Understanding CRPS: My Personal Experience
At 22 years old, standing 5 feet 3 inches tall and weighing 220 pounds, I have been navigating the complex challenges of a medical condition following a significant injury to my hand. Four months ago, I sustained an oblique fracture to my fourth metacarpal that was not only displaced but also shortened by nearly 5mm. Despite my insistence on needing surgical intervention, several medical professionals dismissed the seriousness of my injury, failing to recognize the extent of the damage and its implications for my recovery. Since having the cast removed, I've encountered a multitude of difficulties. My hand has remained consistently swollen and painful, limiting my ability to perform even the simplest tasks. Unfortunately, I received minimal guidance or resources from my medical team, but through experimentation, I managed to discover a supportive brace that has proven somewhat effective for my needs. About four weeks ago, I observed a marked reduction in swelling, yet a prominent red discoloration emerged along the dorsal aspect of the fracture site – precisely where the bone protrudes by approximately 2mm. Accompanying this was an increase in sharp pain, especially when the surrounding soft tissue moved over the area, intensifying as the swelling subsided. In a matter of days, the pain endured and manifested as a significant discoloration, with the skin beginning to thin. I’ve become acutely aware of a cyclical pattern of pain that seems to alternate with my activity levels. Over consecutive days, the discomfort builds as I use my hand, often culminating in a sudden increase in pain within an hour, regardless of whether swelling is present. Following such episodes, rest—sometimes alongside medication—allows the pain to diminish over several hours. During these times, I experience notable pain localized around the fracture site and even in areas of my palm and between the metacarpals. It appears that mechanical triggers, such as gripping objects or long periods of holding things, exacerbate my condition. Anti-inflammatory medications provide moderate relief, while muscle relaxants do not seem to help at all. I try to limit my reliance on the brace, but when worn for extended periods, it can sometimes grant me a brief window of pain-free activity. What puzzles me is that I lack many characteristic symptoms of Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) aside from the persistent pain and skin changes. My hand specialist insists that they are unable to provide further assistance, yet I do not experience discoloration in other areas of my hand during pain flares, nor do I observe significant swelling where it is affected. Pressing on the painful regions does not typically cause discomfort, except for when applying considerable pressure directly on the fractured site or during movement when tissue interacts with it. The swelling itself also seems to fluctuate randomly, which makes me question its relation to CRPS. None of the classic symptoms align with my experience. I have diligently adhered to my rehabilitation program without noticeable improvement, and my therapist has recommended I undergo a reevaluation before progressing with treatment. Admittedly, I am not a medical expert and possess limited knowledge regarding this condition, yet I firmly believe that the CRPS diagnosis does not resonate with my situation. Based on my findings, the therapeutic approaches typically recommended for CRPS do not align with my specific challenges, leading me to doubt their potential effectiveness in my case. While I am not actively seeking a diagnosis, I yearn for a clearer understanding of CRPS, hoping to gain insights that could better illuminate how my symptoms might relate to this condition.
Answers (1)
9/11/2025, 1:50:50 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel confused and frustrated given what you've been experiencing with your hand after your injury. Your symptoms and the complexity of your situation seem to be causing you a lot of distress. Let’s address your concerns about Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) and offer insight on what steps you might take moving forward.
Key Points:
- Understanding CRPS: While some of your symptoms align with CRPS, such as persistent pain and skin changes, many classic indicators may not fully apply to your case.
- Focus on Managing Symptoms: Implementing strategies to control pain and improve function in your hand is crucial.
- Seek Detailed Evaluation: A reevaluation with a pain specialist could provide more specific insights.
Explanation:
CRPS is typically characterized by prolonged pain and changes in the skin, which may include swelling, color changes, and temperature differences. However, everyone’s experience can vary significantly, and your observation that you don’t exhibit many classic CRPS symptoms is valid. Your fluctuating pain, swelling, and lack of significant discoloration in areas outside the affected site can complicate diagnosis and management.
It’s common for chronic pain conditions to lack a consistent presentation. Despite some overlap in symptoms, your unique situation might not entirely fit into CRPS criteria, which is often diagnosed based on specific presentations.
