Struggling with a Persistent Finger Injury Since January
I’m a 28-year-old woman seeking advice on a troubling injury to my left index finger, which has affected me since January. Despite consulting several specialists, including orthopedic doctors and rheumatologists, I remain without a clear diagnosis. Here’s a brief account of what has transpired: - One morning in January, I awoke to find my finger swollen and painful, making it difficult to bend. I don’t remember an explicit injury occurring, although I had engaged in yoga and solid core workouts recently. - Initially, I decided to overlook the issue, hoping it would resolve itself within a few days. However, the symptoms only escalated. - A trip to urgent care ensued, where an x-ray revealed no fractures. The prognosis was a probable sprain from my workouts, and I was provided a standard finger splint. - After a week in the splint, my finger swelled dramatically; any attempt to bend it caused unbearable pain. - I subsequently scheduled an appointment with an orthopedic specialist, who opted for buddy taping my finger and suggested I might have torn a ligament on the joint’s right side. I was advised to perform daily bends to restore my range of motion. - Although my mobility improved somewhat, lingering pain persisted. An MRI in April, performed without contrast, indicated swelling around the PIP joint but could not conclusively determine its location. There were no signs of ligament or tendon tears, prompting a recommendation for additional pathology follow-up. - Following this, I consulted a rheumatologist who ordered extensive blood tests to eliminate the possibility of arthritis or infections such as Lyme disease, MRSA, and Bartanella. Fortunately, all results returned negative. - The rheumatologist prescribed methylprednisolone, administered a cortisone injection, and mentioned a synovectomy to potentially "clean out" the joint and allow for tissue regeneration. However, the doctor expressed reservations, saying he wouldn’t personally opt for such a procedure. - Seeking a second opinion in June, another doctor suggested remedies like Epsom salt soaks, Voltarin, and co-ban wrapping. I inquired about another MRI with contrast due to the lack of improvement, but the doctor dismissed it as unnecessary. Currently, my situation remains challenging. I often feel embarrassed voicing my frustration over this injury, which may seem minor, yet it causes me daily distress. Simple tasks—gripping the steering wheel, carrying grocery bags, putting on or removing jewelry—are daunting, and the pain sometimes interrupts my sleep. This issue is affecting my everyday life in significant ways. I find myself desperate for feedback or suggestions. I have a follow-up appointment with the second opinion doctor next week. What inquiries would you propose? Should I advocate for the synovectomy, or is there another course of action you would recommend? Thank you for taking the time to read and for any guidance you can provide.
Answers (1)
8/21/2025, 2:52:07 PM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you’ve been through a challenging journey with your finger injury, and it's completely understandable to feel frustrated about the lack of clear answers and persistent pain. Your experience is legitimate, and it’s important to continue seeking solutions that can help alleviate your discomfort and improve your quality of life.
Main Points:
- Persistent pain and limited mobility require focused attention.
- Preparing for your upcoming consultation can enhance your care.
- Exploring alternative therapies and rehabilitation could be beneficial.
Explanation:
Given the duration and impact of your injury, it's clear that addressing your finger pain is critical for your daily functioning. While you’ve already consulted with various specialists, including orthopedic surgeons and rheumatologists, each has provided different insights without a definitive resolution. Your symptoms seem to be complex, possibly involving inflammation or soft tissue rather than a clear ligament or tendon tear, as evidenced by negative imaging results. Medications like corticosteroids may help with inflammation, but their effects can vary from person to person.
Next Steps:
-
Prepare for Your Next Appointment:
- List Symptoms: Document a detailed account of your symptoms, including pain levels, any triggers, and how the pain affects daily activities. This may help your doctor better understand your condition.
- Inquire about Alternative Diagnostic Tests: Ask your doctor if another MRI with contrast might provide more insight into the inflammation around the PIP joint or if a different imaging technique (like ultrasound) could be useful.
