8-Year-Old Experiencing Eardrum Perforation Following Tube Removal
Greetings, Reddit medical community, I am reaching out regarding our 8-year-old daughter, who had her ear tubes extracted about six months ago after being inserted for a year. During the removal, one tube dislodged on its own, while the other required intervention from an ENT specialist. Unfortunately, the removal of the second tube resulted in a perforation of her eardrum. We were advised to monitor the situation to see if the eardrum would self-repair. However, after a period of six months, there has been no significant healing. The ENT presented us with a few choices: 1. We can continue to observe for another six months to see if natural healing occurs. 2. A surgical option exists to patch the perforation using cartilage grafted from the ear. The ENT recommends waiting until she turns 9, as this would allow the Eustachian tube to grow and develop further. Proceeding with this now carries a risk of the graft failing, given her current age. 3. Another possibility is to use a paper patch, which only requires local anesthesia. We inquired about the feasibility of performing this under general anesthesia due to her age, but the ENT expressed a preference for the graft method in that case (option 2). At this point, we are inclined to wait for another six months while continuing to monitor her condition. Alternatively, we considered the paper patch with general anesthesia, but it seems that our ENT does not support this approach. Currently, she exhibits no symptoms such as drainage, discomfort, or hearing loss. What recommendations do you have? Has anyone experienced a similar situation with their child? Thank you for your insights!
Answers (1)
8/7/2025, 11:50:45 PM
OpenHealth AI
Thank you for sharing your daughter's situation regarding her eardrum perforation. It’s understandable to seek clarity and support during this challenging time. Here's a summary and some helpful recommendations based on your description:
Key Points:
- Your daughter has had a perforated eardrum without significant healing after six months.
- You have options to either wait, pursue surgical options later, or consider a paper patch.
- Currently, she exhibits no distress or hearing issues.
Explanation:
A perforated eardrum can result from various factors, including trauma, infections, or in this case, post-tubing complications. Generally, small perforations often heal on their own, but larger or persistent ones can require intervention. The absence of symptoms like drainage or hearing loss is promising, suggesting her body is coping well.
Next Steps:
-
Continue Monitoring: Since the ENT suggested observation and your daughter displays no symptoms, it's reasonable to continue monitoring for the next six months. Maintain regular check-ups to assess any changes.
-
Symptom Diary: Keep a log of any changes in her condition, such as any new symptoms (e.g., pain, drainage, changes in hearing) over the next few months. This information can be valuable for future discussions with your ENT.
-
Open Communication with the ENT: If choosing to wait, express any concerns you may have about this approach, and discuss clear criteria for when to consider more proactive intervention (like increasing symptoms or persistent lack of healing).
-
Educate About the Options: As your daughter approaches 9, start discussing the potential benefits and risks of the surgical graft option as well as the paper patch method, to ensure you’re prepared for that decision.
-
Get a Second Opinion: If you feel uncertain or would like to explore the paper patching option further, considering another ENT consult may provide additional perspectives.
It’s completely natural to want the best for your daughter. Trust in the process while being proactive about her care will help you navigate this situation effectively. If you have more questions or concerns as you go, feel free to reach out.
Related Questions
Unexplained Symptoms Over the Past Few Years
Greetings, Around three years ago, I started to experience a variety of symptoms that appeared quite abruptly. They seemed to improve briefly, only to return later. This initial onset threw me into a panic, leading me to suspect something severe, like cancer. After consulting my physician, I underwent tests through a neurologist and had multiple lab analyses, yet no definitive diagnosis emerged. Frustrated by the ongoing uncertainty, I ceased my attempts to find answers and have not revisited the doctor for these issues in years. This situation dates back to approximately 2021, coinciding with my time as a nursing student. While I can't be sure if there's a connection, it was around this period that I contracted COVID-19 for the first time and also received my annual flu shot as part of my nursing curriculum. Additionally, I was treated for melanoma during this time, undergoing a Mohs procedure to eliminate it, which was part of the initial anxiety surrounding my symptoms. Below are the symptoms I’ve documented: The first change I noticed was an unrelenting muscle fatigue. Simple tasks such as carrying groceries or working outdoors left me feeling immensely winded. I began to realize that the muscles in my neck felt excessively weak, and my arms and legs, although still functional, felt distinctly weaker than before. Although I could still perform my usual activities, I often felt unsteady, especially when descending stairs. Shortly thereafter, I began suffering from frequent muscle cramps at night and persistent twitching in my muscles during the day, particularly in my legs. I also observed involuntary movements in the inner arches of my feet, which, while somewhat common, were consistently present and unusual for me. Another concerning symptom was the onset of intermittent blurred vision. This issue varies in intensity, making it particularly troublesome during episodes that seem to flare up, often exacerbated by bright lighting, like that from screens or sunlight streaming through open windows. I found myself increasing the font size on screens and printed material because reading became quite challenging. While I haven’t seen an eye care professional yet, the suddenness of these vision problems caught me off guard. Additionally, I observed a significant size disparity between the muscles in my arms; my left arm appeared noticeably bulkier than my right. As a left-handed individual, I had never paid much attention to this before, though it’s possible it’s been like this for some time. The most perplexing symptom, one that’s been difficult to research, involves my right shoulder area. The deltoid region developed an odd squishy sensation. This prompts me to mention the flu and COVID-19 vaccinations. I’ve found no information on this symptom, and inquiries yield little guidance. Initially, it felt as if a lump had developed beneath my deltoid. Gradually, the entire area became squishy, resembling fibrous, lumpy tissue rather than muscle. In contrast, when I flex my left arm, it feels muscular and firm, whereas the right arm feels substantially softer. This strange condition raises questions—could a flaw in the vaccine administration by classmate healthcare students have contributed to this issue, or is it related to my other unexplained symptoms? As for medical evaluations, my Basic Metabolic Panel and Magnesium levels were unremarkable, as was my Complete Blood Count. Further inflammatory markers including CRP, CK, and ESR all returned normal results. My hemoglobin A1c was towards the high end of normal but did not classify as pre-diabetic. Autoimmune tests yielded no significant findings, and a nerve conduction study did not reveal any abnormal results either. The results from an EMG suggested mild increased insertional activity in several tested muscles, though it was deemed possibly normal, yet it might indicate an EMG disease. Unfortunately, I was unable to undergo MRI imaging due to insurance challenges at that time. I am a 42-year-old male with no significant past medical history beyond the prior melanoma and not currently using medication, aside from over-the-counter Benadryl for sleep issues. Apologies for the detailed narrative, but I felt this could be a valuable forum for seeking perspectives. I appreciate your time. It’s important to clarify that I am not prone to hypochondria; prior to these developments, I rarely sought medical care and, oddly enough, didn’t even have a primary care provider when these symptoms began.
