Is It Common for Medical Students to Observe Invasive Procedures Without My Consent?
Recently, I underwent a gynecological operation that required general anesthesia. Before the procedure, I anticipated the presence of key medical personnel such as the surgeon, anesthesiologist, and nursing staff. However, upon entering the operating room, I was surprised to find several medical students in attendance as well. While I was quickly sedated, I distinctly remember how the students appeared to observe me as if I were an object of study rather than a person. This sensation was unsettling. They did not introduce themselves or even greet me before the procedure began, which contributed to my discomfort. When I regained consciousness after surgery, I was in tears. At first, I attributed my emotional response to their scrutinizing gazes as I was wheeled in. However, upon reflection, I realized it also troubled me that I had not given permission for these students to witness the insertion of a catheter and an ultrasound into my body. Is it normal practice for students to observe such intimate procedures without explicit consent? It’s important to note that this wasn't at a teaching hospital, and their presence wasn't essential for my care. I fully acknowledge the need for medical training, but I recall an instance with a different physician who consulted me beforehand about a trainee's presence when I had a minor procedure on my foot. She sensitively asked for my consent before allowing the trainee to join. - Age: 33 - Approximate height & weight: 5'5", 135 lbs - Gender: Female - Medications: None - Smoking status: Non-smoker - Previous and current medical issues: Elective surgery - Duration and location of complaint: Elective surgery
Answers (1)
2/15/2026, 9:30:35 AM
OpenHealth AI
It’s understandable to feel uncomfortable about the presence of medical students during your procedure, especially without being informed or asked for your consent. In many healthcare settings, including teaching hospitals, it's common for students to observe procedures as part of their training, but patient consent should always be prioritized and respected.
Key Points:
- Patient Consent: Informed consent is crucial before any medical procedure. This includes not only consent for the procedure itself but also for the presence of students or trainees. Ideally, medical staff should explain who will be present and obtain your permission.
- Respect and Awareness: It’s concerning that you felt like an object of study and that the students did not introduce themselves. This can significantly impact the emotional wellbeing of patients, and it's valid to feel unsettled by this experience.
Next Steps:
-
Feedback to the Hospital: Consider providing feedback to the healthcare facility regarding your experience. Sharing your feelings can help improve the practice of obtaining patient consent for the presence of observers and enhance sensitivity training for medical students.
-
Know Your Rights: Familiarize yourself with your rights as a patient. Generally, you have the right to ask about who will be involved in your care and to decline the presence of additional observers if you're uncomfortable.
-
Support Your Emotional Wellbeing: It’s okay to feel upset about this experience. If these feelings persist or interfere with your daily life, consider talking to a counselor or therapist who can help you process your emotions.
-
In the Future: For any upcoming medical procedures, don’t hesitate to ask explicit questions about who will be present and express your preferences regarding observers. This sets a precedent for your care and reinforces your comfort and autonomy.
Your feelings are important, and voicing concerns about your care can contribute to better practices in the healthcare system.
Related Questions
Assessing the Implications of Peptoniphius Harei
At 62 years old, I face the challenges of lupus alongside various other health complications. Recently, I underwent hip replacement surgery, during which I developed a cyst located near my vagina on my buttocks. This cyst became infected shortly after my surgery, and while I'm unsure if there's a connection to the hip procedure, I think it's important to mention it. I initially consulted my primary care physician, who attempted to drain the infection and prescribed an antibiotic. He advised that if the issue persisted, I should see a gynecologist. About ten days later, I visited a gynecologist, who also tried to drain the cyst and took a sample for testing. She indicated that the sample size was quite small but expressed hope that it would yield the necessary information. Over the weekend, I received notification on the patient portal regarding the test results, revealing that Peptoniphius harei had been detected. The information I've found regarding this bacterium varies significantly: some sources indicate it's a minor concern, while others suggest that it may necessitate hospitalization. I expect to learn more tomorrow when the gynecologist reviews the findings. This raises a question for me: should I be discussing this situation with my rheumatologist? In the past, I've had mixed experiences with the coordination of my medical care. Nevertheless, I hesitate to inform my rheumatologist about every minor issue and try to reserve communication for matters that truly require her attention.
