Navigating the Choice: Traditional Surgery or Endoscopic Repair?
Hello, Medical Professionals, I am a 20-year-old male, standing at 5'1" and weighing 160 lbs. My medical background includes gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1). Recently, I have been diagnosed with the following conditions: - A 4 cm hiatal hernia - Hill Grade IV - LA Grade B esophagitis - A DeMeester score of 32.6 - Ineffective esophageal motility (IEM) with 60% failed swallows - Gastritis My doctors have recommended that I pursue surgical intervention, as neither lifestyle modifications nor proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy have provided relief. The initial surgeon I consulted referred me to a specialist in endoscopic procedures. This endoscopic surgeon presented two options: TIF (Transoral Incisionless Fundoplication) or ARMA (Anterior Rectus Musculofascial Augmentation). However, he seemed uncertain about the effectiveness of the endoscopic approach, suggesting that due to the severity of my hernia, traditional surgery might be a more effective solution. He noted that while he could perform the endoscopic procedure if I preferred, the chances of success would be low because the hernia would not be corrected. The general surgeon concurs with this assessment, mentioning that he proposed the endoscopic option as a temporary measure. He indicated that the failure rate for this method over six months could be as high as 60% in my case. On the other hand, if I choose the surgical approach, the recommended procedure would be a Watson Fundoplication along with a hiatal hernia repair utilizing biological mesh. I have been conducting extensive research to inform my decision, but I am still struggling to reach a conclusion. Any advice or insights you might provide to assist me in making this choice would be highly appreciated. Thank you for your time.
Answers (1)
9/5/2025, 9:01:14 PM
OpenHealth AI
Making a choice between traditional surgery and endoscopic repair for your hiatal hernia and associated conditions is an important decision that should consider both effectiveness and your personal health goals. You’re navigating complex factors related to GERD, your hernia severity, and your unique medical history.
Main Points:
- Traditional surgery may offer greater long-term relief for your severe hiatal hernia and related issues.
- Endoscopic options, while less invasive, may have higher failure rates for your specific condition.
- Your overall health, preferences, and the risks associated with each procedure should guide your choice.
Explanation:
Given that you have a 4 cm hiatal hernia along with significant gastroesophageal issues (like LA Grade B esophagitis and ineffective esophageal motility), the concerns raised by your surgeons are valid. Typically, traditional surgery like Watson Fundoplication can provide a complete repair of both the hernia and reflux symptoms, which is especially important given the severity of your condition.
Conversely, endoscopic procedures like TIF or ARMA are generally less invasive but may not address the hernia adequately, particularly in severe cases, as indicated by the specialist. The high failure rate mentioned (up to 60%) for endoscopic methods over six months is significant and should not be taken lightly—especially since you’ve already experienced minimal relief with lifestyle changes and PPI therapy.
Prioritized Next Steps:
-
Discuss Further: Have detailed discussions with both the traditional surgeon and the endoscopic specialist about your specific risks, benefits, and recovery timelines for each option.
-
Consider a Second Opinion: If possible, seek another surgical opinion from a specialist in hiatal hernia management to confirm the best approach for your case.
-
Evaluate Your Lifestyle and Goals: Reflect on how each option could affect your quality of life and daily activities, including the impact of potential surgery recovery times versus ongoing reflux management.
-
Prepare for Surgery If Chosen: If you lean towards traditional surgery, begin preparing yourself mentally and physically—this could include following pre-operative guidelines or strengthening your nutritional status.
-
Stay Informed: Continue researching reputable medical literature or guidelines regarding surgery for hiatal hernias to bolster your understanding.
Ultimately, prioritize what's best for your health and well-being, keeping open communication with your healthcare team. It’s essential that you feel confident in your chosen approach. Please let me know if you need more detailed information on specific aspects of the procedures or outcomes!
Related Questions
Rash on My Arm: Should I Be Concerned?
