Will Weight Affect Celiac Testing with My Doctor?
I’m a 29-year-old female, standing at 5'3" and weighing 214 pounds. Additionally, I used to smoke but have since quit. My family history includes gluten-related issues; my grandfather is gluten intolerant while my father suffers from celiac disease. Recently, I have endured a range of troubling symptoms—joint discomfort, anxiety, depression, bloating, fatigue, mental fog, irritability, slight constipation, stomach cramps, and migraines. In discussing these concerns with my father, he pointed out that he experienced similar issues prior to his celiac diagnosis, but they subsided once he changed his diet. Curious about the possibility of having celiac myself, I tried going gluten-free for a month. It may have been a rash decision, but to my surprise, every single symptom vanished. My joints felt normal again for the first time in ages, the bloating disappeared, and my mental clarity returned—I truly felt like my old self. With a doctor's visit on the horizon and while I am undergoing a gluten challenge, I'm feeling anxious about how my weight may play into the situation. My previous experiences have shown that doctors have often attributed my health issues to my size and suggested simple weight loss as a solution. Admittedly, I initially believed that my weight was the root of the problem too. In the past months, I have managed to shed almost 20 pounds intentionally; however, as soon as I reintroduced gluten, all the symptoms returned, regardless of the progress I made in losing weight. Given my symptoms and the results of my self-experiment, do you think that my doctor will be open to conducting celiac tests? As a healthcare professional, would you consider testing someone like me, despite my weight status and the fact that my weight loss isn't excessive?
Answers (1)
7/25/2025, 10:50:43 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to have concerns about how your weight may affect your doctor's willingness to test for celiac disease, especially given your family history and the resolution of your symptoms upon eliminating gluten. Let's break down your situation and explore next steps in a supportive and reassuring way.
Key Points:
- Celiac Disease Susceptibility: Given your family history and the symptoms you've experienced that improved on a gluten-free diet, testing for celiac disease is appropriate.
- Weight Consideration: While weight can influence health discussions, your symptoms and family history should be the primary focus for your doctor.
- Gluten Challenge: Since you're currently undergoing a gluten challenge, it’s crucial to ensure that testing can be accurately performed.
Explanation:
Celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder triggered by the ingestion of gluten, leading to various symptoms – many of which you've reported. Your health history, including the significant improvement when removing gluten and your family background, aligns with the criteria for testing. Physicians should prioritize symptoms and risk factors over weight alone when considering celiac testing.
Next Steps:
- Communicate Openly: Be prepared to discuss your symptoms and family history during your appointment. Emphasize how your symptoms improved with a gluten-free diet, as this is strong evidence to support testing.
- Request Testing: When speaking with your doctor, express your desire for celiac testing. Ask about the specific tests, such as serological tests (like tTG-IgA) and potentially an intestinal biopsy if needed.
- Document Symptoms and Dietary Changes: Keep a detailed diary of your symptoms, dietary choices, and any changes you observed, both when consuming gluten and when you were gluten-free. This can help illustrate the connection between your symptoms and gluten.
- Manage Anxieties: It’s normal to feel anxious about your weight and how it might be perceived. Remind yourself that your health concerns are valid, and effective communication with your doctor about your symptoms is essential.
By focusing on your overall health and specific symptoms, you can guide the conversation with your doctor toward getting the testing you need. Remember, you deserve care that respects your experiences and addresses your health conditions comprehensively. Let me know if you have further questions or need additional support!
Related Questions
Understanding Allergy Panel Testing
Seeking Advice: Food Allergy Evaluations and Digestive Issues I am reaching out on behalf of a colleague (we are both medical professionals) who is experiencing digestive problems such as food intolerances and fatigue. My friend is a 28-year-old male, standing 5'10" and weighing 65 kilograms, of South Indian descent. He has been struggling with gastrointestinal difficulties since the start of this year. Notably, he has no ongoing health conditions and is not taking any medications apart from dietary supplements. Furthermore, there is no family history of digestive ailments. Given these complications, we are now considering the possibility of food allergies or sensitivities as underlying factors and are contemplating undergoing a comprehensive IgE and IgG test panel. I would like to gather insights on the following: - Which specific allergy tests are genuinely beneficial for identifying issues? - Is it advisable to combine IgE and IgG testing, or would that be excessive? - If anyone has experience with labs such as Radcliffe, DNA Labs, MyDiagnostics, Max Labs, or Vijaya Diagnostics, could you share which ones are the most dependable, particularly if you're based in India? - Have you come across any false positive results with IgG testing? - I am hoping to connect with any immunologists or individuals familiar with these matters to provide clarity on my query. Any recommendations or shared experiences would be highly valued. I appreciate any expert advice from those who have faced similar situations.
