Seeking a Third Opinion on My Scaphoid: Am I Overreacting?
28-year-old male. I consume alcohol socially, but I do not smoke or use recreational drugs. Medication: Daily intake of 30mg Vyvanse. Back in January, during a rugby match, I extended my arms and unfortunately ended up injuring my wrists. At first, I assumed I merely sprained both wrists since I had previously fractured a wrist and this didn’t seem nearly as painful. I continued playing despite the discomfort until I aggravated the injury again in May, leading me to seek medical attention. X-rays revealed an ulnar styloid fracture, but no major concerns, and I was prescribed a splint. A month later, a CT scan brought up inconclusive results, yet I was fitted with a removable thumb spica cast that I wore for another month. After a lengthy wait, I finally advocated for an MRI, which occurred eight months post-injury. The MRI indicated a “chip” in the distal pole of my scaphoid, according to the surgeon; however, no further actions were taken, with the orthopedic hand surgeon informing me that I would likely endure discomfort for several more months before regaining normalcy. This situation occurred nearly a year ago and I still experience significant pain frequently enough to seek a second opinion from another hand surgeon. He evaluated my existing scans and conducted a new x-ray, which confirmed the earlier fracture but found no signs of nonunion. I received a steroid injection, which provided substantial relief, eliminating pain for several weeks, and I felt reassured during the follow-up consultation a month later. Yet, now several months have passed, and my pain has returned to its previous intensity, leading me to question if the discomfort might be psychosomatic or if I am merely being overly anxious. Regardless, the frustration is palpable. I can’t shake the fear that a nonunion or avascular necrosis may have been overlooked, and considering I rely heavily on my right hand, avoiding a SNAC wrist or potential arthritis is crucial. I wonder if that possibility has already passed. Is pursuing a third opinion warranted? Or am I simply overreacting?
Answers (1)
8/10/2025, 4:50:49 PM
OpenHealth AI
It’s understandable to feel frustrated and anxious when dealing with persistent pain, especially after a sports-related injury. Based on your experiences, it's clear you've been proactive in seeking care. Here’s a summary of important points regarding your scaphoid injury and the potential need for a third opinion.
Main Points:
- Persistent Pain After Injury: It's common for pain to linger after a wrist injury, especially if complications like scaphoid fractures are involved.
- Concerns About Nonunion/Avascular Necrosis: Your worries about potential complications are valid, given the importance of the scaphoid bone in wrist function.
- Considering a Third Opinion: Seeking further evaluation can provide peace of mind and possibly different treatment options.
Explanation:
Scaphoid fractures can be tricky because they can lead to complications like nonunion (where the bone doesn't heal properly) or avascular necrosis (when the blood supply to the bone is interrupted). Given your ongoing pain and the previous inconclusive imaging, it's natural to question whether all potential issues have been thoroughly explored.
The steroid injection temporarily alleviated your pain, suggesting inflammation may still be contributing to your symptoms. It's common for these injuries to be frustrating and for healing to take longer than expected. Psychosomatic concerns can arise from chronic pain, but given your long history and objective findings, it’s equally important to consider that physical issues may still be at play.
Next Steps:
-
Consider a Third Opinion: If it provides reassurance and you still feel pain, pursuing a third opinion—especially from a specialized orthopedic hand surgeon—can be a reasonable step. Ensure this provider is familiar with complex wrist injuries.
-
Discuss Imaging Options: During your next visit, discuss the possibility of advanced imaging (e.g., repeat MRI or specific MRI sequences) to assess the scaphoid in more detail, looking for any signs of nonunion or avascular necrosis.
-
Pain Management Strategies: In the meantime, consider physical therapy to strengthen and stabilize the wrist, incorporate range-of-motion exercises, and possibly explore additional pain management alternatives if ongoing pain persists.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Keep a detailed log of your pain, including triggers and the intensity. This information can be valuable for your next consultation.
-
Seek Support: Given the emotional toll of chronic pain, consider talking to a mental health professional to help manage anxiety related to your injury and ongoing discomfort.
Remember, advocating for your health is essential, and pursuing a third opinion when you have concerns is a proactive step toward finding relief and regaining function.
Related Questions
Experiencing Heart Palpitations?