Hi there! I’m a 65-year-old female, and for the past four days, I’ve been dealing with a strange rash on my arm. Unfortunately, I can’t visit a healthcare professional until Monday, so I’m hoping to get some clarity in the meantime. I’ll share some images. If they don’t upload here, I’ll post them in the comments instead. The first image, taken last night, is a bit out of focus, but this morning, the rash has appeared even redder. Although it doesn’t itch now, I did experience some itching during the initial two days. As for my health history, I generally don’t have major health concerns apart from elevated cholesterol levels and a recent A1C reading of 5.9, but I do not have diabetes. I keep fairly active for my age group. During the first couple of days, there was some pus, and I managed to clean it with an alcohol wipe, which helped remove it. Could this be related to a spider bite? I noticed some small spiders (specifically daddy long legs) in my bedroom, especially near the balcony door, and I eliminated a few of them today, so that could be a possibility. Should I be wary of any serious complications from this rash? Any advice would be immensely appreciated! My ER co-payment is quite steep, and there’s no urgent care facility nearby. My only option is to request an appointment with my primary care physician next week, but I’m uncertain if it’s something that warrants immediate attention.
Navigating Recurrent Prostate Cancer: A Patient's Journey
As a 60-year-old man living in New York, I faced a challenging battle with prostate cancer approximately 4.5 years ago. My initial biopsy results indicated a Gleason score of 6. However, in September 2025, my PSA levels alarmingly soared to 27.7. To investigate the possibility of an infection, my doctor prescribed a month-long course of antibiotics. Afterward, my PSA levels showed a slight reduction, dropping to 25.5. Following another biopsy procedure, the Gleason score unexpectedly escalated to 10. This prompted serious discussions with my healthcare provider. He explained that, given the radiation treatment I had previously undergone, the surgical removal of my prostate would be quite complex, with very few surgeons willing to perform such a procedure. Consequently, I sought a second opinion from a specialist in urological cancer. The specialist echoed similar concerns, indicating that the potential complications could severely affect the urethra and rectal lining. Instead of surgery, he proposed cryoablation as a viable alternative. Simultaneously, I commenced treatment with testosterone hormone blockers. To say that this experience has been frustrating is an understatement. Most importantly, I also struggle with urination issues that complicate my daily life. I am reaching out for any insights or advice that might assist me in navigating this difficult situation.
Micronodules Detected in Lung
Hello, I recently underwent a coronary artery calcium (CAC) scan to assess arterial plaque, and I was pleased to receive a favorable score of 7.75. However, the report highlighted the presence of several clustered micronodules located in the right upper lung, accompanied by adjacent ground-glass opacities. I am a 60-year-old male, 6 feet tall and weigh 190 pounds. I do not currently take any medications and generally enjoy excellent health. There is a family history of heart disease on my father's side. Additionally, I am a non-smoker, apart from occasional use of cannabis, and consume alcohol very infrequently. Thank you in advance for any insights you can provide!
Experiencing Widespread Muscle Weakness
I’m a 36-year-old male and have recently been facing a troubling situation where the muscles throughout my body seem to be losing function—including my eyelids. The trouble began in May 2021 when I lifted a heavy garbage can with my right arm in a shrugging action. Following that, I felt a combination of pain and weakness concentrated in my right shoulder blade, as well as my shoulder and collarbone. Soon after, I noticed my shoulder began to pop and click. Afterward, I consulted with an orthopedic specialist who conducted x-rays on both of my shoulders. He informed me that everything appeared normal and dismissed the popping sounds as inconsequential. I also mentioned experiencing neck pain, but he indicated that addressing neck issues wasn’t his area of expertise. He diagnosed me with bilateral shoulder and neck discomfort and recommended physical therapy. The day after my appointment, I attempted to adjust my position in my desk chair by leaning on the left armrest, putting my forearm under the weight of my body. Suddenly, my shoulder jolted, and I felt a sharp weakness in my arm, accompanied by popping and clicking noises, similar to what happened with my right arm. I reached out to the orthopedic office to inform them about this incident, but the physician assistant who responded said the doctor would not see me again simply due to how I was sitting, and suggested I attend physical therapy first. She mentioned that if I continued to experience weakness, a neurologist might be necessary. Feeling concerned, I returned to my primary care physician for a follow-up appointment and recounted my experience. He didn’t appear worried, and my blood tests returned normal