Is This Shingles?
I’m a 52-year-old woman currently managing anxiety with Zoloft (50 mg daily), and I’m also on Lipitor for my cholesterol. Additionally, I take vitamin D to address a deficiency, Allegra for seasonal allergies, and a multivitamin tailored for women over 50. Last October, I underwent a complete hysterectomy due to endometrial intraepithelial neoplasia (EIN), during which a stage 1A borderline tumor was discovered on one of my ovaries. Fortunately, I did not require chemotherapy or radiation treatment. For more than a year now, I have been experiencing discomfort with a persistent spot on my arm that itches and/or causes pain. At times, scratching this spot results in pain that seems disproportionate to the sensation. On other occasions, the discomfort can feel like a stabbing sensation without itching at all. There's no visible rash or any signs that something is amiss. This issue intensifies with heat, emotional stress, or when I’m feeling particularly upset. I’ve experimented with various remedies including cortisone cream, Benadryl cream, anti-itch gel, and nearly every over-the-counter anti-itch solution available, yet nothing seems effective. During my recent annual checkup, I raised this concern with my general practitioner. Regrettably, I felt dismissed when she suggested it might be an allergy and recommended Zyrtec, even though I already take Allegra. This lack of resolution has left me feeling extremely frustrated. I’ve started to speculate whether this condition might indicate shingles, despite my assumption that shingles is always accompanied by a rash. I contracted chickenpox at the age of 8. The discomfort remains localized to this one area, and while it occasionally eases, it resurfaces intensely enough to make me consider rushing to the nearest emergency room to demand clarification. Any insights or advice would be greatly appreciated by this distressed woman who is reaching her breaking point.
Answers (1)
9/15/2025, 4:30:52 AM
OpenHealth AI
Your experience with persistent discomfort on your arm can indeed be distressing, especially given the lack of resolution and support. While it’s understandable to worry about conditions like shingles, it's important to clarify a few points regarding your symptoms and next steps.
Main Points:
- Shingles is typically associated with a rash, but not always in its early stages. However, based on your description, your symptoms may not fit the classic presentation.
- Persistent discomfort and pain without visible rash can have various causes, including nerve issues, dermatological conditions, or even psychological factors like anxiety or stress.
- It's crucial to explore and address underlying causes, focusing on effective self-care and communication with healthcare providers.
Explanation:
Shingles is a viral infection that manifests after the reactivation of the chickenpox virus, typically characterized by a painful rash. It does not always start with noticeable symptoms like a rash; it often can begin with localized pain or discomfort. However, your description of itching, pain, and triggers related to emotional stress may suggest other conditions such as neuropathy, a dermatitis that isn’t visually apparent, or even stress-related issues.
Given your background, the focus should be on identifying what exacerbates your discomfort and whether there’s a deeper underlying issue. The fact that it intensifies with emotional stress is particularly noteworthy as it suggests a potential connection to anxiety or tension.
Next Steps:
-
Keep a Detailed Symptom Journal: Document when the discomfort occurs, its intensity, any triggers (both physical and emotional), and any changes in the area. This will help in identifying patterns over time.
-
Consider Neuropathic Pain: Given the stabbing pain you described, it might be beneficial to read up on conditions like neuropathic pain, which can present with discomfort without clear physical causes. Note how this aligns with your symptoms.
-
Implement Stress Management Techniques: Since emotional stress seems to be a trigger, engaging in stress reduction techniques such as mindfulness, yoga, or deep-breathing exercises may alleviate symptoms.
-
Follow Up with Your Doctor: If your symptoms persist without improvement, consider requesting further evaluation from a dermatologist or a neurologist. Clearly share your concerns and document any new patterns in your discomfort to ensure an effective discussion.
-
Explore Treatment Options: There are potential treatments for neuropathic pain or other conditions (like nerve pain medications or physical therapy) that could be more effective than over-the-counter solutions.
Conclusion:
Your symptoms are real and frustrating, and it's important to pursue them until you find answers that provide relief. Prioritizing tracking your symptoms and managing stress can be empowering steps while you navigate this challenging experience. Keep advocating for your health, and hopefully, with the right focus and support, you can find the clarity and resolution you seek.
Related Questions
Concerns about Food Aspiration
Hello, I'm a 23-year-old female, currently using pregabalin to manage chronic migraines. Recently, I made the unfortunate choice to chat while indulging in a soft chocolate bar. This happened about thirty minutes ago, and ever since, I’ve been anxious about the possibility of aspirating some of the chocolate. Shortly after eating, I noticed an unusual sensation in my throat—nothing painful, but definitely off, accompanied by a strange feeling in my neck. Although I haven’t experienced any coughing or the typical sensation of something going the wrong way, I’m still feeling a bit odd in my throat and neck area. Additionally, I had some belching and felt a wave of dizziness right after the incident, which I’m still experiencing to some extent. I'm genuinely worried about the risk of developing aspiration pneumonia, and it’s causing me a lot of stress.
Is Eating an Old Starburst Safe?
Recently, I sampled a Starburst that I saved from last Halloween. I’m 9 years old, roughly 4 feet tall, and weigh about 80 pounds. The packaging looked perfectly intact, and the wrappers seemed fine too. The candy itself didn’t show any signs of spoilage, such as browning or mold. I also made sure to wash it before eating. Should I be concerned about this choice?
Seeking Advice for Ingrown Toenail Care
Hello, I'm a 17-year-old male dealing with an ingrown toenail issue. I underwent surgery to address it a few months back, and while it initially healed well, I've noticed it's not looking quite right again. My plan is to soak my foot nightly in a warm bath with Dettol for about 20 minutes over the next two weeks before consulting with a professional for further treatment and medication. I would really appreciate any additional suggestions or remedies you might have to help manage this situation.
Concerning My Husband's Persistent Discomfort Related to His Throat
My husband, who is 33 years old, frequently expresses distress over a sensation of constriction caused by his Adam’s apple. This discomfort has been a part of his life for as long as he can remember. He shared with me that at the age of 18, he sought medical advice for this issue, but the doctor's response was dismissive. As a woman, I find it challenging to fully grasp his experience since I lack insight into certain physiological aspects. He often describes feeling as though his throat is tightening. This is not a rare complaint for him; in fact, he brings it up nearly every day. A few months back, we visited the hospital to get a comprehensive understanding of his health, particularly because he is frequently labeled a hypochondriac, and while he does have a tendency for dramatics, my quick research online suggests that this might be a more common concern than we initially thought. I genuinely wish to offer him reassurance rooted in factual knowledge. If necessary, I can provide a visual reference of his Adam’s apple. Any guidance or advice would be immensely helpful.
Inquiry about Genetic Testing and Its Implications
Age 45, height 5'4", weight 240 lbs, Caucasian; has a background of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and obesity (achieved a weight loss of 74 pounds over the last two years); suffers from hypertension and elevated cholesterol levels; has endured various joint injuries due to an accident that required lumbar fusion from L3 to S1, along with reconstructive surgeries on the shoulder, ankle, and knee; experiences anxiety, depression, and migraines. I recently underwent comprehensive genome sequencing and discovered several significant abnormalities that require consultation with an endocrinologist. I am interested to know how healthcare providers react when patients present these types of findings. My intention is not to come across as demanding or to imply that I possess greater knowledge than my physician. However, after numerous tests and persistent efforts to seek answers over the years, I feel that we may have uncovered a genuine explanation for my symptoms, and I wish to ensure that my concerns are acknowledged and taken seriously.