Navigating the Choice: Traditional Surgery or Endoscopic Repair?
Hello, Medical Professionals, I am a 20-year-old male, standing at 5'1" and weighing 160 lbs. My medical background includes gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1). Recently, I have been diagnosed with the following conditions: - A 4 cm hiatal hernia - Hill Grade IV - LA Grade B esophagitis - A DeMeester score of 32.6 - Ineffective esophageal motility (IEM) with 60% failed swallows - Gastritis My doctors have recommended that I pursue surgical intervention, as neither lifestyle modifications nor proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy have provided relief. The initial surgeon I consulted referred me to a specialist in endoscopic procedures. This endoscopic surgeon presented two options: TIF (Transoral Incisionless Fundoplication) or ARMA (Anterior Rectus Musculofascial Augmentation). However, he seemed uncertain about the effectiveness of the endoscopic approach, suggesting that due to the severity of my hernia, traditional surgery might be a more effective solution. He noted that while he could perform the endoscopic procedure if I preferred, the chances of success would be low because the hernia would not be corrected. The general surgeon concurs with this assessment, mentioning that he proposed the endoscopic option as a temporary measure. He indicated that the failure rate for this method over six months could be as high as 60% in my case. On the other hand, if I choose the surgical approach, the recommended procedure would be a Watson Fundoplication along with a hiatal hernia repair utilizing biological mesh. I have been conducting extensive research to inform my decision, but I am still struggling to reach a conclusion. Any advice or insights you might provide to assist me in making this choice would be highly appreciated. Thank you for your time.
Answers (1)
9/5/2025, 9:01:14 PM
OpenHealth AI
Making a choice between traditional surgery and endoscopic repair for your hiatal hernia and associated conditions is an important decision that should consider both effectiveness and your personal health goals. You’re navigating complex factors related to GERD, your hernia severity, and your unique medical history.
Main Points:
- Traditional surgery may offer greater long-term relief for your severe hiatal hernia and related issues.
- Endoscopic options, while less invasive, may have higher failure rates for your specific condition.
- Your overall health, preferences, and the risks associated with each procedure should guide your choice.
Explanation:
Given that you have a 4 cm hiatal hernia along with significant gastroesophageal issues (like LA Grade B esophagitis and ineffective esophageal motility), the concerns raised by your surgeons are valid. Typically, traditional surgery like Watson Fundoplication can provide a complete repair of both the hernia and reflux symptoms, which is especially important given the severity of your condition.
Conversely, endoscopic procedures like TIF or ARMA are generally less invasive but may not address the hernia adequately, particularly in severe cases, as indicated by the specialist. The high failure rate mentioned (up to 60%) for endoscopic methods over six months is significant and should not be taken lightly—especially since you’ve already experienced minimal relief with lifestyle changes and PPI therapy.
Prioritized Next Steps:
-
Discuss Further: Have detailed discussions with both the traditional surgeon and the endoscopic specialist about your specific risks, benefits, and recovery timelines for each option.
-
Consider a Second Opinion: If possible, seek another surgical opinion from a specialist in hiatal hernia management to confirm the best approach for your case.
-
Evaluate Your Lifestyle and Goals: Reflect on how each option could affect your quality of life and daily activities, including the impact of potential surgery recovery times versus ongoing reflux management.
-
Prepare for Surgery If Chosen: If you lean towards traditional surgery, begin preparing yourself mentally and physically—this could include following pre-operative guidelines or strengthening your nutritional status.
-
Stay Informed: Continue researching reputable medical literature or guidelines regarding surgery for hiatal hernias to bolster your understanding.
Ultimately, prioritize what's best for your health and well-being, keeping open communication with your healthcare team. It’s essential that you feel confident in your chosen approach. Please let me know if you need more detailed information on specific aspects of the procedures or outcomes!
