Seeking Guidance for a 19-Year-Old with a Potential Labrum Tear from Rock Climbing
I'm currently facing a challenging situation that adds to my already busy life. It appears that I may need surgery to address a possible labrum tear, although my surgeon seems quite confident that I do have one. Due to the difficulty in visualizing the tear through MRI scans, they recommend going in surgically to examine my shoulder directly. After my initial injury, my shoulder would make popping noises whenever I moved my arm, but the pain was minimal unless I moved in a specific way. At present, I’m not experiencing much discomfort, as I only engage that particular movement while climbing. Since the day of the injury, I haven't climbed at all, and any soreness I feel while sleeping is infrequent. Interestingly, my doctor pointed out that injuries like this often come with dislocations, which I don't think I’ve experienced. I recently started a new job and could use the money, so the thought of undergoing surgery is quite daunting for me. In my day-to-day activities, this injury doesn’t hinder me significantly; however, it does prevent me from practicing my passions like MMA and rock climbing, which saddens me. If I proceed with the surgery, I risk losing my job as a barista due to the lengthy recovery and movement restrictions involved. I'm torn about whether to take the surgical route. On a scale where 10 signifies an urgent need for surgery, my situation feels like a mere 1.5. Only in specific positions does the pain rise to a 2 or 4, which is rare. It's disheartening because I have a deep love for rock climbing and am concerned that I might never reach my previous level of skill or thrill in the sport again. I would greatly appreciate any advice on how to navigate this situation. Thank you!
Answers (1)
7/31/2025, 12:50:55 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel overwhelmed by the possibility of surgery for a potential labrum tear, especially given your passion for rock climbing and the impact on your job. Here's a structured approach to help you navigate this situation:
Main Points
- Non-Surgical Options: Given your current minimal pain and daily functionality, consider conservative management methods first.
- Explore Strengthening: Focus on physical therapy to improve shoulder stability without immediately resorting to surgery.
- Decision-Making: Assess your personal and athletic goals to determine if surgery aligns with your long-term aspirations.
Explanation
A labrum tear in the shoulder can sometimes lead to issues like popping or discomfort, particularly during specific activities like climbing. Many athletes with similar injuries may manage their symptoms effectively without surgery, especially when pain is minimal and everyday activities are not significantly hindered. Your concerns regarding surgery and recovery time are valid, especially since you have just started a new job.
Before making a final decision about surgery, consider engaging in physical therapy. A physical therapist can assess your shoulder's strength, flexibility, and stability, focusing on exercises that may alleviate symptoms and help you regain confidence in your shoulder's performance. This might include stabilization exercises, stretches, and even modifications specific to climbing.
Next Steps
- Consult with a Physical Therapist: Schedule an appointment to evaluate your shoulder's condition and discuss a tailored rehabilitation plan.
- Modify Activities Temporarily: While engaging in physical therapy, avoid activities that exacerbate your shoulder pain, such as climbing and MMA.
- Monitor Your Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in pain levels, mobility, or functionality, especially during activities you miss. This data will help you make informed decisions about surgery later.
- Re-evaluate After Therapy: After a set period of physical therapy (e.g., 6-8 weeks), reassess the need for surgery based on your recovery and pain levels. This will provide more clarity on how to proceed without rushing into surgery.
Please remember, it’s important to listen to your body during this time and prioritize your overall well-being. You can also explore supportive communities in climbing or sports, who may provide insights and encouragement. Let me know if you have more questions or need further assistance!
Related Questions
Micronodules Detected in Lung
Hello, I recently underwent a coronary artery calcium (CAC) scan to assess arterial plaque, and I was pleased to receive a favorable score of 7.75. However, the report highlighted the presence of several clustered micronodules located in the right upper lung, accompanied by adjacent ground-glass opacities. I am a 60-year-old male, 6 feet tall and weigh 190 pounds. I do not currently take any medications and generally enjoy excellent health. There is a family history of heart disease on my father's side. Additionally, I am a non-smoker, apart from occasional use of cannabis, and consume alcohol very infrequently. Thank you in advance for any insights you can provide!
Liver Mass Assessment
Patient Profile: - Age: 61 years - Height: 5'9" - Weight: 240 lbs - Gender: Female - Lifestyle: Non-drinker, non-smoker, no illicit drugs Current Medications: - Atenolol 10mg (morning and evening) - Rosuvastatin 40mg (evening) - Duloxetine 60mg (evening) - Spironolactone 25mg (recently added) - Jardiance 10mg (recently added) Medical History: The patient has a notable history of multiple pheochromocytomas and paragangliomas, having undergone surgery on eight occasions. According to scans performed three years ago, two subcentimeter retroperitoneal masses were identified, suggestive of potential paraganglioma. Additionally, she suffers from secondary polycythemia and possesses the PHD1 gene mutation. Previously, she received treatment at a prominent research institution in the United States. However, her endocrinologist has since retired and returned to their home country. Current Condition: At present, she is mostly asymptomatic. However, in January 2026, she experienced a concerning event requiring an ambulance transport to a local emergency room, where her oxygen levels registered at 88-89%. This incident was unsettling, given her extensive medical history. The emergency physician initially diagnosed her with congestive heart failure (CHF), but upon discharge, her family medicine doctor suggested pneumonia. During her hospital stay, a cardiologist—who has never managed a pheochromocytoma patient—recommended a chemical stress test. A CT scan performed on her chest revealed a 3.2 x 2.5 cm mass located in the left lobe of her liver. Her blood tests typically show elevated levels related to pheochromocytomas; however, the laboratory does not conduct resting catecholamine testing, which leads to unreliable results, despite them being consistent over time. Furthermore, she has received care at major hospitals in Minnesota and both leading hospitals in Cleveland, Ohio. Unfortunately, when she required her last surgery, the tumor board declined her case, citing an unfavorable risk-benefit ratio. This leaves her without a specialist in pheochromocytomas. Request for Guidance: The patient is seeking advice or recommendations for her current health situation and management of her conditions.
