Can a Zio Monitor Identify POTS?
Summary: I used a Zio monitor for a week that ruled out POTS, yet I'm exhibiting symptoms others believe align with it. My cardiologist indicated the monitor excludes POTS, but numerous opinions suggest otherwise. Who should I believe? Hey there! I'm a 23-year-old female dealing with various health issues, none of which are heart-related. Last year, I experienced severe anxiety that led me to the ER, mistakenly thinking I was having heart palpitations, but it only turned out to be an anxiety attack paired with a minor sinus arrhythmia. As a result, I underwent a 7-day Zio monitor test, and the results primarily came back within normal limits, with only minor irregularities that my healthcare provider deemed very common—such as some trivial valve issues that he assured me were not concerning right now, perhaps only as I grow older. After discussing the findings, I inquired about testing for POTS because of the multiple symptoms I had. The cardiologist stated that the monitor's results had ruled out POTS completely and advised against any further testing. However, in my conversations with other doctors and my extensive research, I've found that a Zio monitor typically does not detect POTS and that diagnosis usually requires a tilt table test or alternative evaluations. I often feel dizzy when I stand, regardless of how I change positions, and I frequently experience exhaustion, along with near-fainting spells. These signs, along with a family history of similar conditions, make me wonder about my diagnosis. While I understand that the cardiologist is specialized in this field, the healthcare facility in my region has a notorious reputation for poor service and I’ve had several frustrating experiences with this medical group. What should I believe?
Answers (1)
8/1/2025, 11:50:42 PM
OpenHealth AI
Understanding your concerns regarding the Zio monitor and the possibility of Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome (POTS) is important, especially given your symptoms of dizziness, exhaustion, and near-fainting spells. Let's break this down.
Key Points:
- A Zio monitor primarily tracks heart rhythm and may not provide sufficient information to rule out POTS.
- Your symptoms, such as dizziness when standing and fatigue, align with POTS, but additional tests may be necessary for a definitive diagnosis.
- Consider seeking further evaluation either through a different healthcare provider or through specialized testing.
Explanation:
The Zio monitor is designed to detect arrhythmias and assess heart function, but it does not directly test for POTS. POTS is primarily characterized by an abnormal increase in heart rate upon standing and is typically assessed through tilt table tests or active stand tests. Your symptoms, especially given the dizziness and near-fainting episodes when transitioning to an upright position, should be taken seriously, especially since they have a familial link.
It’s understandable to feel frustrated with the current healthcare system, especially if previous experiences have been negative. Given that your cardiologist has indicated that POTS is ruled out based on the Zio monitor, but you still experience concerning symptoms, it's important to advocate for your health.
Next Steps:
-
Symptom Diary: Start keeping track of your symptoms, noting when they occur, their duration, and any possible triggers. This information will be useful for any future medical consultations.
-
Seek a Second Opinion: If you're unsure or uncomfortable with your current cardiologist's conclusions, consider seeking a second opinion from another cardiologist or a specialist in autonomic disorders. Look for one with experience in POTS.
-
Request Comprehensive Testing: If you do see another healthcare provider, discuss your symptoms in detail and ask about the possibility of a tilt table test or active stand tests to assess for POTS more conclusively.
-
Hydration and Support: In the meantime, remain hydrated, as dehydration can exacerbate POTS symptoms. Some patients find increased salt intake helpful, but always check with a healthcare provider before making dietary adjustments.
-
Lifestyle Adjustments: Consider gradual changes in your activity levels, and if you feel faint, don’t rush when moving from a seated or lying position to standing.
-
Join Support Groups: Connecting with others who have similar symptoms can provide emotional support and practical advice. Look for groups focused on POTS or autonomic dysfunction.
Remember, you deserve to have your symptoms taken seriously, and persistence in seeking answers is key. Let me know if you need further clarification on any specific points!
Related Questions
Can Eating More Fiber Alleviate Menstrual Cycle-Related Constipation?