-
Discuss Current Treatments and Propose Options:
- Ask about the pros and cons of undergoing a synovectomy. Given your doctor's reservations, discuss alternative treatments they may recommend if the current approach continues to show limited results.
- Explore physical therapy with a hand specialist to focus on exercises and treatment modalities to improve mobility and reduce pain.
-
Consider Adjunctive Therapies:
- Inquire about the role of occupational therapy to assist you in adapting daily tasks more comfortably.
- Discuss integrating non-pharmacological treatments like heat therapy, gentle stretching exercises, or modalities like ultrasound therapy that may contribute to pain relief and mobility enhancement.
-
Stay Proactive about Pain Management:
- Since you mentioned medication like Voltaren and Epsom salt soaks, consider continuing with these (as tolerated) while monitoring your response. Always inform your healthcare provider of any treatments you are implementing.
Emotional Support:
Your feelings of embarrassment and frustration are valid. Sharing them with supportive friends or family can help alleviate some of the emotional burden. Seeking counseling or support groups for those dealing with chronic pain or injuries might also be beneficial.
If your pain persists or worsens, don't hesitate to push for further evaluation or a second opinion, as advocating for your health is essential. Remember, you’re not alone in this, and many people face similar struggles. Keep communicating openly with your healthcare providers—this is a critical part of getting the support you need.
Related Questions
Concerns About RBC and Haematocrit Levels Post-Kidney Surgery
I am a 38-year-old male, standing at 6 feet tall and weighing 78 kilograms. Aside from having just one kidney, I consider myself healthy and active. While I have to wait a while to discuss my situation with my doctor, I thought I would reach out here for some insights. To provide some context, I had one of my kidneys removed due to cancer a little over a year ago. Here are my lab results: - 22/07/24: Two days post-surgery - 11/02/25: Six-month follow-up test - 21/08/25: One-year anniversary test I am particularly concerned about my red blood cell (RBC) count and haematocrit levels. **RBC Levels** - July 24: 4.56 - February 25: 4.71 - August 25: 4.42 **Haematocrit Levels** - July 24: 0.4 - February 25: 0.43 - August 25: 0.39 Additionally, I noticed my creatinine levels fluctuated from 139 to 162, then decreased to 141. All other parameters were within the normal range. Is there an alternative explanation for the decreases in my RBC and haematocrit? I'm feeling anxious about the health of my remaining kidney. It's worth mentioning that today's test was conducted without my usual hydration, and I've been experiencing soreness from a recent gym workout, including delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) and a swollen knee. Could these factors have contributed to the altered results?
Did I Expel a Colon Polyp? I Suspect So.
41 years old and female. Following a bout of constipation, I managed to pass my stool, and there seemed to be something linked to it. It was roughly an inch in width and seemed to be connected by a slender thread-like structure. Fortunately, there was no sign of bleeding.
Concerns After Appendectomy: Seeking Advice
I am a 40-year-old woman who recently had a health scare. I was prescribed antibiotics for an unrelated issue, as confirmed by a laboratory test. Just two days afterward, I found myself in the emergency room where my white blood cell count registered at 29,000, my AST level was 75, and a venous lactate measured 2.6. This alarming situation led to an urgent appendectomy. Upon reviewing the pathology report, the pathologist highlighted acute inflammation in the outer layers of my appendix, along with a diagnosis of endosalpingosis, while confirming there were no signs of dysplasia or cancer. The report included a note that the inflammation appeared confined to the outer layers, which might indicate a source of inflammation originating outside the appendix. Clinical correlation was deemed necessary, particularly pointing to the presence of endosalpingosis in the mesoappendix. After consulting with my surgeon, they reassured me that it is likely not a significant concern. However, I have a medical history that raises some alarms: I have been diagnosed with interstitial cystitis, experienced a life-threatening ectopic pregnancy in my twenties, and underwent a vulvar vestibulectomy due to vulvodynia back then. Recently, I have also been confronting issues with low ferritin levels and recurring migraines. Given my background, would it be prudent for me to investigate this further?
