OpenHealth Q&A

Get answered by medical professionals

Persistent Strep Throat Problems

8/21/2025, 2:31:05 PMMale25-34

As a 23-year-old woman, standing at 5’2" and weighing 120 pounds, I have no prior health issues and do not smoke or take any medications. My boyfriend experienced a sore throat back in July. Fortunately, he recovered within a few days, but shortly after that, I met him and shared a kiss, only to find myself unwell the following week. I presumed he had strep throat, which seemed to have cleared up naturally before he inadvertently passed it to me. After visiting urgent care, the doctor examined my throat and prescribed cephalexin, which helped me feel better within 48 hours. (I have a known allergy to penicillin stemming from childhood, which is why it wasn't prescribed). The week after completing my antibiotic course, I saw my boyfriend again and, despite knowing the risks of kissing someone potentially contagious, I went ahead and did it anyway. My lack of knowledge about the duration of contagiousness was a poor excuse, and soon after, I fell ill again with similar symptoms. I consulted my doctor, who conducted a rapid strep test that came back positive, confirming my earlier diagnosis. He prescribed a ten-day course of Biaxin (clarithromycin), yet it did not alleviate my symptoms. Once I finished the medication, I returned to the doctor as my symptoms persisted, marked by enlarged tonsils but no longer a sore throat. After performing blood tests and a throat culture, the doctor suspected mononucleosis, yet I tested positive again for strep throat. It has now been four weeks of battling swollen tonsils. On my recent visit, my doctor decided to prescribe amoxicillin. I have been taking it for three days now and, surprisingly, I still suffer from swollen, infected tonsils. Could this be an indication of antibiotic resistance? I genuinely feel at a loss regarding how to proceed. Is amending my tonsils the only solution to resolve this? It seems outrageous to have undergone four rounds of antibiotics for strep throat. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.

Internal MedicineEndocrinologyRheumatology

Answers (1)

Cony

8/21/2025, 2:31:29 PM

OpenHealth AI

It sounds like you’ve had a challenging experience with persistent throat issues, and I understand how frustrating and concerning this can be. Given your circumstances, let’s break down what you’re facing and how to proceed effectively.

Key Points:

  1. Recurrence of Strep Throat: You’ve experienced multiple episodes of strep throat despite several rounds of antibiotics.
  2. Possible Antibiotic Resistance: While your situation may raise concerns about resistance, there are other factors to consider.
  3. Tonsil Health: You are questioning the necessity of tonsil removal and considering your symptoms.

Explanation:

Strep throat is usually caused by a bacterial infection (Streptococcus pyogenes) and is typically treated effectively with antibiotics. Persistent symptoms, such as swollen tonsils, suggest the possibility of:

  • Incomplete resolution of the infection: Sometimes, bacteria can be more resistant than typical strains.
  • Secondary infections or complications: Conditions like mononucleosis can complicate recovery.
  • Other underlying issues: Chronic tonsillitis or other infections/inflammatory conditions can also contribute.

Next Steps:

  1. Continue Watching Symptoms: Monitor for any new symptoms, such as fever or difficulty swallowing, as these could suggest complications.
  2. Complete the Amoxicillin Course: Finish the full course of amoxicillin as directed. Sometimes antibiotics take longer to show improvement, especially with inflammation.
  3. Supportive Care:
    • Stay hydrated and consume soothing foods (like warm teas or soups) that are easy to swallow.
    • Gargle with salt water several times a day to help reduce swelling and soothe your throat.
    • Over-the-counter pain relievers (like ibuprofen or acetaminophen) can also help manage discomfort.
  4. Follow-Up Care: If symptoms persist after completing the amoxicillin, or if they worsen, you should return to your doctor for further evaluation. Discuss the possibility of seeing an Ear, Nose, and Throat (ENT) specialist to consider if tonsillectomy could be beneficial in your case due to recurrent strep throat or chronic tonsillitis.
  5. Discuss Testing Options: If you have not yet had testing for other potential causes (like mononucleosis or viral infections), ensure this is explored with your doctor.

Additional Consideration:

Avoid close contact with anyone who is ill during this recovery phase, to prevent reinfection. Sharing drinks or utensils should also be avoided until you are symptom-free.

Please let me know if you have any further questions or need additional support. Your health is important, and it’s okay to seek further clarity in your care process.

