Proctologist Claims 'Hemorrhoid Banding is Outdated'—Concern Over Grade 2 Hems?
I recently visited a rather pricey proctologist concerning my grade 2 hemorrhoids, which have been a concern for nearly a decade. The short version: After confirming my suspicion about having grade 2 hemorrhoids, the doctor dismissed the idea of hemorrhoid banding, labeling it as an outdated practice riddled with complications. Instead, he advocated for a procedure called "laser proctology," which comes with a hefty price tag of 1,400€, compared to the 40€ I would have spent on banding. As for my personal experience, I’m a 21-year-old male who has dealt with these hemorrhoids since childhood. The issue began when I often faced difficulty while trying to relieve myself before school. Currently, my hemorrhoids only present as prolapsing; I don’t suffer from any other distressing symptoms like bleeding, itching, or mucus discharge—likely because I've always had access to a bidet. During my consultation, the proctologist confirmed my self-diagnosis of grade 2 hemorrhoids. However, he mentioned that many clinics in Eastern Europe have ceased performing rubber band ligation (RBL) procedures, suggesting that I should opt for laser treatment instead. Given that there are no painful symptoms involved—only the discomfort of prolapse—does it really seem reasonable to invest 1,400€ in laser treatment for what I perceive as a manageable issue? While he neither condemned banding for my situation nor recommended it, he made it clear that they’ve discontinued it for hemorrhoids altogether. I’m curious to know if others share my sentiments regarding this recommendation or if I'm out of touch. Would love to hear some thoughts!
Answers (1)
7/29/2025, 3:11:02 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel uncertain about the recommendation you've received, especially given the significant cost difference between hemorrhoid banding and the suggested laser treatment.
Key Points:
- Grade 2 Hemorrhoids: These can cause mild discomfort without severe symptoms, making management a personal choice.
- Treatment Options: While banding is a common option for this grade, concerns about its modernization and efficacy may be influencing your proctologist's recommendation.
- Exploring Alternatives: It's important to weigh treatment effectiveness against costs and any potential risks involved.
Explanation:
Grade 2 hemorrhoids can protrude outside the anus when you have a bowel movement but tend to retract on their own without significant pain or bleeding. This level of severity often allows for conservative management methods. Rubber band ligation (RBL) has been standard practice, but some practitioners may be moving towards other techniques due to perceived complications or advancements in technology. However, RBL remains a valid treatment option, particularly for patients with minimal discomfort that you describe.
Your discomfort level is low, and without distressing symptoms, you might not need immediate treatment. Laser procedures are effective and less invasive but come with higher costs and may not significantly improve your quality of life compared to less expensive options.
Recommended Next Steps:
-
Consider a Second Opinion: If you're unsure about the recommendation, consult another healthcare provider who specializes in proctology. This can provide clarity on your options, including the status of RBL in your area.
-
Evaluate Lifestyle Changes: Until you decide on treatment, focus on dietary adjustments, such as increasing fiber intake and hydration, as they can significantly reduce hemorrhoid symptoms.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in your condition. If you start experiencing pain, bleeding, or other symptoms, seek medical advice promptly.
-
Research and Inform Yourself: Look into reputable sources about both banding and laser treatments, understanding their risks, benefits, and what to expect post-procedure.
-
Question the Cost: If laser treatment is the path you consider, verify if there are financing options, payment plans, or insurance coverage that could make it more manageable.
Your feelings about the treatment options are valid; ensure you feel comfortable and informed, whichever path you choose.
Related Questions
Eye Discomfort from Catarrh
I am a 19-year-old female weighing 92 pounds. Over the past few days, I've been suffering from flu-like symptoms, although feels so severe that I suspect it might be COVID-19 instead. My nasal passages are completely congested, and despite taking medication to alleviate the symptoms, my condition hasn’t improved. In fact, the congestion has led to catarrh oozing from my right eye, which is quite distressing. Each morning, I find my eyelashes stuck together due to the discharge, and I can't seem to halt this issue. The catarrh has caused considerable swelling and reddening of my eye, both internally and on the surrounding skin. It appears as if I’ve sustained a blow to the face. At this point, the soreness is so intense that I struggle to move my eyeball without discomfort.
Navigating Conflicting Medical Opinions: Should I Discuss a Second Opinion with My Orthopedist?
As a 25-year-old woman, measuring 5’5” and weighing 108 pounds, I recently experienced an unfortunate incident that resulted in a fracture of my middle finger. Approximately three weeks ago, I was diagnosed with a non-displaced fracture in the head of my third metacarpal, leading to my concern regarding the future functionality of my grip. To address this issue, I opted for a titanium implant to stabilize the fracture. However, despite ongoing treatment, including oral antibiotics, I continue to notice concerning symptoms such as yellow discharge, indicating a potential infection. I've been diligent about attending weekly follow-up appointments with my primary physician, but my condition doesn't seem to improve; it feels as though my hand remains in the same state. My doctor mentioned that if the situation does not improve, the next step might involve IV antibiotics. Seeking additional perspectives, I consulted another orthopedic specialist, who proposed a different course of action: removing the implant to allow for natural healing. This alternate recommendation has left me feeling uncertain about which path to pursue. In light of this contrasting advice, would it be advisable for me to communicate with my orthopedic surgeon about the second opinion I obtained and the differing suggestions I received?
Sensations of Pressure and Nail Changes
Age 27, no formal diagnosis. I have been experiencing a recurring feeling of pressure accumulating in my head, which sometimes radiates to my face and ears. Occasionally, I also struggle with breathing, as though there is a weight pressing against my upper chest and neck. This sensation is particularly pronounced when I lie flat on my back, although it can occur even while I am sitting upright. Moreover, about three days ago, I observed the development of white horizontal lines across my thumbnail. I am uncertain how this might relate to my other symptoms since I've never noticed these lines before. I'm at a crossroads regarding what steps to take next. I fear that if I consult my general practitioner regarding these issues, he might not take my concerns seriously or simply brush them off. Has anyone else encountered similar symptoms? Any guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Fears about Waking Up - 21 Years Old
I’m a 21-year-old female currently struggling with a relapse of anorexia, weighing in at 35.6 kg with a height of 168 cm, which puts my BMI at roughly 12.7. Despite my condition, I continue to engage in intense daily workouts and walk excessively—exceeding 25,000 steps each day—all while holding down a job at a supermarket. However, I am increasingly anxious about how much longer my body can endure this strain. To be honest, I'm scared about what might happen next. The challenge lies in figuring out where to begin in making changes, as the overwhelming nature of it all leaves me feeling paralyzed. I’m currently receiving outpatient care from an eating disorder team, but their resources are quite limited since my blood tests and ECG results have come back normal. This makes the prospect of inpatient treatment feel out of reach, yet I worry that I’m running out of time before my body ultimately fails. If anyone has suggestions or can offer support, it would mean a lot to me.
Could This Be DVT? Seeking Guidance!
I’m a 22-year-old woman, standing 5’4” tall and weighing 110 pounds. Generally, I consider myself healthy, though I might have some issues with chronic health anxiety. I’m not currently on any medication. Recently, my anxiety has escalated, and it’s been difficult to cope. Just yesterday, I took two flights that lasted about 2 hours and 15 minutes in total, and during the journey, I noticed some stiffness in my left calf while seated. Later, around 3 AM, I noticed something unusual (referencing the attached image). There is no skin discoloration, and the calf doesn’t hurt unless I press on it, which results in mild tenderness rather than any intense pain. Importantly, I haven’t observed any swelling. Could this indicate a blood clot, or is it more likely just a bruise? I would greatly appreciate any insights!