Inquiry Regarding Stroke Protocol in the Emergency Room
I would like to discuss my grandfather, who was 85 years old at the time of his incident. He had previously suffered a minor stroke in 2021, but on May 2024, he experienced a more severe hemorrhagic stroke which is the focus of my inquiry. While mowing the lawn, he suddenly fell, losing his ability to speak or move. Emergency services were summoned, and he was transported to the hospital. Upon his arrival at the emergency department, the medical team did not instantly identify the stroke; it took them two hours to recognize the symptoms and start conducting tests, including CT scans, to confirm his condition. After the diagnosis of the hemorrhagic stroke, he was moved to the ICU. I am concerned about whether those two hours were critical for his treatment. If the medical staff had promptly recognized the signs of a stroke upon his admission, might it have altered his outcome? Following the stroke, he developed several complications including dysphagia, an inability to speak, aspiration dysphagia, and paralysis on his right side. Interestingly, there was no significant intracranial pressure due to the hemorrhage, which meant that surgery for pressure relief was not necessary. Sadly, he passed away 12 days later. I am questioning the role of his age in his treatment. Was it more paramount for the staff to act swiftly considering his advanced age? Additionally, could this situation be seen as negligence on the part of the hospital staff?
Answers (1)
6/25/2025, 11:30:56 PM
OpenHealth AI
I'm deeply sorry to hear about your grandfather's passing and understand the concerns you have regarding his care during this critical time. Your questions about timely treatment and the implications of age in stroke management are important, and I'll do my best to provide clarity.
Main Points:
-
Rapid Recognition of Stroke Symptoms: The quick identification of stroke symptoms is crucial for effective treatment. Time is often referred to as brain when it comes to stroke management.
-
Age Considerations: While age can influence treatment decisions, the primary focus should always be on the immediate medical presentation and the potential for recovery.
-
Assessment of Care: Evaluating the care provided and determining if any negligence occurred is a complex issue that typically involves detailed review by medical professionals and legal standards.
Explanation:
When a person presents with signs of a stroke—such as sudden loss of speech, movement, or coordination—it's essential for healthcare providers to act swiftly. Research indicates that interventions for strokes are most effective when initiated as soon as possible, ideally within a few hours of the onset of symptoms.
While the medical team may not have recognized the stroke immediately, the diagnostic delay could potentially influence treatment options and outcomes. However, the specific causes and impacts of this delay would depend on various factors, including the hospital's protocols and the medical team’s expertise.
With regard to your grandfather’s age, older adults may have different responses to strokes and their ability to recover. Nonetheless, emergency protocols should prioritize the immediacy of care based on symptoms rather than age.
Next Steps:
-
Follow-Up with Medical Records: Request a copy of your grandfather’s medical records, including the timeline of events and interventions that took place upon admission. This could help address your questions about the time taken to diagnose his stroke.
-
Seek a Second Opinion: If you're considering the possibility of negligence, it may be helpful to consult with a medical malpractice attorney or patient advocacy group who can review the information and provide guidance on the next steps.
-
Engage in Supportive Services: Losses like this can be profoundly difficult. Seeking support through counseling or patient support groups can be beneficial in processing grief and the complexity of these experiences.
If you have more questions or concerns about specific aspects of his care or need further clarification, please don’t hesitate to ask.
Related Questions
Navigating Acoustic Neuroma Treatment Options
**Profile: 45-year-old Male, 6'0", 220 lbs, No Regular Medications** My husband maintains a relatively healthy lifestyle despite experiencing some service-related disabilities. About a year and a half ago, he underwent knee replacement surgery, and he utilizes a CPAP machine due to sleep apnea—an issue linked to a jaw surgery performed many years ago. Additionally, he has a history of appendectomy. For the past three years, he has been prescribed hearing aids due to bilateral hearing loss, although he rarely uses them. About eight months ago, he experienced what he described as the "worst headache of his life." Given that he seldom suffers from headaches, we decided to visit the emergency room. A CT scan showed no abnormalities, and he was diagnosed with a migraine. Since then, he has grappled with weekly migraines. He has a triptan medication, but it offers limited relief. Additionally, he has been reporting non-migraine headaches every few days. Before this incident, he reported headaches perhaps twice a year, typically after consuming alcohol, which he does occasionally and in moderation. He also frequently mentions a sensation of pressure or fullness in his head, though he is uncertain if he would categorize it as a headache. Given the stressors our family has faced over the past couple of years, I hoped this might subside as we return to a more typical routine. Two weeks ago, my husband’s boss alerted us that an ambulance was called after he fainted while walking down the hall at work. After regaining consciousness, he attempted to sit up but felt intense dizziness, forcing him to lie back down. Although his fall wasn't witnessed, he was found roughly two minutes later. At the ER, tests including a CT scan and EKG returned normal results. He was then referred back to his primary care manager (PCM), who ordered an MRI with and without contrast. The MRI revealed the presence of an acoustic neuroma. Through my investigation, it appears that many of his symptoms—headaches, pressure sensations, dizziness, and cognitive fog—could be linked to this condition. We are currently awaiting a follow-up appointment with his PCM for a specialist referral. I want to ensure that he is equipped to advocate for himself during this process. Considering his MRI results and associated symptoms, should we seek the expertise of a specialist familiar with acoustic neuroma? I am concerned that our small-town ENT may not have extensive experience with this issue, and I want to avoid a mere monitoring approach if more proactive treatment is advisable. With a busy family and an active lifestyle, his symptoms over these past months have certainly impacted him, as well as our family dynamics and his professional duties. I would greatly appreciate any insights regarding treatment options or specialist locations you might be able to share. Thank you!
