ache that radiates from the right side of my neck down through my bicep and into my wrist. This discomfort can linger for several days. While ibuprofen offers some relief, it's not very effective. During severe episodes, I find it hard to concentrate, often relegating myself to bed. The sensation can be likened to hot water cascading over my skin. Interestingly, I dislocated my shoulder when I was five, though my parents can't recall which side, and my medical records don't clarify it. I notice that these pain episodes tend to arise under specific circumstances: 1. At the start of my menstrual period, 2. Mid-cycle during ovulation, 3. Following intense emotional moments, like crying. In the past, I experienced periods where the discomfort vanished: 1. While using the progesterone-only contraceptive pill, 2. Throughout my pregnancy and for several months afterward, 3. For a couple of years in between, although I'm uncertain about the cause. After consulting a pain specialist, I underwent an x-ray and MRI, which showed no abnormalities. He suggested that I might have thoracic outlet syndrome and prescribed nortriptyline, which significantly reduced my pain. However, I halted the medication during my pregnancy, and now the discomfort is reemerging. I have concerns about the compatibility of nortriptyline with venlafaxine, which I am currently taking. I'm feeling uncertain about whether thoracic outlet syndrome is indeed the correct diagnosis or if there are alternative explanations. The relationship between my symptoms and hormonal as well as emotional triggers adds to my confusion. I'd prefer to find a permanent solution rather than rely on pain medication for the long term. Thank you for any insights you can provide!
Answers (1)
2/6/2026, 10:20:46 PM
OpenHealth AI
Thank you for sharing your experience with persistent neck and shoulder pain. Your symptoms are understandably distressing, especially given their impact on your daily life. Based on the details you've provided, it seems that you are dealing with a complex situation where both physical and hormonal/emotional factors may be contributing to your discomfort.
Summary of the Main Points:
- You experience sharp, debilitating pain and a dull ache with various triggers including hormonal changes and emotional stress.
- Previous medical assessments indicated no structural abnormalities, and a potential diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome was considered.
- You've found temporary relief with nortriptyline, but have concerns about medication compatibility and prefer a long-term solution.
Explanation:
Your experience aligns with common patterns seen in cases of thoracic outlet syndrome, where nerves or blood vessels are compressed, often leading to pain, numbness, or muscle weakness in the arms and shoulders. The sharp pain you describe may also reflect nerve irritation. The connection to hormonal changes is particularly interesting; hormonal fluctuations can indeed influence pain perception and muscle tension.
Next Steps:
Here are prioritized actions you can take to help manage and potentially alleviate your symptoms:
-
Monitor and Document Symptoms:
- Keep a symptom diary to track pain intensity, triggers (e.g., menstrual cycle, emotional stress), and any relief measures. This can help identify patterns and inform potential management strategies.
-
Explore Hormonal Management:
- Since your symptoms improved with hormonal contraceptives, consider discussing this aspect with your healthcare provider. They can assess if a different hormonal regimen might be beneficial for you now.
-
Explore Non-Pharmacological Therapies:
- Engage in physical therapy that focuses on strengthening and stretching the neck and shoulder muscles. A therapist can provide you with tailored exercises to alleviate discomfort and improve posture.
- Consider mindfulness practices or cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) to help manage emotional triggers. These techniques can help reduce tension and thus potentially decrease pain episodes.
-
Discuss Medication Options with a Healthcare Provider:
- Consult your doctor regarding the compatibility of nortriptyline and venlafaxine, and if it is safe to resume nortriptyline. There might be other medication options that address pain with fewer side effects or concerns.
-
Evaluate Daily Habits:
- Take breaks during activities that strain your neck and shoulders, maintain good ergonomic positions when working, and practice stress-reduction techniques such as deep breathing or yoga.
By focusing on these steps, you can create a comprehensive approach to managing your pain that takes into account both physical and emotional aspects. It's crucial to feel empowered in your care journey, so please continue to communicate with your healthcare providers about what works and what doesn’t. Let me know if you have further questions!
Related Questions
Gastrointestinal Illness
I am a 44-year-old woman managing high blood pressure, for which I take metoprolol and lisinopril. Last Friday, January 23, my son fell ill at school, suffering for approximately two days. Subsequently, on the following Monday, my husband experienced severe diarrhea and stomach cramps, although he didn’t experience any vomiting. Early Tuesday morning, just after 12:30 AM, I became ill as well, dealing with diarrhea, stomach cramps, and vomiting. We were optimistic that we had overcome the illness. However, on February 3, my mother-in-law visited and stayed overnight. Unfortunately, she developed diarrhea and vomiting the next day. Given that more than ten days have passed since our initial illness, what are the chances that she has contracted the same virus from us? Additionally, is there a risk that we could be reinfected by her? Any insights from those who can advise would be greatly appreciated by this exhausted wife and mother.
