Intense Discomfort in My Ankles After Short Walks: A Long-Lasting Mystery for Nine Years
I’m a 48-year-old individual of mixed heritage, encompassing black, European, and Middle Eastern descent, standing tall at 6 feet 2 inches and weighing 193 pounds, with a shoe size of 13 ½ wide. Nine years ago, following a knee dislocation that resulted in a fracture and subsequent surgery, I began experiencing a troubling condition. As I began to resume my routine of walking, I suddenly found myself afflicted by excruciating pain on the outer aspects of my ankles. This painful sensation primarily targets the area around my peroneal tendons and strikes after I’ve walked just a few blocks. Interestingly, only 48 hours prior to this onset, I had managed to walk half a mile without issues. The severity of the pain fluctuates; there are times when merely two blocks will trigger it, while on other occasions, I can manage ten blocks with minimal discomfort. However, the agony is almost guaranteed to return. When I engage in activities that involve stopping and starting—like walking my dogs—I find I can walk indefinitely. It seems that continuous movement without breaks is what exacerbates the situation, as the pain intensifies quickly from a mild annoyance to an unbearable tightness. If I take a seat and rest, the pain subsides within several minutes, yet resuming activity too soon causes it to surge back immediately. When I walk in a group, I typically set a brisk pace ahead of others, pausing to wait for them to catch up. Walking uphill intensifies the experience significantly. I’ve explored numerous footwear options to alleviate this discomfort. I have high arches and utilize Dr. Scholl’s insoles for added support, as well as shoes designed to support my ankles—but none have proven effective. Consultations with two podiatrists have yielded no concrete answers. Both conducted X-rays, with one opting for an MRI as well. The findings were inconclusive! One physician speculated that scar tissue might be affecting an ankle tendon or ligament, but even he acknowledged that this was merely a guess based on limited evidence. I have also sought the assistance of physical therapists, none of whom have been able to clarify the situation. Although I have discovered some strategies to manage the discomfort—such as biking and practicing intermittent walking—there are times when it’s essential to make a swift journey on foot. My former workplace was six blocks away from the subway, and those walks could often be torturous. I can endure the pain somewhat when necessary, but I constantly worry that I might eventually rupture a tendon or ligament. Does anyone have insight into what might be happening with my ankles?
Answers (1)

8/5/2025, 5:51:11 PM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you've been through a considerable amount of discomfort and uncertainty regarding your ankle pain, particularly following your knee injury. This pain, especially localized around the peroneal tendons, suggests that it may be related to a combination of factors, potentially including scar tissue, tendon irritation or inflammation, and possibly issues with your walking mechanics.
Summary of Key Points:
- Nature of Pain: The pain in your ankles, especially after walking, likely relates to underlying issues from your knee surgery.
- Triggering Activity: Continuous walking seems to worsen the pain, while stopping and starting helps alleviate it.
- Current Management: You have made some adaptations to your activities, such as biking and intermittent walking, which are beneficial.
Explanation:
Your pain pattern and persistence suggest it may be influenced by several factors:
- Tendonitis or Tendinopathy: Overuse of your peroneal tendons can lead to inflammation, especially if influenced by altered biomechanics due to your past knee injury.
- Scar Tissue: This could interfere with normal tendon function, causing discomfort when moving.
- Footwear and Foot Structure: High arches can contribute to improper distribution of stress. Even with insoles and supportive shoes, the specific design may not effectively accommodate your particular foot shape.
Next Steps:
- Gradual Warm-Up: Before walking, try a gentle warm-up routine focusing on your ankles and legs to increase blood flow. Simple ankle circles and stretching may help.
- Activity Modification: Continue varying your activities. As you noted, biking is less painful; perhaps increase this activity if it remains comfortable.
- Strengthening and Flexibility: Focus on strengthening exercises for the muscles supporting your ankles (e.g., calf raises, toe tapping) and also include flexibility work (e.g., gentle calf and hamstring stretches).
- Footwear Review: Reassess your footwear with a focus on shoes specifically recommended for high arches and ankle support. Consider consulting a specialist with expertise in custom orthotics that consider your unique foot structure.
- Physical Therapy Reinforcement: If you haven’t already, look specifically for a physical therapist specializing in post-injury rehabilitation. They may offer specific exercises and strategies tailored to your needs.
- Pain Management Techniques: When engaging in activities prone to aggravation, consider the use of over-the-counter anti-inflammatory medications (if appropriate for you) or topical analgesics for immediate relief.
Monitoring any changes in your symptoms and how they respond to these adjustments is crucial. Keep a log of your activities, pain levels, and what seems to help or worsen the problem; it can provide valuable insight over time.
