Considering Surgical Options
I have a history of injuries that I’d like to share: - I underwent surgery for a broken collarbone, resulting in a metal support being placed in my arm. - Additionally, I’ve experienced three dislocations of my shoulder, all occurring after that initial surgery. These issues have all affected my right shoulder. Recently, my physician suggested that I might require surgery for stabilization. However, I find myself uncertain about whether this is the best path forward. I’ve encountered numerous accounts of individuals who report never regaining their original functionality and suffering from persistent shoulder tightness post-surgery. Given my young age (17 years old), I'm contemplating whether this decision is truly advisable. I'm torn between my current struggles and the potential long-term implications of an operation.
Answers (1)
2/4/2026, 5:40:31 AM
OpenHealth AI
It’s understandable to feel conflicted about the decision to undergo surgery, especially when considering your young age and the impact it may have on your shoulder's function. Let's break down the main points and explore your options.
Main Points:
- Your history of shoulder issues, including a broken collarbone and repeated dislocations, complicates your shoulder's stability.
- Surgery could help stabilize your shoulder but carries risks, including the potential for long-term tightness or decreased function.
- At age 17, you have a life ahead that may be affected by the decision now.
Explanation: You have dealt with significant shoulder injuries, which can lead to chronic pain and instability. Surgery is often recommended to restore function and prevent future dislocations, especially in active individuals. However, it’s important to weigh the risks of surgery against the potential benefits, particularly in light of accounts from others who've undergone similar procedures.
Long-term complications can happen, like persistent tightness or a range of motion reduction. Your concerns are valid, and it's good to be cautious, especially since your shoulder function is critical for many daily activities and sports.
Next Steps:
- Get a Second Opinion: Consider discussing your concerns with another orthopedic specialist. They can provide alternative options or different perspectives on surgery.
- Explore Rehabilitation Options: Investigate comprehensive physical therapy focused on strengthening the muscles around your shoulder. This can sometimes reduce symptoms and improve stability without surgery.
- Consider Your Goals: Reflect on your lifestyle and activities. If sports or specific activities are essential to you, communicate these with your healthcare provider—they might alter their recommendations based on your priorities.
- Make Informed Choices: Gather information on the surgery, including effectiveness rates and recovery times, to help you understand what to expect. Ask about the surgeon’s experience with similar cases.
Take your time to assess these factors, and make a decision that aligns with your long-term health goals. Let me know if you need further assistance or clarification!
Related Questions
Long-Term Outlook on RF Ablation
At 33 years old, I stand 6 feet 4 inches tall and weigh 275 pounds. I’m dealing with significant issues including disc desiccation and degeneration spanning from the cervical vertebrae C3 to C7, compounded by a pinched nerve, bone spurs, and a narrowed spinal column. The pain has become overwhelming. Today, I visited a pain management clinic, initially thinking it would simply guide me toward surgical options. To my surprise, I’ve now been scheduled for a radiofrequency ablation diagnostic next week. I find myself feeling somewhat apprehensive about the whole process. I have a prior experience where, due to a nerve blocker, I was able to continue playing baseball for longer than I should have, ultimately resulting in more harm to my shoulder than expected. I can’t help but wonder if disc replacement is not living up to some of the glowing reviews I’ve encountered. With three decades still ahead in a physically demanding career, I’ve repeatedly heard from various doctors that there are no definitive solutions available—only techniques for pain management. It’s disheartening to think that contemporary medicine is advanced enough to perform face transplants, sex reassignment surgeries, and complex heart and lung transplants, yet still appears to be unreliable when it comes to disc replacement. Eventually, I received a referral to a surgeon to explore my options further. While I remain uncertain about the radiofrequency ablation, if it helps alleviate my discomfort until a more permanent solution presents itself, then perhaps it’s a step worth taking.
Concern Regarding Sacral Dimple Discomfort
I’m a 21-year-old female, slightly above my ideal weight, and I have a history of hidradenitis suppurativa (HS). There’s not much beyond that which might relate to my current issue. Since birth, I've had a sacral dimple. A year ago, I dealt with a pilonidal cyst that required draining, but thankfully it healed well and hasn't recurred. Recently, over the past couple of months, I've experienced increased itching at the base of my sacral dimple, right above my anus. I've noticed that this irritation tends to worsen after I wipe following bowel movements, despite my efforts to maintain cleanliness. I often use witch hazel on toilet paper to manage moisture and achieve a fresh feeling, but the itchiness has been persistent. Moreover, I’ve started to feel a tight, tearing sensation in that area when I sit or squat, and there’s occasionally a slight amount of blood—nothing excessive, just a drop or so. I suspect this might be due to moisture making the skin in that area more delicate, but I'm uncertain. I am looking for suggestions on how to promote healing in this area.