Experiencing Neck Discomfort, Joint Sounds, and Numbness in Limbs While Running
I’m a 28-year-old weighing 150 pounds, and I've been dealing with a mild cervical hernia located between the C6 and C7 vertebrae, along with some arthritis and bone spurs. Next week, I am scheduled for an MRI, and I also have a follow-up appointment with a neurosurgeon. This all began about a year and a half ago during a metal concert, where I shook my head vigorously. Just two days later, I noticed significant soreness and discomfort in my neck, which has since been accompanied by a distinct crepitus—a wet crunching sound—each time I move my head. Ignoring it has proven quite challenging. Initially, my condition seemed to stabilize; however, during a recent exam period that required extensive studying, my neck began to feel hot and painful. I did my best to cope, but concentrating on math without referencing the paper was impossible. The second bout of discomfort was notably worse. I found myself studying intensely and under considerable stress. For the most part, my neck felt "okay," but I began experiencing rapid numbness and tingling in the arm I rested on, waking up twice with a completely dead arm. Just as I finished my exams, the situation deteriorated. I had also taken part in a sports test where I needed to run at speeds of up to 14 kph, and I didn't encounter any problems at the time. However, just two days after the running test, I went for another run and experienced tingling and numbness in both arms. It felt like I lost all sensation in my skin. Subsequently, after driving for an hour, I noticed that both my arms and legs were tingling symmetrically for a significant portion of the drive. Currently, I find it difficult to attend classes and concentrate due to the discomfort. My neck feels inflamed, and resting my arm leads to more tingling. I can’t comfortably look down at my tablet, so I’ve adjusted its angle, but I still feel heat and soreness—not quite pain, though. Driving has become unpleasant since turning my head causes my neck to heat up, but it remains a necessity. During the day, my limbs tend to start tingling quite easily. I’ve found that shifting my arms and legs, or changing my neck position, alleviates the sensation. Surprisingly, walking does not cause any issues. What do you think might be going on with me? Is there a chance for recovery? What questions should I consider asking during my neurosurgery consultation? Thank you for your assistance!
Stabilization Procedure for a Highly Mobile Shoulder
A 17-year-old female weighing 230 pounds is sharing her experience. I have been diagnosed with classical Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, which means I experience hypermobility throughout my body, but my shoulders are particularly affected. My right shoulder frequently dislocates, often triggered by simple actions such as turning over in bed or reaching for something. When it happens, I typically manage to relocate it myself, despite the pain and tears, holding off on seeking medical attention out of concern for burdening the healthcare professionals. Eventually, though, I do go for an X-ray. In my last X-ray, the results showed that my shoulder was still subluxated and causing me a significant amount of discomfort. However, as the week progressed, I noticed some improvement. During my visit to the trauma surgery specialist, he mentioned that he would typically recommend stabilization surgery. Nevertheless, he expressed concern that due to my condition, I might simply ‘bend through’ the surgical repairs, leading to further dislocations. This marks my fourth incident of dislocation, and I'm desperate to avoid future occurrences. Has anyone had success with this type of surgery for patients with EDS, or is it likely to be ineffective? I appreciate any insights.
Understanding My Recent Experience with Hearing Semitones
At 30 years old, I've recently encountered an unusual auditory phenomenon, rooted in a sinus infection that has disrupted the pressure in my ears. This situation is entirely new to me. Rather than the usual singular 'ding' sound from an elevator or my automobile, I now perceive a combination of 3 to 4 semitones layered together. When I listen to music, the tonal key seems to shift dramatically based on which ear is nearer to the speaker, and even conversations have taken on this layered sound quality. I expect that once my sinus issues subside, this peculiar experience will diminish. However, I find myself curious about the underlying physiological processes at play here. Is it merely a matter of pressure affecting my hearing?
