Seeking Insights on My Dad's Cancer Claims
Greetings, In brief: I have doubts regarding my father’s claim of having "Stage 4 medullary renal carcinoma," especially considering the demographic and genetic factors associated with this specific cancer. I am a 40-year-old woman with a father in his 60s who exhibits narcissistic tendencies and has a history of estrangement from our family. I’d like to know if any oncologists could provide insight into whether my dad might be lying or embellishing details about his condition. For years, he and I have lived apart—over 15 years without visiting home. A persistent problem with substance abuse has characterized his behavior for as long as I can remember. He is known for being a pathological liar, often fabricating stories and living in his own fabricated reality without hesitation. About a year ago, his sister contacted me through Facebook, claiming he requested her to keep his condition confidential. However, she felt compelled to share that he has been diagnosed with kidney cancer. This revelation opened up a dialogue between my father and me, but extracting any detailed information from him has proven to be exceptionally challenging. Eventually, I managed to confirm his diagnosis as "Stage 4 medullary renal carcinoma." Upon researching, I've found that this cancer is extremely rare in Caucasian males of his age, predominantly impacting younger Black males with a sickle cell trait—a condition he does not possess. Furthermore, the prognosis for this type of cancer is notoriously grim, yet it has been about 16 months since I learned about his diagnosis, which seems inconsistent with the typical progression. As an individual currently experiencing my second remission from two hematological cancers—chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) and acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL)—I find myself feeling torn. My personal experience with rare cancers makes me more empathetic to his situation, yet it also heightens my sensitivity to the possibility that he may be manipulating the truth. This internal conflict is consuming me. I feel compelled to uncover the truth but am at a loss on how to proceed. There is certainly more to this narrative, but my request is simple: any guidance on how to discern the reality behind his claims would be greatly appreciated. I am willing to engage with his tactics if necessary just to gain clarification. I’m aware of the implications of privacy laws such as HIPAA, but the thought of my father potentially fabricating this illness—and targeting me of all people—is particularly distressing. It feels like a mockery of my own experiences with cancer, and I can't fully express just how troubling it is to question his authenticity. Thank you for your assistance.
Answers (1)
7/30/2025, 6:02:34 AM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you’re navigating a very complex situation regarding your father's cancer claims while also dealing with your own experiences with cancer. It's completely understandable to feel distressed and conflicted in this situation. Here are some key points to consider and steps you can take to seek clarity:
Main Points
- Understanding the Cancer: Medullary renal carcinoma is indeed a rare kidney cancer, which is more common in certain demographics.
- Assessing Truthfulness: Your father's history of manipulation and your own experiences may lead to skepticism about his claims.
- Seeking Clarity: There are ways to discern the truth without compromising your own emotional health.
Explanation
Medullary renal carcinoma is primarily diagnosed in younger Black males, making your father's diagnosis somewhat atypical for his demographic. His prognosis and the duration since diagnosis also raise questions since this cancer usually leads to rapid decline. Given his history of substance abuse and dishonesty, it is reasonable to approach his claims with caution.
Next Steps
-
Keep Communications Open: Continue engaging with your father, focusing on empathy but also gently probing for specifics about his condition. Ask open-ended questions about his treatment and symptoms.
-
Document Everything: Write down the conversations you have with him. This could help you track inconsistencies or patterns in his stories.
-
Consider Professional Support: If possible, involve a healthcare professional who specializes in oncology or even a mental health professional to discuss your concerns about both the medical aspects of his condition and your emotional responses.
-
Set Boundaries: Protect your mental health by recognizing when discussions become too stressful. It’s okay to step back if you start feeling overwhelmed.
-
Educate Yourself: Continue researching medullary renal carcinoma to further inform your discussions and questions with him.
-
Seek Support for Yourself: Given your own battles with cancer, consider speaking to a support group or a therapist to help process your feelings about both your health and your father's claims.
Remember, you are not alone in this situation, and seeking clarity is a commendable step. Prioritize your emotional well-being as you navigate these challenging dynamics.
Related Questions
Hernia Diagnosis Without Follow-Up: A Conflicting Situation
A 22-year-old male recently visited the emergency room due to discomfort in his lower abdomen. Upon examination, the medical team was indecisive about whether he was experiencing an oblique muscle problem or a hernia. Surprisingly, they opted against performing a CT scan or ultrasound and did not schedule any follow-up appointments. To the best of my knowledge, hernias typically do not resolve themselves with merely the use of ace bandages or over-the-counter pain medication; surgical intervention is usually necessary for proper treatment. Is there a specific rationale behind their reluctance to pursue further diagnostic testing or surgery?