Next Steps:
-
Symptom Tracking: Keep a detailed journal of your symptoms, including pain levels, triggers, what alleviated it, and any changes in swelling or skin color. This information can help healthcare providers better understand your condition.
-
Follow Up with Specialists: Given the complexity of your symptoms and their impact on your life, consider seeking a second opinion from a pain management specialist or a neurologist experienced with CRPS and chronic pain conditions. They can assess your case holistically and may recommend tests like imaging or nerve conduction studies.
-
Physical Therapy Adjustments: Continue with physical therapy, but communicate your concerns and symptoms clearly to your therapist. They may need to adjust your therapy techniques or focus on different modalities, such as desensitization practices or specific strengthening exercises for your hand.
-
Pain Management Strategies: In addition to anti-inflammatory medications, discuss other pain management options with your doctor, like topical pain relief ointments, nerve blocks, or newer medications that may help with nerve-related pain.
-
Education on CRPS: Consider researching CRPS-related resources from reputable sources like the Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome Association (RSDSA) or similar organizations. This could help you better understand your diagnosis if applicable and highlight overlapping symptoms.
Conclusion:
It’s commendable that you are actively seeking more understanding and looking to enhance your management of these symptoms. Recognize that your experience is valid, and there are strategies to explore that could help improve your situation. You aren’t alone in navigating these challenges, and the pursuit of further clarity through specialists is a productive path forward. If you have further questions or need more information on specific therapies or strategies, feel free to ask!
Related Questions
Inquiry About MRI Findings
Male, 32 years old, height 5'10", weight 78 kg, from the UK. For as long as I can recall, I've been experiencing symptoms of Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), which were so intense that I frequently found myself rushing back home. Recently, this transitioned into severe constipation that felt as though something was physically blocking my system. While laxatives were ineffective, I did find some relief with saline enemas. I would like to inquire whether the coiled, vein-like structure noted on the right side of the MRI images is a normal finding or if it appears inflamed and might be contributing to my colon issues. Additionally, I often experience discomfort in my lower back in the vicinity of this anomaly, which tends to swell significantly. (Note: Created a temporary account for privacy reasons.) *Edited to correct a typographical error.
Seeking Guidance: 24-Year-Old Woman with Neurofibromatosis and Multiple Health Challenges
Hello Reddit community, I am reaching out to gather insights and assistance regarding my health issues from medical professionals and knowledgeable individuals beyond the borders of my country. I find myself in a challenging situation and am uncertain about the next steps I can take, which prompts my appeal for help. As a 24-year-old woman, I have been grappling with a series of complex health problems. To ensure clarity, I will outline my conditions: I have been diagnosed with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1), and I also suffer from a diaphragmatic hernia along with a paralyzed vocal cord nerve. Additionally, I experience Horner’s syndrome, and I had a severed gastric nerve post-surgery, which required stomach surgery and has resulted in reflux. My medical team has conducted various cultures and bronchoscopy but has not detected any bacterial infections. While my condition tends to stabilize briefly, I often experience sudden bouts of extreme breathlessness, along with increased humidity in the air, fever spikes, and require substantial oxygen support. My treatment with meropenem, a broad-spectrum antibiotic, is the only therapy that seems to provide me with any relief. Currently, I find myself with no other alternatives after this treatment. Since English is not my native language, I hope the information I have shared suffices to attract the attention of anyone who can offer valuable advice regarding my condition. I am eager to connect with individuals who might have similar experiences or knowledge of treatments that could be beneficial for patients like me. If there exist medications or therapies outside my country that have proven effective for individuals with my ailments, I would greatly appreciate learning about them, as I am in desperate need of solutions. At present, I am reliant on Optiflow oxygen therapy in intensive care, facing the potential of needing to transition to a ventilator as my only remaining option. My body is currently battling a fever of 39.5 degrees Celsius (103.1 degrees Fahrenheit) on September 11, 2025. To provide further context, I wanted to share several reports from my medical history detailing my hospitalization: 1. **September 1, 2025:** - Conclusion: 24-year-old female with neurofibromatosis type 1 and recurrent respiratory infections. Possible cyclic vomiting or microaspiration post-gastric bypass. 2. **Hospitalized on August 31, 2025:** - Diagnosis: Recurrent respiratory failure due to suspected chemical pneumonitis or silent aspiration. Initiated meropenem treatment for suspected pneumonia. - Summary: Admission with recurrent lower respiratory infections, experiencing dyspnea and fever during treatment with levofloxacin. 3. **August 22, 2025 (Pulmonology):** - Diagnosed with recurrent pulmonary neurofibromatosis alongside respiratory infections and neutrophil dysplasia. Had an ongoing fever with hypoxemia under piperacillin-tazobactam treatment; working diagnosis includes chemical pneumonitis with differential pulmonary infections. - Treatment with meropenem for two weeks. 4. **August 18, 2025:** - Post-termed bronchoscopy with further assessments required after finishing meropenem. 5. **August 13, 2025:** - Conclusion: Patient previously identified with recurrent pulmonary neurofibromatosis who was readmitted due to respiratory failure. Last discharged on July 30 after managing infection with tazocin. - Readmission on August 1 due to another episode of fever and hypoxemia requiring high-level oxygen. I sincerely hope that by sharing my story and these reports, it may shed light on my health challenges and lead to hopeful solutions. Thank you for taking the time to read my plea.
