Struggling with L4/5 Disc Herniation: Is Conservative Treatment Worth It?
Age 22, weighing 85kg and standing at 173cm. I realize this isn't medical advice. It all began with discomfort in my lower back, which led to corticosteroid injections. Unfortunately, this escalated to severe sciatica, landing me in the hospital for five days. Now, two weeks post-discharge, I'm still experiencing significant pain, despite being on strong pain relief medications. The surgeon indicated that surgery might be necessary if my condition doesn’t improve in six weeks while I follow a conservative treatment plan. I've just received an additional cortisone injection in the nerve root at the L5 level, as advised by my neurologist, anticipating that the pain might alleviate after a week. I continue to feel persistent pain in my leg, particularly behind the knee, in my thigh, calf, and ankle, coupled with numbness and limited toe movement. Although I can exert full strength during strength assessments of my legs and feet, I occasionally experience my ankle rolling when walking, which I suspect is due to diminished sensation. The specialist who administered the steroid injection didn’t express much optimism regarding its effectiveness. Everyone I consult seems to know someone who opted for surgery. Given my current situation and after hearing various experiences, I wonder if continuing this conservative strategy is futile. I was hesitant to undergo surgery, yet I dislike relying on painkillers while still struggling with intense discomfort—a consistent level of 5 to 7—even when at rest. Moreover, I face difficulties with bowel and bladder function due to pain from straining. I’m now two weeks into this waiting phase before the upcoming six-week evaluation. Based on what I've shared and your insights or experiences, do you believe pursuing conservative treatment is worth my time?
Answers (1)
2/10/2026, 11:50:39 PM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you are experiencing a challenging situation with your L4/5 disc herniation and the associated pain and sciatica. Many people in similar circumstances feel uncertain about the best path forward, especially when considering conservative versus surgical treatments.
Main Points:
- Conservative treatment is often the first line of management for disc herniation and can take time to show results.
- Monitoring symptoms is critical, especially with new or worsening signs.
- It’s important to focus on self-care strategies during this period to help manage your pain.
Explanation:
Disc herniation can lead to significant pain and, as you've experienced, sciatic symptoms affecting daily activities. Conservative treatments typically include physical therapy, medication, and possibly injections to reduce inflammation and pain. The goal during this treatment phase is to allow the body to heal naturally and determine if surgery is necessary based on your progress.
Given your current level of pain and discomfort, it’s understandable to question the effectiveness of conservative treatment. While surgery can provide relief for some, many individuals find success with non-surgical approaches. However, you are right to remain vigilant, particularly with the issues you're experiencing with bowel and bladder function, which may signal a more urgent need for evaluation.
Next Steps:
-
Keep a Symptom Diary: Track your pain levels, any changes in sensation, and how your bowel/bladder function is affected. This can help provide valuable information to your healthcare team at your next appointment.
-
Gentle Activity and Physical Therapy: Engage in light, guided physical activities that do not exacerbate your pain. A physical therapist can tailor exercises to strengthen your core, improve flexibility, and reduce sciatica symptoms.
-
Pain Management: Continue using pain relief medications as prescribed and consider non-pharmacological options like heat/cold therapy, relaxation techniques, or mindful movement practices (e.g., yoga or tai chi), if appropriate.
-
Follow Up on New Symptoms: If you notice any sudden worsening of symptoms, including increased numbness, difficulty walking, or significant changes in bowel/bladder control, seek immediate medical attention.
-
Consult a Pain Specialist: If your pain remains unmanageable, discuss with your healthcare provider the possibility of referral to a pain management specialist who can explore other options, including different medications or intervention techniques.
It's important to give the conservative treatment some time to see if it brings you relief, while remaining vigilant about your symptoms and communicating openly with your healthcare team. You’re not alone in this, and with appropriate care and monitoring, many people find a path through such challenges. Take care of yourself, and I hope you find relief soon!
