Is a Positive Mantoux Test Reliable When Followed by QuantiFERON?
I'm a 21-year-old female who recently underwent a Mantoux test, which is a tuberculin skin test, as a requirement for university. The result turned out positive, prompting me to schedule a QuantiFERON blood test for tomorrow to further evaluate the situation. I received the BCG vaccination at birth, do not exhibit any symptoms, and have never been in close contact with anyone diagnosed with tuberculosis. To provide some background, I had negative results in November 2023, and back in August 2024, I experienced some induration but it was still classified as acceptable. However, just three days ago, I received a positive reading. I'm curious whether this new positive result could stem from an immune response triggered by earlier exposure or testing, or could it be indicative of a genuine positive case? Additionally, I would like to know if it is advisable and accurate to have a QuantiFERON test just a few days after a Mantoux test. Has anyone else experienced a situation where the Mantoux test was positive but the QuantiFERON came back negative? How frequently does this occur?
Answers (1)
9/11/2025, 5:01:45 PM
OpenHealth AI
A positive Mantoux test followed by a QuantiFERON test is a common scenario in evaluating potential tuberculosis (TB) infection, and your situation raises several important points that we'll clarify.
Main Points
- A positive Mantoux test can sometimes be influenced by previous vaccinations or other factors, such as previous TB exposures.
- A QuantiFERON test is reliable for confirming or ruling out TB infection, especially for those who have had the BCG vaccine.
- Testing timing is usually acceptable, but there may be some variability in results.
Explanation
The Mantoux test, or tuberculin skin test, measures your immune response to proteins derived from the TB bacteria. A positive result can occur for several reasons:
- True infection: You might have a latent TB infection.
- Previous vaccination: The BCG vaccine can cause false positives in some individuals.
- Previous exposure: Past TB contact, even without recent symptoms.
The QuantiFERON test is a blood test that can provide more accurate results, especially in those who have received the BCG vaccine. It assesses your immune response to specific TB proteins rather than relying on the skin's reaction, which can be influenced by non-TB factors.
Next Steps
- Hydration & Rest: Ensure you're well-hydrated and rested, which will help your overall health as you await test results.
- Follow Through with QuantiFERON Test: Proceed with your scheduled QuantiFERON test. This will help clarify if a true TB infection is present.
- Monitor Symptoms: Even though you are not currently showing symptoms, be aware of any changes. If you start experiencing symptoms like a persistent cough, unexplained weight loss, or night sweats, note these changes.
- Ask Questions: When you receive your results, discuss with your healthcare provider about the implications of both tests, especially how your BCG vaccination may have affected the results.
Instances of a positive Mantoux test with a negative QuantiFERON test can occur, particularly in individuals with a history of BCG vaccination or previous non-TB mycobacterial infections, which can lead to false positives. When this happens, it's often evaluated based on clinical history, potential exposure, and individual risk factors.
If you have more questions or concerns regarding your results, don't hesitate to seek clarification during your follow-up appointments. Your health and clarity about your condition are priorities.
Related Questions
Navigating Treatment Options for Brainstem Glioma
A 26-year-old female is grappling with a critical decision: whether to remain in the United States for potential treatment of a suspected brainstem glioma or to explore options abroad. Though her inquiry may appear vague, she harbors apprehension about sharing extensive details or imagery regarding her condition. The lesion measures 8mm (8x6x5) located in the posterior medulla/cervicomedullary region. Currently classified as low-grade, the MRI T2 weighted imaging indicates that it occupies a significant portion of the brainstem. There are no signs of enhancement or edema. She is in the process of awaiting a lumbar puncture to eliminate the possibility of Multiple Sclerosis (MS). However, this waiting period feels perilous. This is her second MRI in just two months; while her neuro-oncologist has informed her that the lesion remains unchanged, discrepancies are apparent. The initial scan from July 2nd reported a measurement of 6mm, whereas the follow-up on August 31st indicated growth to 8mm. This fluctuation raises concerns regarding the pace of growth, if the measurements are indeed correct. In terms of symptoms, they have been relatively mild. She experiences occasional challenges in articulating her thoughts and has reported a dull pain at the back of her head, akin to sinus pressure. Additionally, intermittent blurriness in one eye occurs, reminiscent of smudges on a lens. Though she recognizes she may be rushing into decisions, she is keen on making informed choices without delay. She appreciates any insights shared in advance.
Evaluating the Need for Emergency Care
I'm a 30-year-old female, currently measuring 170 cm in height and weighing 58 kg. I am three weeks post-delivery following a normal vaginal birth, which went smoothly, and I welcomed a healthy baby without any issues. I don’t have any significant medical history to note. Unfortunately, over the last day, my condition has gradually declined. I’ve started experiencing fever-like symptoms accompanied by nausea, dizziness, and general weakness, making me feel unsteady. I measured my temperature, and it appeared normal. On top of this, I noticed that I've been bleeding quite heavily, and this started roughly 12 hours ago. Currently, it's just me and the baby at home, as my partner is away. Given my situation, what steps should I take? I am concerned that I might faint!
