Concerns Over Breathing Difficulties and a Discrepant Physician Response
I've been experiencing respiratory challenges since October, initially presenting as a sensation of air deprivation and an inability to fully expand my lungs. This eventually developed into peculiar symptoms associated with gas exchange and difficulties in inhalation, accompanied by a feeling of fatigue and stiffness in my respiratory muscles. Fortunately, I noticed some alleviation in January after allowing time for recovery and addressing what turned out to be silent reflux. My physician also introduced me to a very low daily dose of Symbicort, though I can't pinpoint exactly what contributed most to my improvement. After waiting for three months, I finally attended my scheduled appointment at the pulmonologist's office. The doctors concluded that there were no structural abnormalities within my lungs, and chest X-rays revealed no indications of asthma or any severe respiratory complications. During the consultation, I was asked to perform a basic breathing test, where I inhaled deeply and was instructed to exhale forcefully into a large tube for approximately 4-5 seconds. Unfortunately, I consistently ran out of breath after about 2 seconds of exhalation. The device indicated it was unable to give an accurate reading due to my insufficient exhalation duration. Typically, I can manage a longer exhalation if I use pursed-lip techniques, but the intensive effort required for the test seemed to deplete my respiratory capacity too quickly. The physician had me repeat this procedure three additional times with identical results. Each attempt appeared to frustrate him more, as if my inability to complete the task was a result of insufficient effort on my part, until he eventually conceded to discontinue the test. Surprisingly, he remained rather unconcerned about the results. He simply suggested scheduling further breathing assessments at the hospital for precautionary purposes yet reassured me that he personally did not suspect any serious complications based on his examination of my breathing through a stethoscope. Isn't the inability to successfully complete a straightforward breathing test somewhat alarming, or does it primarily indicate weakness in my respiratory muscles rather than a critical lung or airway condition?
Answers (1)
2/4/2026, 2:01:06 AM
OpenHealth AI
Thank you for sharing your detailed experience regarding your respiratory challenges. It's understandable to feel concerned about your ability to complete a breathing test, especially given the symptoms you've described. Let's break this down to clarify your situation and outline your next steps.
Main Points:
- Your respiratory symptoms may not be linked to serious lung conditions, based on your pulmonologist's assessment.
- The difficulty with the breathing test could indicate a lack of muscle endurance or technique rather than a critical issue with lung function.
- It's essential to continue monitoring your symptoms and explore strategies to improve your breathing capacity.
Explanation:
From what you've described, it sounds like you’ve had a complex experience with your breathing but have made some progress since addressing reflux and starting Symbicort. It's important to recognize that not being able to complete a standard breathing test can be frustrating, but the fact that your doctor did not find structural abnormalities is a positive sign. This may suggest that your symptoms are related to respiratory muscle fatigue or technique rather than a severe underlying lung disease.
Pursed-lip breathing is a technique that can help you manage your breathing in daily life, and it might be useful to practice this method outside of formal tests to enhance your overall respiratory function.
Next Steps:
-
Practice Breathing Techniques: Focus on pursed-lip breathing in a relaxed setting. Inhale deeply through your nose for about 2 seconds, then purse your lips and exhale slowly for a count of 4-6 seconds. This practice can help improve your control and endurance over time.
-
Exercise Your Respiratory Muscles: Consider engaging in light aerobic exercises, such as walking or stationary cycling, tailored to your comfort level. Gradually include breathing exercises that specifically target lung expansion and respiratory muscle strength, like diaphragmatic breathing.
-
Keep a Symptom Diary: Document your daily respiratory symptoms, exertion levels, and how you respond to different activities. This will help you and your healthcare provider track improvements or identify patterns.
-
Follow-Up Assessments: Since your doctor recommended further assessments, consider scheduling those breathing tests at the hospital. They may be able to use different equipment that can offer a more accurate evaluation of your lung function.
-
Communicate Concerns: If you're feeling frustrated with medical responses, or if you find the testing process stressful, don't hesitate to share your feelings with your healthcare providers. Open communication is vital in ensuring that your concerns are addressed.
If your symptoms change or worsen, especially if you experience increased breathlessness, chest pain, or fatigue, it's essential to report that promptly. Take care, and please remember that improvements in respiratory health can take time and may require ongoing management.
Related Questions
Herniated Disc: Will My Foot Sensation Return?
For over a year, I've been struggling with back problems that seemed to alternate between improving and flaring up. Initially, my condition was attributed to either irritated sciatica or inflammation, and I managed it with courses of oral steroids and occasional injections. In early December 2025, I experienced another setback, this time affecting the right side of my lower back. I began to notice a tingling and numb sensation in my right foot. The pain intensified to a level 9, prompting me to get an MRI. It took some time for the results to be processed, but I received them in the first week of January and was referred to an orthopedic specialist. During my consultation, the physician noted that I had significant disc protrusion, which was linked to genetic factors rather than a result of any injury. Consequently, he suggested that physical therapy might not bring any benefit. My only viable option presented was a pain management injection. While there was a possibility for surgical intervention, my current weight did not meet the necessary criteria for the procedure. I have since started a diet and have lost 20 pounds, yet I remain far from the required weight for surgery. As I awaited the pain management appointment, my discomfort escalated, despite my avoidance of any strenuous activities. The numbness and tingling sensations have now spread down to just below my knee, making it exceedingly difficult to walk or stand for extended periods. It has been a week since I had the pain block procedure. While the pain has not completely dissipated, it is at least more bearable. However, my mobility remains challenging, and I've found myself tripping more often than before. I am aware that the pain relief from the block is likely temporary, and I worry about the possibility of the pain returning. I can’t help but ask: will I ever feel normal again? At just 22 years old, my condition has hindered my ability to work, and I am desperate for solutions or answers to my predicament. Thank you for your time. If additional information is needed, feel free to ask me.