Understanding Trichomoniasis
Female | Age: 27 | Weight: 125 lbs | Generally in good health I engage in sexual activity with one partner. Recently, I began to experience some discomfort in my vaginal area and, after seeking medical assistance, was diagnosed with Trichomoniasis, for which I was given a prescription. (For context, I have never faced any urinary tract infections, sexually transmitted infections, or related issues, so this has been incredibly distressing for me.) Upon informing my partner about the diagnosis, he expressed disbelief, insisting he has never had Trichomoniasis because his test results came back "negative." Is it even plausible for this to happen? How could I have contracted the infection if not from him? What could be the source of this condition?
Could My Symptoms Be Due to a Hamster Allergy?
At 21 years old, I've been experiencing some troubling health issues over the past three weeks. These include shortness of breath, persistent coughing, difficulties with sleep, and a few other vague symptoms. My doctor suspects that I might have a chest infection since I exhibit signs of "crackling lungs." However, despite two courses of antibiotics, I haven’t noticed any improvement in my condition. Upon reflection, I realized that my symptoms began around the same time I started looking after my sister’s hamster. Working from home means that the little creature's habitat is located only about 10 cm away from my workstation. Now, I can’t help but wonder if the hamster or its bedding might be contributing to my ailments. Although I feel somewhat hesitant to raise this topic with my doctor, as it might seem trivial, the timing of my symptoms is quite coincidental. Is it possible that I could be allergic to the hamster or its hay?
What Does a Bone Scan Result Indicate About Cancer?
Late Friday night, I received a concerning report that has left me feeling anxious, especially since I couldn't reach anyone for clarification. As a nearly 40-year-old woman standing 5'4" and weighing 145 pounds, I lead an active lifestyle. I've been using Wegovy for the past month and had a bone scan due to persistent joint pain. My medical history includes controlled psoriasis, which raised my concerns about the possibility of psoriatic arthritis. The joint discomfort primarily affects my hands, wrists, and feet, prompting my rheumatologist to recommend the bone scan. This is my first experience with such a test, and the results are perplexing: they mention "Impression: progression of metastatic pattern." How can there be a pattern if this is the very first assessment? Additionally, in the past year, I have undergone numerous pre-operative blood tests related to cosmetic procedures, and each time, the results were normal. The report concludes with: FINDINGS: Bones: Calvarial activity appears stable. There is worsening involvement in the spine and ribs along with a newly detected sacral lesion. Joints: No signs of arthritis present. Soft tissues: Normal physiological distribution. This has left me bewildered and frightened. It seems contradictory for the report to note "worsening" and a "new lesion" when I have never had a previous scan. I am at a loss about what this could mean for my health!
Understanding Strongyloides IgG Antibodies
Hello everyone, I recently completed extensive blood tests and have been battling allergies since childhood. In addition to allergy testing, my allergist included several panels that assessed thyroid function, autoimmune diseases, and intriguingly, parasitic infections. Surprisingly, my test for IgG antibodies related to Strongyloides came back positive. Despite my knowledge, I have never experienced an infection nor undergone treatment for it. I haven't had any prior blood tests for parasitic infections, so I'm uncertain whether this antibody has been present for a long duration. Strangely enough, I reside in the United States, seldom travel abroad, and have not displayed any symptoms indicative of Strongyloides or similar parasitic or helminthic infections. Additionally, my lifestyle doesn't expose me to risk factors such as working with animals, going barefoot outdoors, or having encounters with fecal matter. The only possible exposure I can think of is having a dog during my childhood. I have a few questions: 1. How prevalent are false-positive results for this test? 2. Is there a risk of transmitting this to those around me, particularly to family members who are immunocompromised? 3. What are the possible ways I might have contracted this, and what implications does it hold for my health moving forward?