Choosing Between Physical Therapy and Chiropractic Care
Just over a year ago, at the age of 17, I suffered a spinal injury in a car accident. Unfortunately, my parents insisted that I refrain from going to the hospital, and since I was underage, I couldn't arrange a medical appointment myself. Recently, two months ago, I managed to get an X-ray of my back. The results indicated that everything looked normal. However, I'm reluctant to pursue physical therapy if it's unlikely to provide any benefits, especially since my schedule is already packed with work and school commitments. Despite this, the doctors are insisting I undergo a few weeks of physical therapy before considering alternative options. My lower back remains in persistent discomfort, and I frequently notice bruising along my spine. I'm desperate for a solution to alleviate this pain, as I don’t know how much longer I can endure it.
Answers (1)
2/4/2026, 11:10:36 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel overwhelmed given your history and ongoing discomfort. Physical therapy and chiropractic care can both support recovery following a spinal injury, but your situation requires careful consideration. Here’s a breakdown to help you navigate your options:
Main Points
- Physical Therapy (PT) is often recommended after a spinal injury to strengthen muscles, improve flexibility, and enhance function.
- While the X-ray is normal, your persistent pain and bruising might indicate soft tissue issues which PT can address.
- Chiropractors often focus on spinal alignment and may offer symptomatic relief, but it’s essential to weigh both options carefully.
Explanation
Your X-ray results are reassuring, indicating no fractures or serious structural issues in the spine. However, persistent discomfort suggests other underlying problems, such as muscle strain or ligament issues that PT is particularly designed to address. Physical therapy aims to restore strength and motion, which can help reduce pain over time. Skipping it may lead to further complications or prolonged discomfort.
Next Steps
-
Consider a Physical Therapy Assessment: Since your doctors recommend it, they see potential benefits. Initial consultations often focus on creating a tailored plan that fits your busy schedule, with sessions that may be shorter or less frequent.
-
Document Your Symptoms: Keep a journal of your pain levels, location, and activities that worsen or improve your discomfort. This information is valuable for your PT and could help fine-tune your treatment.
-
Self-Care Measures: In the interim, practice gentle stretching (like seated forward bends or knee-to-chest stretches) and apply heat or cold packs to your lower back to alleviate discomfort. Avoid any heavy lifting or strenuous activities.
-
Explore Time Management Options: If scheduling is a concern, speak to your physical therapist about what times could work best for you, or see if telehealth options are available for some sessions.
-
Assess Chiropractic Care: If you still have concerns about PT, research local chiropractors and read reviews. If you go this route, ensure they are aware of your injury history to avoid unnecessary complications.
By prioritizing physical therapy along with self-care, you may find significant relief and improve your quality of life. Your wellbeing is paramount, so stay proactive in seeking the best solutions for your pain.
Related Questions
Squeaky Breathing Concern
I’m a 22-year-old woman with no known physical conditions, although I am diagnosed with anxiety and take 20 mg of Prozac for that. I also use melatonin at night to help me sleep and have occasionally smoked marijuana—about five times in the past six months, and not at all in the last month since this issue emerged. For the past month, I’ve been experiencing a peculiar creaking noise when I take a deep breath, originating from the lower part of my rib cage on the right side, near the center of my chest. It seems to coincide with my breathing, as I can also hear it in my throat when I recline. While it feels like the source is lower in my chest rather than my throat, it’s not painful, though I get a sensation of air that might not be where it should be. It’s challenging to describe, but I do feel something accompanying the squeaky noise. This sound isn’t constant; I mainly notice it in the evenings and primarily when I take a deep breath. Interestingly, taking a hot shower seems to alleviate it, and it becomes more pronounced when I lie on that side but improves when I switch to the other side. I visited urgent care about a week after it started, where a chest X-ray was performed, and the results were normal, which hasn’t eased my anxiety about the situation. Additionally, I have some mild discomfort in my ribs on that side; however, it may be related to stress or poor posture. There was a moment last night when the discomfort surfaced briefly, and the squeaking noise stopped for a few minutes before resuming. Other than this, I haven’t experienced any additional symptoms—no cough, shortness of breath, or difficulty in breathing. The discomfort I felt was minor and fleeting, and I haven’t noticed it since. However, I do feel like I may be hearing the noise more frequently, which could also be a result of my anxiety—if it is more frequent, it’s not by much. My next doctor’s appointment isn’t for another three weeks, and I would appreciate some reassurance that this isn’t indicative of a serious issue. I’m not very active on Reddit, so I’m unsure about the protocol, but I could share a video of the noise to aid in understanding if that would be beneficial. Thank you for your help!