Dental and Sinus Issues: My Experience with Amoxicillin
Age: 25 Gender: Female Last Sunday, I awoke with discomfort localized in several of my teeth on the left side, specifically my front left tooth and the three adjacent ones. Throughout the day, I managed the pain with Tylenol, suspecting that it might be related to sinus issues, which I commonly experience at this time of year. By Monday morning, I noticed the pain had intensified, accompanied by slight swelling. I continued taking Tylenol into the evening and arranged for a consultation the following day. On Tuesday, I had a virtual appointment with the CVS MinuteClinic where I detailed my symptoms, including swelling in the area between my nose and upper lip, pressure in my cheek, and persistent tooth pain on that side. I did not experience any sensitivity to extreme temperatures. The MinuteClinic staff concluded that my symptoms were likely due to a sinus condition and recommended Flonase, Sudafed, warm compresses, and Advil. Wednesday morning, however, the swelling had escalated dramatically around my face, affecting my left nostril and the space between my nose and lip. I sought a virtual consultation through Geisinger urgent care, where I received a prescription for amoxicillin. I was advised to schedule a dental visit soon and was assured that the swelling should subside within two days. Currently, the swelling has spread closer to my eye, prompting concern as I can see my cheek in my peripheral vision, especially when I look down. My left nostril is congested, and I can physically feel the swelling when I touch the inside of my nose. As of today, the swelling remains consistent. This morning, I took my third dose of amoxicillin (875/125 mg), which I’m instructed to take every 12 hours. I find myself wondering whether I should continue waiting for the amoxicillin to take effect or if I should return to the urgent care for additional treatment. Should I consider going to the emergency room or an in-person urgent care facility instead? The worsening swelling is quite distressing. The pain level seems similar to yesterday, located at the base of my left nostril—it’s tender when I blow my nose, kiss my partner, or even touch it. The pain is also persistent and throbbing when unprovoked. Additionally, I’m feeling pressure in my cheek. I checked my temperature two times, first recording 97.8°F and then 97.6°F. I increasingly suspect that my ailment is more dental-related than sinus in nature, which is why I have scheduled a dental appointment for Tuesday after completing most of my antibiotic course. This situation is unusual for me; although I had a similarly less severe facial swelling incident years ago linked to the same tooth, my doctor had attributed it to sinusitis at that time, which resolved following a course of antibiotics—potentially amoxicillin, though I can’t recall exactly as it was almost a decade ago.
Is a Month-Long Wait for Neurologist Feedback Typical?
I’m currently assessing whether the delay I’m experiencing is standard practice or if I need to intensify my efforts. My brother is facing severe neurological and cognitive challenges, and I previously sent a fax to his neurologist outlining specific queries and relevant information to assist with his treatment. This is pressing since his condition appears to be deteriorating, and I require guidance on interim actions we can take. Here’s the sequence of events: - **July 23**: Sent a fax to the general number provided by the clinic. - **July 24**: Made multiple attempts to verify receipt but was informed that confirmation isn’t an option. - **July 25**: Received a voicemail from the clinic stating they hadn’t received my fax and provided a direct fax number instead. - **July 29**: Resent the fax to the new direct number. - **August 19**: Called for confirmation and was informed that the fax was received and had been “assigned” to the neurologist. The staff indicated that the doctor typically reviews such information closer to the scheduled appointment. I stressed the urgency of the situation, and they assured me that my fax had been printed and placed on the neurologist’s desk along with my message and contact details. - **August 21 (today)**: I have yet to receive any feedback from the doctor. As we approach a month since I first initiated contact and over a week since the office confirmed receipt, this timeline feels quite excessive given the urgency of the matter. Is such a delay normal within neurology or specialty medical practices, or does this suggest that the office is neglecting to handle my inquiry properly? Would it be advisable for me to escalate this issue by reaching out to the office manager, a nurse, or the patient relations department? For further context, I am listed in my brother’s medical records as a designated contact for communication regarding his care.