Could This Bump Be a Simple Irritation or a Sign of Something Serious?
I am a 25-year-old male, weighing 80 kg and standing 186 cm tall. I do not have any chronic illnesses and I'm a non-smoker. My sexual activity is regular. Recently, I've been battling a cold for a few days and have been consuming a lot of hot beverages, including teas and soups. This leads me to wonder if the bump I’ve noticed is due to irritation from hot liquids, though I can't recall specifically burning my tongue. Is there a reason to be worried about this bump?
Navigating My Mother’s Health Decline
I’m reaching out for guidance on how to engage with my mother’s primary care physician (PCP) and what information to seek out. My mother is on a managed care plan, yet her symptoms continue to deteriorate, rendering her nearly unable to consume food. **Current Challenges:** My mom has recently experienced a significant increase in numbness in both her arms and legs, along with severe pain in the muscles of her inner thighs. She is plagued by persistent coughing spells and has lost her appetite drastically, averaging fewer than 600 calories daily. Notably, she struggles even with rice, which sometimes leads to vomiting. Additionally, her water intake has significantly decreased. Despite regular visits to her PCP, she feels dismissed, as her recent blood tests showed no concerning issues, and she was advised to return home. This lack of nourishment has resulted in a weight loss of over 20 pounds in less than three months, dropping from a starting weight of 120 pounds. Movement is now limited for her; she can barely walk from one end of the living room to the other due to weakness and continuous coughing episodes throughout the day. **Medications:** Currently, she is prescribed sodium chloride tablets to address a previous sodium deficiency, Zoloft at a 25mg dosage to assist with sleep, and Gabapentin at 100mg for the numbness in her extremities. She also has a medication for bowel issues, though I can’t recall its name, which she takes only when she has not had a bowel movement for three days. **Duration of Symptoms:** These health concerns have persisted since May 15, 2025, spanning approximately four months. **Upcoming Specialist Appointment:** Next week, she has an appointment with a pulmonologist to go over the results of a PET scan related to a nodule found in her right lung. **Background Information:** In May, my mother was diagnosed with SIADH. She fainted twice post-hospital discharge, likely due to her low sodium levels. The incidents occurred on June 19 and again in August. Both times resulted in hospital visits, yet fortunately, CT scans revealed no fractures or significant head trauma. Prior to May 2025, her health issues were limited to knee pain. In early May, she sought medical attention due to a sizable abscess located at the back of her neck, just beneath her hairline. After failing to improve, it was drained at the hospital. Following this procedure, she was prescribed sulfamethoxazole for antibiotics and wound care. However, a week later, she had a reaction and was treated with banophen for the rash, along with Keflex and methylprednisolone. A day later, she drove herself back to the hospital due to neurological distress, experiencing nerve pain that prevented her from finding comfort. After leaving against medical advice, she appeared disoriented the following morning and was subsequently readmitted for more than a week. During that time, doctors noted elevated troponin levels, indicating possible cardiac issues, alongside low sodium and high blood pressure. Upon my insistence regarding her numbness and dietary struggles, they conducted several imaging tests, but no clear diagnosis was established. Only a nephrologist addressed her low sodium concerns. Ultimately, after being treated for SIADH with tolvaptan, which she could not tolerate due to severe nausea causing further fainting episodes, she was switched to sodium chloride pills after a subsequent hospitalization in August. A concerning nodule (2.1 cm) was discovered in her upper right lung lobe during that stay, leading to a referral for a PET scan. The results hinted at possible neoplastic changes, but we await the pulmonologist's review next week for clarification on whether this indicates cancer or a benign growth. Since her hospital discharge following the second fainting episode, her ability to eat has rapidly declined, with her being unable to tolerate even simple foods like bananas and rice. She relies on Ensure for nutrition, as she does retain some hunger yet continues to struggle with sleep due to persistent pain and numbness in her limbs.