Young Plumber with Herniated Discs Seeks Guidance
Greetings, medical professionals. I am a 17-year-old plumber who has dedicated the past two years to this trade, beginning when I was just 15. About two years ago, I was involved in a car accident that led to the discovery of three herniated discs: one located in my upper back, while the other two are situated in the mid to lower back region. While it's possible that these injuries stemmed from the accident, I suspect they might not be entirely related. Interestingly, disc problems seem to be common in my family. I'm concerned about my prospects moving forward. What can I expect in terms of health as I age, especially regarding these injuries? Moreover, how can I prevent a situation where I may struggle with mobility in my 50s or 60s? For some time, my pain subsided, but recently, I've started to experience discomfort again in the mid to lower back area, reminiscent of what I felt initially. Any advice or insights would be greatly appreciated!
Inquiry Regarding FDG-PET Scan Findings
I recently underwent an FDG-PET/CT scan for my brain to investigate some cognitive difficulties I've been experiencing. Although the report is now available on My Chart, my follow-up appointment with the doctor is scheduled for three weeks from now. I have a query regarding the standard deviation scale presented in the report, which lists values from -2 to -4.6. What does the lowest value signify? Is the scale graded on a 1-5, 1-10, or perhaps 1-100 basis? I appreciate your assistance with this! Notable regions noted for decreased metabolic activity include: - Left Inferior frontal gyrus, triangularis: SD "4.6" - Left Heschl gyrus: SD "3.8" - Left Superior temporal gyrus: SD "3.6" - Left Middle temporal gyrus: SD "3.4" - Left Supramarginal gyrus: SD "2.6" - Left Inferior parietal lobule, supramarginal area: SD "2.1" Other areas displaying low metabolism are: - Right Superior frontal gyrus, medial: SD "3.2" - Left Superior frontal gyrus, medial: SD "2.2"
Unexplained Left Chest Pain, Electric-Like Jabs in Lower Back, and Unusual Headaches
Hi there, I’m a 15-year-old experiencing some peculiar health issues lately. A visit to my doctor led to a diagnosis of anxiety and poor posture after I complained about headaches and strange, electric sensations rising through my head. However, after that appointment, I became aware of pain in my heart and strange discomfort in my left chest accompanied by difficulty breathing. Initially, I thought these symptoms aligned with anxiety, but they persisted long enough to cause concern. To rule out any serious conditions, I underwent a blood test, which fortunately came back normal. Despite the positive results, I continued to feel unusual pains in my heart region and a peculiar ache in my lower abdomen. The doctor had previously mentioned my poor posture and identified an issue with my occipital nerve, which I’ve somewhat addressed. Now, though, I find myself having intermittent back pain and brief discomfort just beneath my left lung. These pains are indeed strange; they don’t always last long, sometimes just fading after five seconds or they might stick around for several minutes. I tend to spend a lot of time in bed and don’t often leave the house, yet when I do, these pains still occur. Thankfully, they aren’t debilitating, but I can't help but feel anxious thinking something might be significantly wrong with my health. It’s unsettling and I’d prefer not to dwell on such thoughts. To summarize: I experience chest pain in my lower left quadrant, specifically near my lung, alongside a mild but uncomfortable sensation that waxes and wanes. Additionally, I suffer from headaches located on the upper left side of my head. I apologize for any grammatical errors as I used voice-to-text for this message. Another detail that might be relevant is that I have recently quit vaping, now almost 22 days ago, and I wonder if this could be part of the recovery process.
Expectorated Large Tissue with Blood
At 28 years old, I experienced a fever the previous night, after which I had no other cold symptoms. To my surprise, today I coughed just once and expelled a significant piece of tissue mixed with blood. Following this alarming incident, I sought medical attention at an urgent care facility because I developed a headache immediately afterward and felt a peculiar "butterfly" sensation in my chest. The healthcare professionals did not conduct any laboratory tests or imaging studies, instead opting to prescribe antibiotics for what they suspected might be an infection. Is this an appropriate response to my situation? This is quite concerning.