Seeking a Third Opinion on My Scaphoid: Am I Overreacting?
28-year-old male. I consume alcohol socially, but I do not smoke or use recreational drugs. Medication: Daily intake of 30mg Vyvanse. Back in January, during a rugby match, I extended my arms and unfortunately ended up injuring my wrists. At first, I assumed I merely sprained both wrists since I had previously fractured a wrist and this didn’t seem nearly as painful. I continued playing despite the discomfort until I aggravated the injury again in May, leading me to seek medical attention. X-rays revealed an ulnar styloid fracture, but no major concerns, and I was prescribed a splint. A month later, a CT scan brought up inconclusive results, yet I was fitted with a removable thumb spica cast that I wore for another month. After a lengthy wait, I finally advocated for an MRI, which occurred eight months post-injury. The MRI indicated a “chip” in the distal pole of my scaphoid, according to the surgeon; however, no further actions were taken, with the orthopedic hand surgeon informing me that I would likely endure discomfort for several more months before regaining normalcy. This situation occurred nearly a year ago and I still experience significant pain frequently enough to seek a second opinion from another hand surgeon. He evaluated my existing scans and conducted a new x-ray, which confirmed the earlier fracture but found no signs of nonunion. I received a steroid injection, which provided substantial relief, eliminating pain for several weeks, and I felt reassured during the follow-up consultation a month later. Yet, now several months have passed, and my pain has returned to its previous intensity, leading me to question if the discomfort might be psychosomatic or if I am merely being overly anxious. Regardless, the frustration is palpable. I can’t shake the fear that a nonunion or avascular necrosis may have been overlooked, and considering I rely heavily on my right hand, avoiding a SNAC wrist or potential arthritis is crucial. I wonder if that possibility has already passed. Is pursuing a third opinion warranted? Or am I simply overreacting?
Answers (1)
8/10/2025, 4:50:49 PM
OpenHealth AI
It’s understandable to feel frustrated and anxious when dealing with persistent pain, especially after a sports-related injury. Based on your experiences, it's clear you've been proactive in seeking care. Here’s a summary of important points regarding your scaphoid injury and the potential need for a third opinion.
Main Points:
- Persistent Pain After Injury: It's common for pain to linger after a wrist injury, especially if complications like scaphoid fractures are involved.
- Concerns About Nonunion/Avascular Necrosis: Your worries about potential complications are valid, given the importance of the scaphoid bone in wrist function.
- Considering a Third Opinion: Seeking further evaluation can provide peace of mind and possibly different treatment options.
Explanation:
Scaphoid fractures can be tricky because they can lead to complications like nonunion (where the bone doesn't heal properly) or avascular necrosis (when the blood supply to the bone is interrupted). Given your ongoing pain and the previous inconclusive imaging, it's natural to question whether all potential issues have been thoroughly explored.
The steroid injection temporarily alleviated your pain, suggesting inflammation may still be contributing to your symptoms. It's common for these injuries to be frustrating and for healing to take longer than expected. Psychosomatic concerns can arise from chronic pain, but given your long history and objective findings, it’s equally important to consider that physical issues may still be at play.
Next Steps:
-
Consider a Third Opinion: If it provides reassurance and you still feel pain, pursuing a third opinion—especially from a specialized orthopedic hand surgeon—can be a reasonable step. Ensure this provider is familiar with complex wrist injuries.
-
Discuss Imaging Options: During your next visit, discuss the possibility of advanced imaging (e.g., repeat MRI or specific MRI sequences) to assess the scaphoid in more detail, looking for any signs of nonunion or avascular necrosis.
-
Pain Management Strategies: In the meantime, consider physical therapy to strengthen and stabilize the wrist, incorporate range-of-motion exercises, and possibly explore additional pain management alternatives if ongoing pain persists.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Keep a detailed log of your pain, including triggers and the intensity. This information can be valuable for your next consultation.
-
Seek Support: Given the emotional toll of chronic pain, consider talking to a mental health professional to help manage anxiety related to your injury and ongoing discomfort.
Remember, advocating for your health is essential, and pursuing a third opinion when you have concerns is a proactive step toward finding relief and regaining function.
Related Questions
Is It Common for a 9-Year-Old to Experience Facial Paralysis for 6 Months?
At the age of nine, I was told by my father that my smile appeared uneven; essentially, the left side of my face seemed partially paralyzed. Although I could still move it to some degree, blinking was a challenge on that side, which often left my eye feeling dry. We visited the hospital that very day, where they administered laughing gas to facilitate a lumbar puncture due to their suspicion of Lyme disease, along with a blood test to rule out other potential issues. The lumbar puncture was intensely painful, a discomfort I had never experienced before, even with the gas administered to dull the sensation. In the end, the test results yielded no conclusive diagnosis—doctors speculated that a nerve might have been inflamed or something along those lines. Despite having access to free healthcare, the experience was frustrating. To manage my symptoms, I used a patch taped over my eye to help retain moisture, which eventually resolved the issue. Though I suspect that nerve swelling was the culprit, I occasionally find myself reflecting on the incident and wonder if other factors could be responsible.
