64-Year-Old Patient with Large Renal Tumor: Surgical vs. Neoadjuvant Treatment Discrepancy Among Institutions
Greetings, I'm reaching out for a medical opinion regarding my uncle, who is 64 years old. Recent imaging via CT has revealed a significant mass on the left kidney, measuring around 14 to 15 cm, and there are accompanying indications of regional lymph node involvement. Fortunately, there are no signs of distant spread to the liver, bones, or lungs thus far, although we are awaiting results from a brain MRI. His overall health status remains stable. He does not have any notable comorbid conditions. He previously smoked but quit around 24 years ago. In recent weeks, he has experienced weight loss, fatigue, and a diminished appetite, leading to the imaging that prompted his diagnosis. We have consulted two prominent oncology centers, but their proposed treatment plans vary significantly: - At Center A, the recommendation from the oncologist and cardiologist is to proceed with a radical nephrectomy immediately, without conducting a biopsy beforehand. They argue that at the size of this tumor, relying solely on systemic treatment would be inadequate and that undergoing a biopsy could pose risks such as bleeding or potential tumor seeding. - Conversely, Center B advises starting with a biopsy, followed by discussions among a multidisciplinary tumor board. Their approach may involve initiating systemic therapies—such as immunotherapy or targeted treatments—before contemplating surgical intervention, suggesting that advancements in treatment could potentially diminish the tumor burden before a high-risk surgery takes place. The critical issue we're facing is this: In a suspected stage III case of significant renal mass, which is technically operable and currently lacks evidence of distant metastasis, is it still customary to pursue primary surgical intervention? Or is the trend shifting towards favoring neoadjuvant systemic therapy in such scenarios? We are trying to ascertain whether opting for immediate surgery or beginning with systemic treatment aligns more closely with contemporary international treatment guidelines. Thank you in advance for any insights you can provide on this matter.
Answers (1)
2/13/2026, 10:31:01 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel overwhelmed by the treatment options available for your uncle's significant renal tumor. The decision between immediate surgery and starting with systemic therapies is crucial and reflects current practices in the management of renal cell carcinoma (RCC).
Key Points:
- Tumor Size and Stage: The tumor is large (14-15 cm) and likely classified as Stage III due to regional lymph node involvement.
- Current Recommendations: There are differing opinions on whether to proceed with immediate surgery (radical nephrectomy) or to start with a biopsy followed by systemic therapy.
Explanation:
-
Surgical Intervention: Traditional treatment for localized RCC is radical nephrectomy, especially when there's no evidence of distant metastasis. This approach eliminates the tumor and affected kidney, and it can offer a definitive solution. Immediate surgery is favored in many cases for large tumors, particularly when they are deemed operable.
-
Neoadjuvant Therapy: In recent years, there has been a growing focus on using neoadjuvant systemic therapy (like immunotherapy or targeted therapy) to shrink large tumors prior to surgery. This strategy aims to reduce tumor burden, potentially making surgery easier and safer, and it may also help in cases where there is a risk of aggressive disease.
Next Steps:
-
Consultation with a Urologic Oncologist: It's critical that your uncle discusses his situation with a specialized urologic oncologist who can weigh the benefits of each approach considering his health and specific tumor characteristics.
-
Multidisciplinary Tumor Board Discussion: Engaging a multidisciplinary team that includes urologic surgeons, medical oncologists, and radiologists can provide a comprehensive approach to the treatment strategy. They can review imaging and pathology to ensure the best course is taken.
-
Consider a Clinical Trial: Explore whether there are clinical trials available that weigh the risk/benefit of neoadjuvant therapy against immediate surgery. This could provide access to cutting-edge treatments and contribute to valuable research.
-
Follow-Up on Health Status: Continually monitor your uncle’s overall health, noting any changes in weight, appetite, or energy levels, and ensure he remains supported throughout this process.
-
Emotional and Psychological Support: Consider providing your uncle with resources for emotional support, as the journey through cancer treatment can be both physically and mentally taxing.
Each patient's situation is unique, so it's important to tailor the treatment plan to your uncle's specific needs and preferences. Please reach out if you need further clarification on this topic or support navigating the healthcare system.
Related Questions
Experiencing Intense Dizziness Upon Waking (27F)
In the past month, I’ve encountered a troubling issue twice after awakening flat on my back. Upon opening my eyes, it feels as if the entire room is swaying, and attempting to sit up results in almost losing my balance. My vision seems to flicker uncontrollably, making it impossible to focus, compelling me to simply shut my eyes and wait for it to subside. Thankfully, these episodes typically resolve within a few minutes. However, during the second incident, I felt a wave of nausea and experienced significant trembling afterwards. I’m not currently on any medication and I do not have any known medical conditions. Can anyone offer insights into what might be causing this? Is it advisable for me to consult a healthcare professional?
