OpenHealth Q&A

Get answered by medical professionals

Exploring Rhinoplasty Options: Specialized Surgeons vs. General Practitioners

9/8/2025, 5:01:21 PMMale25-34

As a 27-year-old woman in good health and a non-smoker, I'm contemplating undergoing my first rhinoplasty. I've come across surgeons in Beverly Hills, such as those at the Beverly Hills Rhinoplasty Center, who seem to specialize solely in nose procedures rather than offering a broader selection of cosmetic surgeries. Is this specialization a common trend in the field? On one hand, a surgeon dedicated exclusively to rhinoplasty might possess unparalleled knowledge and expertise in this area. Conversely, I wonder if a general plastic surgeon, who has experience across various cosmetic procedures, could leverage a wider range of surgical techniques that might influence both the aesthetics and functionality of the results. My aspirations for this surgery are: - To achieve subtle, natural results - To minimize visible scarring - To either maintain or enhance my ability to breathe comfortably I would greatly value feedback from both practitioners and individuals who have undergone similar procedures. Do surgeons who focus solely on rhinoplasty tend to yield superior results compared to their generalist counterparts? Are there any recognized benefits or potential drawbacks associated with either choice?

Internal MedicineEndocrinologyRheumatology

Answers (1)

Cony

9/8/2025, 5:01:49 PM

OpenHealth AI

Choosing the right surgeon for rhinoplasty is essential for achieving your desired results. Here’s a breakdown of considerations regarding specialized versus general plastic surgeons.

Main Points:

  1. Specialization vs. General Practice: Both types of surgeons can provide quality care, but their focus may impact outcomes.
  2. Desired Surgical Outcomes: Your goals for a natural appearance, minimal scarring, and maintained or improved breathing should guide your choice.

Explanation:

Surgeons specializing in rhinoplasty often focus solely on this procedure, which allows them to refine their techniques and stay updated on the latest advancements. Their dedicated experience can be beneficial for achieving aesthetic goals and managing complex nose shapes. They may be more familiar with varying nasal anatomy and how to achieve both functional and cosmetic improvements.

On the other hand, general plastic surgeons bring a broader range of skills and might apply techniques learned from various types of surgeries that could enhance your specific outcome. They might also provide integrated care for other cosmetic procedures if you ever consider them in the future.

Next Steps:

  1. Research Specialized Surgeons: Look for board-certified surgeons who specialize in rhinoplasty. Check their before-and-after photos, reviews, and patient testimonials.
  2. Schedule Consultations: Meet with at least two surgeons (one specialized and one generalist) to discuss your goals and see how each approaches your specific needs. Pay attention to their suggested techniques for achieving a natural look and maintaining breathability.
  3. Inquire About Techniques: Ask about their approach to minimizing scarring and maximizing functionality. Surgeons should have a clear plan detailing how they can help you meet your goals.
  4. Review Results: Witnessing prior outcomes through photos and patient stories can provide insight into what you can expect.
  5. Trust Your Instincts: Choose the surgeon you feel most comfortable with and who best understands your aspirations.

Feel free to ask further questions or share additional concerns you might have about the process!

Related Questions

Understanding Lymph Node Sensitivity

A 32-year-old female with a BMI of 28 poses a concern about potential lymph node activity. Over the past three months, she has noticed tender areas coinciding with her menstrual cycle. She has detected slight lumps, but is careful not to press deeply into the tissue to avoid further discomfort. Initially, in December, the sensitivity was localized to the left side of her breast. In January, she observed similar tenderness in her inner left thigh, and by February, both areas and the region above her armpit were affected. Additionally, she has been experiencing fluctuations in her hormonal balance lately. The discomfort in her left breast has persisted for most of this time since December. She wonders whether this is a typical response from lymph nodes due to hormonal changes or if it would be advisable to consult her general practitioner for further evaluation.

Thyroid DisordersInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
24 minutes ago

What Could This Bump Be? Should I Be Concerned?

I’m a 22-year-old male, standing at 6 feet 2 inches tall and weighing 180 pounds. I currently don’t take any medications and have no significant medical history. Recently, I discovered two small, white bumps on my finger, which appeared around two days ago. They feel firm, much like the sensation of a splinter lodged underneath the skin, and they stick out slightly above the surface. One bump is located at the joint of one finger, while the other is positioned at the tip of another finger on my opposite hand. These bumps are neither painful nor bothersome, but I’m curious to know whether I should consider having them removed or if they might resolve on their own over time. I would appreciate any guidance regarding this matter. Thank you!