Concerns About My Daughter's Morning Health Issues
My 17-year-old daughter experiences troubling symptoms each morning, particularly on days when she needs to rise early for school or work. She often wakes up feeling dizzy and nauseated, accompanied by a rapid heartbeat exceeding 100 beats per minute. This situation prevents her from being able to eat and may persist for several hours, or in some cases, throughout the entire day. Standing at 5 feet 8 inches tall (172 cm) and weighing 121 pounds (55 kg), her physical health otherwise seems fine. I have a personal history of inappropriate sinus tachycardia (IST), which is why I take beta-blockers for management. A few years ago, she consulted a cardiologist regarding her frequent episodes of near-fainting, who recommended increasing her water intake and adding more salt to her meals. Given the persistent nature of her symptoms, I am contemplating whether a follow-up appointment with the cardiologist is warranted, especially since all previous tests, including ECG and ultrasound, came back normal. This situation significantly affects her daily life, restricting her ability to engage fully in school and work. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Navigating the Complexity of Symptoms: Is It PCOS or Something Else?
While I’m not an expert in self-diagnosis, I find myself puzzled by an array of symptoms that overlap, making it challenging to pinpoint what might be affecting my health. Let's break down my situation: - Age: 25 years, Gender: Female, Height: 5’1”, Weight: 125 lbs. - The last menstruation occurred in June 2024. Prior to this, my menstrual cycle was remarkably consistent since I was around 12 years old, typically without severe premenstrual symptoms, heavy flow, or irregularities. - Various blood tests over time reveal that most hormone levels fall within normal ranges, with the exception of estradiol (persistently between 10-20) and progesterone (remaining below 0.2). - A couple of results raised some concerns for me personally, even if my doctors weren’t alarmed: my morning cortisol was measured at 13.4 and in the afternoon at 9.49. One test indicated a TSH level of 2.35, which increased to 3.93 months later. My fasting glucose consistently hovers around 80, whereas random glucose levels were recorded at 68, and postprandial glucose was 65. - An MRI indicated a "deviation of the pituitary stalk, potentially linked to a small pituitary adenoma." - An ultrasound revealed "multiple oval, well-defined, anechoic images with posterior acoustic enhancement, measuring a few millimeters, located around the edges of the stroma." - The symptoms I am experiencing include disrupted sleep (frequent awakenings, particularly around 3 AM, making it hard to resume sleep), lack of energy, difficulty in weight management, persistent hunger, heightened anxiety, and hair thinning. - Birth control (drospirenone and ethinyl estradiol) exacerbated nearly all of my symptoms, leading me to discontinue use after two weeks despite experiencing a withdrawal bleed. - My lifestyle is generally healthy; I consume a lot of whole foods, engage in weightlifting, and run regularly. Given that I’ve received a diagnosis of PCOS, I’m wondering if this assessment seems accurate. What options do I have moving forward, especially since the contraceptive method didn’t provide relief and I appear to exhibit signs of additional complications such as thyroid issues or cortisol dysregulation?
A Mysterious Illness That Resembles Strep Throat
As an 18-year-old college student, standing at 5'4" and weighing 140 pounds, I maintain an active lifestyle. I do not smoke or have any preexisting health issues, aside from the vitamins and supplements I take daily. Approximately five days ago, I began to feel unusually fatigued and achy. Within just a day, my symptoms escalated to include a high fever reaching between 101°F and 102°F that ibuprofen couldn’t seem to alleviate. I experienced extreme tiredness that kept me bedridden all day, along with a persistent headache and intense throat pain, which was compounded by swollen lymph nodes and the familiar white patches often associated with strep throat. Having dealt with strep throat before, I recognized a need for antibiotics. Two days into feeling unwell, I visited an urgent care facility for an assessment and received a rapid strep test, which unfortunately came back negative. I recalled a previous incident where my rapid strep test also indicated a false negative, only for the culture sent for further testing to confirm the presence of strep bacteria. Given my symptoms and the findings from the examination, the healthcare provider prescribed Cefdinir, as I am allergic to amoxicillin, despite the negative rapid test results. The antibiotics proved effective, and I felt nearly back to normal, leading me to believe that my culture results would also come back positive for strep, suggesting a recurrence of my previous infection. However, I received the culture results yesterday, and to my surprise, they came back negative for strep. While I lack medical expertise, I’ve been led to believe that false negatives in cultures are exceedingly rare. Now, I find myself puzzled about what kind of bacterial infection I might have had if it wasn’t strep. Any insights or information regarding my situation would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!