Questioning My Doctor's Conduct During a Physical Exam
I'm unsure if this is the appropriate forum for my concern, but since there are healthcare professionals here, I'd appreciate your insights on the standard procedure for physical examinations. At the age of 21 and having experienced only one examination as an adult two years ago, I occasionally reflect on that encounter, as it left me feeling quite uncomfortable. I’m not circumcised, and during the latter part of my examination, the physician instructed me to lower my pants, which I assumed was a normal part of the process. However, what struck me as unusual was that he didn’t leave the room or turn his back, which seemed contrary to my expectations of privacy. As he examined me, he unexpectedly pulled back my foreskin without any explanation and then pinched the tip of my penis quite hard, causing significant discomfort. I reacted, exclaiming, "What the hell is wrong with you?" but he ignored my response. I’ve kept this experience to myself until now, and I’m looking for a professional perspective on this situation. Was there any legitimate medical reason for his actions, or was this an inappropriate violation of professional boundaries? Despite not discussing it with my family, I chose to switch to a different doctor afterward.
Answers (1)
6/27/2025, 1:40:57 PM
OpenHealth AI
Your experience during that physical examination sounds very distressing and it’s completely understandable that you have lingering concerns about it. It's important to have trust and comfort when receiving medical care, and any situation that makes you uncomfortable warrants discussion.
Main Points:
- Expectations of Privacy and Comfort: Patients have a right to privacy during examinations, especially during personal assessments.
- Informed Consent and Communication: A healthcare provider should explain procedures and obtain consent, especially for sensitive examinations.
- Professional Boundaries: Medical professionals are expected to respect boundaries and prioritize patient comfort.
Explanation:
During a physical examination, particularly of sensitive areas, guidelines suggest that physicians should maintain a professional demeanor, communicate clearly, and ensure the patient's comfort. Explanations for actions taken during an examination are essential to support patient understanding and trust. If a physician performed an examination without adequate explanation or consideration for your comfort, it may not align with accepted practices.
In your case:
- Lowering your pants may have been an expected part of the examination, but privacy should be maintained.
- Pulling back the foreskin and applying pressure without explanation can be seen as unprofessional and inappropriate, especially if it caused discomfort and wasn't justified by the examination purpose.
Next Steps:
- Reflect on Your Experience: Take time to process your feelings about this encounter and the discomfort it caused you.
- Gather Information: If you're open to it, consider researching best practices for physical examinations or speaking to another health professional about typical procedures.
- Seek Support: Talking about your experience with someone you trust might help you find some closure. This could be a friend, family member, or mental health professional.
- Consider Reporting the Incident: If you feel it is appropriate, reporting this conduct to the medical board or practice where the physician worked can help ensure that standards are upheld.
Your feelings are valid, and prioritizing your comfort and mental well-being is important as you move forward in your healthcare journey. If you feel uncertain about future medical encounters, it may help to discuss your concerns with your new doctor to build a supportive relationship.
Related Questions
Unusual Tongue Condition
Last weekend, I participated in a three-day sleepover with my younger cousin, who seems to have a habit of coughing openly. Upon returning home, I began to feel unwell; I woke up with a pounding headache and a painful throat. By the final day of the sleepover, my discomfort intensified. I noticed a rash spreading across my face, and my throat was incredibly sore, similar to the experience of having stage 2 sunburn (an ordeal I went through last year) but without the blistering. Eating and drinking became increasingly painful, and even resting caused discomfort. Though the rash eventually faded, I was left with a peculiar appearance on my tongue. Frustratingly, my parents refuse to seek medical attention, dismissing my concerns as typical hypochondria. I find myself wondering about the strange changes happening with my tongue and whether I should urge them for a doctor’s visit.
Are There Lasting Effects from Long-Term Use of Montelukast?
Hello everyone! To provide some background, I was prescribed montelukast at a young age—around 4 or 5 years old—continuing until I was about 10 or 11. During that time, I experienced significant levels of aggression. Unfortunately, none of the medical professionals we consulted suggested discontinuing the medication or indicated that my symptoms could have been related to its use. This has left me with some unresolved feelings so I’d rather not delve deeper into that right now. Currently, it has been some time since I stopped taking montelukast, but I find myself grappling with certain challenges. While I’m hesitant to elaborate unless absolutely necessary, I’m curious whether anyone knows about potential long-term side effects from prolonged use of this medication during childhood. Thank you so much for your insights! Much appreciated! <3
Food Bolus Lodged for an Extended Period
28-year-old female Currently taking Guanfacine, Prozac, and Lyrica. It’s been quite the rollercoaster for me these past two weeks! To give you some context, I’ve experienced my fair share of food getting lodged in my esophagus several times each week since I was in high school. Typically, it’s not a huge deal; I manage to induce vomiting and continue with my day. However, today was different. I took a single bite of a turkey sandwich, and ever since, I’ve been regurgitating saliva and the sensation of food being trapped persists. The food got stuck around 11 AM, and now it’s already 8 PM. What can I do to alleviate this predicament?
Concerns About Hand Discoloration
A 30-year-old woman, who stands at 5 feet 7 inches and weighs 140 pounds, has been experiencing concerning symptoms with her hands and wrists. They have developed a reddish and blotchy appearance, which has now spread down to the wrists. She is on medication for Borderline Personality Disorder and depression. Although she recognizes the need to consult a doctor soon, her anxiety levels are significantly elevated as she prepares to schedule this appointment.
Understanding Patent Ductus Arteriosus
I recently learned that my 7-year-old daughter has a minor patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). She underwent an echocardiogram due to our family's background of bicuspid heart valves, which I, along with my father and brother, also have. While her heart valves appear healthy, the echocardiogram did reveal this small PDA, as indicated in the report I received. Although I anticipate hearing from the doctor by Monday, that means I have two days to ponder this situation and feel anxious about it. I’m curious—do all PDAs require surgical intervention? Considering her age, it’s unlikely that it will close spontaneously. If anyone has any experiences or knowledge regarding this condition, I would greatly appreciate your input! Thank you!