To Operate or Not: An Evaluation of a Shoulder Injury
**Patient Overview: Shoulder Trauma** - **Patient Age:** 39 - **Date of Injury:** August 2, 2025 - **Incident Description:** The patient experienced a fall from an electronic bicycle, resulting in an impact to the right shoulder. **Medical Evaluation (from Emergency Room and CT Imaging):** 1. Anterior dislocation of the right shoulder was managed with sedation in the emergency department. 2. A significant bony Bankart lesion was identified, indicating a fracture of the glenoid rim. 3. The CT scan indicates an estimated loss of approximately 13% to 20% of the articular surface. 4. Additionally, a moderate-sized Hill-Sachs lesion is present on the humeral head. 5. Notably, the patient has no history of previous shoulder dislocations or instability. **Inquiry for Further Guidance:** In light of the findings, is surgical intervention the recommended course of action, or would a conservative, non-surgical approach suffice?
Answers (1)
8/14/2025, 7:11:04 AM
OpenHealth AI
Based on your detailed assessment of the shoulder injury, it is essential to weigh the specifics of your situation concerning surgical intervention versus conservative management.
Main Points:
- The presence of a significant bony Bankart lesion and a Hill-Sachs lesion suggests a higher likelihood of recurrent injuries and instability.
- Surgical intervention may be more beneficial given the potential for long-term complications if the injuries are left untreated.
Explanation:
- Bony Bankart Lesion: This type of injury typically occurs from a dislocation, where a piece of bone is detached from the glenoid rim. It affects shoulder stability and can lead to recurring dislocations if untreated.
- Hill-Sachs Lesion: This is an indentation on the humeral head that often occurs with dislocations. It adds to the instability of the shoulder.
- Even though you have no prior shoulder dislocations, the extent of the injuries indicated on the CT scan, notably the loss of 13% to 20% of the articular surface, suggests that conservative treatments may not suffice in preventing future dislocations and maintaining shoulder function.
Next Steps:
-
Consider Surgical Evaluation: Given the potential for ongoing instability and complications, consulting with an orthopedic surgeon specializing in shoulder injuries is crucial. They can evaluate the injury comprehensively and discuss the implications of surgery versus non-surgical options.
-
Symptom Management: In the meantime, focus on managing any pain and swelling:
- Use ice packs on the shoulder for 15-20 minutes several times a day.
- Consider over-the-counter pain medications like ibuprofen or acetaminophen, ensuring you follow dosage guidelines.
-
Gentle Physical Activity: Begin gentle range-of-motion exercises as tolerated. Avoid any movements that cause pain, but try to keep the joint moving to prevent stiffness.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Pay attention to any changes in symptoms, especially increased pain, swelling, or new sensations of instability.
-
Follow-Up Appointments: Stay consistent with follow-up appointments to keep a close monitor on recovery progress and to reassess the decision regarding surgery based on your healing trajectory.
Be assured that your concerns are valid, and taking proactive steps now will aid in better recovery and long-term shoulder health. If you have further questions or need clarification, feel free to ask.
Related Questions
Concerns Regarding Lung Nodules and Possible Tuberculosis
Greetings! I am a 47-year-old female who does not take any medications and does not smoke. For the past year, I have experienced intermittent coughing, which I initially attributed to lingering effects from COVID-19. Occasionally, I could hear phlegm in my lungs, but I didn't encounter any other symptoms at that time. Recently, I noticed mild fever, with evening temperatures fluctuating between 37.0 and 37.5 degrees Celsius. This prompted me to undergo a chest x-ray. Overall, I feel well and haven't experienced any breathlessness. The x-ray revealed multiple shadows measuring up to 15mm, leading to the necessity of a CT scan, the results of which I will summarize (translated from another language): - The rib cage appears normal in shape. - No visible abnormalities are found in the soft tissues of the rib cage. - The tracheobronchial tree is normally developed, with the trachea and bronchi showing no obstructive formations. The walls of the bronchial tubes are unevenly thickened on the left side. - Lung roots and mediastinal structures are clearly defined. **Lung findings:** - On the right lung, no infiltrative changes or masses are evident. - In the left lung, particularly in segments S1+2, S4, S5 of the upper lobe and S6, S9, S10 of the lower lobe, there are numerous scattered polymorphic