Seeking Insights: Unexplained Symptoms During Luteal Phase
**Demographic Information:** - Female, 46 years of age - Height: 165 cm - Weight: 87 kg - Ethnicity: Caucasian (based in Australia) - Non-smoker, no illicit drug use, infrequent alcohol consumption. **The Concern:** The symptoms manifest exclusively during the luteal phase and can be tracked from day 17 up until menstruation begins. These episodes have consistently appeared monthly since September 8 of the previous year. I will include some medical background at the bottom, which could provide context, though it may not be directly relevant. **Description of Symptoms:** - Symptoms resemble those of hypoglycemia, although my Continuous Glucose Monitor (CGM) indicates otherwise; also, I am not diabetic. - I experience more frequent dizziness, especially when changing posture, alongside heart palpitations. The intensity escalates around days 19-21 of my cycle. - On day 19, the following symptoms typically intensify: pronounced dizziness, heightened heart palpitations, a sensation of pressure in the chest, elevated heart rate (20 bpm above normal levels), impaired vision, dry mouth, extreme fatigue, fainting sensations, compromised cognitive functions, lack of coordination, and difficulty speaking. - In severe incidents—which necessitate calling for emergency help—my body can become immobilized. I have found myself needing to lean heavily on a shopping cart, unable to control my legs, and ultimately collapsing to the floor while remaining partially conscious. During these moments, I focus on regulating my breathing despite feeling starved for air and trying to prevent hyperventilation. - Moderate to severe episodes typically ramp up in intensity around mid-morning and can last several hours, diminishing by the afternoon (around 3-4 PM). **Observational Data:** - Home blood pressure readings and monitoring by paramedics consistently indicate normal or slightly low blood pressure. - Blood glucose levels are generally stable, except for one incident in the hospital where hypoglycemia occurred a few hours after eating. - Heart rate fluctuations are minimal, with no occurrences of tachycardia or bradycardia (increased rates around 20-30 bpm). - Hospitalized cardiac assessments and blood tests for any heart damage have all yielded normal results. - Results from a 24-hour Holter monitor did not raise any alarms. - My current CGM data confirm stable glucose levels throughout episodes, which aligns with handheld glucose readings. - The CGM has highlighted rapid glucose fluctuations following carbohydrate intake, prompting me to adjust my diet accordingly, aiming for more stable glucose levels. Nonetheless, these fluctuations occasionally mimic hypoglycemic reactions. - Symptoms appear to worsen with the use of progesterone HRT; I abstained from it this month and still experienced symptoms. **Completed Tests:** - Hormonal assessments during the mid-luteal phase returned balanced results, but it's uncertain whether levels are sufficient. - ACTH, aldosterone/renin levels, fasting glucose, insulin, HBA1C, and prolactin were all within normal ranges. - Kidney evaluations show an oscillation in eGFR related to symptom severity, with creatinine increasing and GFR decreasing during severe episodes (GFR values range from 67 to 89). - Hematological assessments show temporary changes during symptomatic events returning to baseline later, with minor fluctuations considered normal post-incident. - PTH level is normal; sufficient for all vitamins assessed (A, E, B1, B6, folate, B12). Homocysteine is slightly elevated. Blood counts demonstrate no issues. - Vitamin D was measured at 186 nmol/L. Iron levels following an injection three months ago were noted to be at the lower end; a second injection is planned soon. Remaining iron studies indicate positive results. Copper and zinc levels are balanced and regularly supplemented. Thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) and Free T4 levels are normal, with negative TPO antibodies and ThAb at 22.2 IU/mL. A thyroid ultrasound in October 2024 showed no abnormalities. **Pending Test Results:** - Free T3 and rT3 levels. - Multi-point cortisol saliva test results. **My Thoughts and Speculations:** - If my symptoms were linked to fluctuations in cortisol or adrenaline, I would expect subsequent changes in glucose levels, contrary to the stability observed. - The significant impairment in leg function, motor control, and cognition during these episodes suggests they are not simple fight-or-flight responses. - I observe characteristics of reactive hypoglycemia in my daily food consumption and have considered insulin resistance as a possibility; still, I have never experienced post-meal hypoglycemia, only short-lived hyperglycemia followed by a quick drop. - The luteal phase is known to increase insulin resistance, leading to less stable glucose levels compared to the high estrogen phase. - Since symptoms progressively develop throughout the morning, I find it hard to label these occurrences as panic attacks since I do not experience a sensation of impending doom. - Anxiety attacks also do not fit the severity of these episodes. **Medical Background and Treatments:** - Underwent gastric sleeve surgery in May 2021; post-operative meals remain between 1/2 cup and 1 cup in size. - Currently undergoing evaluations for lipedema. - Notable changes in some lymph nodes over the past month, but likely unrelated; no ultrasounds performed yet. - Experienced MCAS-like symptoms for several months last year, likely related to estrogen HRT usage. Discontinuation of estrogen led to an apparent reduction in flare-ups by December 2025. - On a stable dose of 70mg Vyvanse daily for a year, it's evident that an increase in dosage might be needed during the luteal phase. - Maintain a low sodium diet (300-500mg daily) and began sodium supplementation about three weeks ago, raising daily intake to approx. 1g; fluid intake remains challenging, but increased sodium has reduced the frequency of urination to every 30-45 minutes. I am currently postponing a referral to an endocrinologist. Living in a smaller regional city means I'll face long public waitlists, with our local hospital having several years' worth of delays for non-urgent cases. Affording a private specialist is also beyond my means at the moment. Thank you to everyone who has taken the time to read through my post.
