Navigating the Choice: Traditional Surgery or Endoscopic Repair?
Hello, Medical Professionals, I am a 20-year-old male, standing at 5'1" and weighing 160 lbs. My medical background includes gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1). Recently, I have been diagnosed with the following conditions: - A 4 cm hiatal hernia - Hill Grade IV - LA Grade B esophagitis - A DeMeester score of 32.6 - Ineffective esophageal motility (IEM) with 60% failed swallows - Gastritis My doctors have recommended that I pursue surgical intervention, as neither lifestyle modifications nor proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy have provided relief. The initial surgeon I consulted referred me to a specialist in endoscopic procedures. This endoscopic surgeon presented two options: TIF (Transoral Incisionless Fundoplication) or ARMA (Anterior Rectus Musculofascial Augmentation). However, he seemed uncertain about the effectiveness of the endoscopic approach, suggesting that due to the severity of my hernia, traditional surgery might be a more effective solution. He noted that while he could perform the endoscopic procedure if I preferred, the chances of success would be low because the hernia would not be corrected. The general surgeon concurs with this assessment, mentioning that he proposed the endoscopic option as a temporary measure. He indicated that the failure rate for this method over six months could be as high as 60% in my case. On the other hand, if I choose the surgical approach, the recommended procedure would be a Watson Fundoplication along with a hiatal hernia repair utilizing biological mesh. I have been conducting extensive research to inform my decision, but I am still struggling to reach a conclusion. Any advice or insights you might provide to assist me in making this choice would be highly appreciated. Thank you for your time.
Answers (1)
9/5/2025, 9:01:14 PM
OpenHealth AI
Making a choice between traditional surgery and endoscopic repair for your hiatal hernia and associated conditions is an important decision that should consider both effectiveness and your personal health goals. You’re navigating complex factors related to GERD, your hernia severity, and your unique medical history.
Main Points:
- Traditional surgery may offer greater long-term relief for your severe hiatal hernia and related issues.
- Endoscopic options, while less invasive, may have higher failure rates for your specific condition.
- Your overall health, preferences, and the risks associated with each procedure should guide your choice.
Explanation:
Given that you have a 4 cm hiatal hernia along with significant gastroesophageal issues (like LA Grade B esophagitis and ineffective esophageal motility), the concerns raised by your surgeons are valid. Typically, traditional surgery like Watson Fundoplication can provide a complete repair of both the hernia and reflux symptoms, which is especially important given the severity of your condition.
Conversely, endoscopic procedures like TIF or ARMA are generally less invasive but may not address the hernia adequately, particularly in severe cases, as indicated by the specialist. The high failure rate mentioned (up to 60%) for endoscopic methods over six months is significant and should not be taken lightly—especially since you’ve already experienced minimal relief with lifestyle changes and PPI therapy.
Prioritized Next Steps:
-
Discuss Further: Have detailed discussions with both the traditional surgeon and the endoscopic specialist about your specific risks, benefits, and recovery timelines for each option.
-
Consider a Second Opinion: If possible, seek another surgical opinion from a specialist in hiatal hernia management to confirm the best approach for your case.
-
Evaluate Your Lifestyle and Goals: Reflect on how each option could affect your quality of life and daily activities, including the impact of potential surgery recovery times versus ongoing reflux management.
-
Prepare for Surgery If Chosen: If you lean towards traditional surgery, begin preparing yourself mentally and physically—this could include following pre-operative guidelines or strengthening your nutritional status.
-
Stay Informed: Continue researching reputable medical literature or guidelines regarding surgery for hiatal hernias to bolster your understanding.
Ultimately, prioritize what's best for your health and well-being, keeping open communication with your healthcare team. It’s essential that you feel confident in your chosen approach. Please let me know if you need more detailed information on specific aspects of the procedures or outcomes!
Related Questions
Unusual Heart Sensation
I’m an 18-year-old, weighing 50 kilograms and standing at 170 centimeters (and yes, I’m aware that I’m quite slender). For the past couple of years, I’ve developed a habit of smoking about half a pack of cigarettes each day. So, the other day I was lying on my left side, relaxing, when I stumbled upon an unusual sensation. It felt as though my heart was pulsating so intensely that it was almost outside my body. Out of curiosity, I pressed a bit on the area and was instantly hit with a rush; my head started to tingle, my vision momentarily blurred, and it felt as though my heart dropped. It was as if my entire system had malfunctioned. Just for context, I’ve experienced something similar before after a ketamine overdose, and it persisted for about a month afterward, occurring occasionally while trying to sleep or during random moments in bed. This current episode has me quite anxious, especially since it hasn’t happened in a while, but this time felt particularly alarming.
Mass on the Glottis
Patient Details: 63-year-old male, height 165 cm, weight 66 kg, Asian descent. Lifestyle Factors: No history of smoking or alcohol consumption. Medical History: Diagnosed with asthma and angina. Current Medications: Uses a Symbicort inhaler and takes Concor tablets. Main Concern: A mass was detected during a gastroendoscopy carried out a year ago. There is no report of pain, but the patient experiences mild hoarseness. What might be the diagnosis?