Hello everyone! I’m a 22-year-old with a background of significant anxiety, depression, and traits associated with borderline personality disorder. Just yesterday, I began to notice frequent episodes of extrasystoles, particularly in the evenings when I’m resting in bed, right before I’m set to embark on a two-day getaway. Last month, I underwent a comprehensive cardiac evaluation, which included a standard ECG and a high-lead ECG to exclude Brugada syndrome, a condition that is prevalent in my family—my father has been diagnosed with it. Thankfully, all the results were entirely normal. However, I’m feeling very anxious about this situation. The only symptom I’m experiencing is these palpitations. Is it possible that anxiety is causing this? I often feel nervous about being away from home.
Addressing Persistent Blood in Stool
A 29-year-old male has been experiencing intermittent blood in his stool over the past couple of years. After a year of these symptoms, he finally sought medical attention. Blood tests indicated there was no significant blood loss, and although he underwent a scope examination, further testing for celiac disease and a colonoscopy was postponed. This decision was influenced both by a busy work schedule and a feeling of embarrassment regarding the procedure, which his doctor believed was linked to hemorrhoids. Recently, he has noticed a consistent presence of blood when wiping, with occasional traces in the stool itself. Although he experiences no pain, he does suffer from constipation, which he attributes to a protein-heavy diet stemming from his interest in bodybuilding. Despite trying to increase his fiber intake, he has not seen any improvement. While the amount of blood varies, it has not reached a level that he finds alarming. He seeks advice on how to manage this situation independently and wonders whether he should proceed with the colonoscopy regardless of his reservations. Scheduling the procedure poses a challenge, especially since he feels uncomfortable going alone. While he displays a degree of concern over his health, he remains uncertain about the extent to which he should feel alarmed given the symptoms' nature and frequency.
Visiting the ER After Experiencing Strangulation
A 37-year-old male reports an incident occurring during consensual sexual activity on Saturday night where he was strangled. Since then, he has been experiencing persistent lightheadedness accompanied by a moderate headache, as well as a feeling of eye strain. Additionally, he has been experiencing mild bouts of dizziness. Despite recognizing the importance of seeking medical attention for his symptoms, he is hesitant. His concerns revolve around disclosing the identity of the person involved, fearing that this individual might find out about his visit to the emergency room. He is also apprehensive about possibly being admitted against his will. Uncertain about the procedures involved in such a visit and anxious about the potential questions and actions that medical staff might take, he seeks insight from others. He acknowledges that worrying over these details may seem irrational but is seeking clarity about what to expect during his time at the ER.
Could a Rollercoaster Cause a Concussion?
A 17-year-old recently enjoyed two exhilarating rides on the Hulk rollercoaster in Orlando just two hours prior and has since been experiencing a sense of confusion and a peculiar feeling in his head. Is it possible that he has sustained a mild concussion? He recalls jostling his head during the initial ride, which raises concerns about the impact's effect.
Understanding QL Pain After Surgery: Insights and Questions
Hello, I’ll keep my background brief. Last year, I endured about seven months marked by intense pain and persistent nausea before undergoing a hip replacement procedure six months ago, followed by a laminectomy (without discectomy, but involving instrumentation such as screws and rods) five months ago to address severe lumbar stenosis. I am a 50-year-old woman of average weight with over seven years of experience dealing with inflammatory arthritis, aligning with a diagnosis of non-radiographic axial spondyloarthritis as confirmed by my rheumatologist. This condition initially manifested in my right ankle and has now affected both my hands and feet. Currently, I’m on Cosentyx, which has recently been increased to a higher dose. Additionally, I am dealing with "advanced" facet arthrosis, which may be linked to my active youth, coupled with my hypermobility. A cyst was identified at my L4 facet joint, causing severe symptoms prior to my surgical intervention. Recently, my physical therapists identified that my right quadratus lumborum (QL) is chronically tight. This tightness has flared up recently, leading to days of painful vomiting and retching until I could take muscle relaxants to alleviate the discomfort. Even when the spasm subsides, any twisting motion of my torso triggers a sharp sensation in my right rib cage. Furthermore, I experience persistent nerve pain in my right leg, which intensifies when I am seated. Despite these challenges, I strive to maintain my strength and health, making an effort to remain active with daily walks. I have two primary concerns: 1. Are the episodes of pain and spasms in my QL connected to my spine? This issue significantly impacted my life and career last year, so understanding this relationship is crucial. 2. Is the QL pain and spasms associated with neurological or surgical factors? I have experimented with narcotics and gabapentin; thus far, only muscle relaxers provide some relief, though it is limited. Thank you for your assistance!