Related Questions
Navigating Conflicting Information on Cholecystitis Diagnosis
Background Information: Age 29, Height 5'11", Weight 285 lbs, generally out of shape, occasional light alcohol consumption, non-smoker, currently taking 200 mg of Sertraline and Quetiapine daily. Symptoms: Over the last 12-18 months, I have experienced abdominal pain approximately 4-6 times. This pain is described as crampy and gnawing, akin to hunger pangs, at times feeling as though my abdomen might burst. The discomfort is mainly centered about an inch above my navel, accompanied by slight stomach distension. The episodes usually last around 6-8 hours, and I have had recent bouts of diarrhea. Absence of Symptoms: I would like to clarify that I have NOT experienced nausea, vomiting, fever, sweats, or pain radiating to my lower back. Incident Timeline: - **August 24:** - 6 PM: Consumed a Chipotle bowl with chips and guacamole. - 10 PM: Tried to sleep but discomfort prevented it. - **August 25:** - 4 AM: After a sleepless night, I decided to go to work early. - 4:30 AM: Found it difficult to remain still at work due to discomfort; drove myself to urgent care. There, I received hydration via an IV (2L saline, 1 bag of acetaminophen, and 1 bag of antibiotics over two hours). - 5 AM: Underwent blood testing, a urinalysis, and a CT scan. The results indicated an inflamed gallbladder, leading to a diagnosis of acute cholecystitis and an incarcerated umbilical hernia. A significantly elevated white blood cell count was prevalent. The doctor advised me to schedule a follow-up with a primary care physician (PCP) for further evaluations and a possible surgical referral. Prescriptions included Clindamycin (300 mg four times a day) and Tramadol (50 mg as needed). - **August 26:** - 7 PM: Ate a Salata wrap. - 10 PM: Experienced the same pain as previously, took Tramadol which provided relief, allowing me to sleep. - **August 27:** - 4 AM: Woke up due to pain; took Tramadol and fell back asleep. - Noticed very dark stool (not tarry) and bright orange urine on this day, wondering if it might be a side effect of the medication. - **August 29:** - Saw a PCP who agreed with the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis and confirmed the presence of a visible hernia, but disputed the incarceration classification. She suggested scheduling a visit with a surgeon, noting that I was protective during the abdominal examination. - **September 4:** - Consulted with a surgeon, who confirmed the symptoms matched the acute cholecystitis diagnosis. He stated the hernia was present but defined it as fat, not intestine. He recommended an ultrasound for thorough evaluation and planned a cholecystectomy for September 9. - **September 5:** - Underwent an ultrasound where the technician observed that the gallbladder appeared normal, with no gallstones present. There was also no inflammation or thickening of the walls. The technician seemed puzzled by my diagnosis since I reported pain in the mid-abdomen rather than the upper right quadrant and felt no discomfort during the gallbladder examination. Current Situation: I find myself uncertain about proceeding with surgery, especially given the absence of abnormalities in the ultrasound results. I am keen to avoid unnecessary surgery. I anticipated the ultrasound would reveal some issues, but the technician’s findings and confusion regarding my pain’s location have raised my doubts. Three professionals recommended the gallbladder removal, while one expressed caution. Asking for Insights: Do my symptoms align with the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis? I haven’t exhibited the typical signs associated with gallbladder issues, which leaves me perplexed. While the CT findings seemed conclusive, the ultrasound results have shaken my confidence. I have my medical documentation available if anyone requires further review. Thank you in advance for any insights you can provide.
Osteonecrosis Affecting Both Femoral Heads
Greetings, I am a 36-year-old male who recently experienced intense leg pain, prompting a visit to the emergency room. During my examination, the physician ordered X-rays for my hips. Although no fractures were detected, the scans revealed osteonecrosis in both femoral heads, which have unfortunately collapsed. I am curious about the likelihood of requiring surgery in my situation. Any guidance or information would be greatly appreciated.
