Visited the Podiatrist for Foot Pain Advice and Left with a Prescription for Physical Therapy
Greetings, everyone! I’m a 30-year-old female, standing 5 feet 6 inches tall and weighing 215 pounds. Today, I consulted with a podiatrist seeking guidance on handling foot discomfort I've been experiencing at work. As a teacher, I commute on foot, and since the school year commenced, my feet have been in a great deal of pain. I’ve tried various shoe options, but even those that seem fine tend to wear out rather quickly. The ache is persistent, somewhat dull, and correlates with irritation in my plantar fascia, although it typically subsides after a few hours of rest. The discomfort particularly intensifies on days when I spend a lot of time standing at the board. I wanted to talk to a specialist not only for advice but possibly an examination, as I’m tired of purchasing improper footwear and insoles. To his credit, the podiatrist provided me with some insoles and mentioned that my foot could be cast for custom orthotics, pending insurance approval (he could only confirm that on Monday). Interestingly, he didn’t suggest any specific shoe brands but casually mentioned that some people prefer Hokas, followed by an odd question about my beach plans. I had clearly stated that my main concern was work-related foot pain; the beach wasn’t on my mind at all. It felt as though he wasn’t fully attentive to my concerns. I brought up a past instance where my mother suffered from plantar fasciitis, and he quickly jumped to proposing injections, which I turned down. He then informed me that I would also require six weeks of physical therapy—which he described as "painful at the start"—and would need to get X-rays. Despite my explanation that I reside in the city (while he practiced in the suburbs), he insisted that I should use the facilities he recommended in the suburbs, hinting that this was the preferable option. It felt as if he was vying for a long-term patient without adequately explaining why my seemingly minor ache necessitated such an extensive treatment plan. I felt pressured into scheduling a follow-up appointment a month later after I finish physical therapy, even though I was hesitant about proceeding with it before trying new shoes or inserts. Am I overreacting and possibly in need of more serious treatment than I anticipated, or was this podiatrist employing high-pressure sales tactics? I left feeling quite unsettled. While I don’t usually think of myself as someone who believes they know more than professionals based on online research, it was disheartening to feel unheard and as though I was being sold something. What should my next steps be?
Answers (1)
9/7/2025, 1:50:42 AM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you're feeling frustrated and uncertain about the treatment plan proposed by your podiatrist for your foot pain. You deserve to feel heard and to have a treatment approach that aligns with your needs. It’s common to have concerns about recommendations that seem extensive or unclear.
Summary of Key Points:
- Your foot pain may be related to plantar fasciitis, which often requires a multifaceted approach to treatment.
- It’s essential to ensure you feel comfortable and informed about any recommended treatments, including physical therapy and the use of orthotics.
- Consider alternative options and prioritizing what makes you feel secure in managing your condition.
Explanation:
Plantar fasciitis commonly causes pain on the bottom of the foot, particularly during activities that involve prolonged standing or walking. Treatment typically involves:
- Proper footwear and possibly customized orthotics.
- Physical therapy to strengthen muscles and improve flexibility.
- Gradual activity modifications to reduce stress on the plantar fascia.
Your concerns about the podiatrist's focus and the treatment suggestions are valid. It's important that your healthcare providers listen to your specific needs and explain why they recommend certain treatments.
Next Steps:
-
Reflect on Your Priorities: Take a moment to consider what you are most comfortable with moving forward. Is it trying new shoes/inserts, or are you open to pursuing the physical therapy and orthotics?
-
Research Footwear Options: Look for supportive footwear designed for people who stand for long periods. Brands like Hoka are designed for comfort, but it’s worthwhile to try on different brands to see what feels best. Consider shoes with:
- Good arch support
- Cushioning
- A wide toe box
-
Consultation for Second Opinion: If you're uncertain about the proposed physical therapy or injections, seeking a second opinion from another podiatrist may help clarify your options and confirm whether the suggested treatments are appropriate.