What’s Causing the Peeling and Wrinkling of My Hands?
Hello! I'm a 24-year-old female, weighing 200 pounds, and I'm not currently on any medication, nor do I have a smoking background. Recently, I've been facing a troubling skin issue on my hands where they repeatedly peel and become wrinkled. In the past, I experienced peeling skin every couple of years, but that typically resolved within a week and didn’t lead to any noticeable wrinkles. However, this time, it has persisted for over a month, and the peeling continues without signs of improvement. The areas where my skin is shedding seem localized, resembling small craters, while the wrinkling worsens gradually. It’s especially noticeable on the pads of my fingers, though my palms are also affected. Initially, I suspected an allergic reaction, so I reverted to my usual soap and shampoo, yet that didn’t alleviate the issue. Next, I considered dryness as a culprit, and I increased my water intake and applied lotion frequently, but to no avail. Now, I’ve been dealing with this situation for about three weeks and am feeling quite frustrated trying to resolve it. While the peeling isn’t itchy or painful and seems relatively harmless, I can’t shake off my concern that it may lead to a more significant issue down the road. I’d appreciate any insights or advice on this matter!
Understanding the Fluctuation of Monoclonal Antibodies in Test Results
At 38 years old, standing at 5 feet 2 inches tall and weighing 105 pounds, I encountered a perplexing situation. During an immunofixation test, faint traces of monoclonal antibodies, specifically IgG kappa light chains, were detected, yet no monoclonal spike (m-spike) was evident. Alongside this, I experienced a range of systemic immune-related symptoms such as flu-like feelings, enlarged lymph nodes, bouts of itching, unintentional weight loss, and discomfort in my joints, muscles, and nerves, as well as tendonitis and dysautonomia. After starting a steroid regimen, my symptoms improved significantly. However, several months following my initial evaluation, follow-up tests revealed that my laboratory results had returned to normal. Could this indicate that there was merely a false positive initially? Any insight would be appreciated.
Chronic Patellar Pain and Skin Issues: Exploring PsA or a Mechanical Cause?
Greetings, I am a 40-year-old man residing in the Bay Area seeking insight into my condition. Though I have not been officially diagnosed with psoriatic arthritis (PsA), I am eager to determine how medical professionals might assess my symptoms. **Medical Background** In July 2024, I experienced a sudden onset of sharp pain beneath my right knee cap, without any identifiable injury. Gradually, this pain transitioned into a duller yet more activity-related discomfort, particularly noticeable when navigating stairs, performing squats, or walking downhill. While I have found that my tolerance for sitting has improved somewhat, the pain continues to significantly disrupt my daily life. More recently, I have been experiencing sporadic pains in my fingers, especially at the toes and thumbs, as well as in the shoulder and scapular region. These sensations often arise with movement or pressure but are not accompanied by spontaneous swelling. I’ve noticed possible stiffness in the morning and after physical activities lasting over 30 minutes, though quantifying this has proven challenging. Visually, there is no indication of joint deformity. **Imaging Results** - Two MRI scans of my right knee conducted at 3T (as of September 2024) revealed: - Absence of synovitis - No evident cartilage damage - No erosive changes - A recent musculoskeletal ultrasound of the same knee, utilizing Doppler technology showed: - Thickening of the patellar tendon, approximately up to 10 mm - Mild neovascularity - No signs of tear or erosions - Conclusion: Patellar tendinopathy **Lab Tests** - Rheumatoid factor: Negative - HLA-B27: Negative - ESR and CRP levels repeatedly within normal ranges **Skin Observations** - Mild reddish patches observed on the elbows (dermatologist believed they were not significant enough for a biopsy) - Intermittent erythema and peeling around the eyes - Genital skin discomfort (a biopsy was offered but I declined due to its sensitive location) - Temporary red spots on my lower legs that resolved months ago - No official diagnosis of psoriasis thus far **Inquiry** One rheumatologist proposed the initiation of empiric biologic treatment pending a skin biopsy that could confirm psoriasis, although obtaining this biopsy has been challenging. Conversely, another specialist advised proceeding with ultrasound and biopsy as initial steps and believed that imaging results leaned towards mechanical tendinopathy rather than an inflammatory pathology. Considering: - Normal MRI findings over approximately one year - Ultrasound indicating patellar tendinopathy - Negative results for inflammatory markers and serological tests - Mild and inconsistent skin manifestations How might clinicians evaluate the likelihood of psoriatic arthritis in my situation? Is it justifiable to consider empiric biologic therapy, or would a more common approach involve observation and conservative treatment until further evidence emerges? I appreciate any clinical expertise you can provide on this matter.