Male, 37, Experiences Intense Abdominal Pain for Two Decades: Seeking Insights
**Demographics:** 37-year-old male **Physical Stats:** Height 5 feet 10 inches, Weight 175 pounds **Ethnicity:** Caucasian **Main Issue:** Patient reports episodes of acute abdominal pain, lasting between one to two hours. The pain is particularly severe, described as debilitating, originating near the navel and radiating towards the back. Symptoms include bloating, gas, and an urge to defecate, yet relief is not achieved post bowel movement. These painful episodes typically arise in the evening around 7 to 8 PM. Applying heat brings some comfort, and the individual maintains a normal state in between episodes. **Previous Medical Investigations:** - Diagnosed with Gilbert’s syndrome. - Exhibits iron deficiency with low ferritin levels (~11 ng/mL) and diminished iron saturation around 12%. Additionally, serves as a regular blood donor, with the last donation occurring in June. Patient's diet is noted to be low in red meat and animal products. - Autoantibody testing revealed ANA at 1:320 (homogeneous), but the rest of the autoimmune panel (dsDNA/ENA/complement levels) was normal. - Slight elevation in tryptase levels, measured between 13-14 μg/L (the patient’s child has a similar condition). - A solitary lipase value indicated approximately 2.5 times the upper limit of normal, taken around 17 days after an attack. - Recent endoscopy and colonoscopy with biopsies returned normal results, ruling out celiac disease and inflammatory bowel disease; H. pylori test was negative. - Disaccharidase levels are within normal ranges. - Mild elevation in urine porphyrin fractions, although not assessed during an active episode. - Historical ultrasound and MRI imaging were normal. - A CT scan has been performed, with a capsule endoscopy and abdominal ultrasound yet to be completed. Any recommendations? Should I also consider consulting a rheumatologist in addition to my existing gastrointestinal care?
Abdominal Rash Inquiry
Hello, Reddit community, I would like to seek your insights regarding a rash that has appeared on my 6-month-old son’s abdomen. He weighs 6.8 kg and measures 66 cm long, and there are no pre-existing health concerns. About six days ago, after attending swimming lessons, we noticed this rash, and unfortunately, it hasn't improved since. We initially thought it may be a reaction to chlorine; however, he has been participating in swimming lessons weekly for the past couple of months without experiencing anything similar. He does not have a fever or any other accompanying symptoms. We have attempted treatment with antihistamines and moisturizers, but there’s been no noticeable improvement. The rash consists of raised, red bumps. Does anyone have any suggestions or ideas on how to treat this? Thank you in advance for your help!
Evaluating My Suitability for Mastectomy
At 41 years old, I have been dealing with recurrent cysts in my breasts since I was 18. Over the years, I have undergone annual ultrasounds and, for the past three years, mammograms as well. These mammograms reveal my breast tissue to be exceptionally dense, leading to additional ultrasound follow-ups. My mother sadly passed away at the age of 64 after battling ovarian cancer, which was diagnosed when she was 62. She also previously had breast cancer diagnosed at 58 and tested negative for the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes. The ongoing anxiety from discovering new lumps is overwhelming, and I often experience significant breast pain. This raises the question of whether I might be a candidate for a mastectomy, especially considering my mother’s genetic testing results. I have also attached the notes from my most recent ultrasound for further information: **Ultrasound Report:** *This examination was compared with several prior assessments to evaluate the mammographic masses further.* *A complete ultrasound of the right breast and a limited ultrasound of the left breast was conducted.* *Numerous hypoechoic to anechoic lesions were identified in the areas of the breasts that were imaged. The largest lesion in the right breast is situated approximately 1 cm from the nipple at the 12 o'clock position, measuring 3.1 x 2.3 x 1.2 cm. The most significant one detected in the left breast is around 3 cm from the nipple at the 10 o'clock position, measuring 1.4 x 1.3 x 0.8 cm. None of these lesions exhibited concerning sonographic characteristics, likely indicating a mix of simple and complex cysts.* *There is no evidence of axillary lymphadenopathy.* **Conclusion:** *No alarming findings are noted; however, a follow-up ultrasound in six months is recommended to monitor the stability of these observations.* **BI-RADS 3**