Exploring Wilson Disease Concerns Regarding KF Rings (M/28)
Hello there! I recently underwent a blood test that revealed low ceruloplasmin levels, which was prompted by high liver enzyme readings. For some time now, I've been dealing with various vague symptoms, including fatigue and neurological difficulties. As a next step, my physician has requested that I provide a 24-hour urine sample for further analysis. I’m a bit curious about my eyes and whether they appear normal; I have a feeling that the upper section looks somewhat unusual. I understand I need to be patient and await a thorough examination, but I can’t help but feel anxious about it. I really appreciate any insights. For context, my height is 1.58 meters, and I currently weigh 89 kilograms. Here are some of my diagnosed health conditions: - Chronic migraines - Slow transit syndrome - Hypothyroidism - Insulin resistance Additionally, I have some potential diagnoses pending, such as mitochondrial disease or congenital Myasthenia Gravis syndrome, for which I’m waiting on genetic testing. Thankfully, my symptoms of Myasthenia have been manageable with Mestinon.
Unexplained Geometric Mark on My Friend's Back: Seeking Serious Advice
Hello, medical experts of Reddit, I have a friend, a 28-year-old male from Australia, who has discovered a peculiar geometric red design on his back. While some internet conversations suggest it could be related to alien encounters, I’m hoping for a more serious and medically informed analysis. He engages in occasional drinking and smoking and has Coeliac disease. Recently, he has been supplementing his diet with Swiss vitamins including Vitamin C, magnesium, zinc, a sleep aid, and calcium. Given the unusual nature of this mark, we’re puzzled about its origin, especially since we can’t identify any surfaces or materials he may have been resting against that could explain this impression. Any insights you could share would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!
Should I Be Concerned About My Gallbladder Polyp Diagnosis?
I’m a 21-year-old male, standing at 5'5" and weighing 117 pounds. Currently, I’m studying abroad, which has complicated my understanding of the medical details due to a language barrier with my doctors. While I managed to grasp some critical information regarding my health, I’m left uncertain about the severity of my diagnosis concerning an irregular gallbladder polyp. From my perspective, it seemed like a low-risk situation since they conducted a blood test that came back normal, prescribed some medication, and provided little else in guidance. However, my research online suggests that my polyp is quite large, measuring approximately 2cm by 1cm. It’s concerning because, prior to the tests, the doctor did bring up the possibility of cancer, which has increased my anxiety about the situation. Should I be worried? Additionally, I began taking PrEP a couple of weeks ago, and I’ve heard from others experiencing similar side effects to mine, although none of them mentioned gallbladder issues or polyps. Is there a chance these could be connected? To provide more context, I’ve been dealing with significant stomach pain, which is starting to fade without any medication. I also experienced a brief but intense dizziness after lunch that lasted for about 3 to 5 minutes.
Persistent Hand Eczema: Seeking Solutions for Ongoing Condition
My mother, aged 53, stands at about 5 feet 4 inches (162 cm) tall and weighs 145 pounds (66 kg). She does not smoke or consume alcohol and has no chronic health issues other than her current skin concern. She has not reported any known allergies and is not taking regular medications aside from topical creams that have previously been recommended for her eczema. For several months, possibly even longer, she has been struggling with persistent eczema on her hands. This condition manifests as extreme dryness, severe itching, irritation, and frequent cracking, significantly hampering her ability to perform daily tasks. Despite her consistent use of moisturizers and previous attempts with prescribed steroid creams, her condition never seems to fully resolve, often returning without warning. Given that she frequently engages in household chores where her hands come into contact with water and various cleaning agents, we are starting to question whether this could be indicative of chronic hand eczema, contact dermatitis, an allergic reaction, or even a fungal infection. We are eager to understand what diagnostic tests or treatment options may be suggested when hand eczema proves stubborn and resistant to treatment, including the possibility of patch testing, fungal cultures, or exploring alternative treatment methods.