Discomfort in My Right Leg When Extending After Rest
Hello, I'm a teenage boy experiencing discomfort in my right leg whenever I stretch it out after lying down for an extended period. Following this pain, I notice a popping sound, similar to cracking knuckles, which eventually alleviates the discomfort. However, this situation is becoming quite bothersome, and I'm finding it difficult to move my leg side to side. If anyone has insights or reasons for this issue, I would be grateful for your suggestions.
Intense Discomfort along the Lower Rib Area of the Back
Hello, I'm an 18-year-old female currently on medication for mental health issues, including depression and anxiety, as well as sleep aids. I'm not on any treatment specifically for physical ailments. Last night, while I was sitting against the wall of my bed, I began experiencing discomfort on my left side, right along the lower ribs. On a pain scale, I would rate it between a 5 and 6. The sensation feels deep and only mildly increases with pressure when I push down firmly on it. Although the discomfort persisted until I fell asleep, it gradually improved to around a 3 or 4. Upon waking this morning, the pain had completely vanished. However, after getting up and moving around a bit, it resurfaced, returning to a 5-6 level. If I take a deep breath, the pain escalates to a 7 or 8. I’ve tried applying ice, but it hasn’t provided any relief. Unfortunately, this afternoon, the discomfort continues to linger without any decrease. I haven't experienced any falls or any accidents that would have impacted that particular area of my body. What steps should I take next?
Concerned About Ongoing Symptoms Despite Normal Test Results
For the past fortnight, I've been experiencing episodes of dizziness and an irregular heartbeat, and as a 17-year-old assigned female at birth, it's been concerning enough to prompt three visits to the emergency room. Each time, I've sought clarity on whether I might be facing a serious health issue, yet so far, all tests have yielded normal results. I've undergone a series of evaluations, including blood and urine analyses, a chest x-ray, an ultrasound, and several ECGs, and each time, the conclusions have indicated that everything appears to be functioning well, with no evidence of blood clots or nutrient deficiencies. Just yesterday, I found myself anxiously contemplating the possibility of a heart attack, as I started to feel breathless and experienced tightness in my chest. Although I'm unsure if the breathlessness is related to my issues—since my mother recently developed a cough and has been feeling a bit wheezy—my return to the ER again showed no abnormalities. My concerns tilt towards a potential neurological issue; however, both my mom and one of the medical professionals assured me that it’s likely nothing serious, as previous tests would have revealed any critical problems. Despite their reassurances, I can't shake the feeling that further investigation might be warranted, just to be certain. This ongoing uncertainty has left me feeling increasingly frustrated and disheartened, especially given the lack of definitive answers. Is it really conceivable that my symptoms aren’t indicative of anything severe? I feel isolated in my worry as if I'm the only one contemplating the possibility that something might be wrong, and I would appreciate some reassurance—either confirming that I ought to pursue more tests or the comfort of knowing that waiting, as advised by the doctors, is acceptable and that I may just be overthinking my health.
Seeking Help for a Muscle Injury After Vomiting
Hello everyone, I'm a 30-year-old woman weighing 135 pounds. It may sound bizarre, but about five weeks ago, I experienced some harsh vomiting and subsequently spent around ten minutes trying to clear my nose. During this entire episode, I somehow managed to cause a significant injury to myself. The pain manifests as a prominent knot that runs vertically from deep within the lower part of my left shoulder blade all the way down to beneath my bottom left rib. Every time I laugh, twist my body, or cough, it triggers an intense spasm. This discomfort radiates from the affected area throughout my left ribcage and even to the front side of my left torso. I visited a walk-in clinic where they performed X-rays, which thankfully revealed no fractures, and provided me with muscle relaxants about four weeks ago. Initially, I experienced some improvement. However, recently, I found myself back at square one after twisting awkwardly while getting out of bed a few days ago, which escalated the pain to an unbearable level of 20 out of 10. I returned to the clinic today, received another prescription for muscle relaxants, and I have scheduled my earliest appointment with a chiropractor next Wednesday, as that was the most convenient and affordable option I could find. I’m reaching out for any advice or suggestions, as I'm open to hearing from anyone who has experienced something similar. Currently, I apply heat to the area three to four times a day and do some light stretching. A friend has also been massaging the painful area, which provides me with brief relief, but the situation is still quite distressing. I’m feeling quite down about the whole thing as I’m unable to go to work, and I risk losing all the progress I’ve made with one wrong movement. I would greatly appreciate any tips or insights to help me manage until my pain can be further evaluated. Thank you in advance for your support!