Every month, during the week and a half leading up to my menstrual period, I experience constipation. I'm curious if boosting my fiber consumption might ease this issue. I already ensure that I drink plenty of water throughout the day. I am a woman in my mid-20s.
Seeking Relief from Mild Fecal Impaction: Should I Go to the ER?
At 20 years old, I find myself dealing with a frustrating issue: fecal impaction. It's not something I've faced before, or at least I can’t recall, but I’ve had chronic stomach difficulties throughout my childhood, including constipation from ages four to twelve. Recently, I've been experiencing more digestive challenges after a few years of feeling normal. Currently, I’m under the care of a gastroenterologist, and we’re working on diagnosing the underlying problems. For about five days now, I haven't been able to relieve myself. While I’ve had considerable gas, that’s been the only symptom. Today has been particularly difficult; I’ve spent the last 11 hours in the bathroom grappling with severe discomfort and impaction. Each attempt to relieve the situation is excruciating, to the point where my body is resisting the effort—it’s so painful that I find myself in tears. I imagine this is what birth must feel like. I suspect this intense fear and pain are remnants of my past struggles, as for many years I’ve feared using the bathroom due to the agony it causes. Despite trying various remedies like Miralax mixed with coffee, a bullet suppository, and even a manual approach with gloves, nothing is yielding results. I’m genuinely tempted to head to the emergency room and ask them to put me under so they can help me without the pain. My mother suggests they would likely opt for a liquid suppository treatment like they did during my childhood, which was quite traumatic. I’m torn—it feels like the ER might be my last resort, but I'm concerned they won’t take me seriously since my situation doesn’t seem dire. How foolish would it be to bring up wanting sedation? I desperately want to avoid this pain; it’s becoming increasingly difficult, and I’m fighting back tears from the frustration. Can they truly provide sedation for this type of issue even when it isn’t severe? I worry that my parents might react negatively to my quest for relief and think I’m being dramatic. I’m utterly drained and don’t know where to turn. When there’s no painful push against my body, I can’t even sense the severity of the issue, yet, I am experiencing leakage, leaving me unsure. Would it be unreasonable to pose this question to the doctors in the ER? I apologize if this message is jumbled; I’m also dealing with a migraine, making it hard to focus. For context, my daily medications include phentermine, iron supplements, and vitamin D. I stand at 5’4” and currently weigh 204 pounds as part of my ongoing weight loss journey.
Eight Years of Persistent ‘Hunger’—Is It a Functional Gut Disorder?
Greetings everyone, I’m a 28-year-old woman standing at 5 feet 4 inches, and for nearly eight years, I have struggled with a constant, hollow sensation in my upper abdomen that resembles hunger. Here are some key points about my experience: - This sensation arises between meals or soon after I have eaten. - It gets momentarily better after eating but eventually returns. - Though it feels like hunger, I know it's not genuine hunger. - Mornings are especially tough as the sensation intensifies. I maintain a regular meal schedule and consume enough calories without any restrictions. Currently, I find it difficult to trust my hunger cues, so I'm tracking my calorie intake. I do not take any medications and have previously used proton pump inhibitors without any noticeable improvement. Additionally, I neither smoke nor consume alcohol. Visits to my general practitioner have yielded no definitive diagnosis, with much of the feedback being centered on dietary adjustments. I am currently facing a waiting period of approximately eight months for a gastroscopy. Strangely, I also notice that I feel particularly weak during my workouts, despite my calorie intake being sufficient. Has anyone else faced a similar long-term issue? Did you find it to be functional dyspepsia, gastritis, visceral hypersensitivity, or something entirely different? Were you able to obtain assistance through a gastroenterologist, a dietitian, or therapy? Thanks for your insights!