You’re actively seeking solutions, and that’s an important step toward improving your comfort. If your pain worsens or new symptoms arise, exploring further specialized evaluations might still be beneficial.
Related Questions
Subacromial Bursitis: Understanding the Recovery Process
As a 26-year-old man, I've been practicing calisthenics for more than two years. Recently, I experienced some discomfort in my shoulder and triceps after a training session, and this pain persisted for several days. Although it subsided after about a week, I still have difficulty raising my right arm completely and have noticed a significant reduction in strength. I visited my primary care physician twice and underwent an MRI, which confirmed a diagnosis of subacromial bursitis. Following this, I consulted with an orthopedic specialist who reviewed the MRI results and performed a few physical examinations. He concluded that while my condition isn't severe, healing would require at least six weeks, with a recommendation to avoid stressing the shoulder during recovery. For a little over a month now, I have adhered to this advice without seeing much improvement. I haven't engaged in any training, as nearly all my previous exercises involve some use of my shoulder. Initially, I was able to perform pull-ups without much discomfort, but I've since ceased all overhead activities, realizing they might hinder recovery. Currently, I'm not on any particular medication; I’m merely taking supplements such as magnesium, creatine, and iron. Despite my efforts, I still struggle to lift my arm fully, and I've fallen from doing 35 push-ups to being incapable of completing even one. This decline, combined with my stagnation in progress, is quite discouraging. It feels as though the achievements I've worked hard for over the years are slipping away, leaving me feeling powerless. I understand the necessity of patience in the healing process, yet I'm curious about how long I might expect this situation to last. Is recovery typically gradual, or can it sometimes improve abruptly, as the injury did? As it stands, I fear that by the six-week mark, I may still be in the same position unless some miraculous turnaround happens soon.
Understanding Snapping Hip Syndrome
As a 20-year-old male, I have been experiencing a peculiar snapping or gliding sensation on the outer part of my right hip for the last four months. This sensation tends to be accompanied by discomfort, particularly after I engage in leg workouts or take long walks. Although I can't remember if this snapping was present before, the pain began about four months ago, without any similar issues on my left side. It seems to align with external snapping hip syndrome, possibly linked to a tight iliotibial (IT) band or weak gluteal muscles. Interestingly, there is no associated sound; it’s purely a physical sensation that occurs mainly when I lift my leg or bend down. To address this, I have incorporated glute bridges, hip abductions, and stretches for the IT band into my routine. I’m seeking insights into whether this diagnosis appears accurate and if rehabilitation can provide relief, or if I should consider a more thorough examination.
Seeking Guidance on Back Issues
I'm a 19-year-old male facing some concerns with my back. It's been observed that I have pronounced lumbar lordosis, which seems to be primarily a result of muscle spasms in the area around my spine. Additionally, there are some mild disc bulges detected at the L4-L5 and L5-S1 levels, with a notable decrease in disc height at the posterior aspect of L5-S1. There is also a possibility of a small, potentially serious tear in the annulus of the L5-S1 disc. I’m wondering if there’s hope for a complete recovery and if I’ll return to my normal self again?
Persistent Twitching in My Lower Eyelid for a Month
Hello everyone, I’ve been experiencing an unusual twitch in my left lower eyelid for about a month now. The episodes are intermittent; initially, I would notice it about 3 to 4 times within a single day, with each twitch lasting anywhere from 3 to 5 seconds. However, after I started to delve into it, driven by worries that Google connected it to Parkinson’s disease, my anxiety seemed to exacerbate the situation. Now, it happens 10 to 20 times every hour. For context, I’m a 22-year-old male, I smoke around 10 cigarettes daily, and I limit my coffee intake to just one espresso per day.
An Intriguing Health Experience
I’m a 41-year-old male, standing at 186 cm and weighing 125 kg. I have a history of managing my blood pressure effectively with Amlodipine, and besides that, I don’t really have any significant health problems. Around two months ago, I experienced numbness in my pinky and ring fingers, which extended to the back of my hand and part of my forearm. This sensation did not subside. Then, roughly two weeks ago, I noticed that my elbow began to swell significantly without any prior injury or visible damage. Interestingly, as this swelling progressed, I began to regain feeling in my fingers, and the numbness lessened. When I visited the emergency department, the doctors seemed indifferent to my concerns. They conducted a blood test, which returned normal results, and suggested that I may have sustained an injury elsewhere in my body. They prescribed a week-long course of antibiotics due to a small cut I had on my swollen elbow. Remarkably, the swelling reduced almost entirely within a day; however, I developed a large bruise that has been slowly spreading around my forearm ever since. Now, nearly two weeks later, it continues to expand. While I'm confident that I'm on the path to recovery, I can't help but wonder about the underlying cause of these strange symptoms. 🤔