Comparing DOs and MDs: Which Should You Choose?
As a 6'1" man weighing approximately 280 pounds, I'm currently in the process of arranging a visit to a colorectal surgeon, as I suspect I may have a fistula. My general practitioner referred me to a gastroenterologist, however, individuals who have experienced similar issues have advised me that a CRS is more suitable for this condition. Fortunately, my insurance allows for self-referrals, so I'm eager to set up an appointment with a colorectal specialist. I'm curious about the distinctions between a Doctor of Osteopathy (DO) and a Doctor of Medicine (MD). Does one offer better care than the other? Are there any significant disadvantages to choosing one over the other?
Answers (1)
2/15/2026, 11:00:46 PM
OpenHealth AI
Both Doctors of Osteopathy (DOs) and Doctors of Medicine (MDs) are fully qualified physicians capable of diagnosing and treating a variety of health conditions. However, they do have distinct training philosophies and approaches. Here’s a simplified comparison to help you understand the differences and choose the right specialist for your needs:
Main Points:
- Training & Philosophy: DOs emphasize a holistic approach, considering the body as a whole. They receive additional training in the musculoskeletal system and practice osteopathic manipulative treatment. MDs typically focus on conventional, evidence-based medical practices.
- Scope of Practice: Both DOs and MDs can prescribe medication, perform surgery, and specialize in any field of medicine, including colorectal surgery.
- Personal Preference: The choice may come down to personal comfort with a physician's approach and philosophy of care.
Explanation:
- DOs and MDs both complete medical school and can practice in all medical specialties. After obtaining their degrees, they complete residencies in their chosen fields, which can be the same for both types of physicians.
- The key distinction lies in their training. DOs learn additional techniques in holistic patient care and body mechanics while MDs focus more on acute care, research, and diagnosis.
- For specific conditions like a fistula, both DOs and MDs are qualified to provide care. It may be beneficial to consider the individual physician's experience in colorectal issues rather than solely focusing on the degree.
Next Steps:
- Research Specialists: Look for colorectal surgeons (CRS) who have experience with fistulas and check their credentials, reviews, and approach to treatment.
- Schedule Consultations: If you're able to, meet with both a DO and an MD specializing in colorectal surgery to discuss their treatment philosophies. This can help you gauge which approach feels more comfortable for you.
- Trust Your Instincts: Choose the physician you feel most confident in, as the doctor-patient relationship plays a vital role in your healthcare experience.
It's great that you're being proactive about your health. Both types of physicians can offer excellent care, so focus on finding someone who understands your specific needs and concerns.
Related Questions
Concerns with Eye Care Provider
At 24 years old, I have been managing binocular vision disorder with prism glasses for over a year, which have significantly improved my daily life. Recently, I found it necessary to obtain an updated prescription due to a resurgence of my symptoms. Unfortunately, my usual eye doctor was unavailable, so I consulted with a resident at the clinic. While I did receive a new prescription, the crucial detail regarding the base direction of the prisms was omitted. Once I noticed this, I reached out to the resident to request the missing information, as it is essential for me to order my new glasses. To my dismay, her response was dismissive, stating that all required details were included in the prescription and implying that if I required further clarification, I was the one misunderstanding the document. Now, I find myself in a difficult position—I need that specific information to proceed with acquiring my glasses, but I feel as though my inquiries are met with hostility. It has left me uncertain about how to proceed. Should I seek a second opinion from another eye care professional? I’m truly conflicted about what steps to take next.
Concerns After High Dosage of Paracetamol Taken 48 Hours Ago
Approximately two days ago, I mistakenly ingested an estimated 6000 to 7000 milligrams of paracetamol (also known as acetaminophen). My body weight is roughly 80 kilograms. Should I be alarmed by this quantity in relation to my weight? Are there potential delayed effects that could manifest after this time period? Would it be advisable to wait until morning for a medical evaluation, or should I pursue immediate healthcare assistance?
Seeking Assistance for a Persistent Facial Rash
As a 25-year-old woman, I have been dealing with a facial rash for several years. Despite consulting a dermatologist and attempting various treatments, nothing has proven effective. At present, my rash has intensified, although it typically appears less inflamed and more subdued in color. My ongoing medications include levothyroxine and Apri. For skincare, I utilize Vanicream both for cleansing and moisturizing my face.
Seeking Clarification on Medical Terminology
The report indicates that there is a slight irregularity in the white matter of my brain, described as minimal punctate lesions. This finding is not particularly specific and appears slightly more than what would typically be anticipated for my age. It is advised that this should be evaluated alongside clinical symptoms, and follow-up imaging in a year is suggested for further assessment. As a 29-year-old female, I found myself urgently hospitalized after experiencing my first seizure, which required an ambulance for immediate care.
Struggling to Communicate with My Doctor
Today, I attended a medical appointment to receive my medication injections, but I faced a significant communication barrier. Recently, I've been informed by others that my English can be difficult to comprehend, which is perplexing since I am a native speaker. There shouldn’t be any reason for my speech to be unintelligible. The staff mentioned that I spoke too quickly, leading to confusion, and they couldn’t allocate time for my concerns today. Consequently, I now have to return tomorrow solely for the purpose of clarifying my needs. Honestly, I find this situation quite frustrating and unclear.