foci, varying from minimally detectable sizes to 13mm. Notably, segments S5 and S10 show areas of consolidation in the lung tissue, the largest measuring approximately 33 x 16mm in segment S10. - No fluid accumulation is detected in the pleural spaces. - The mediastinum remains in its normal position and is not dilated, showing no additional formations. - Intrathoracic lymph nodes appear normal in size and density. - The heart is situated normally, with no enlargement. - There is no fluid observable in the pericardial cavity. - The aorta maintains a normal diameter. - The pulmonary artery trunk is also of standard size. - No bony lesions were found in the ribs, sternum, or thoracic vertebrae. The Diaskin test returned positive results. The following are the results of my complete blood count (CBC): - Red Blood Cells: 4.65 (normal range 3.92-5.08) - Hemoglobin: 125 (normal range 119-146) - Hematocrit: 38.6% (normal range 36.6-44.0) - Mean Corpuscular Volume: 83.0 fL (normal range 82.9-98.0) - Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin Concentration: 32.4 g/dL (normal range 31.8-34.7) - Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin: 26.8 pg (normal range 27.0-32.3) - Red Cell Distribution Width (SD): 45.9 fL (normal range 38.2-49.2) - Red Cell Distribution Width (CV): 14.4% (normal range 12.1-14.3) - Platelets: 299 (normal range 173-390) - Mean Platelet Volume: 9.9 fL (normal range 9.1-11.9) - Plateletcrit: 0.30% (normal range 0.18-0.39) - Platelet Distribution Width: 11.7% (normal range 9.9-15.4) - White Blood Cells: 6.87 (normal range 4.37-9.68) - Neutrophils: 5.21 (normal range 2.00-7.15) - Neutrophils %: 75.8% (normal range 42.5-73.2) - Eosinophils: 0.23 (normal range 0.03-0.27) - Eosinophils %: 3.3% (normal range 0.0-3.0) - Basophils: 0.03 (normal range 0.01-0.05) - Basophils %: 0.5% (normal range 0.0-0.7) - Monocytes: 0.45 (normal range 0.29-0.71) - Monocytes %: 6.5% (normal range 4.3-11.0) - Lymphocytes: 0.95 (normal range 1.16-3.18) - Lymphocytes %: 13.9% (normal range 18.2-47.4) I find it hard to believe that I might have tuberculosis, as I have not been in close contact with anyone who is ill. Since 2021, I have primarily been working from home, venturing out only for groceries. I live alone and see my family members infrequently, perhaps twice a month. I wonder if my previous job in customer service before 2021 could have exposed me to an infection that long ago? (Apologies for my English)
Could Regular Hookah Use Lead to Reddish Urine or Other Health Concerns?
At 22 years old and typically in good health, I've made some recent changes to my habits. After quitting cigarettes, I now find myself smoking hookah nearly every day—about one session daily—for the last couple of weeks. I don’t consume alcohol frequently and make an effort to stay fit. However, I've recently observed that my urine has taken on a slightly reddish hue. While I don’t experience any significant pain or discomfort, it certainly raises some red flags for me. Is it possible that my hookah usage is responsible for this change? Additionally, what other potential health risks should I consider when it comes to daily hookah smoking?
Persistent Headaches: Seeking Answers
I’m a 34-year-old male, weighing 180 pounds, and I don’t typically have any health concerns. I do engage in vaping and consume alcohol, but I've refrained from drinking for the past three days. I recognize the need for medical advice and plan to consult my GP tomorrow. For the last week, I've been experiencing a headache that fluctuates in severity, sometimes nearly vanishing but still lingering for a full seven days, which has been quite draining. This discomfort is nearly constant and can occasionally be quite severe. Interestingly, I’ve noticed that playing hockey provides a temporary relief from the pain, at least for a short while afterward, but I end up needing to take Tylenol again. I had a drink last Sunday, which I regretted when I woke up with a terrible headache on Monday. In terms of hydration, I’ve been diligent, drinking over three liters daily and incorporating electrolyte beverages into my routine. This headache situation is unusual for me. Just yesterday, I underwent an eye examination to rule out any strain, and the results came back normal. With two young children and the stresses of life, combined with my job that requires working on a laptop, things can get hectic. However, I’m not experiencing any additional symptoms like flashes, double vision, or weakness that might indicate a stroke or cognitive decline. It’s primarily this nagging headache that’s persisted longer than I’ve ever experienced before. Naturally, I’ve contemplated potential neurological issues, although I’m not overwhelmed with fear about it. I would appreciate any insight you have regarding what might be happening.