Understanding My Lack of Appetite
I’m a 14-year-old girl about to turn 15, standing at 155 cm (5' 1'') and weighing around 53-54 kg. My exact weight remains unclear since I am battling anorexia and have been advised against using the scale. I am currently on a regimen of antidepressants (150mg of semonic daily) and antipsychotics (15mg of olanzapine). Along with my eating disorder, I've struggled with self-harm and have been diagnosed with a conduct disorder (though I'm unsure if that is the correct term in English as I'm receiving treatment in Spain). In September, coinciding with the start of the school year, I experienced a relapse regarding my eating disorder. This phase lasted a few weeks until I transitioned to homeschooling. Initially, recovery felt manageable; I experienced satiety quickly, and I was relieved to allow myself to eat once more. However, I’ve noticed a significant decrease in my appetite. I rarely feel hungry, and even when I do, it doesn't seem to bother me. I’ve lost the desire for typical meals, though I still find myself yearning for snacks, particularly sweets or salty options, which are much more appealing and easier to consume. Foods like rice are particularly challenging; I have to push myself to continue eating them because they don't excite me at all. I’m uncertain if this change is due to some underlying issue or merely stress, although I don't currently feel stressed. Perhaps my lack of physical activity contributes to my diminished appetite, as I haven't been particularly active and might not need as much food as others. It’s also worth noting that I haven’t grown taller for about a year or two, remaining at 5' 1''. This situation wouldn’t be as concerning if I weren’t dealing with anorexia, allowing me to simply eat less. Yet, given my background, I require supervision at mealtimes, which complicates my relationship with food. Whenever I lack the desire to eat, those around me jump to the conclusion that I am relapsing, which I am not. I enjoy food tremendously, especially sweets, and I snack throughout the day. It’s just the full meals that elude my cravings completely.
Rapid Heart Rate During Illness
A 27-year-old male, standing at 6 feet 3 inches tall and weighing 275 pounds, presents as non-smoking with a medical regimen including buspirone, sertraline, and Nexium. He does not consume alcohol or use illicit drugs. His medical background highlights anxiety and a previously noted Wolff-Parkinson-White (WPW) pattern observed on an ECG in 2023, without any prior ablation or recorded arrhythmias. On February 5th, I visited the emergency room after experiencing a sudden and alarming increase in my resting heart rate to approximately 130 beats per minute while at home. This spike was particularly distressing given my history of chronic anxiety. Reflecting on the earlier part of the day, I recall experiencing mild body aches, a cough, and a sensation akin to a low-grade fever, which now appear to have been early signs indicating I was becoming ill. Once at the emergency room, the medical team administered 10 mg of propranolol, resulting in a gradual decrease in my heart rate from 130 to the mid to upper 90s over a span of about one hour and 45 minutes. The ECG revealed only sinus tachycardia, and notably, the doctor informed me that the WPW pattern from 2023 was no longer evident. All laboratory tests returned normal results with standard electrolyte levels, kidney function (eGFR at 108), and a complete blood count showing only a typical stress response characterized by elevated neutrophils and reduced lymphocytes, alongside normal urine tests. There were no indications of dehydration, infection, thyroid irregularities, or arrhythmia. After returning home, it became clear that I was battling a viral infection. I experienced chills, extensive body aches, and fever peaking at 101.8°F, as well as a cough with medium brown mucus (not excessively dark or bright red). I have not experienced shortness of breath or wheezing at rest. Notably, my heart rate has paralleled my fever. When my fever ranges between 101°F and 102°F, my resting heart rate typically aligns between 105 and 125 beats per minute. Conversely, as my fever declines into the 99°F range, my heart rate drops to the 80s and 90s. Under normal circumstances, my resting heart rate hovers around 60 beats per minute. Currently, I am measuring a temperature of approximately 100.6°F to 100.8°F, with a heart rate around 110 to 115 beats per minute. About an hour ago, I took Tylenol, and am staying hydrated and resting. The only discomfort I feel is due to persistent coughing. I have a few inquiries: - Is this heart rate fluctuation typical during a viral infection accompanied by fever? - Should I expect to see an elevated heart rate persist even during sleep when my fever is elevated? - Is there any cause for concern regarding my previous WPW even though the recent ECG indicates that pattern is no longer present? Thank you for your assistance.