Concern Over Prescribed Supplements Without Testing
At 24 years old and weighing 56 kg, I visited the doctor due to issues like back discomfort and a clicking sound from my shoulder. To my surprise, the physician recommended vitamin D and calcium supplements without conducting any diagnostic tests. This concerns me, particularly the possibility of overdosing on these nutrients. Should I consider having tests performed independently before I start these supplements? The doctor’s examination was rather brief; he only bent my wrist to determine the necessity of the vitamins.
Answers (1)
7/31/2025, 3:31:08 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to be concerned about starting supplements without thorough testing, especially regarding potential overdoses. Here's a breakdown of your situation and what you can do next.
Main Points:
- Concerns about Supplement Safety: It's valid to worry about taking vitamin D and calcium without prior tests, as both can be harmful in excess.
- Importance of Testing: Assessing your current levels through tests can help determine if you truly need these supplements.
Explanation:
Your doctor recommended vitamin D and calcium supplements likely due to a perceived deficiency or risk based on your symptoms, like back discomfort. Both nutrients are essential for bone health; however, taking them unnecessarily, especially in high doses, can lead to side effects. For example, too much vitamin D can lead to hypercalcemia (excess calcium in the blood), causing symptoms like nausea and kidney issues.
Next Steps:
- Consider Testing: Before starting supplements, it would be wise to request tests for vitamin D and calcium levels. This will help ensure you're not taking unnecessary supplements.
- Monitor Symptoms: Keep a record of your back discomfort and shoulder clicking—note any changes in intensity or frequency. This will help you understand if these are related to nutrient deficiencies or other factors.
- Research Supplement Dosages: Familiarize yourself with the recommended daily allowances for both vitamin D and calcium. This will help you gauge what might be appropriate if supplements are deemed necessary.
- Communicate with Your Doctor: Discuss your concerns with your healthcare provider. Express your desire for testing before initiating any supplementation regimen so that you can make an informed decision.
This approach allows you to feel confident and safe in your health decisions. If you need further assistance or details about testing options, feel free to ask!
Related Questions
Nail Trouble: Splitting and Chipping
A 67-year-old woman shares her concern about her nails. She leads a healthy lifestyle, refraining from smoking, alcohol, or coffee consumption, and only takes supplements including calcium, vitamin D, and a multivitamin on occasion. Recently, she has noticed that her fingernails are not only splitting but also breaking frequently. Given that she has avoided manicures due to nail buffing, which further weakens her thin nails, she has taken to researching potential dietary deficiencies but found none. Another thought that comes to mind is her extensive gardening in a warm climate, which may be affecting her nails due to excess moisture. She wonders if there are other contributors to this issue, especially living in a hot and humid region of Florida.
Concerns About Possible Cancer?
Hello, I'm an 18-year-old male from India. Recently, I've been aware of a small, movable lump in the lower left section of my neck, which I suspect might be a lymph node. This lump is not painful and isn't noticeable on the outside. Along with that, I've experienced occasional discomfort in my lower neck, just above the shoulder blades, as well as sporadic pain near my sternum and sometimes in my arm. Given this situation, do you think I should seek medical advice? I do not smoke, vape, consume alcohol, or use any recreational substances.
