Do Physicians Deceive for Patient Benefit?
Recently, I encountered an unusual situation with a gynecologist. The interaction was surprising and made me think about the relationship between patient care and honesty. It raised the question: do healthcare professionals sometimes use a little deception for the sake of a patient's well-being? Such situations can provoke a range of emotions and lead to interesting discussions about ethics in medicine. While one might expect complete transparency from their doctor, the reality can be more complex, especially when the intention is to protect or aid the patient in some way.
Answers (1)
2/17/2026, 2:10:38 AM
OpenHealth AI
The relationship between physicians and their patients is built on trust, and this trust often relies on the expectation of honesty. However, the question of whether healthcare professionals might sometimes use deception for a patient’s benefit is indeed a complex and sensitive topic.
Understanding the Dilemma:
-
Ethical Considerations: Physicians are guided by ethical principles that prioritize patient well-being, autonomy, and informed consent. While complete transparency is generally expected, there are scenarios where doctors might withhold certain information if they believe it would cause unnecessary distress or harm.
-
Motivation Behind Deception: In some cases, a physician's intention to protect a patient—such as conveying overly harsh realities of a diagnosis—could lead them to use softer language or emphasize positive outcomes. This is often referred to as "therapeutic privilege."
What This Means for Patients:
-
Emotional Impact: Encountering unexpected or non-transparent behavior from a healthcare provider can naturally evoke various emotions, including confusion or frustration. It's important to acknowledge these feelings as valid responses to potentially unsettling experiences in the healthcare relationship.
-
The Need for Trust: The cornerstone of effective healthcare is trust. If a patient feels misled, it can undermine their relationship with their physician, which may affect their willingness to engage openly in their care.
Next Steps for You:
-
Reflect on Your Experience: Consider what specific interactions led to your feelings about possible deception. Understanding your emotions and thoughts can provide clarity on what you value in patient care.
-
Open Communication: If you feel comfortable, discuss your thoughts and feelings about this incident with your gynecologist or another healthcare provider. Open conversations can help address concerns, clarify intentions, and rebuild trust.
-
Education on Ethics in Medicine: Familiarizing yourself with the principles of medical ethics can be beneficial. Many resources are available online to help you understand the delicate balance between honesty and compassion in patient care.
-
Consider Your Care Choices: If ongoing concerns about transparency arise, you might consider seeking a second opinion or exploring other healthcare providers who align more closely with your expectations for communication and honesty.
It's normal to feel conflicted about these experiences. Engaging with your healthcare provider and seeking clarity can empower you in your health journey. If you wish to discuss this topic further or have specific concerns about your care, feel free to share!
Related Questions
Could I Have Injured a Nerve in My Hand?
I'm an 18-year-old female and about one to two months ago, I accidentally struck the palm of my hand beneath my pinky finger. Initially, the impact caused a burning sensation, which quickly escalated to a profound tingling feeling that eventually subsided. Lately, however, I've observed that this area has become increasingly sensitive; for instance, when I attempt to push myself off a chair, I sometimes experience a sudden return of tingling in the same region where I was hurt, followed by discomfort. Additionally, I've noticed that this spot can become quite warm, especially when I change my position in bed. Just this morning, I detected a pulsing sensation in that area. Although it hasn’t been bothersome enough to seek medical advice, I'm curious to hear what others think about this condition and whether it’s something I can just let be or if I should be concerned.
Unusual Sensation Post-Surgery
I am a 48-year-old woman, standing at 5 feet 4 inches and weighing 135 pounds, generally in good health. My routine medications include Effexor at a dose of 225 mg, Trazodone 150 mg, and Atorvastatin 20 mg. Occasionally, I take Ambien 5 mg for sleep, but it’s not a regular habit. Currently, I am four days post-op from a bilateral prophylactic mastectomy, which was performed without preserving the nipples. As advised, I am taking the maximum daily dosage of ibuprofen and acetaminophen, and I have been prescribed Kedlex 500 mg to take four times a day until tomorrow. I also use oxycodone sporadically for any sharp pain that arises. While I anticipated experiencing some numbness in my chest area following the surgery, I am mostly feeling well and healing nicely, aside from a few twinges of discomfort around one of the surgical ports, which doesn't concern me. However, I am noticing an unusual sensation in the back right side of my head. It’s not fully numb, but it feels as if only part of the nerves are functioning when I touch that area. Interestingly, my ear seems unaffected, yet the remainder of that section feels strangely muted. My facial sensations remain normal. Could anyone provide insight into this odd experience?
