Discrepancy Between CT and MRI Findings of Liver Size
Subject: 35-year-old female, height 5'3", weight 110 lbs; not on any medications besides a calcium supplement, and previously took 1g of salt tablets from June through July. Backstory: In April, I began experiencing a worsening of chronic symptoms alongside some new issues. This culminated in a visit to the emergency room due to near-fainting spells and low blood pressure. I also noticed a significant decrease in my appetite, which made eating quite uncomfortable, leading to a weight loss of approximately 10-15 lbs. Upon consulting a new primary care physician, I underwent extensive blood tests. The results largely appeared normal, including liver function tests, although my serum iron and transferrin saturation levels were elevated. Consequently, I was referred to a hematologist, who diagnosed me with hemochromatosis and recommended a liver MRI to check for potential iron deposits. Simultaneously, my PCP ordered an abdominal CT scan to investigate my early satiety issues. The abdominal CT scan conducted in late June returned normal results, specifically noting that my liver was “within normal parameters.” Due to scheduling conflicts, I only managed to get the liver MRI this past week (September). The findings indicated a mildly enlarged liver, measuring 19 cm. Reflecting on my alcohol consumption, I used to drink heavily in my twenties—averaging 4-8 beverages on most nights. Though I moderated my drinking in my thirties, prior to the ER visit in April, I was still consuming about 2-4 beers on an evening, sometimes reaching 5 drinks. Since then, I’ve significantly cut down to 0-1 beer most nights, and a maximum of 2-3 drinks once or twice a week. Despite some ongoing appetite loss, I maintain a well-rounded omnivorous diet, primarily composed of homemade meals rich in fruits and vegetables. I avoid excessive consumption of fried foods and saturated fats, opting for a balanced approach instead. I have consulted with a cardiologist who performed an echocardiogram and a continuous EKG monitor, finding nothing alarming. He added me to salt tablets temporarily for low blood pressure, which I discontinued in July as my readings stabilized. Furthermore, my hematologist confirmed that my bloodwork did not suggest any cancer risk. In summary, I'm puzzled by how my liver could appear normal on the June CT scan while the MRI in September indicated a size of 19 cm, especially in light of my reduced alcohol intake. Could the enlargement simply have not been detectable on the CT? Also, how concerning is a liver measuring 19 cm for someone who is 35 years old and weighs 110 lbs? Any insights would be greatly appreciated as I await communication from my healthcare providers, hopefully by Monday.
Answers (1)
9/13/2025, 4:20:49 AM
OpenHealth AI
Your situation regarding the discrepancy between the CT and MRI findings of your liver size is understandably concerning, especially given your health history and recent symptoms. Let’s break this down to understand it better and provide you with actionable insights.
Key Points
- Discrepancy in Imaging Results: The difference in liver size between the CT and MRI could be due to the different imaging techniques and their sensitivity to detect certain changes.
- Current Condition Monitoring: A mildly enlarged liver is noteworthy and should be monitored, especially given your hematologist's diagnosis of hemochromatosis.
- Lifestyle Factors: Your reduced alcohol intake and balanced diet are positive changes for your liver health.
Explanation
Imaging Techniques: CT scans and MRIs use different technology to capture images of organs. Sometimes, certain conditions like mild enlargement might be more apparent on an MRI, which can provide more detailed images of soft tissues compared to a CT scan. Therefore, it is possible for the CT to report a "normal" liver size while an MRI might detect subtle changes or enlargement.
Liver Size Measurement: In adults, a normal liver size usually measures around 15-17 cm in length. A liver size of 19 cm is considered mildly enlarged and could suggest early liver disease or other conditions. It's important to interpret this finding in the context of your overall health, laboratory results, and symptoms.
Next Steps
-
Monitor Symptoms: Continue to keep track of any symptoms such as appetite changes, weight loss, or discomfort. Documenting these changes can provide useful information to your healthcare providers.
-
Follow Up with Healthcare Providers: Contact your primary care physician and hematologist about the MRI results. They may want to repeat blood tests to monitor liver function or iron levels, or perform further imaging if necessary.
-
Lifestyle Considerations:
- Maintain your reduced alcohol consumption as it can significantly benefit liver health.
- Continue your balanced diet with foods high in antioxidants, such as fruits and vegetables, and consider foods rich in omega-3 fatty acids like fish.
- Stay hydrated and avoid any substances that can further stress your liver, such as excessive medications or supplements not prescribed by your doctor.
