Understanding Rib Injuries
Hello everyone, I’m a 23-year-old woman, standing at 5 feet 1 inch tall and weighing around 120 pounds. Approximately a week ago, I experienced a fall that resulted in an injury to my rib area. The impact left me with a significant bruise that is dark in color surrounding the ribs, and the pain has made it extremely uncomfortable to touch or move that part of my body. Two days after the incident, I decided to visit urgent care due to the intensity of the pain I was feeling. During my examination, the attending physician suggested that I might have either a dislocated or fractured rib. Although I couldn't undergo an X-ray at that time, the doctor could identify the separation through physical examination. Several days after this initial visit, I had a follow-up appointment with my primary care physician. However, her assessment differed greatly from the first. She recommended an X-ray, which ultimately came back cleared. When I attempted to express my continued discomfort—especially while moving, deep breathing, or pressing on the affected spot—she appeared to dismiss my concerns. Her response was that if I had truly sustained a broken rib, I would likely experience "a lot" of pain, even though I had already shared my symptoms with her. Now, I find myself feeling frustrated and undervalued. She remarked that a rib fracture or dislocation could not be confirmed solely through touch, which raises questions for me. Is it possible for certain rib injuries not to be clearly visible on X-rays? I’m not trying to undermine anyone's expertise; I simply seek clarity regarding my condition and reassurance that my feelings are valid.
Answers (1)
8/25/2025, 8:31:16 PM
OpenHealth AI
I understand that you’re feeling frustrated about your rib injury and the different opinions you received from healthcare providers. It's important to know that your feelings and concerns are valid, and you deserve clarity and support regarding your condition.
Main Points:
- Rib injuries can be difficult to assess, and not all injuries may be visible on X-rays.
- It's common for bruising and pain to persist even after an X-ray appears normal.
- Managing your symptoms and ensuring you take care of yourself is important.
Explanation: Ribs can be complex injuries, and sometimes fractures or dislocations, especially very small ones or stress fractures, might not show up on X-rays. This can lead to persistent pain and discomfort, even if imaging doesn't reveal a serious injury. The surrounding bruising indicates trauma, and while rib fractures can be painful, the level of pain can vary widely between individuals. Factors such as your pain tolerance and the location of the injury can contribute to your experience.
Next Steps:
- Pain Management: Focus on managing your pain with over-the-counter pain relief, like ibuprofen or acetaminophen, as needed. Always follow the recommended dosage.
- Rest and Avoid Strain: Give your ribs time to heal. Avoid activities that cause you discomfort, especially those that involve heavy lifting or intense movement.
- Deep Breathing: Although painful, try to take deep breaths several times a day. This helps expand your lungs and can prevent complications like pneumonia. If it’s too painful, gentle, small breaths can also work.
- Monitor Symptoms: Keep track of your symptoms. If you notice worsening pain, difficulty breathing, or new symptoms (like coughing up blood), seek medical attention promptly.
- Seek Support: Consider reaching out to another healthcare provider if you continue feeling unheard or dismissed. A second opinion can be valuable in understanding your condition better.
You are not alone in managing this discomfort, and it's completely okay to seek additional reassurance and care. Let me know if you need more information or support as you recover.
Related Questions
Navigating MALS Challenges: Seeking Guidance
Hello everyone! I’m a 36-year-old female dealing with multiple health conditions, including EDS (Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome), MALS (Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome), and ulcerative colitis, among several other unrelated issues. I wanted to share my experience with MALS, which has been confirmed for me. Back in May 2024, I underwent revision surgery. Unfortunately, the recovery did not go as hoped. Due to my EDS, the celiac artery lacks the ability to function independently, which my surgeon described as it being "too floppy." At that time, I accepted this outcome because the excruciating pain had subsided, and I was able to eat and gain weight again. However, now I find myself facing a resurgence of pain that is quite intense. A CT scan I had last week revealed severe stenosis in my celiac artery, coupled with a soft tissue prominence at the diaphragmatic crus and the beginning of the celiac axis. Currently, I’m taking Norco 10-325 three times a day and Lyrica 75 mg three times daily. While these medications provide some relief, the pain is overwhelming, and I can’t help but feel as if I’ve returned to my previous struggles from two years ago. Doctors are suggesting that the only option is to go in and "clean out the adhesions". I come to you all for your insights: Do you think pursuing a clean out procedure is advisable, or could it pose too much risk considering my EDS? I appreciate your thoughts and thanks for reading my story.
Sore Throat and Tonsil Discomfort for Three Weeks
For the past two weeks, I have been experiencing significant pain in my tonsils. After consulting with urgent care, I underwent tests for both strep throat and mononucleosis, but the results were negative. The doctor advised me to be patient as the discomfort was expected to subside on its own. Unfortunately, my condition worsened, prompting me to return to urgent care three days later. During this visit, I was prescribed dexamethasone, a type of steroid, along with a ten-day course of amoxicillin. Remarkably, my symptoms began to diminish within hours. However, just three days later, I am starting to feel the throat and tonsil pain return. I am still on the amoxicillin regimen. What could be causing this resurgence of pain, and what steps should I take next?
Concerns About Persistent Cough: Is It Cardiac Related?
Greetings everyone, I’m a 20-year-old male weighing 320 pounds, which qualifies as overweight. Having dealt with asthma for the majority of my life—although it’s generally mild—I typically rely on a nebulizer during occasions of typical chest colds. For some context, I came down with a cold around January 9th. Being on a college campus frequently means exposure to a variety of illnesses, and I suspect I contracted bronchitis, given the lasting cough and breathlessness I experienced for a couple of weeks afterward. However, I believed I had fully recuperated and moved on. Recently, since about Monday, I have noticed a return of my breathlessness along with a persistent cough and a sensation of fluid in my chest and throat. I find myself coughing as I attempt to clear my throat. This comes and goes, but it tends to intensify in the mornings right after I wake up and at night when I try to sleep. Additionally, I spend time with friends who smoke on occasion, and I initially thought that secondhand smoke might be a contributing factor. My concern has grown, and I’m unsure what to think. So, I’m reaching out for guidance: could this be residual effects from my cold in January, or should I be concerned that this might indicate a more serious issue related to my heart?
Hernia Diagnosis Without Follow-Up: A Conflicting Situation
A 22-year-old male recently visited the emergency room due to discomfort in his lower abdomen. Upon examination, the medical team was indecisive about whether he was experiencing an oblique muscle problem or a hernia. Surprisingly, they opted against performing a CT scan or ultrasound and did not schedule any follow-up appointments. To the best of my knowledge, hernias typically do not resolve themselves with merely the use of ace bandages or over-the-counter pain medication; surgical intervention is usually necessary for proper treatment. Is there a specific rationale behind their reluctance to pursue further diagnostic testing or surgery?
Experiencing Wheezing During Deep Breaths
Greetings, everyone! I'm seeking your insights on a particular issue I'm facing: I experience a wheezing sound only when inhaling deeply. Interestingly, it's noticeable on one side, and it's audible to others as well. I've never used tobacco or any other substances, nor do I consume alcohol. My weight falls within a healthy range, and I do not have asthma. Additionally, my oxygen levels are normal, and I don’t struggle with breathing; this situation is more of an irritation than a serious problem. I’ve recorded the noise, but I’m unable to share it here; it honestly resembles the sound of a rubber chicken. I would appreciate any thoughts or suggestions! Thank you in advance!