results. During the summer of 2021, I began physical therapy where the therapist diagnosed me with strains in my trapezius and rhomboid muscles. The subsequent therapy sessions consisted of painful exercises and stretches, yet I observed little to no improvement in terms of strength or stability. Activities like using the arm bike and weight machine were excruciating, and I frequently inquired whether my symptoms could be attributed to a tear or nerve damage, but the therapist insisted that was not the case and dismissed my concerns. After my tenth session, I decided it was best not to return. In April 2022, I visited a neurologist. I struggled to lift myself onto the examination table and needed assistance from a step stool. He didn't suspect any neurological issues when I asked him about an EMG or other assessments, he declined to proceed with those tests. Disheartened by these experiences, I chose not to pursue further medical consultations. Fast forward to April 9, 2025, I misstepped while descending some stairs, causing my right heel to catch, and I landed hard with my toes pointed. I had no visible signs of injury such as swelling or bruising, but soon after, I began to experience persistent pain and weakness, especially in my toes and the arch of my foot. By April 13, I instinctively elevated the toes on my left foot, and to my dismay, the same pain and weakness emerged, again without any visible signs like bruising. Since then, both feet have lacked strength, and my big toes feel unusually floppy. In July 2025, I had a troubling experience after having my hair washed at a salon. I held my neck in an awkward position for the duration, which resulted in a burning sensation. Regrettably, I didn’t express my discomfort, fearing a scene. Following this, I noticed significant weakness in the muscles at the front of my neck, under my chin, which gave the appearance of a receding chin. Additionally, my facial muscles, particularly in my cheeks, felt weak and could easily be pressed in with minimal resistance. In January 2026, I bought a new game controller for my laptop, having not played video games for a long time. Initially, it was manageable, but soon after, my hands and forearms began to feel uncomfortable and painful. This discomfort escalated significantly to where I had to discontinue use completely; my hands felt drained of energy and experienced achiness, tingling, and numbness. Then, on February 3, 2026, while seated and using my laptop, I noticed a peculiar sensation when moving my eyes. My eyelid muscles felt weak, and one of my eyelids began twitching. I found it increasingly difficult to open my eyes as widely as I used to. I plan to see a primary care physician once more, but I’m uncertain how to communicate all of this effectively to receive proper care. My circumstances have reached a point where my parents must assist me with everyday tasks, including driving, opening doors, and even lifting light objects. My ability to raise my arms above my head has become severely limited as well.
Liver Mass Assessment
Patient Profile: - Age: 61 years - Height: 5'9" - Weight: 240 lbs - Gender: Female - Lifestyle: Non-drinker, non-smoker, no illicit drugs Current Medications: - Atenolol 10mg (morning and evening) - Rosuvastatin 40mg (evening) - Duloxetine 60mg (evening) - Spironolactone 25mg (recently added) - Jardiance 10mg (recently added) Medical History: The patient has a notable history of multiple pheochromocytomas and paragangliomas, having undergone surgery on eight occasions. According to scans performed three years ago, two subcentimeter retroperitoneal masses were identified, suggestive of potential paraganglioma. Additionally, she suffers from secondary polycythemia and possesses the PHD1 gene mutation. Previously, she received treatment at a prominent research institution in the United States. However, her endocrinologist has since retired and returned to their home country. Current Condition: At present, she is mostly asymptomatic. However, in January 2026, she experienced a concerning event requiring an ambulance transport to a local emergency room, where her oxygen levels registered at 88-89%. This incident was unsettling, given her extensive medical history. The emergency physician initially diagnosed her with congestive heart failure (CHF), but upon discharge, her family medicine doctor suggested pneumonia. During her hospital stay, a cardiologist—who has never managed a pheochromocytoma patient—recommended a chemical stress test. A CT scan performed on her chest revealed a 3.2 x 2.5 cm mass located in the left lobe of her liver. Her blood tests typically show elevated levels related to pheochromocytomas; however, the laboratory does not conduct resting catecholamine testing, which leads to unreliable results, despite them being consistent over time. Furthermore, she has received care at major hospitals in Minnesota and both leading hospitals in Cleveland, Ohio. Unfortunately, when she required her last surgery, the tumor board declined her case, citing an unfavorable risk-benefit ratio. This leaves her without a specialist in pheochromocytomas. Request for Guidance: The patient is seeking advice or recommendations for her current health situation and management of her conditions.