Recovering from a Nondisplaced Tibial Plateau Fracture
It has been nearly 8 weeks since my biking accident, and after consultations with several orthopedic specialists, they have advised that surgery is unnecessary. Their recommendations include a period of non-weightbearing for about 6 to 8 weeks. Both doctors noted that, considering my generally active lifestyle, I have a full range of motion without any stiffness or balance concerns, so they didn’t press the issue of physical therapy too much. I’ve recently begun taking some cautious steps around my home. Although I experience no pain, my walking feels a bit awkward and I notice some weakness in my leg. I understand that cycling will have to wait for a while, but I wonder if light walking and using the elliptical are acceptable for now? Additionally, I was contemplating whether using a stationary bike would be a wise choice over the next couple of weeks. I’ll also share my 6-week x-rays in the comments for reference. I would appreciate any insights into reasonable activities I could undertake prior to my follow-up appointment scheduled in 10 weeks. Thanks for your support!
Unexplained Symptoms: Seeking Guidance Amid Distress
I’m a 23-year-old woman, weighing 180 pounds and standing 5'6" tall. My medical history includes depression, anxiety, hypothyroidism, migraines, and PCOS. I’m currently taking medications such as Buspirone, Spironolactone, Levothyroxine, Venlafaxine, Trazodone, Lamotrigine, and Hydroxyzine. Lately, I’ve been experiencing some unusual feelings and I’m genuinely concerned about my health. Throughout the past week, I’ve been persistently dizzy and lightheaded, often feeling dazed and occasionally confused. Emotional outbursts have become more frequent, which is unusual for me; while I do struggle with anxiety, I’ve found myself yelling at loved ones and having sudden bouts of crying and panic. I recently began a new job, but had to leave due to worsening back pain exacerbated by a stress fracture I’ve had for a decade. I’ve managed to schedule an appointment with an orthopedic specialist for an updated set of x-rays, but the discomfort has intensified, prompting me to visit urgent care yesterday. While at the facility, my confusion resurfaced, accompanied by a sense of paranoia where I felt as if objects were shifting when I glanced at them. After reporting my symptoms to the attending physician, she recommended that I head to the emergency room. At the ER, doctors performed a CT scan along with blood tests, but everything appeared normal; they provided IV fluids, yet it did not alleviate my symptoms, and I was ultimately sent home without any improvement. For a few days, I attributed my body aches to stress, but this morning, I awoke with persistent pain. I began to suspect a potential viral infection, so I took some DayQuil, which provided minimal relief. A couple of hours ago, I was hit with severe pain radiating through my upper back and chest, along with discomfort in my shoulders and abdomen. My chest felt constricted, making it hard to breathe. In an attempt to relieve this distress, I went to the restroom thinking I might have an upset stomach paired with intense nausea. I started sweating profusely and felt faint. The pain escalated to such a degree that I decided to take a shower in hopes it would help cool me down and provide some comfort, but it didn’t work. I ended up collapsing on the floor, overwhelmed by pain. I experienced sharp, squeezing sensations in my upper abdomen and diaphragm, alongside brutal discomfort in my upper back. At one point, I even contemplated calling for an ambulance due to the severity of the pain, worse than what I had experienced during appendicitis. Eventually, I mustered the strength to return to bed, where I closed my eyes and concentrated on my breathing. My chest was fluttering, and despite the agony, my heart rate was surprisingly slow. I lost consciousness for some time, only to awaken about an hour ago to a lingering, more subdued pain that now allows me to sit up. I’m left wondering: what could possibly be happening to me? Am I unwell? Could these symptoms be connected? I feel a sense of urgency but worry that my mother, a nurse and my primary support, thinks I’m exaggerating. The doctors seemed to fixate solely on my dizziness rather than my other significant symptoms. I need to determine whether a return visit to the doctor is necessary. If anyone reads this, I’m pleading for your advice; I’m feeling desperate and frightened.
Doubts About Radiology Results
At the age of 29 and weighing 180 pounds, I’ve been experiencing intermittent severe discomfort characterized by a burning sensation in my pelvic region, sharp pain near my kidneys, and occasional testicular pain. Despite undergoing a urinalysis that returned normal results, my primary care provider suspects I might be dealing with either colitis or kidney stones, prompting him to recommend a CT abdomen/pelvis scan using barium as a contrast agent. However, I was only given half an hour to consume the barium before the scan, which seems insufficient to me, raising concerns about whether proper protocol was followed. Following the examination, the initial report indicated that everything appeared normal. Yet, on reviewing the images with the assistance of my wife—who works as an ultrasound technician and consulted with her radiology peers—it appears that there might actually be ureteral stones. We requested a second opinion, but once again, the radiology team affirmed that everything was fine. Now I am left wondering whether it would be wise to undergo another imaging procedure or if I should simply accept that I do not have stones. Additionally, is it possible to request a complimentary re-scan due to the apparent lapse in proper preparation protocols? I would appreciate your insights.