Seeking Guidance on Recent Health Concerns
Greetings, Reddit medical community. I find myself in need of some guidance regarding a recent health issue that has arisen. This past Tuesday, while working at my computer, I experienced a peculiar sensation in my right eye. For a brief period, whenever I typed, the last character would take a couple of seconds to come into focus, appearing slightly blurred before becoming clear again. Fortunately, this odd phenomenon subsided after some time. Feeling concerned, I visited a clinic during my lunch break. The doctor conducted a quick vision test and reported no immediate issues. She speculated that it might be a transient ischemic attack (TIA), often referred to as a mini-stroke, but didn’t provide further insight. To be safe, she gave me a referral for a comprehensive eye examination. Naturally, I was quite anxious, and later that day, I developed a mild headache. My sleep that night was restless, and upon waking, I felt lightheaded but lacked any other symptoms. Thankfully, my vision returned to normal. Believing an early night would benefit me, I managed to get around nine hours of sleep on Wednesday. Yet, I still woke up on Thursday feeling similarly lightheaded. While I wouldn't describe it as dizziness or weakness, something seemed off; it felt like a strange combination of sensations. My head and legs felt unusually light, yet I could adequately concentrate on my tasks and even engage in some running. I went to the gym later that day and was able to complete a weight training session without issue, but when not focusing, my sensations seemed rather disconcerting. Today is Friday, and the symptoms persist as they were yesterday. I can't help but wonder if my anxiety is contributing to how I'm feeling, potentially causing me to overthink things. A bit about my background: I am a 29-year-old male who has undergone a significant lifestyle change over the past six weeks, involving near-daily workouts, hitting 10,000-15,000 steps a day, and strength training five times a week. Previously, I weighed 180 lbs and was less active, but I've dropped to 163 lbs through a strict caloric deficit, which often exceeds 1,000 calories daily. My diet predominantly consists of proteins and vegetables, with limited seasoning, having entirely eliminated sugars and carbs. My sleep averages around six to seven hours each night. Prior to this six-week period, I rarely exercised and had a less healthy diet, which makes this shift feel quite dramatic. I’m not certain if this intense lifestyle change is negatively affecting me, even if it is generally positive. I have tried to eat more in the past two days and reduced physical exertion, but I am unsure if it is making any difference. I also began taking omega-3 fish oil, multivitamins, vitamin B complex, and L-arginine two weeks ago, following the prescribed dosage. My daily intake includes three to four protein scoops to increase my protein consumption. I stay well-hydrated, drinking more than two liters of water each day, and I take five grams of creatine before workouts, though I don't use it otherwise. I'm unsure if these supplements might be influencing my current sensations, hence I mention it. During my clinic visit, my blood pressure was measured at 120/70, and my heart rate was around 57 bpm. At this moment, I'm feeling somewhat adrift and anxious. Although I tend to worry excessively, I’d like to understand what could be transpiring with my health, aside from the severe concerns suggested by Google, like strokes or cardiovascular issues. I am scheduled for blood tests soon, but I welcome any preliminary insights or thoughts from the community. I have been focusing on improving my health for the last month and a half, and I trust my bloodwork will reflect positive results. Thank you for your attention and assistance. Please don’t hesitate to ask for any additional information you might need. I apologize for any formatting or language issues, as I rarely post and English is not my first language.
Should I Continue My Skincare Regimen Prior to a Gastroscopy?
I hope this question isn't too silly! I'm scheduled for a gastroscopy on August 4th and while I completely understand that makeup, body lotion, perfume, and nail polish are off-limits, I'm curious about skincare products like toner, serum, moisturizer, and sunscreen. I’ve been diligent with my skincare routine, and it’s essential for maintaining my complexion, but I definitely don’t want to interfere with the procedure in any way. The nurse who went over the pre-procedure instructions didn’t clarify this point, so I'm feeling a bit uncertain. (For clarity: I’m a 24-year-old female, approximately 170 cm tall, and weighing 114 kg.)
Concerns Over Health Symptoms While on HRT
Greetings, I'm a 26-year-old trans woman (transitioning from male to female), standing at 173 cm tall and weighing 76 kg, residing in Queensland, Australia. Recently, I've been experiencing intense chest discomfort that has persisted for over a week, accompanied by a petechial rash, occasional blurred vision, and feelings of nausea. In addition, I've noticed an increased tendency to bruise easily on my hands and fingers, coupled with sensations of pins and needles. My symptoms seem to escalate in the evening, particularly a few hours following the application of my Estradiol gel. I also have a history of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). In the past weeks, during visits to the emergency department, my white blood cell count fluctuated, being elevated one week and normal the following. My D-Dimer and platelet levels remained consistent and within normal range. As for my medications, I take Esomeprazole at 40 mg daily, Paroxetine at 30 mg daily, and I use Sandrena Gel (Estradiol) at a dosage of 3 mg per day, along with cyproterone acetate at 12.5 mg weekly. Prior to this recent week, I was receiving Estradiol valerate injections, set at 5 mg weekly instead of using the gel. I've also undergone an echocardiogram recently, which showed no structural issues with my heart that could explain my chest pain. I am seeking help because I am genuinely frightened by these symptoms.