Throat and Breathing Discomfort Following Meals
Hello everyone! For the past couple of months, I've been experiencing a persistent issue where I frequently feel the need to clear my throat after meals. At the age of 19, I find this particularly bothersome. About an hour following my meals, I am plagued by this uncomfortable sensation of having something lodged in my throat, accompanied by occasional minor breathing difficulties. This reaction seems to occur regardless of the type of food I'm consuming—be it dry bread, soup, fruits, or even ice cream. Interestingly, while water causes me no issues, I find that milk-based coffee can trigger this sensation slightly. During the act of eating, I do not experience any pain and can enjoy my meals without concern; it's only after I've finished eating that this annoying feeling arises. I've made an appointment with my doctor to discuss a referral to an ENT specialist. Living in a rural area means I've had to wait six weeks for this consultation. I'm not on any medications currently, nor do I have any known allergies. Has anyone else dealt with similar symptoms? I would love to hear about your experiences!
Is It Splenic Flexure Syndrome or Something Different?
Hello! I'm a 34-year-old woman who underwent an urgent cholecystectomy in January 2025. About six months post-surgery, I began experiencing unexpected cramps in the upper left section of my abdomen. These cramps strike without warning during various activities; they can occur while I’m leaning over my computer at a desk, performing Pilates core exercises like a V-sit, or simply bending down to tie my shoes. These cramps are inconsistent; there’s no certainty they will happen every time I engage in these actions. However, when they do occur, they feel like a sharp, cramp-like "charley horse" localized precisely in the same spot, dissipating immediately once I straighten up. After discussing these symptoms with my primary care physician, she suspects I might be dealing with Splenic Flexure Syndrome. We conducted a CT scan to eliminate the possibility of a hernia, which showed no abnormalities, reinforcing her belief in the diagnosis of Splenic Flexure Syndrome. However, something feels off to me regarding the frequency of these cramps and their specific triggers. Is it possible that we’re overlooking a different issue? Also, I noticed after bending down to tie my shoes yesterday that I experienced another sharp cramp, and for the very first time, I now have a lingering dull pain in that area. To add to the situation, I did some crunches after experiencing that cramp, so I’m uncertain if they’re connected.
Two Months After COVID: Ongoing Pressure in Upper Jaw – Is it Silent Sinusitis?
I’m a 35-year-old male, standing at 5’11” and weighing 175 pounds. Generally, I maintain a healthy lifestyle; I exercise regularly and follow a nutritious diet. To date, I have not been prescribed any medications and do not have any pre-existing health issues. Here’s my situation, and I could use some guidance: I contracted COVID-19 in early December, which persisted for about a week with typical symptoms such as a fever reaching 101°F and muscle aches. After a week, I tested negative and felt a significant improvement. However, about a week later, I awoke to discomfort in my left incisor. This sensation escalated into throbbing pain radiating through the left side of my upper jaw and occasionally descending to my lower jaw. It wasn’t sharp, but rather a persistent throb that intensified when bending down or during flights. Upon visiting my doctor, I was informed that my symptoms were likely indicative of sinusitis, particularly given my recent COVID-19 infection. Interestingly, I didn’t have notable mucus or nasal discharge—just an inexplicable pressure in my mouth. The physician prescribed amoxicillin, and within a few days, I experienced about a 90% reduction in pain. I completed the 7-day course of antibiotics, and for a week, I felt nearly back to normal. However, after an outing snowboarding at an elevation of 12,000 feet, I noticed the discomfort returning—not as severely as before, but with a persistent pressure affecting my teeth. I typically find relief from combining Sudafed, Zyrtec, and ibuprofen, although today has been less effective. Recently, I began refinishing my kitchen counter, a butcher block, which involved extensive sanding and staining, and although I wore a mask, the pressure re-emerged, disrupting my sleep that night. The pressure often shifts around my mouth, and I’ve found flossing, along with both cold and warm water, to provide some comfort. While I don’t feel as bad as I did during the peak of my sinus issues, this persistent pressure in my lower sinus region is unusual compared to classic sinus infection symptoms. It’s been a month since this discomfort started, two months since my COVID infection, and I’m eager for relief. Reports indicate that COVID can lead to some lingering symptoms like this, and now I’m left wondering if more antibiotics are necessary. Is this duration for sinusitis recovery typical? I'm reaching out for any insights or suggestions that might help me navigate this situation or clarify if my assumptions are misguided.
What Could This Red Spot at the Back of My Throat Be? 23M
I’ve been experiencing a bit of a sore throat and noticed a reddish mark at the rear of my mouth, possibly on my tonsils. I'm uncertain whether it’s simply an irritation or something more serious. I’d like to share a video for a clearer view, but I'm not quite sure how to do that.