Experiencing Heart Palpitations Following Chest Impact
I'm a 17-year-old female who has struggled with tachycardia for several years, having been diagnosed with postural tachycardia syndrome (POTS) about five years ago, although I haven't pursued further testing because I haven't completely lost consciousness. Recently, over the past month or two, I've started to experience sensations of my heart skipping beats, accompanied by difficulty in breathing during these episodes. These occurrences have become significantly more frequent, even when I'm at rest. Five years ago, I underwent a Holter monitor test, which indicated primarily tachycardia with occasional premature ventricular contractions (PVCs), but nothing alarming was found. In early December, I was struck hard in the chest by an elbow while in a mosh pit, which resulted in some pain when taking deep breaths for a few days. My sternum became bruised and slightly swollen, and it remained tender to touch for about two weeks, but this discomfort was manageable. I still feel some soreness when stretching, although it’s not severe. Additionally, I have diagnoses of Crohn’s disease and hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (HEDS), and I am currently on immunosuppressants. Given these circumstances, would it be advisable for me to seek medical evaluation, or could these symptoms be considered typical?
Post-Gallbladder Surgery Concerns: Potential Infection Three Weeks Later?
Subject's Age: 35 Gender: Female Height: 5 feet 4 inches Weight: 160 pounds Ethnicity: Asian Duration of Symptoms: Last Three Weeks Geographic Location: United States Relevant Medical History: Almost three weeks ago, I underwent gallbladder removal surgery. In the last few days, I have observed a small amount of cloudy discharge emerging from my incision site. Recently, I noticed what appears to be pus leaking from the area. While there is no significant pain, I do feel a mild soreness when I touch or move the site. I have not experienced any fever or chills, and there’s no unpleasant odor coming from the wound. Should I continue to clean the area with soap and water, or is it advisable to seek medical attention at the emergency room for further evaluation?
Understanding My Experiences with Dissociation and Physical Symptoms
Hello everyone! I'm 15 years old and I’ve been grappling with intense feelings of dissociation recently. About two years back, I experienced what I now refer to as a "silent seizure" for the first time. It happened around 2 PM while I was at school in the band hall. Suddenly, I found myself zoning out completely; I was just sitting there, disassociated from reality, until it dawned on me that I couldn’t seem to reconnect with my surroundings. Feeling lost, I turned to a friend and anxiously asked, "Where am I?" She chuckled, unaware of the seriousness of my situation, but I stood up and wandered out of the classroom, aimlessly walking towards the bathrooms. The sensation was akin to being in a dream—you know you’re somewhere, yet you can’t fully engage with the moment for what felt like 5 to 10 minutes. Strangely, I even had the feeling of observing myself from above as I moved through the halls, like a scene from a dream. In a state of panic, I contacted my mom. By the time I managed to leave school, my mind was clearing. She took me to her workplace where a colleague checked my blood sugar levels, revealing it was low. I had eaten that day, so this was unexpected (especially since my mother also faces issues with low blood sugar). This occurrence was unprecedented for me; thankfully, I haven’t faced such low levels since then. In the following weeks, I experienced intermittent dissociative episodes, prompting me to visit a doctor. I underwent blood tests, an electrocardiogram (EKG), and a routine examination. Everything appeared normal, except I was diagnosed with anemia—something my mother and sister also deal with. I walked away from that appointment without any real explanations, and after a while, the episodes subsided—thankfully, a relief. FAST FORWARD TO NOW: (15 years old) (Potentially relevant context) Recently, I’ve been enduring severe heart and chest discomfort. I’ve been noticing irregular heartbeats, sporadic strong pulsations, and sharp pain localized in my heart region and upper right chest. Lying on my side can be quite painful, and sometimes I struggle to take deep breaths. I make it a priority to get a full eight hours of sleep each night, I take daily vitamins, and I’m actively involved in competitive cheerleading, maintaining a healthy fitness level for my height and weight. We sought medical advice again, underwent numerous tests, and, once more, everything checked out fine. My heart was deemed healthy, and all other measurements were satisfactory. Initially, we suspected anxiety might be a factor, but my mom is hesitant to consider antidepressants, believing that my age may limit treatment options. She has recommended that I hydrate more and practice breathing exercises (which is somewhat ironic since I struggle to breathe when these pains occur, yet I don’t argue). UPDATE: During practice today, I unexpectedly experienced my first "silent seizure" episode in two years. It was more disconcerting than I recalled. I lost track of my location again and couldn’t re-engage with reality. It felt as if I was observing those around me from a dream-like vantage point. This realization frightened me, thinking that I had moved past these episodes. It took about ten minutes for me to regain my awareness of my environment. Additionally, this week, I noticed moments of dissociation, albeit not as intense as previous episodes. I found myself vacantly staring, and my vision felt oddly lazy, frequently. It's worth noting that I do not have a lazy eye. I plan to document these occurrences meticulously, and if they persist, I will consult my doctor again. Meanwhile, if anyone has suggestions about what might be happening to me, I would greatly appreciate it. Is this potentially linked to anxiety? I’m genuinely confused about my condition!