Persistent Right Ear Discomfort: Seeking Insights After A Year
Hello everyone, I’m a 33-year-old man residing in the beautiful region of Western Australia. I generally maintain a healthy lifestyle and have no significant medical concerns. In my younger years, I was an avid surfer, but now I find myself in the rural Pilbara area where opportunities for surfing are nonexistent, along with access to medical professionals. I occasionally indulge in kitesurfing here, always equipped with earplugs for protection. Since January 2025, I’ve been dealing with persistent pain and discomfort in my right ear. It all began after I spent a week enjoying freestyle swimming in the ocean in Perth. I initially consulted a doctor there who prescribed Kenacomb for swimmer's ear, but it didn’t yield any improvement. Upon returning to the Pilbara, I sought another doctor's advice, who prescribed a similar antibiotic ear drop, which also failed to provide relief. Despite my continuous visits, the physician kept increasing the potency of the ear drops until I finally insisted on seeing a specialist. Six months later, I traveled back to Perth for an ENT appointment, only to find the specialist unhelpful. Utilizing AI for diagnosis, he was unable to identify any issues and recommended an MRI, which ultimately showed no abnormalities. At a follow-up appointment three months later, the only solution he proposed was a prescription for antidepressants, which I declined. I then sought out another ear specialist in Perth, who similarly declared my ear visually healthy with no apparent issues. While in Perth for my appointments, I had a dental check-up, during which my dentist pointed out that I grind my teeth and provided me with a mouthguard to wear nightly. Another physician suggested that I might have TMJ disorder, so I received Botox injections in my right jaw muscle. Though these interventions offered some relief, the core issue still persisted. Curious about my condition, I purchased an otoscope camera to inspect my ear. To my surprise, I discovered an inflamed surfers ear growth located near the eardrum. Poking at it revealed that it very well might be the source of my discomfort. Despite this growth occupying only a quarter of the ear canal, it does not impair my hearing. The discomfort peaks in the mornings, manifesting as a sharp, stabbing sensation radiating from my right ear to the crown of my skull. However, once I rise and start my day, the pain noticeably diminishes. Additionally, I am aware of persistent tinnitus in that ear. Has anyone else encountered similar issues, or do you have any advice? I appreciate any thoughts you may have. Unfortunately, I cannot upload a photo as the application restricts that functionality.
Blood in Urine: Seeking Guidance
A 20-year-old female weighing 140 pounds has not been taking any medications or supplements, and has no prior or current medical conditions. Her menstrual cycle last occurred two weeks ago. While at work, she observed blood in her urine, which appeared light red but darker than pink. Accompanying this symptom, she has experienced some abdominal discomfort. Notably, there was no evidence of blood on her underwear, only when she urinated. Additionally, she felt a moment of lightheadedness upon noticing the blood, which has since subsided; she attributes this feeling to her anxiety about the potential seriousness of the situation. Given these symptoms, what could be the likely cause? She is uncertain whether to visit the emergency room or to wait until urgent care is available tomorrow for a consultation. As she recently relocated and does not have a primary care physician yet, her anxiety is heightened.
Exploring Endolymphatic Hydrops: Could This Be My Condition?
34 years old / Female Current weight: 165 lbs Navigating the challenges of motherhood In early December 2025, I caught a cold. By mid-December, my right ear felt blocked, but I attributed it to the cold virus. As New Year approached, I experienced another cold, which coincided with an onset of ringing in my ears. Disturbingly, sounds started to seem altered from the affected ear, accompanied by a persistent fullness in that area. Additionally, I noticed twitching of my eye and swelling in the salivary gland on the same side. My primary care physician prescribed a decongestant and Flonase; however, because I am currently breastfeeding, I hesitated to take the medications as directed. On January 27, I was evaluated by an ear, nose, and throat specialist, who requested a hearing assessment the following day. The results indicated that I had sensorineural hearing loss affecting my low-frequency hearing range (250 Hz to 500 Hz). The doctor prescribed a steroid with the hope of addressing the issue promptly. Now on day 10 of steroid treatment, I have experienced significant relief. Remarkably, I've noticed a substantial amount of thick, putty-like mucus clearing from my nasal passages. The pressure in my ear has subsided, and sounds are returning to normal, though I still perceive a slight ringing — possibly just a touch of hearing loss remains. What concerns me is whether ongoing sinus congestion could be the root of these symptoms or if I might genuinely be dealing with endolymphatic hydrops. Notably, I have not experienced any episodes of dizziness. In the evenings, I tend to feel considerable pressure building on the right side of my head, almost as if my sinuses are becoming blocked once more. I would greatly appreciate any insights or advice on this matter, as I find myself in a state of uncertainty regarding my condition.
Gene Testing Outcomes Suggest Elevated Risk for MPN
A 27-year-old male of Irish heritage recently conducted a commercial gene analysis, and here are the findings: - **Rs12340895 (C;G)** Result Interpretation: "Doubles the likelihood of developing V617F-positive MPN." - **Rs3780374 (A;G)** Result Interpretation: "Significantly raises the probability of V617F-positive MPN manifestation." Based on my research, it appears that having these two genetic markers indicates a strong predisposition to this particular form of cancer. What steps should I consider taking to either prepare for or potentially postpone the onset of this condition? Should I discuss these findings with my healthcare provider? My studies suggest there isn’t a definitive cure for this condition.