Unexplained Bruises and Welts on My Daughter's Skin
Four nights ago, my daughter developed two noticeable welts on her thighs, which showed no signs of pain or itching. She insisted vigorously that nothing occurred to cause them, and nobody had harmed her. The following day, I noticed that the welts had vanished, leaving behind bruises. This left me quite anxious, fearing she might have sustained an injury. However, since that initial incident, it seems she has developed one or two more welts every evening right before bedtime, which then disappear overnight, only to be replaced by bruises in the morning. Most of these welts have appeared on her legs, ankles, and feet, with the exception of one on her palm that did not result in a bruise. Oddly, none of the welts are itchy, but she mentions that they can be painful when pressure is applied. There's a bit of swelling as well, consistently occurring in the evenings just before she goes to bed. We plan to consult a doctor on Monday, but it's currently the weekend, and I'm curious if anyone has encountered something similar or could have insights on what might be happening.
Navigating Acoustic Neuroma Treatment Options
**Profile: 45-year-old Male, 6'0", 220 lbs, No Regular Medications** My husband maintains a relatively healthy lifestyle despite experiencing some service-related disabilities. About a year and a half ago, he underwent knee replacement surgery, and he utilizes a CPAP machine due to sleep apnea—an issue linked to a jaw surgery performed many years ago. Additionally, he has a history of appendectomy. For the past three years, he has been prescribed hearing aids due to bilateral hearing loss, although he rarely uses them. About eight months ago, he experienced what he described as the "worst headache of his life." Given that he seldom suffers from headaches, we decided to visit the emergency room. A CT scan showed no abnormalities, and he was diagnosed with a migraine. Since then, he has grappled with weekly migraines. He has a triptan medication, but it offers limited relief. Additionally, he has been reporting non-migraine headaches every few days. Before this incident, he reported headaches perhaps twice a year, typically after consuming alcohol, which he does occasionally and in moderation. He also frequently mentions a sensation of pressure or fullness in his head, though he is uncertain if he would categorize it as a headache. Given the stressors our family has faced over the past couple of years, I hoped this might subside as we return to a more typical routine. Two weeks ago, my husband’s boss alerted us that an ambulance was called after he fainted while walking down the hall at work. After regaining consciousness, he attempted to sit up but felt intense dizziness, forcing him to lie back down. Although his fall wasn't witnessed, he was found roughly two minutes later. At the ER, tests including a CT scan and EKG returned normal results. He was then referred back to his primary care manager (PCM), who ordered an MRI with and without contrast. The MRI revealed the presence of an acoustic neuroma. Through my investigation, it appears that many of his symptoms—headaches, pressure sensations, dizziness, and cognitive fog—could be linked to this condition. We are currently awaiting a follow-up appointment with his PCM for a specialist referral. I want to ensure that he is equipped to advocate for himself during this process. Considering his MRI results and associated symptoms, should we seek the expertise of a specialist familiar with acoustic neuroma? I am concerned that our small-town ENT may not have extensive experience with this issue, and I want to avoid a mere monitoring approach if more proactive treatment is advisable. With a busy family and an active lifestyle, his symptoms over these past months have certainly impacted him, as well as our family dynamics and his professional duties. I would greatly appreciate any insights regarding treatment options or specialist locations you might be able to share. Thank you!
Blood in Urine: Seeking Guidance
A 20-year-old female weighing 140 pounds has not been taking any medications or supplements, and has no prior or current medical conditions. Her menstrual cycle last occurred two weeks ago. While at work, she observed blood in her urine, which appeared light red but darker than pink. Accompanying this symptom, she has experienced some abdominal discomfort. Notably, there was no evidence of blood on her underwear, only when she urinated. Additionally, she felt a moment of lightheadedness upon noticing the blood, which has since subsided; she attributes this feeling to her anxiety about the potential seriousness of the situation. Given these symptoms, what could be the likely cause? She is uncertain whether to visit the emergency room or to wait until urgent care is available tomorrow for a consultation. As she recently relocated and does not have a primary care physician yet, her anxiety is heightened.
Exploring Endolymphatic Hydrops: Could This Be My Condition?
34 years old / Female Current weight: 165 lbs Navigating the challenges of motherhood In early December 2025, I caught a cold. By mid-December, my right ear felt blocked, but I attributed it to the cold virus. As New Year approached, I experienced another cold, which coincided with an onset of ringing in my ears. Disturbingly, sounds started to seem altered from the affected ear, accompanied by a persistent fullness in that area. Additionally, I noticed twitching of my eye and swelling in the salivary gland on the same side. My primary care physician prescribed a decongestant and Flonase; however, because I am currently breastfeeding, I hesitated to take the medications as directed. On January 27, I was evaluated by an ear, nose, and throat specialist, who requested a hearing assessment the following day. The results indicated that I had sensorineural hearing loss affecting my low-frequency hearing range (250 Hz to 500 Hz). The doctor prescribed a steroid with the hope of addressing the issue promptly. Now on day 10 of steroid treatment, I have experienced significant relief. Remarkably, I've noticed a substantial amount of thick, putty-like mucus clearing from my nasal passages. The pressure in my ear has subsided, and sounds are returning to normal, though I still perceive a slight ringing — possibly just a touch of hearing loss remains. What concerns me is whether ongoing sinus congestion could be the root of these symptoms or if I might genuinely be dealing with endolymphatic hydrops. Notably, I have not experienced any episodes of dizziness. In the evenings, I tend to feel considerable pressure building on the right side of my head, almost as if my sinuses are becoming blocked once more. I would greatly appreciate any insights or advice on this matter, as I find myself in a state of uncertainty regarding my condition.