NEEDING URGENT HELP!
I'm a 22-year-old female, and I'm feeling quite let down by myself right now. For the past several hours, I’ve been consumed with worry and my mind is racing with the worst possible scenarios. About five hours ago, around 8:30 PM (it’s now 2 AM), I was attempting to straighten my motorcycle’s exhaust with a map gas torch for approximately 10-15 minutes. After around five minutes had elapsed, while my friend was holding the exhaust, I lost focus and instinctively grabbed the pipe for a brief moment. Although it was not extremely hot, it was noticeably warm. The outdoor temperature was a bit chilly, and I’m unsure if it affected the exhaust’s temperature. The skin on my fingers has changed a bit, displaying some slight white patches that resemble light charcoal flecks, but they’re barely noticeable in some spots. I ran the area under lukewarm water for roughly 10-15 minutes. As I write this, I do not feel any pain or burning sensation, and I can still feel sensations when I touch or slightly pinch my skin. The burn appears to be concentrated mostly on the mid-sections of my fingers, with some involvement on my upper left palm and the inside of my thumb. There’s no sign of blistering or anything. I would greatly appreciate any advice or assistance, especially knowing how challenging it is to access quality healthcare these days. To complicate matters, I’m in California and have had difficulties with MediCal, so I’m really hoping to avoid an urgent care visit or a trip to the ER. Any help would be immensely appreciated! Thank you!
Managing Foot and Toe Issues with Neuropathy
I apologize for the lengthy post. I’m a woman in my late forties. Neuropathy affects both of my legs and feet, with the left side being particularly severe. I also deal with several other health issues including postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), asthma, anxiety, depression, chronic migraines that have been relentless since November 2019, gluten intolerance, and scoliosis, among others that currently escape my memory. My medications are all managed by a single healthcare provider (though the spelling of some may be off). I haven't found anything effective for the neuropathy specifically, but my prescriptions include propranolol, midodrine, Zyrtec, Flonase, rizatriptan, and various vitamins. In the fall of 2022, I was hospitalized due to what was initially thought to be gastritis linked to my migraines. During that time, I lost over 30 pounds before it was discovered that I actually had a urinary tract infection that had progressed to septic. I spent 30 days in the hospital and experienced 2 to 3 weeks of memory loss, during which my neuropathy worsened, requiring me to use mobility aids. Starting in the fall of 2024, I began to faint unexpectedly. While doctors do not believe this is related to my POTS, other tests have returned as normal. The only noticeable correlation seems to be the stress from my ongoing divorce, as the fainting episodes typically occur after I've been busy packing or cleaning. Last summer, I experienced a minor mishap where I accidentally dropped my phone on my toe while sitting on the toilet. I didn’t realize anything was wrong until I noticed bruising, as I couldn't feel any pain. After visiting my doctor, I learned that my toe was fractured. When I followed up a few weeks later, it was confirmed that the fracture persisted. The divorce proceedings have been tumultuous, coupled with various other life challenges, so I haven’t attended any further follow-ups. While the bruising eventually faded, there remained a specific area that would ache occasionally, prompting me to occasionally pop the toe. About six weeks ago, I accidentally dropped something heavy on my foot. I only felt a slight twinge in one spot at the time, and I didn’t think much of it then. I assumed my foot was on the mend, but just yesterday, I began to feel discomfort in my toe again. It’s both painful and still makes a popping sensation, accompanied by new bruising on my foot. It’s a particularly hectic weekend for me, so I’m hesitant to spend time at urgent care. Do I need to have this checked out? I attempted to take a picture of the bruising, but it didn’t come out clearly.
Understanding Sensitivity to Stale Air
As a 28-year-old white male who stands 6 feet tall and weighs around 215 pounds, I deal with thyroid disease, which is well-managed through Synthroid. I have no other significant health concerns or medical history to report. Interestingly, I’ve noticed that I appear to be particularly susceptible to hot, stale air compared to most people. Whenever I find myself in a poorly ventilated room with no means to adjust the temperature, I often wake up with an extremely sore throat. In some instances, this discomfort has even progressed to what resembles a full-blown cold. What could be the explanation for this heightened sensitivity? Moreover, are there any recommendations or strategies I can adopt to mitigate these symptoms aside from altering the room’s temperature or opting for a different sleeping space?