Related Questions

Seeking Clarity on Possible Scabies or Bug Bites: A 33-Year-Old’s Dilemma

Hello, everyone. I am looking for some advice regarding my current health situation. - **Demographics**: 33-year-old male - **Region**: Pacific Northwest, USA - **Health Background**: Not on any medications or supplements; no known allergies - **Recent Travels**: Within the last month, I have visited Hawaii, Oklahoma, Missouri, and Upstate New York. - **Lifestyle and Exposure**: I travel frequently for work, often finding myself in rural or natural settings such as forests and fields. **Symptom Timeline**: - Four weeks ago, I discovered insect bites on my ankles and initially assumed they were from chiggers or fleas. I checked my bedding but found no evidence of bed bugs. - Following a week with no improvement and the emergence of new bites further up my legs, my primary care physician assessed the situation visually and diagnosed me with scabies. He prescribed permethrin, Zyrtec, and cefadroxil. After requesting a skin scraping, he conducted it gently, without using mineral oil, magnifying equipment, or performing a burrow test. The results turned out to be negative. - I underwent two treatments with permethrin spaced a week apart and conducted a thorough cleaning of my home, including washing linens and clothes at high temperatures and vacuuming my mattress and sofa. Initially, the symptoms seemed to lessen following the treatment. - However, one week post the second permethrin application, I noticed new itching in areas close to the original bites on my ankles. - A visit to a dermatology assistant involved the use of a dermatoscope connected to an iPad, leading to images being sent to a dermatologist. Their report stated “favor bites, uncertain insect identification.” They recommended clobetasol ointment and suggested that if the problem persists, I might need to consider pest control services. They declined to do additional skin scraping. **Questions and Concerns**: - I’m unclear about the term “favor bites” and what it indicates (does it imply that the condition appears more like insect bites rather than scabies?) - Am I receiving adequate care, or should I insist on more thorough testing, like a scraping or biopsy, to definitively rule out scabies or identify any other underlying issue? - Is it appropriate for the dermatology team to recommend pest control when the source of the issue has not been pinpointed? - What actions do you suggest I take next to avoid stagnating in this situation? I appreciate your insights in advance!

Multiple SclerosisFibromyalgiaInternal Medicine
Male25-34
8 minutes ago

Concerns About RBC and Haematocrit Levels Post-Kidney Surgery

I am a 38-year-old male, standing at 6 feet tall and weighing 78 kilograms. Aside from having just one kidney, I consider myself healthy and active. While I have to wait a while to discuss my situation with my doctor, I thought I would reach out here for some insights. To provide some context, I had one of my kidneys removed due to cancer a little over a year ago. Here are my lab results: - 22/07/24: Two days post-surgery - 11/02/25: Six-month follow-up test - 21/08/25: One-year anniversary test I am particularly concerned about my red blood cell (RBC) count and haematocrit levels. **RBC Levels** - July 24: 4.56 - February 25: 4.71 - August 25: 4.42 **Haematocrit Levels** - July 24: 0.4 - February 25: 0.43 - August 25: 0.39 Additionally, I noticed my creatinine levels fluctuated from 139 to 162, then decreased to 141. All other parameters were within the normal range. Is there an alternative explanation for the decreases in my RBC and haematocrit? I'm feeling anxious about the health of my remaining kidney. It's worth mentioning that today's test was conducted without my usual hydration, and I've been experiencing soreness from a recent gym workout, including delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) and a swollen knee. Could these factors have contributed to the altered results?

Multiple SclerosisInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
18 minutes ago

Inquiry Regarding Herpes IGG Blood Test Results

Greetings, everyone. I’m reaching out to seek clarity about the herpes IGG blood test. At 32, I consider myself to be in good health and maintain a nutritious diet. However, since August of the previous year, I’ve been experiencing a series of unusual symptoms, such as unexplained weight loss, ulcerative colitis, and vision complications. These symptoms emerged following a brief encounter I had with someone through Grindr. I’ve undergone extensive STD testing multiple times, even beyond the recommended window periods. Recently, I had an HSV IGG blood test, the results of which confirmed negative for both HSV-1 and HSV-2. Additionally, I’ve never encountered a cold sore or similar issues. My primary concern now is whether this result is definitive and if I can be certain that I do not have HSV?

Crohn's DiseaseCOPDRheumatology
Male25-34
28 minutes ago

Did I Expel a Colon Polyp? I Suspect So.

41 years old and female. Following a bout of constipation, I managed to pass my stool, and there seemed to be something linked to it. It was roughly an inch in width and seemed to be connected by a slender thread-like structure. Fortunately, there was no sign of bleeding.

Crohn's DiseaseInternal Medicine
Male25-34
28 minutes ago

Concerns After Appendectomy: Seeking Advice

I am a 40-year-old woman who recently had a health scare. I was prescribed antibiotics for an unrelated issue, as confirmed by a laboratory test. Just two days afterward, I found myself in the emergency room where my white blood cell count registered at 29,000, my AST level was 75, and a venous lactate measured 2.6. This alarming situation led to an urgent appendectomy. Upon reviewing the pathology report, the pathologist highlighted acute inflammation in the outer layers of my appendix, along with a diagnosis of endosalpingosis, while confirming there were no signs of dysplasia or cancer. The report included a note that the inflammation appeared confined to the outer layers, which might indicate a source of inflammation originating outside the appendix. Clinical correlation was deemed necessary, particularly pointing to the presence of endosalpingosis in the mesoappendix. After consulting with my surgeon, they reassured me that it is likely not a significant concern. However, I have a medical history that raises some alarms: I have been diagnosed with interstitial cystitis, experienced a life-threatening ectopic pregnancy in my twenties, and underwent a vulvar vestibulectomy due to vulvodynia back then. Recently, I have also been confronting issues with low ferritin levels and recurring migraines. Given my background, would it be prudent for me to investigate this further?

ArthritisCrohn's DiseaseRheumatology
Male25-34
28 minutes ago