Years of Daily Testicular Pain, ‘Normal’ Tests, and a Surgical Discovery
I feel compelled to share my journey in the hope that it may resonate with someone else out there, especially since I endured severe pain for eight long years that baffled numerous doctors. For almost a decade, I struggled with excruciating pain on the left side of my testicle, in my groin, and across my lower abdomen, which afflicted me every single day. This was not simply mild discomfort; rather, it was intense, debilitating pain that struck in relentless episodes lasting between one to three hours. During these episodes, I found myself completely incapacitated. I would wriggle on the floor, attempting every possible position—lying straight, flipping upside down, resting on the couch, or even standing—desperately searching for any relief. I was often drenched in sweat, trembling, and occasionally in tears. At 37, I assure you, I am not one for dramatics, but the severity of this pain was overwhelming; when an attack occurred, my daily life came to a halt. The impact of this pain wasn’t merely physical; it robbed me of significant aspects of life. It led to: - Job loss - A disrupted intimate life - Strained relationships - Difficulty in everyday planning Living with such unpredictable and incapacitating pain for eight years weighed heavily on me—both physically and mentally. As a single male, I frequently had to face this ordeal in solitude, whether I was at work, grocery shopping, or even during a shower. The pain could strike at any moment, and I had no means to predict or control it. The pain typically escalated over five to ten minutes, peaking with a sensation that felt like waves or rolling. It was frequently triggered by: - Urinating - Bowel movements or straining - Sexual arousal - Intercourse or post-ejaculation - Even a minor sip of alcohol would set it off (prompting me to abstain from drinking for eight years). Yet, at times, it would occur for no apparent reason. Even the less intense flare-ups were still profoundly painful. There was no level where I felt I could manage it adequately. For years, I relied on over-the-counter pain relief like Tylenol and ibuprofen, often consuming more than what is safe, yet they offered limited relief. The pain wouldn’t subside because of medications but would diminish on its own after a couple of hours, only to return again, day after day. I underwent multiple ER visits and countless consultations, yet ultrasounds and various tests consistently returned with results indicating everything was “normal.” The absence of any visible issue often led to me being dismissed. I could sense that some healthcare providers believed I was either exaggerating my symptoms or seeking drugs. After enduring this for years, it takes a toll on your mental state—even when the pain is very real. One persistent issue was the abnormal sensation in my left testicle; it often felt out of place, frequently riding high and retracting into my groin. However, each time, my concerns were trivialized. Finally, a urologist was willing to perform a surgical exploration after spotting a small lesion on the ultrasound that might have been linked to my pain. Even then, doubts lingered regarding the source of my affliction. During the procedure, they uncovered what imaging tests had failed to reveal: a thick, fibrotic structure that had become abnormally enlarged, extending from the epididymis towards the inguinal canal—likely the vas deferens. It was significantly thicker than normal and felt unusually rigid. The surgeon was so surprised by the findings that they called in a colleague for a second opinion. About 4 cm of this abnormal tissue was excised alongside a portion of the epididymis, ensuring the testicle was preserved. The lumen was open, indicating this was not a form of cancer or a blockage, but rather severely abnormal scar tissue. At that moment, everything fell into place: - The episodes of intense pain - The pain triggered by urination, straining, and ejaculation - The recurrent nature of the pain lasting 1 to 3 hours - The issue with the high-riding testicle - The repeated failure of ultrasounds and MRIs to identify the problem This was primarily a mechanical issue rather than one detectable by standard imaging techniques. Just returning home from surgery, I feel an overwhelming sense of relief now that I finally have a concrete explanation after enduring years of debilitating pain. I am not exaggerating or imagining things; there was indeed something wrong physically. I had felt voiceless and dismissed by those who never experienced this suffering firsthand. If you are battling significant testicular pain that manifests in severe episodes—especially when correlated with urination, movement, or ejaculation—and diagnostic testing continues to yield normal results, don’t lose hope. My experiences and subsequent diagnosis may provide you with insight. This applies to anyone grappling with chronic pain that feels real yet continues to be overlooked. Seek out information on less common potential causes. Insist on alternative examinations. Be your own advocate. Over those eight years, I had nearly ten ultrasounds and two MRIs, all labeled as “normal.” Sometimes, a problem cannot be detected through imaging. Sometimes, it remains undiscovered until someone is willing to take a deeper look. The eight years lost to this struggle can never be regained, but I can move forward with the understanding of how much resilience it took to endure and with optimism that recovery is within reach. I genuinely hope this message finds someone in need of encouragement; I wouldn’t wish this experience on anyone. You are not alone, and there is light at the end of the tunnel. Never lose hope.