Seeking Guidance for a 19-Year-Old with a Potential Labrum Tear from Rock Climbing
I'm currently facing a challenging situation that adds to my already busy life. It appears that I may need surgery to address a possible labrum tear, although my surgeon seems quite confident that I do have one. Due to the difficulty in visualizing the tear through MRI scans, they recommend going in surgically to examine my shoulder directly. After my initial injury, my shoulder would make popping noises whenever I moved my arm, but the pain was minimal unless I moved in a specific way. At present, I’m not experiencing much discomfort, as I only engage that particular movement while climbing. Since the day of the injury, I haven't climbed at all, and any soreness I feel while sleeping is infrequent. Interestingly, my doctor pointed out that injuries like this often come with dislocations, which I don't think I’ve experienced. I recently started a new job and could use the money, so the thought of undergoing surgery is quite daunting for me. In my day-to-day activities, this injury doesn’t hinder me significantly; however, it does prevent me from practicing my passions like MMA and rock climbing, which saddens me. If I proceed with the surgery, I risk losing my job as a barista due to the lengthy recovery and movement restrictions involved. I'm torn about whether to take the surgical route. On a scale where 10 signifies an urgent need for surgery, my situation feels like a mere 1.5. Only in specific positions does the pain rise to a 2 or 4, which is rare. It's disheartening because I have a deep love for rock climbing and am concerned that I might never reach my previous level of skill or thrill in the sport again. I would greatly appreciate any advice on how to navigate this situation. Thank you!
Answers (1)
7/31/2025, 12:50:55 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel overwhelmed by the possibility of surgery for a potential labrum tear, especially given your passion for rock climbing and the impact on your job. Here's a structured approach to help you navigate this situation:
Main Points
- Non-Surgical Options: Given your current minimal pain and daily functionality, consider conservative management methods first.
- Explore Strengthening: Focus on physical therapy to improve shoulder stability without immediately resorting to surgery.
- Decision-Making: Assess your personal and athletic goals to determine if surgery aligns with your long-term aspirations.
Explanation
A labrum tear in the shoulder can sometimes lead to issues like popping or discomfort, particularly during specific activities like climbing. Many athletes with similar injuries may manage their symptoms effectively without surgery, especially when pain is minimal and everyday activities are not significantly hindered. Your concerns regarding surgery and recovery time are valid, especially since you have just started a new job.
Before making a final decision about surgery, consider engaging in physical therapy. A physical therapist can assess your shoulder's strength, flexibility, and stability, focusing on exercises that may alleviate symptoms and help you regain confidence in your shoulder's performance. This might include stabilization exercises, stretches, and even modifications specific to climbing.
Next Steps
- Consult with a Physical Therapist: Schedule an appointment to evaluate your shoulder's condition and discuss a tailored rehabilitation plan.
- Modify Activities Temporarily: While engaging in physical therapy, avoid activities that exacerbate your shoulder pain, such as climbing and MMA.
- Monitor Your Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in pain levels, mobility, or functionality, especially during activities you miss. This data will help you make informed decisions about surgery later.
- Re-evaluate After Therapy: After a set period of physical therapy (e.g., 6-8 weeks), reassess the need for surgery based on your recovery and pain levels. This will provide more clarity on how to proceed without rushing into surgery.
Please remember, it’s important to listen to your body during this time and prioritize your overall well-being. You can also explore supportive communities in climbing or sports, who may provide insights and encouragement. Let me know if you have more questions or need further assistance!