Desperate for Answers: My Ongoing Health Struggle
**Age:** 30 **Gender:** Male **Height:** 6 ft 2 in **Weight:** 83 kg I reside in the UK where I lead a lifestyle devoid of smoking or recreational drug use and indulge in alcohol only on rare occasions. Despite being prescribed Amitriptyline and Nortriptyline, I haven’t experienced any relief from my symptoms. **Background:** My health issues have persisted for over two years. I’ve undergone numerous consultations with general practitioners and specialists, yet none have arrived at a diagnosis. Initially, my ordeal began with severe jaw pain that quickly radiated to my head and then throughout my entire body. This followed traumatic events in my life, including my mother’s attempt at suicide, her subsequent hospitalization, my brother’s suicide, and an incredibly stressful relocation. Doctors initially diagnosed me with a sinus infection, later contemplating a blocked salivary gland before reverting back to the sinus diagnosis. I endured a year of antibiotics, steroids, and antifungal treatments, which did nothing to alleviate my suffering. In desperation, I requested an MRI, fearing I might have a brain tumor or something equally dire. The results revealed little aside from a minor sinus infection. An ENT specialist subsequently conducted a CT scan, confirming no signs of infection or allergies. He did inquire if I had a history of nasal fractures, to which I responded negatively. Following this visit, I was left without further direction. As I sought help, I also visited both an optometrist and a dentist, hoping they might uncover any issues contributing to my symptoms. While my vision appeared fine, I occasionally experienced blurred sight along with tiredness, headaches, and migraines. The dentist assessed my dental health due to my jaw and tooth discomfort, finding nothing amiss but suggested a mouthguard to address potential teeth clenching, which has not proved effective. With the focus so heavily on my head, I lost touch with the overall state of my body. Once I began to reassess how I was feeling physically, I realized my symptoms were more extensive than I had acknowledged. After a comprehensive evaluation of my body, I compiled the following symptoms I currently endure: * Pain stretching from my forehead to the area behind my ears. * A blocked right nostril, although the ENT remarked that the deviation affects my left side. * Dry sinuses. * Pain localized on the right side of my jaw, which can radiate to the opposite side. * Discomfort extending down my left shoulder. * Cracking and sore joints in my left shoulder. * Aching and cracking joints in my knees. * Similar issues in my ankles. * Widespread muscle soreness resembling flu-like symptoms. * Puffy and fatigued eyes. * Frequent headaches. * Migraines causing intense pain in my right eye. * Neck discomfort. * Occasional sharp pains in various parts of my body or limbs. * Digestive distress. * A recent sore throat. * A peculiar sensation while swallowing, especially on the right side. * Persistent brain fog. Currently, my GP's only action is to refer me to a rheumatologist, suspecting the possibility of fibromyalgia, a condition my mother has, often triggered by traumatic physical or emotional events. In terms of mental health, I have pursued therapy extensively, although it has failed to alleviate my physical symptoms. I find myself at an impasse regarding my health, feeling as though my body is failing or at war with itself. The quality of my life has diminished significantly. At this point, I can only hypothesize that my issues may stem from an allergy or some sort of fibromyalgia, or perhaps an unusual condition that remains unidentified. Any guidance or insight would be immensely valued as I am at the end of my rope.
Girlfriend's Unusual Nighttime Behavior
The title sums it up fairly well, but to clarify, she’s not under the influence of drugs or alcohol. I'm an 18-year-old female, and my girlfriend is 17; we’ve been together for two years and often fall asleep on FaceTime. However, at approximately 2:30 am this morning, I woke up to the peculiar sound of her conversing with herself. Initially, I believed she was speaking with a family member, but after texting her, it became evident that none of her messages made any sense. She seemed to think she was having a conversation with her boss, then transitioned to speaking to me, and then shifted focus to a friend—while she repeatedly called her sister by my name. Throughout this entire episode, both her mother and I were receiving messages from her that were completely incoherent. Despite our pleas for her to lie down and get some sleep, she stubbornly refused to rest. There’s no prior instance of her talking in her sleep or walking around at night, and she doesn't seem to be asleep either, as her eyes are wide open and she is moderately engaged in conversation with me via FaceTime. From my perspective, her thoughts appeared to be scattered, resulting in a delay in her response to each question, with her replies often lacking clarity. Her texts, on the other hand, were utterly nonsensical. Here’s one example of a text I received: "I jofijtnanxart but then oinlose it somewhere in my house and then mad could elk like wehstsbhenfonnwndo." Anyway, does anyone have any insights into what might be happening? This has been going on for at least four hours now.