-
Gradually Increase Activity: If your pain improves with rest, consider gradually increasing your standing time and monitor how it feels.
-
Keep a Pain Journal: Document when the pain intensifies and any changes when trying new shoes or inserts. This information could be very useful for a follow-up appointment if you decide to pursue one.
You know your body best, and exploring alternate options or getting a second opinion could provide clarity and help create a treatment plan that feels right for you. Your comfort and health are paramount, so don’t hesitate to advocate for yourself during this process.
Related Questions
Frustrations with Ongoing Pain and Numbness on My Right Side
I'm feeling quite overwhelmed. Despite the notable compassion and efforts of various medical professionals over the years, my condition appears to be deteriorating, with symptoms intensifying in severity and frequency. I’m unsure whether what I’m experiencing are interrelated issues or separate anomalies that just happen to manifest on the right side of my body. Any suggestions or guidance on how to uncover the underlying causes would be greatly appreciated. For over three years, I’ve endured a numb sensation in the right side of my face, which tends to tingle upon rising and intensifies when I clean my ears. After undergoing an MRI to rule out a tumor, I was informed that it was psychosomatic, a diagnosis I accepted at the time. Around a year ago, I started experiencing severe, stabbing pains just beneath my right rib cage. Initially, these episodes were sporadic, occurring only once every few months, but following a particularly severe incident last year, I have been dealing with a low-level ache that has become a near-constant presence. Currently, doctors are still investigating these symptoms. Although an ultrasound did not reveal any clear issues—likely due to my slightly elevated weight impacting image clarity—a CT scan also yielded no results. I’ve been closely monitoring my diet since these pains reoccurred, but I see no meaningful connection. Interestingly, the onset of this discomfort was not triggered by movement; it has commenced while I was engaged in housework as well as during sleep. I have observed that lying too long can exacerbate the pain, especially if a pillow presses on my stomach. A colonoscopy yielded no findings, nor did stool sample tests. I have an appointment next week to further examine my stomach. Less than a year ago, I unexpectedly suffered a herniated disc despite having a lifestyle with regular walking and stretches between long periods of sitting at my computer. Prior to this, back issues were infrequent for me. The herniated disc affected the lowest lumbar segment, resulting in pain that radiated down my right leg's sciatic nerve. The pain became so unbearable that I required emergency surgery, and even after physical therapy, I still experience numbness and sporadic pain in that area. I routinely undergo blood tests, which generally showcase good results aside from a slightly elevated purine level. I have been diagnosed with bipolar disorder since my teenage years; however, my condition is under control. I also manage polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and hypothyroidism, both of which are effectively treated. Two years ago, I underwent a hysterectomy due to complications arising from PCOS and excessive bleeding. As a citizen of Germany, my current medications include: * Bupropion 300mg (for bipolar disorder) * Duloxetine 60mg (to address facial numbness) * L-Thyrox 175mcg (for hypothyroidism) * Melperone 17.5mg (to assist with sleep) * Metformin 2000mg (for PCOS, paused to assess its impact on stomach pain) * Quetiapine Retard 100mg (for bipolar disorder) * Quetiapine 150mg (for bipolar disorder) * Spironolactone 200mg (for PCOS) * Venlafaxine Retard 187.5mg (for bipolar disorder) * Vitamin D 2000 IU (due to low sunlight in Germany) I strictly refrain from using any recreational drugs. I am of Caucasian descent, stand 175 cm tall, and weigh 110 kg. I am starting to question my sanity from constantly seeking medical advice; I worry that healthcare professionals might think I'm exaggerating or fabricating symptoms because of my bipolar diagnosis. However, I firmly believe that my abdominal issues cannot solely be attributed to stress or psychosomatic conditions (which, while valid, feel insufficient in explaining my current distress). I have consulted with my general practitioner, two neurologists, an internist, my endocrinologist, and an orthopedist. The waiting times for appointments in Germany can be quite lengthy, so any insights or suggestions would be immensely valuable. I sincerely wish to avoid inconveniencing even more specialists who may not specialize in these matters. If you've made it through this lengthy account, I genuinely appreciate your time and attention. I wish you a wonderful day, and I welcome any thoughts or advice you might have!