Related Questions
Considering a VP Shunt with Slit Ventricles
Patient Profile: - **Age:** 40 years - **Gender:** Female - **Weight:** 65 kg - **Height:** 164 cm - **Medications:** Acetazolamide 1000 mg, Vonapro, Voltas, Betaserc **Background of Condition:** For the past three years, I have experienced cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks following a functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). To address this, I have undergone two endonasal repairs and one craniotomy, but the leak has persistently altered from a steady flow to just a few drops. I have noticed a peculiar pattern: debilitating headaches often lead to significant leakage, providing temporary relief. However, post-craniotomy, while I still leak slightly, that relief has ceased. Recent evaluations by ENT specialists and neurosurgeons suggest that my intracranial pressure (ICP) is elevated and the option of a ventricular-peritoneal (VP) shunt was discussed. A subsequent CT scan revealed that I have slit ventricles, which has complicated the decision about the shunt placement. Doctors express concern regarding the complexity of this procedure, and after spending a week in the hospital filled with uncertainty, I learned about slit ventricles through my own research. This raised my anxiety about the risks involved with surgery, especially given my context—receiving medical care in a developing country increases my apprehension about potential postoperative deficits. In reflection, my previous trust in my medical team is faltering as one neurosurgeon, who performed my craniotomy, has opted out, intensifying my doubts about proceeding with the VP shunt. **Current Symptoms:** - Intense headaches that were previously alleviated by CSF leakage. - Sensation of pressure around my eyes and surgical site, along with a feeling of pressure in my ears. - Difficulty maintaining a straight walking path; I often feel unsteady. - Episodes of dizziness. - Pulsatile sounds in my ears. - Visual disturbances, including temporary darkness and, on three distinct occasions, sensations resembling mirages—like undulating waves in my vision, with two occurrences just recently. - Brief moments of hearing loss, followed by a loud ringing sound until my hearing returns. - When reading, I often see duplicate words or blurry images, which has impacted my ability to write this message coherently. **Inquiry:** Given these complexities, is undergoing the VP shunt truly the most suitable option for my condition considering the presence of slit ventricles? Or might I be able to manage with the symptoms I currently have? I appreciate you taking the time to read my concerns, and I would be grateful for any insights or advice.
Should This Episode Be Registered?
I have a history of diverticulitis and other conditions, including BPH and OSA, with my primary medication being beta-sitosterol. Additionally, I've been taking some supplements including vitamin K2, vitamin D, fisetin, grape seed extract, soluble and insoluble fiber, and zinc. During my hospitalization for diverticulitis surgery, the medical team mentioned that experiencing three or more episodes within a year could lead to the necessity of a colostomy bag. A few months later, my gastroenterologist advised that I need not visit the clinic for antibiotics unless I develop a fever or experience vomiting. A colonoscopy revealed pandiverticulosis along with internal hemorrhoids, and a polyp was also removed during the procedure. Recently, I've experienced some discomfort in my lower gastrointestinal tract that resembled, but was not nearly as intense as, my first diverticulitis episode. This discomfort began approximately one week after I neglected to take my fiber supplements with me while on vacation. Fortunately, I am nearly back to normal now, with symptoms that lasted three days and no episodes of fever or vomiting. Given these circumstances, should I classify this as my second episode? I'm uncertain if this is indeed diverticulitis and I'm reluctant to seek imaging every time I exhibit symptoms. Appreciate any guidance you can provide!
I (19M) Notice Epicanthic Folds, Wondering if It's Related to FASD
At 19 years old, I've observed that I possess epicanthic folds, a feature not seen in either of my parents. This observation has led me to ponder whether I might be experiencing Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD). I also have a previous diagnosis of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), which, from my research, can sometimes be mistaken for FASD. For context, I should mention that my ethnicity is Turkish, as I'm not of Asian descent.
28-Year-Old Male Struggles with Persistent Post-Nasal Drip and Green Mucus
Hello everyone, I’m a 28-year-old man who has been facing an ongoing issue with post-nasal drip for around three years. The mucus is often a light green shade. I’ve adapted to this condition to some extent, but I always carry tissues with me wherever I go. Whenever I visit a healthcare professional, I typically receive recommendations for antihistamines or occasional courses of antibiotics. I've also experimented with saline sprays for rinsing, but unfortunately, none of these approaches have yielded any improvement. Additionally, I suffer from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), and I’ve noticed an increase in the need for tissues just before or during my meals. This has led me to ponder whether there might be a relationship between the two issues. Has anyone encountered a similar situation, or are there any medical professionals here who can offer insights into what might be happening or suggest possible next steps for me? I appreciate your help!
Is This a Wart?
Hello everyone, I’m a 31-year-old woman, standing at 5'7" and weighing around 143 pounds. I don’t smoke or drink alcohol, and I’m not on any medications at the moment. Approximately a year ago, I discovered a small growth on my palm, and I initially suspected it could be a wart (images excluded for privacy). To address it, I applied a topical treatment containing lactic acid and salicylic acid, which resulted in some removal of the growth. However, it reappeared quickly, prompting me to use the treatment again. While it seemed to work temporarily, the issue continues to recur. Is there anyone here who can confirm whether this is indeed a wart and offer advice on how to effectively eliminate it permanently?