Delayed Treatment for Knee Injury Concerns
My 13-year-old nephew, referred to here as M, suffered a knee injury last week while skiing—it happened on Monday, February 2nd. After the fall, he found himself unable to bear weight on the affected leg and described the pain as being "deep inside" the knee joint. Despite the severity of the incident, his parents did not seek medical attention until Thursday, February 5th. During the consultation, a nurse practitioner assessed the injury and conducted X-rays, which fortunately showed no fractures. However, the practitioner suspected there might be damage to the surrounding tissues and advised that if the pain and limited movement did not improve shortly, an MRI would be necessary. As of today, the pain persists along with the restricted mobility, although there are no signs of swelling or bruising. It appears that his parents are not overly concerned about the situation. They prefer to monitor M’s condition, hoping that the discomfort will subside on its own. I'm apprehensive that this wait-and-see approach could result in lasting damage to his knee. Personally, I ignored a meniscus injury at the age of 25, and I continue to feel the repercussions of that decision, which makes me fear for my nephew's prognosis. Should it be a meniscus injury, how much time do we realistically have before it could lead to irreversible damage?
Answers (1)
2/8/2026, 8:50:31 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to be concerned about your nephew's knee injury, especially considering your past experience. His ongoing pain and limited movement following a skiing accident warrant careful attention, even without swelling or bruising.
Key Points:
- Persistent pain and mobility issues following an injury, especially in the knee, may indicate ligament or cartilage damage, such as a meniscus injury.
- Delayed diagnosis and treatment can lead to worsening symptoms and longer recovery times.
Explanation: The meniscus is a C-shaped cartilage in the knee which acts as a cushion between the bones. Injuries to the meniscus can cause pain, swelling, and limited motion, even if there are no visible signs like bruising or swelling. The timeline for treatment is important—waiting too long can lead to chronic problems, including arthritis or further tissue damage.
Although the X-rays did not show fractures, the persistent symptoms suggest there may still be underlying issues. Monitoring without intervention can sometimes lead to complications; therefore, it’s crucial to take the situation seriously.
Next Steps:
- Encourage Further Evaluation: Advocate for a follow-up appointment soon, specifically to discuss the possibility of an MRI. This can provide a detailed view of the soft tissues and help confirm if there’s a meniscus or other injury.
- Limit Activity: Advise M to avoid weight-bearing activities that exacerbate the pain. Using crutches can help unload the knee while he recovers.
- Pain Management: Suggest over-the-counter pain relief like ibuprofen or acetaminophen (if there are no contraindications) to manage discomfort.
- Physical Therapy: If M continues to have pain and limited motion, physical therapy may help strengthen the knee and restore function, potentially preventing long-term issues.
- Monitor Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in pain levels or mobility, and report these details during the follow-up.
It's important to ensure that any lingering issues are addressed promptly to promote full recovery and prevent future complications. Your concern and proactive approach can help protect M's overall knee health.
Related Questions
Tibial and Fibular Fracture - Buckling Incident
I’m a 38-year-old male weighing 16 stone and 5 pounds. Recently, I encountered an unfortunate event where I fell down the stairs, leading to what the emergency room physician diagnosed as a leg fracture. However, I find myself questioning the accuracy of the doctor’s assessment. Could I be doubting the diagnosis, or is it merely my reluctance to accept the reality of being in a cast for the next two months? I appreciate any thoughts you may have on this situation.
Big Toe Injury - Turf Toe Overview
In early July 2025, I sustained a significant injury to my big toe, which involved avulsion and structural damage. I was required to wear a long aircast for several weeks to support the healing process. By September 2025, I noticed a gradual improvement in my condition. I was able to walk normally again and even began light jogging with minimal discomfort. However, on October 5, 2025, I experienced a setback due to a re-sprain caused by an unfortunate movement. Although I did not feel acute pain, there was ongoing irritation in the affected area. From October to November, I continued my daily activities, including walking, navigating stairs, and attending classes, though at times I walked with a noticeable limp. I supplemented my recovery with leg strength training and self-directed physiotherapy, incorporating exercises like calf raises and toe curls. Regrettably, my symptoms began to deteriorate. Toward the end of November and into early December, I faced further decline, likely attributed to overuse of the injured toe. Starting December 15, 2025, I prioritized weight-bearing relief. While I wore the aircast outdoors and occasionally used crutches, I minimized weight on the toe while at home. By mid-January 2026, I began to walk indoors without the aircast, gradually increasing my activity level. For about three weeks, I managed to walk at home and for short trips without the aircast, opting for regular shoes when outside, although I would occasionally wear the aircast for additional safety. Currently, in February: - I am able to walk without pain. - However, I experience some redness and warmth when bearing weight, which subsides quickly when I elevate my foot. - My mobility in the big toe is somewhat limited, - With occasional slight pulling sensations. An MRI showed only a non-specific light in the imaging without any clear indicators of new structural damage. Consulting several orthopedic surgeons yielded differing opinions, some suggesting bruising or potential Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS), but I exhibited no clinical signs of CRPS. Based on my evaluation and the progression of symptoms, it appears that I am experiencing irritation of the capsule and ligaments of the big toe, resembling turf toe, possibly combined with issues related to blood circulation caused by the prolonged period of immobilization. Currently, I am engaged in physiotherapy, massage, and light cardio activities like cycling. I can walk normally now without experiencing pain, but I refrain from putting excessive strain on my toe.
Seeking Guidance: Should I Visit a Doctor After My Knee Incident?
Greetings. I'm a 38-year-old male, generally in good health with no ongoing medical conditions. Yesterday evening, I had an unfortunate accident while leaving a store; I slipped on a wet floor caused by the snow. As I turned to exit, I landed heavily on the outer side of my knee. Now, roughly 20 hours later, while the intense pain has diminished significantly, I find that my knee's flexibility is still limited, with only about 50% of its usual range of motion. Attempting to bend it past this halfway point results in a sharp, sudden pain located on the outer back side of the joint. Given these symptoms, should I consider consulting a physician, or would it be wise to wait and see if my condition improves on its own? I appreciate any insights. Thank you!
Do I Need to Consult a Podiatrist for This Ingrown Toenail?
Subject: Inquiry About Ingrown Toenail I'm a 22-year-old male weighing 100 kg. I don't have any underlying health conditions and am not taking any medications. I've been dealing with this issue for about a year now. A few months ago, the area became painful, and in an attempt to alleviate the discomfort, I tried to trim the side of the nail myself. While that provided temporary relief, it seems to have caused the nail to start growing sideways and even over the top. At present, I am not experiencing any pain, but there is noticeable redness around the toe. What course of action do you recommend? Thanks!
Navigating Recovery After Arm Surgery
I am a 26-year-old woman, and I recently experienced a serious accident. A car struck me, leading to significant damage to my arm, which was subsequently broken and run over. Following this incident, I required hospitalization and underwent surgery two days ago, during which a metal plate was inserted into my arm. I’m curious if others could share their experiences during recovery. I know everyone’s journey is unique, but I could really use some insights. Currently, I'm on day two after my operation and grappling with persistent feelings of anxiety and fatigue. Everything seems surreal, almost as if it’s shrouded in static. Over the past week, my sleep has been quite disturbed; last night was the first time I managed to get a decent amount of rest—around seven to eight hours, though I did wake up frequently. I would greatly appreciate any advice or sharing of personal recovery journeys, as I seek to navigate this challenging time.