Post-Appendix Surgery Complications in a 70-Year-Old Woman
Hello everyone, I am reaching out to seek guidance regarding my mother, who is in her early 70s. Prior to her emergency operation for a perforated appendix, she was completely self-sufficient and mentally sharp. Now, she finds herself in the hospital facing multiple challenges after the surgery. I would greatly appreciate any recommendations on what inquiries I should pose to her medical team. ## Primary Concerns: - **Delirium and Confusion**: My mother has been excessively drowsy, occasionally forgetful, and at times fails to recognize me. She struggles to recall how she arrived at the hospital and keeps questioning when her surgery will occur, despite it already having taken place. She is currently on a range of medications, including Zosyn (piperacillin/tazobactam), gabapentin, clonazepam, and Tylenol. She received Toradol for just two days but exhibited confusion even prior to that. Could her medications or the infection she’s battling be contributing to her cognitive impairment? - **Abdominal Distension and Discomfort**: Her abdomen appears hard and swollen. Two KUB X-rays indicated a potential obstruction; however, the surgeon suspects an ileus because she’s had watery stools. Should I advocate for further diagnostic procedures, such as a CT scan? - **Stool Concerns**: She has experienced frequent green, watery diarrhea. Is this a side effect of the antibiotics? Would it be appropriate to request a C. difficile stool test? - **Urinary Symptoms**: She mentions a burning sensation during urination. The nursing staff indicated that a urine test is unnecessary since she’s receiving antibiotics. Is this correct, or should I insist on getting a urinalysis or culture? - **Severe Lethargy**: She has been sleeping extensively throughout the day. Could this be attributed to her medication, her renal function (eGFR approximately 52-60), or an ongoing infection? - **Hemoglobin Levels**: Her hemoglobin dropped to 8.5 and has since risen to 9.8, with the doctors asserting that a transfusion isn’t required. Should I explore the possibility of iron supplements or alternate treatments? - **Dietary Needs**: She remains on a liquid diet, and lab results show low albumin and protein levels. There have been contradictory responses from the doctors regarding the progression of her diet. Would it be wise to request a consultation with a nutritionist or recommend supplements? - **Hydration Issues**: My mother appears weak and has not been drinking sufficient fluids. For several days, she was administered only IV antibiotics without continuous fluid support until I intervened. Lab results revealed low CO₂ and high chloride levels. How can I ensure she maintains adequate hydration? ## Additional Information: - Blood cultures have identified Bacteroides fragilis. - She is currently receiving IV Zosyn. - Although her fever has subsided, she is still experiencing significant weakness, bloating, and fatigue, about five days post-operation. ## Questions for the Community: 1. Are symptoms such as confusion, abdominal swelling, watery stools, painful urination, and excessive tiredness to be expected after a perforated appendix surgery and subsequent antibiotic treatment? 2. What potential complications should I ensure the medical team investigates before her discharge? 3. Is it necessary to press for further tests, like a repeat CT scan, urinalysis, a C. difficile stool test, or a nutrition consultation? 4. Could her current medication regimen (gabapentin, clonazepam, Toradol, Zosyn) be exacerbating her lethargy and confusion? 5. What topics should I address in discharge planning to ensure she might continue IV antibiotics at home safely? 🙏 I would greatly appreciate any assistance you can provide. My goal is to ensure that I am asking the appropriate questions and not overlooking anything critical.