Related Questions
Elevated Liver Enzymes: Preparing for My Follow-Up Test
Recently, I underwent a blood test and the nurse informed me that my liver enzymes were slightly above the normal range. To be honest, I haven’t prioritized my health over the last several months, neglecting exercise and indulging in an unhealthy diet, compounded by excessive drinking just before the test. I had been drinking quite a bit the weekend prior and again on Sunday, while the test was on a Tuesday. Since that time, I’ve completely cut out alcohol and have committed to a healthier eating regimen, and honestly, I’m feeling quite good. Thankfully, I haven't experienced any of the symptoms often mentioned, such as abdominal pain, jaundice, or swelling. However, the lab results were definitely concerning, and I won’t pretend otherwise. I have my follow-up blood test scheduled for tomorrow, so I’m reaching out for advice on how best to prepare for it. Thank you!
Experiencing Unusual Symptoms After HFM: A Personal Journey
I always viewed myself as someone who maintained good health and fitness. My daily routine involves working outdoors, and I avoid alcohol and tobacco. However, in early 2025, I contracted hand, foot, and mouth disease from my two-year-old child. This illness persisted for an exhausting seven weeks from April to May. I endured severe ulcers that prevented me from eating for several days and faced painful blisters that covered my hands, feet, and groin. Eventually, the skin on both my palms and the soles of my feet peeled away completely. The culmination of this ordeal resulted in epididymitis, leading to an alarming swelling of one of my testicles, which measured 36ml. Despite a hospital stay, the doctors assured me that recovery would take weeks, yet I still feel a lingering difference. By June 2025, I suffered a lower back injury from overexertion and fatigue, a recurring issue in my life. Normally, I would recover swiftly from such injuries, but this time was different. Bending or lifting became unbearable due to intense pain, and I began to experience sciatic discomfort in my left leg. Additionally, my foot would frequently feel numb, making it difficult to stand or sit for extended periods. After consulting with doctors, I was given a diagnosis of a possible slipped or herniated disc and prescribed Celecoxib to manage inflammation. Throughout the summer, I pursued various treatments, including physiotherapy, chiropractic sessions, and acupuncture. Despite months of strength training, stretching, and techniques like dry needling and nerve flossing, I still felt a sharp stabbing pain in my lower back and sacral region. Another doctor speculated that I might have a partial tear in my anterior longitudinal ligament, but healing seemed uncertain and would require patience. As September rolled in, I awoke with a severe kink in my neck, which plagued me through numerous sleepless nights, leading to physical weakness and peculiar sensations. I discovered that I could no longer contract my right serratus anterior muscle, which had been a defining feature of my physique since my early teenage years. I struggled to lift my right arm overhead and was diagnosed with scapular winging. Following this diagnosis, my doctor prescribed Pregabalin and referred me to a neurologist in December. The neurologist explained that my nervous system had essentially turned on itself to combat the infection, a scenario he noted wasn't entirely uncommon. During my visit, he illustrated the nerve activity in my surrounding muscles, revealing that while my serratus nerves were active, their firing rate was significantly low. He advised against surgery since it had already been six months since I first noticed the muscle weakening, but warned that if I didn’t see improvement by June 2026, surgery to attach my shoulder blade might become necessary. He also indicated that physiotherapy might not yield much benefit in this situation. Recently, I woke up with yet another painful kink in my neck. For four days now, I've been experiencing pins and needles in my right arm and wrist. Currently, I am awaiting an MRI appointment. I apologize for my lack of medical terminology; I am just trying to understand whether my symptoms could be related to the hand, foot, and mouth disease, how to express this concern to my doctor, and what specific tests I should inquire about. With a young family to support and daily labor to endure, I appreciate your time and any advice you might be able to provide.
Inquiries about Papilledema
At 24 years old, I recently underwent my annual eye examination, where the optometrist identified some swelling in my eyes. Consequently, the doctor provided me with a referral (see attached) and mentioned that it could take one to two weeks for me to receive a response from the specialist’s office. He advised that if I do not hear back within that timeframe, I should reach out directly to arrange my appointment. Additionally, he cautioned that I should visit the emergency room if my symptoms worsen. I am seeking further information regarding this issue.