-
Prepare Questions: When you meet with your healthcare team, consider asking about:
- Potential implications of the enlarged liver and what follow-up might be needed.
- Recommendations for managing your hemochromatosis effectively.
- Any need for additional lifestyle modifications.
Conclusion
Your concern about liver size is valid, and it’s wise to stay proactive. While it's understandable to be worried about discrepancies in test results, discussing them with your healthcare providers will yield the most accurate follow-up steps tailored to your needs. Remember, you're actively participating in your health, which is a significant step forward. If you have any further concerns, I'm here to help.
Related Questions
Seeking Answers: Unexplained Symptoms
Profile Information: - **Age**: 15 - **Gender**: Female - **Height**: 5'3 - **Ethnicity**: Caucasian **Medication Regimen**: - Lisdexamfetamine: 40 mg daily - Famotidine: 20 mg, twice daily - Cetirizine: 40 mg daily I have been experiencing persistent pain for as long as I can recall, even before I started taking any medication, so I am skeptical about the drugs affecting my condition. Below is a compilation of my symptoms that I can remember offhand. My family has been advised on multiple occasions to consider testing for Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS) due to the alignment of my symptoms with the condition. My latest physician conducted laboratory tests to evaluate my tryptase levels without an initial baseline measurement. This was taken roughly 1.5 hours post-flare-up, which came back low. Consequently, she concluded that I do not have MCAS, but after researching further, I found that low levels do not definitively rule it out. I am reaching out for guidance—can anyone assist me in understanding my situation? **Presented Symptoms**: - Persistent hives - Facial flushing - Cognitive fog - Recurring headaches - Abdominal discomfort - Irregular bowel movements (ranging from diarrhea to constipation) - Anxiety attacks - Low blood pressure - Episodes of dizziness - Rapid heartbeat - Chronic fatigue - Episodes of fever - Severe joint pain - Night sweats - Bloating - Elevated sensitivity to sunlight - Intolerance to heat I frequently experience multiple symptoms together during flare-ups, with at least one flare occurring daily. The hives tend to emerge 1 to 3 times each day, primarily triggered by sun exposure and heightened emotional states, although at times they arise with no apparent cause. These flare-ups can occur abruptly, lasting anywhere from 15 minutes to several hours.
Should I Seek Medical Attention?
At 22 years old, I am a female who has been on medications like duloxetine, lamotrigine, and hydroxyzine for several years. I have managed to keep my Graves' disease under control, but I have reasons to believe I may also be experiencing symptoms of POTS (Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome). Last year, I was scheduled to consult a neurologist regarding hand tremors and the possibility of fibromyalgia. Unfortunately, I could not continue my treatment after relocating and losing my health insurance. Just 15 minutes ago, I fainted. Prior to that incident, I was feeling unwell—dizzy, my vision was blurry, and I experienced a whooshing sensation along with heat in my ears. My face and arms also felt tingly. After fainting, I experienced a heavy, aching sensation in my head, and I still have a headache now. Additionally, I’ve been waking up with headaches for a couple of days. I want to know if it's advisable to go to the emergency room. It's important to note that this isn’t my first fainting spell; I had one incident years back, which helped me recognize the signs when it started happening. At that time, I was lifting a heavy bed frame, and when I began to feel faint, I tried to sit down but stood back up to assist, and that’s when I lost consciousness. I’m unsure how long I was out, but I initially thought I was just sleeping before realizing what had happened when I regained awareness.