Week 7 of Pleurisy Suffering
A 36-year-old woman weighing 200 pounds with a history of transient ischemic attacks is experiencing intense chest discomfort rated 7 out of 10, persisting for seven weeks. Since the beginning of the year, I've been trapped in a cycle of severe pain that I thought would ease after a course of antibiotics. Initially, the pain was unrelenting, but after a brief treatment with a Z-pack, it transformed into painful flare-ups occurring every few days. I believed I was on the mend, but today the agony returned so fiercely that I found myself in tears before my family. I've visited the hospital twice recently, only to feel dismissed by the rural emergency room doctors. Now, I am attempting to endure this without seeking immediate help again, although it's proving to be incredibly challenging. My symptoms began on January 1st, starting with a sore throat that quickly escalated to chest pain. Taking deep breaths became painful, and I began to experience overwhelming feelings of doom at night, accompanied by an inability to fully inhale. At that time, I did not have a cough or a runny nose; I suspect I contracted an infection after my daughter had RSV just a week earlier. On January 10th, I went to urgent care, where I underwent an X-ray and an EKG. The doctors did not provide a diagnosis and advised me to reach out to my primary care provider (PCP) for an appointment later in the month. However, by January 19th, the pain intensified to the point where I feared something serious was wrong, prompting me to visit the emergency room. I have a history of stroke from when I was eight, which was accompanied by migraines—managed with medication that I stopped taking in my teenage years due to my parents not keeping up with it. When I arrived at the hospital, I informed the staff about my previous blood clot issues and requested tests for a possible pulmonary embolism. They conducted another series of X-rays, a CT scan, an EKG, and a stress test, all of which returned normal results. The doctors noted unusual findings with my thyroid and observed two small, round glass-like nodules at the base of each lung, recommending future testing. Unfortunately, my visit concluded without any specific diagnosis—just the label of unspecified pain—and I was sent home. Desperate for relief, I tried another nearby hospital. I explained my situation, but after another round of tests, including an ultrasound of my chest, it was determined I had a small pulmonary effusion. The doctor reassured me that it was minor and would resolve on its own, advising me to follow up with my PCP. Upon visiting my PCP, she confirmed the effusion and prescribed steroids to alleviate inflammation. Unfortunately, this did not bring relief, and the pain persisted, leading me back to the ER. The physician's assistant was unsympathetic, questioning me about intravenous drug use and presumptively dismissing my condition before I was even formally registered. He contradicted the earlier findings, claiming I had pleurisy instead, with an expectation for it to resolve naturally. Returning to my PCP for further help, she finally prescribed a Z-pack and assured me that if my pain continued, she would refer me to a lung specialist. I completed the antibiotic course last week, hopeful for improvement, but I am still grappling with pain. I reached out to her office today—only to learn that due to the overwhelming backlog, I won’t be able to see her for a referral until April. Now, here I am in my seventh week of distress, questioning whether this is how my life will be from now on, and struggling with the idea of being a parent while just wishing I could curl up and escape it all. Below are some of my abnormal blood test results. I apologize if there are any repetitive items, as I’m flipping through my medical records. Any advice or insights from others who have dealt with pleurisy would be immensely appreciated. **Abnormal Lab Findings:** - **WBC**: 18.1 - **MVC**: 76.9 - **MHC**: 22.8 - **MCHC**: 29.6 - **RDW**: 15.3 - **AST**: 10 - **Alkaline Phosphatase**: 186 - **Reactive Lymphocytes**: 11% - **Neutrophils (Absolute)**: 9.24 - **Immature Granulocytes (Absolute)**: 0.35 - **Morphology**: Abnormal - **D-dimer**: 724 - **Platelet Count**: 452
Desperate for Answers
**Age:** 21 **Gender:** Female **Height:** 170 cm **Weight:** 140 lbs **Ethnicity:** White **Duration of Symptoms:** Lifelong **Location:** Tennessee, United States **Relevant Medical History:** **Current Treatments:** Cymbalta (90 mg), Nextellis From childhood into adulthood, I have endured unexplained suffering, with no healthcare professional able to uncover the root of my issues. These struggles began when I was around six years old and have progressively worsened; at 21, I find myself at an all-time low. Below is a compilation of my symptoms: - **Chronic Joint Pain:** My nerve pain began in my ankles during childhood and has now spread to my hips and arms. I manage this with 90 mg of Cymbalta, which was initially effective but has since lost much of its potency. - **Exhaustion and Cognitive Difficulties:** When not on Cymbalta, I am rendered nearly immobile due to extreme fatigue, accompanied by brain fog and restless nights. Dizziness adds to my struggles, making daily activities a challenge. - **Nerve Sensations and Numbness:** Before adjusting my Cymbalta dosage, I often experienced my legs giving way unexpectedly, both while standing or seated. The painful pins and needles sensation, coupled with numbness, is intense enough to bring me to tears. Given my high pain threshold, this doesn't seem normal to me. - **Menstrual Complications:** After starting hormonal contraception (Nextellis), I found relief from many symptoms. In its absence, I suffer from severe mood swings, suicidal thoughts, fatigue, and painful menstruation, during which I may pass a tissue as large as a fist. - **Migraines:** This recent development has added to my woes. While I frequently had painful headaches as a child, these have now escalated to crippling migraines, often preventing me from even opening my eyes in the morning due to the pain. Despite undergoing various routine tests, nothing unusual has been discovered: - **Brain MRI:** No abnormalities found. - **ANA Test:** Positive at 1:80 with nuclear, homogeneous, and cytoplasmic patterns. - **Nutritional Deficiencies:** No issues present. - **Localized Pain:** The discomfort appears specifically in joint areas (ankles, knees, hips, and elbows). - **Hip X-rays:** Indicate slight deterioration. I am reaching out in desperation for guidance on what steps I should take next. I have consulted more than ten doctors and have been advised to seek strength through various methods—stretching, yoga, multi-vitamins, prayers, you name it. This prolonged ordeal has drained me, and I am beginning to believe that my local medical professionals may not be able to assist. Any suggestions or insights would be immensely appreciated.
What Could This Swollen Lymph Node Indicate?
At 22 years old and weighing 134 pounds, I recently discovered a lymph node that has me concerned. It's a small, round, painless bump, approximately the size of a pea, and I can easily move it around. I'm uncertain if this is what’s known as a Virchow node. Interestingly, I had scratched my neck a few hours before noticing this swollen gland, which caused some bleeding and swelling in the area above it. I'm seeking insights into what this lymph node might signify.