Is My Sacral Discomfort Due to Normal Anatomy or Something Else?
Lately, I’ve encountered a peculiar feeling of discomfort when I lie down or sit in specific curled or slouched positions. It has come to my attention that there is a notable triangular bony structure at the top of my buttocks, particularly in the sacrum and PSIS region. This sensation is not painful and feels different from a solid mass. It doesn’t hinder my mobility, daily activities, or sleep patterns. I mainly become aware of it when any pressure is applied directly to that area, such as when I’m lying down or sitting in a crouched position. However, I don’t perceive it at all during walking or movement. Additionally, there are no accompanying signs like redness, swelling, or bruising, nor do I experience fever, numbness, weakness, or any neurological issues. I maintain a lean stature and have consistently been underweight, which leads to my confusion regarding this newfound prominence of the bone after years of being the same body type. My weight has remained stable, so I wonder why this bony structure has suddenly become more noticeable. The sensation feels more like an awareness of the bony area rather than actual pain. Does this align with the typical anatomy of the sacrum and the effects of posture or pressure sensitivity, or could this indicate an issue that requires further examination? This discomfort has lingered for weeks. Whenever I recline and feel this sensation, I can’t help but worry that something might be wrong in that region. I would greatly appreciate any insights. Thank you!
Swelling and Discoloration at the Tip of My Big Toe
I am a 34-year-old assigned female at birth, standing 6'1" and weighing 225 pounds. I do not smoke and my current medications include Lexapro, Metformin, and Tirzepatide. Recently, I accidentally trimmed my toenail a bit too short, though there was still visible nail left. Initially, I experienced some discomfort accompanied by redness, tightness, and swelling around the toe, but I decided to manage it without seeking immediate attention. However, a few days ago, I began to notice the emergence of purple dots and streaks, which have progressively worsened. Furthermore, I have also detected a painful purple area at the edge of my second toenail, which is surprising as I haven’t trimmed them in several weeks. I would appreciate any insights on this issue, as I’d like to avoid unnecessary expenses for a medical consultation that may lead to a dismissive response like “just let it grow out.”
Experiencing a Pinched Nerve Near the Shoulder Blade
At 25 years old, and without any previous health issues or medications, I suddenly find myself dealing with a pinched nerve in my shoulder. The cause is unclear to me. I've encountered pinched nerves before, primarily in my neck, but this experience feels distinctly different. It's only been three days, yet the pain has rendered me nearly incapacitated. Simple tasks like using the bathroom, sleeping, and even showering have become incredibly challenging due to significant pain and restricted movement. After looking into this condition, I’ve learned that recovery may take anywhere from four to six weeks, a timeline I'm not equipped to manage given the intensity of my discomfort. My profession involves physical activity, and my hobbies mirror that requirement. In an effort to find relief, I have tried a variety of approaches: alternating ice and heat, taking over-the-counter pain relievers like Tylenol and Advil, resting whenever possible, and incorporating stretches recommended in online videos. Unfortunately, nothing seems to alleviate the pain. I’m reaching out for guidance. Would physical therapy be beneficial in my situation? Are there particular stretches known to provide relief for pinched nerves? A friend of mine mentioned that muscle relaxants failed to help her during a similar episode; should I consider trying them nonetheless? Is visiting a doctor necessary at this point? I appreciate any advice you can provide to help me navigate this painful situation.
Braved the Cold Without Gloves at -20
19-year-old from Toronto here. After being outside in frigid temperatures, I've returned home feeling quite cold. My right hand is experiencing numbness and tingling in the fingertips. What steps should I take? It's been around 7 to 8 hours since I was outdoors.