Should I Consult My GI Specialist About Mild Active Crohn's Disease?
Greetings! I've been dealing with recurring high-grade obstructions in my small intestine, particularly at the same location in my terminal ileum, as highlighted by CT scans over the years. Each time I undergo colonoscopies or CT imaging, the inflammation tends to resolve post-blockage, and has not been evident in the most recent MRI I got from my gastroenterologist. This MRI indicated that there is a short segment of the terminal ileum that is slightly thickened and demonstrates hyperenhancement after receiving gadolinium contrast. According to the report, these observations are suggestive of mild active Crohn's disease. Fortunately, there were no signs of fistulas or strictures present. Additionally, a limited area of diffusion restriction was detected within the terminal ileal portion, with some minor thickening of the wall measured at 0.4 cm along a segment that spans around 7 to 10 cm. Although there is hyperenhancement in that segment, again, there is no indication of strictures or the formation of fistulas. On a positive note, the other parts of the small intestine appear normal, and no abnormal thickening or pathological lymph nodes were identified in the visualized colon. I’ve yet to discuss these MRI results with my gastroenterologist. Given that the findings are rated as mild, should I still reach out to him? Or is it best to refrain from contacting him since mild cases may not warrant treatment?
Concerns About My Infant's Cold Sore and Eye Protection
Age: 10 months Gender: Male Height: 27 inches Weight: 18 pounds Ethnicity: Caucasian Duration of Symptoms: 1 day Affected Area: Lower lip Pre-existing Conditions: Eczema on cheeks Current Medications: None Greetings, As a slightly anxious first-time mother, I'm reaching out for some reassurance. My little one has been battling a cold since Friday, and this morning, I noticed a cold sore on his lower lip. Since my husband is experiencing a flare-up of the same issue, I believe this is where the infection originated. Although I understand cold sores pose a greater risk for infants younger than six months, I’m particularly worried about my son’s habit of frequently putting his hands in his mouth and subsequently rubbing his eyes. During moments of distress, like when I'm changing his diaper or dressing him for sleep, he tends to put his hands in his mouth and then immediately touch his eyes. Today, I did my best to sanitize his hands after he put them in his mouth, but there were multiple instances where I wasn’t quick enough to stop him from transferring germs to his eyes. I've come across information suggesting that if this virus infects the eye, it could potentially lead to serious damage or even blindness, which increases my anxiety. I contacted our pediatrician out of concern for his eyesight. She explained that there’s no treatment for the cold sore and reassured me that if the sore isn’t oozing, the risk of spreading it to his eyes is minimal. She advised me to try to prevent eye-rubbing, which seems nearly impossible unless I constantly restrain his arms. Despite the reassurance, I can’t help but worry about the risk to his eyes. I would like to know if the likelihood of the virus spreading to his eyes remains low if the cold sore appears simply as a blister, despite his repeated hand-to-eye contact today. If infection were to occur, would there be noticeable symptoms, or could it happen silently, causing damage without my knowledge? Additionally, do infants ever receive antiviral treatment for cold sores? I’m considering whether that might be advisable as a proactive measure against eye infection. Is there anything further I can do now to shield his eyes from the virus? During instances when I’m unable to intervene, should I take specific actions after he puts his hands in his mouth and then touches his eyes? Though I recognize that administering eye drops to him would be challenging, would they potentially aid in clearing out any contaminants? As he also has eczema on his cheeks, I came across recommendations to consult a doctor if a child with eczema develops a cold sore. I'm uncertain why this combination raises additional concerns, but it's something I wanted to highlight. I apologize for the lengthy message; I am eager to comprehend the risks involved considering his direct exposure and ensure I’m taking every possible step to avert any harm to his eyes. I realize that I might be overreacting, but watching him repeatedly rub his eyes with hands that have just been in contact with his mouth, coupled with what I’ve learned about potential eye damage or blindness from this virus, has left me tremendously worried. Any advice or insights you could offer would be immensely appreciated. Thank you in advance!