ArthritisLupusInternal Medicine
Male25-34
34 minutes ago

Is This a Hemorrhoid or Something Different?

Greetings everyone, I'm a 24-year-old male weighing 82 kg, and I’ve noticed a small, pinkish growth at the edge of my anus that appeared last Wednesday. This bump doesn’t seem to be deeply rooted, is only mildly painful, and mainly causes an uncomfortable sensation when I cough or tense the area. Notably, I haven’t observed any pus, significant swelling, or fever accompanying this. Currently, I am on a regimen that includes sertraline, Bifilac (a probiotic), and omeprazole. It's worth mentioning that I had an abscess before—located in my abdominal area—and that experience was quite distressing. Because of this, I find myself feeling anxious and concerned that I might overlook any early indicators this time around. Interestingly, the same day the bump appeared, I also began experiencing nasal congestion and a general sense of fatigue, resembling mild cold or viral symptoms. Do you think this situation aligns more with the characteristics of a hemorrhoid or perhaps a skin tag (papule), rather than an abscess? What typical signs and sensations might accompany early-stage hemorrhoids? I apologize for any discomfort caused by this topic, but I’m not looking for a diagnosis, just some insight into whether this aligns with common issues. Thanks for your help!

ArthritisLupusInternal Medicine
Male25-34
1 hour ago

Seeking Guidance on Recurring Pilonidal Sinus Issues

I'm a 17-year-old male of Indian descent, standing at 5'8" and weighing 103 kilograms, and I'm dealing with pilonidal sinus problems. My issues began when I noticed blood on the toilet seat; I initially dismissed it as perhaps an anal fissure. However, after four months, I visited a doctor who diagnosed me with a pilonidal sinus. My symptoms included an unpleasant odor and bloody discharge that often stained my clothing. Subsequently, I was placed on a surgical waiting list. By the time my surgery arrived, the situation had worsened significantly, making the procedure even more traumatic and painful than anticipated. The surgeon ended up removing more tissue than originally planned. During my recovery, I inspected the surgical site and discovered a noticeable indentation at the top with various irregular bumps extending down. The doctor assured me that these would eventually fade, but instead, they collected lint and hair over time. Fast forward a year, and I began to notice the same familiar odor again, filling me with anxiety about a potential recurrence. Now, as an 11th grader, I am under pressure to maintain good grades and cannot afford to miss school. Presently, my symptoms include the telltale smell, although I haven’t observed any discharge or developed any additional openings aside from the dimple left from my previous surgery. Before the operation, the infected sinuses extended close to the rectum, which is why I am concerned that a new pilonidal sinus may have formed in the same area. At this moment, I am free from pain but cannot shake the anxiety surrounding the reappearance of the odor associated with this uncomfortable condition.

Multiple SclerosisCrohn's DiseaseInternal Medicine
Male25-34
1 hour ago

Concerned About My Toes' Health

At 27 years old, I’m feeling overwhelmed about my foot condition. For over a decade, since I was 16, I’ve dealt with recurring athlete's foot, primarily between my last two toes on both feet. Despite my efforts to manage this issue with various creams, sprays, powders, and even discarding all my footwear to start anew, the problem persists. Now, I suspect I might be experiencing a nail infection. All of my toenails are fragile and don’t trim easily, and they seem to grow in an unusual manner. Particularly troubling is my big toe on both feet, which appears to have several layers of nails; it seems as if the nails detach from the base and grow upwards rather than falling off, resulting in a stack of nails. While my feet are not foul-smelling and there’s no discharge, I do notice some swelling, and occasionally, I experience pain while walking; it comes and goes. Recently, I observed that the area where my athlete's foot initially developed is now taking on a greenish hue. This has left me feeling quite embarrassed. Despite trying multiple treatments for athlete's foot and toenails, nothing has provided relief. I even reached out to my doctor, only to be informed that they don’t handle cases of athlete's foot. I am at my wit's end and genuinely concerned about what might happen to my toes. I would greatly appreciate any advice from medical professionals regarding my situation.

ArthritisInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
1 hour ago