Seeking Guidance for My Mother's Sudden Hearing Loss Case
I am looking for advice regarding my mother's situation with sudden sensorineural hearing loss (SSNHL). **Patient Overview:** - **Age:** 48 years - **Gender:** Female - **Medical Issues:** Hypothyroidism and overweight (approximately 95 kg at the onset) - **Treatment:** Thyroid medication (25 mcg taken daily) **Medical Background:** In November 2025, my mother experienced an abrupt hearing loss in her right ear accompanied by dizziness and nausea. We consulted several ENT specialists within approximately 36 hours following the onset of her symptoms. She received a diagnosis of SSNHL but unfortunately, she did not undergo intratympanic steroid injections during the critical first 24 hours that could have aided her recovery. Despite receiving subsequent treatment, she has not regained hearing in her affected ear. **Examination Results:** - **Audiogram:** Loss of approximately 100 dB in the right ear; left ear shows normal hearing. - **Brain MRI:** A normal scan was conducted previously, ruling out tumors. - **Laboratory Tests:** Recent blood tests (including thyroid function, HbA1c, renal and liver function tests, CBC, etc.) show elevated TSH (6.73) and a HbA1c of 8.5%. We are currently preparing for a contrast MRI to eliminate the possibility of a vestibular schwannoma or nerve issues. **Current Condition:** The hearing loss persists in her right ear. She is feeling anxious about the upcoming contrast MRI, which involves gadolinium injection. However, she has started making positive lifestyle changes and has lost about 4.5 kg over the past two months, adhering to a protein-rich diet and a walking regimen. **My Inquiries:** 1. Is it still beneficial to perform a contrast MRI several months after the initial SSNHL diagnosis, considering that a normal MRI has already been completed? 2. For cases such as this—severe SSNHL with delayed steroid intervention—are there realistic prospects for hearing recovery at a later date? 3. Are there any additional tests or treatments that should be taken into account at this stage? 4. For family gatherings where loud music will be present, would high-quality earplugs or noise-canceling earbuds be a good option to safeguard her healthier ear? 5. Is it advisable for her to continue with whey protein supplementation and the weight-loss plan? 6. What should we prioritize for long-term management: hearing aids, rehabilitation, regular monitoring, etc.? I recognize that the chances of recovery may be slim, but I want to ensure we are covering all bases and that her care plan is appropriate. I appreciate any insights or suggestions you can offer. Thank you for your assistance!
Evaluating the Reliability of Blood Tests for Liver Disease
As a 30-year-old man who has indulged in heavy drinking during weekends for the past decade, I recently sought to understand the health of my liver through a blood test conducted at a laboratory. Initially, I felt a wave of relief when I received my results indicating that all my liver enzyme levels were within normal limits. However, my sense of security was short-lived as I stumbled upon information suggesting that some forms of liver disease might not be detectable through standard blood testing. This has prompted me to question the extent to which I can rely on my test results. Is it possible that underlying issues might still exist despite what the blood work revealed?
Mysterious Health Decline
My uncle, a 64-year-old man, is experiencing a steep decline in health, yet the physicians he has consulted seem baffled by his condition. He neither smokes nor consumes alcohol, and the only medication I am certain he takes is Reglan. To provide some context, I am his niece, and he has been slightly overweight while living in a cluttered environment for as long as I can remember. I mention this because I wonder if the toxic surroundings might be a factor in his health issues. Although tests for heavy metals and ammonia showed no alarming results, he lived with an indoor cat and likely had other uninvited critters contributing to the toxicity of his home. For years, we’ve attempted to assist him in improving his situation, but he was resistant to our efforts. In September 2025, he underwent gallbladder removal surgery. Prior to this, he was capable of functioning independently. Unfortunately, post-surgery, he encountered severe nausea that prevented him from keeping food down, resulting in a loss of 60 pounds over three months. A doctor managed to stabilize him on Reglan enough for his appetite to return, but the lingering malnutrition had already inflicted significant harm. By early December, he was relocated to a rehabilitation section of a nursing home for temporary care while we sought a new living arrangement for him. Since that time, he has lost all mobility in his legs and his left arm. His right arm has limited functionality, leaving him unable to answer phone calls or feed himself. Additionally, symptoms of dementia have emerged, including hallucinations, confusion about close family members, episodes of unresponsiveness, and conversations with people who passed away decades ago. Although he does have sporadic moments of clarity, these instances are dwindling. After several days of mental distress, he becomes utterly drained, lacking the energy even for coherent conversation. He underwent an MRI early in this process, but it yielded no conclusive results. Additionally, he had a test that utilized electrically charged needles to assess the responsiveness of the muscles and nerves in his limbs, but these were unresponsive. Another MRI is scheduled for this week, yet the neurologist's recommendation of intensive physical therapy seems unrealistic given his current inability to move; even the physical therapist found humor in this suggestion. Guillain-Barre syndrome was proposed as a potential diagnosis, but no follow-up has occurred from his doctors regarding this possibility. Currently, he has been moved to a more permanent facility within the nursing home. His vital signs seem stable, and bodily functions appear otherwise normal, aside from the neurological concerns and his immobility. Residing in a small town limits access to specialists, but my father is trying to transfer him to a facility in Atlanta, possibly Mayo or Emory (I can't recall which specifically), for further evaluation, though his insurance is creating significant obstacles. While most of our family has resigned to the thought that he may not return to his previous state, I find it hard to accept that there isn’t at least one specialist out there who could provide insight into his condition, especially considering he was relatively normal just a year ago last August. Any thoughts or suggestions for additional testing would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for taking the time to read this lengthy message.