Unexplained Episodes of Abdominal Discomfort
Age: 28 Gender: Female Weight: 194 lbs Height: 5’7" Current Medications: Vitamin D, Fish Oil, B Complex Vitamins, Birth Control Pills, Vyvanse 30 mg Health Background: Asthma, Eczema, Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD) Since August 2025, I've experienced three occurrences of intense abdominal discomfort that necessitated visits to the emergency room for pain management. These episodes usually strike at night, escalating to unbearable levels within around 30 minutes. None of the sitting positions seem to provide relief, and gastrointestinal medications have proven largely ineffective. Only strong pain relievers seem to alleviate the suffering. After the peak of the pain subsides, my abdomen remains sensitive for more than three days. I can accurately identify the location of the discomfort, which appears to be between the midepigastric area and near the gallbladder. The pain is difficult to articulate, yet it presents as a severe burning and aching sensation. Interestingly, there does not seem to be any specific food intake related to these pain episodes. I underwent an H. Pylori breath test that returned negative results. Additionally, I had an esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD). Although the biopsies were also negative for H. Pylori, they did reveal residual liquid in my stomach and a small section of intestinal metaplasia. My complete blood count (CBC) and comprehensive metabolic panel (CMP) results were normal, except for elevated LDL levels, which I’m already aware of. My gastroenterologist has recommended a gastric emptying study (GES) to evaluate the functionality of my stomach. If results indicate no issues, we will then investigate the gallbladder. Are there alternative explanations for my symptoms? Should I be worried about autoimmune metaplastic atrophic gastritis (AMAG)? While I have been diagnosed with GERD, this pain feels distinctly different from the GERD-related discomfort. I am not entirely sure it is gastroparesis, even though I occasionally regurgitate if I eat too quickly; I do not experience nausea or malnutrition. I have researched extensively, and my symptoms align with biliary colic. However, I am anxious about the possibility of gallstones not appearing in the ultrasound. My gastroenterologist is not particularly concerned about the intestinal metaplasia, but being only 28 years old, I find this worrying. As a medical student, these painful episodes significantly hinder my studies and academic progress.
Understanding My Symptoms: A Personal Account
I’m sharing my experiences here, as I haven’t received much feedback elsewhere. I am a 15-year-old female, measuring about 5 feet tall (152 cm) and weighing between 105 and 110 pounds (47-50 kg). I identify as Hispanic and Cuban, and legally fall under the white classification. I reside in Palm Beach County, Florida, and I am a U.S. citizen. I have a diagnosis of Autism and previously had ADD, although that diagnosis has been dropped, which leaves me unsure about my current condition—whether ADHD applies or not. Additionally, I have a past history of anemia, although it is currently not diagnosed. For the past year, I've experienced a range of symptoms that appear intermittently and are often present almost daily. While these symptoms vary, they haven’t subsided. I’ve noticed that both physical activity and caffeine can either trigger or exacerbate these issues. Now, I’d like to detail the symptoms I've been facing. One of my major concerns is my balance; when I stand, I often feel unsteady, and sometimes I even limp. This particular symptom is quite troubling as it occurs frequently. I also experience occasional dizziness and fatigue, which leaves me feeling too weak to move, causing me to remain still for prolonged periods. During episodes of significant fatigue or balance issues, I find myself starting to stutter and I suspect my speech may slur at times. Additionally, my hands sometimes shake, especially when I struggle to walk. There could be other symptoms I haven’t recalled yet, but this is what I remember for now. I will provide updates if I think of anything else, and I welcome any engagement. Furthermore, I’ve noticed irregularities with my heart rate. Initially, when these symptoms began, my resting heart rate dropped from the 80s and 90s to the 50s and 60s; this lower rate has persisted. Lately, however, even simple tasks such as standing, walking short distances, or rocking back and forth (which I do as a self-soothing mechanism) have caused my heart rate to spike to the 100s. These changes are new, while the other symptoms have been consistent for about a year. I genuinely seek guidance or support, as I feel uneasy relying on AI for self-assessment. Unfortunately, I can't afford doctor visits at this time, and my caretaker has shown little concern for my well-being. Therefore, please refrain from suggesting medical consultations. Thank you for taking the time to read my story. I’m open to any questions.
Understanding Lymph Node Sensitivity
A 32-year-old female with a BMI of 28 poses a concern about potential lymph node activity. Over the past three months, she has noticed tender areas coinciding with her menstrual cycle. She has detected slight lumps, but is careful not to press deeply into the tissue to avoid further discomfort. Initially, in December, the sensitivity was localized to the left side of her breast. In January, she observed similar tenderness in her inner left thigh, and by February, both areas and the region above her armpit were affected. Additionally, she has been experiencing fluctuations in her hormonal balance lately. The discomfort in her left breast has persisted for most of this time since December. She wonders whether this is a typical response from lymph nodes due to hormonal changes or if it would be advisable to consult her general practitioner for further evaluation.
What Could This Bump Be? Should I Be Concerned?
I’m a 22-year-old male, standing at 6 feet 2 inches tall and weighing 180 pounds. I currently don’t take any medications and have no significant medical history. Recently, I discovered two small, white bumps on my finger, which appeared around two days ago. They feel firm, much like the sensation of a splinter lodged underneath the skin, and they stick out slightly above the surface. One bump is located at the joint of one finger, while the other is positioned at the tip of another finger on my opposite hand. These bumps are neither painful nor bothersome, but I’m curious to know whether I should consider having them removed or if they might resolve on their own over time. I would appreciate any guidance regarding this matter. Thank you!