Inquiry About Medical History: ITP vs. ALPS
I am simply seeking some clarity regarding my late fiancé's health issues. Tragically, she passed away at 38 due to an aggressive form of B-Cell lymphoma that had gone unnoticed. I’m now left wondering if her condition might have actually been ALPS rather than ITP. Twelve years prior, she began experiencing unexplained and severe bruising, which was attributed to ITP. Doctors noted her swollen lymph nodes and conducted tests for lymphoma; however, the results were negative. Subsequently, she underwent a splenectomy due to the significant enlargement of her spleen, and her ITP subsequently went into remission. Throughout the ensuing years and multiple medical consultations, she consistently had swollen lymph nodes and elevated white blood cell counts. Each time we met a new physician, she was tested for lymphoma out of caution, yet every result came back negative. Physicians reassured us that the elevated white blood cells were typical for someone with a history of ITP post-splenectomy, leaving us without explanations for the persistent lymph node enlargement. Around six to eight months before her passing, she began to bruise again—initially, it was mild, leading us to question whether ITP had returned. Having navigated ITP previously, we were not overly alarmed but scheduled checkups three months ahead of her passing. However, the healthcare system's pace is often slow, and we were not pressing for urgent care as she hadn’t shown alarming symptoms. Unfortunately, she ended up hospitalized just a week before her death, suffering from shortness of breath and muscle weakness. It turned out to be an undiagnosed, highly aggressive B-Cell lymphoma that drastically affected her blood chemistry, overwhelming the capability of dialysis and bicarbonate treatments. Now I’m left pondering: given her history of ITP, spleen enlargement, and continually swollen lymph nodes leading to a diagnosis of B-Cell lymphoma, could it be that she had ALPS instead of ITP? I ask this simply for my own peace of mind. I do not wish to assign blame; I recognize everyone involved was doing their best, and I understand that rare genetic conditions can easily be overlooked. Navigating this loss has been incredibly difficult, and I am just trying to make sense of it all. Thank you for considering my inquiry.
Answers (1)
7/31/2025, 3:50:56 AM
OpenHealth AI
I'm truly sorry for your loss, and I can only imagine how difficult this situation is for you. It’s understandable to seek clarity regarding your late fiancé's health issues, especially with the complexities you’ve described. I’ll do my best to help address your concerns regarding Immune Thrombocytopenic Purpura (ITP) and Autoimmune Lymphoproliferative Syndrome (ALPS).
Main Points:
- Underlying Conditions: Both ITP and ALPS can present with symptoms like bruising and swollen lymph nodes, but they stem from different underlying mechanisms.
- Differentiation: ALPS is a genetic disorder leading to excessive lymphocyte proliferation and can mimic some of the symptoms you observed in ITP.
- Understanding the Symptoms: It’s possible that symptoms observed could have overlapped between the two conditions, complicating the diagnosis.
Explanation:
-
Immune Thrombocytopenic Purpura (ITP): This condition is characterized by a low platelet count, leading to easy bruising and bleeding. It can be primary (with no identifiable cause) or secondary (due to other health issues). In some cases, as you mentioned, splenectomy (removal of the spleen) can help manage symptoms and lead to remission.
-
Autoimmune Lymphoproliferative Syndrome (ALPS): This is a rare genetic disorder that causes an abnormal increase in lymphocytes, often leading to lymphadenopathy (swollen lymph nodes), splenomegaly (enlarged spleen), and autoimmune symptoms. The symptoms you noted, including persistent swollen lymph nodes and elevated white blood cell counts, could suggest ALPS.
-
Diagnosis Challenges: Since both conditions can exhibit overlaps in symptoms, diagnosing one over the other can be challenging, especially if certain tests, like for lymphoma, returned negative.
Next Steps:
-
Consider Genetic Testing: If there’s interest in understanding her condition further, genetic counseling or testing for ALPS could provide insight, not only for your peace of mind but potentially for family planning and awareness for relatives.
-
Review Medical Records: If you have access, reviewing her past medical records with a healthcare provider may shed light on the tests conducted and why ALPS might not have been initially considered.
-
Engage with Support Groups: Connecting with others who have faced similar experiences can help you process your feelings. Support groups for bereavement or for those affected by rare diseases could be beneficial.
-
Seek Emotional Support: It’s vital to take care of your emotional well-being. Consider talking to a counselor or therapist experienced in grief to help navigate through this difficult time.
Please take this information as a means to find peace regarding your fiancé's medical journey, and remember that it’s okay to seek out the answers that will help you heal. If you have any more questions or need further clarification, feel free to ask.
Related Questions
Persistent Neck Swelling and Unresolved Symptoms
I am a 29-year-old woman who smokes, and I have been enduring a variety of troubling symptoms for the last six months. During this period, I’ve frequently visited doctors and undergone numerous blood tests, including TSH (due to my mother's history of hyperthyroidism), ANA, EBV, HIV, Hepatitis A, B, and C, cholesterol, serum folate, ferritin, magnesium, calcium, and B12, among others. My general practitioner informed me that there are no further tests available to me. Apart from a positive result for EBV, indicating a past infection, all other tests returned normal results. Initially, doctors diagnosed me with glandular fever, but that was half a year ago and my condition has only deteriorated since then. In an effort to advocate for myself, I reached out to my doctor’s office, requesting more thorough investigations. They responded by scheduling me a lengthy appointment; however, the physician I met with dismissed my concerns, noting "no neck nods" in my file, implying I was exaggerating my issues. He recommended that I discontinue my mini contraceptive pill, ADHD medication, engage in daily neck exercises, and take walks. His condescending attitude left me feeling overlooked and frustrated. Fortunately, I later consulted a nurse practitioner who agreed to refer me to a Chronic Fatigue Syndrome clinic, asserting that they had exhausted their options. To date, I have not undergone any ultrasounds or imaging tests. I have a telemedicine appointment scheduled for tomorrow, but I plan to insist on an in-person visit since a phone consultation cannot reveal the visible problems with my swollen and tight neck. Each visit seems to turn into a battle to be acknowledged and taken seriously. The ongoing dismissal from medical professionals and the lack of understanding from my family has become mentally exhausting. There have been moments when I contemplated giving up, feeling as though I’m being relentlessly worn down while already grappling with significant physical discomfort. Consequently, my mental health has noticeably deteriorated. The pushback from medical personnel has led me to doubt my own reality, even questioning if I am spiraling into a sort of health-induced delusion. I miss the joyful and vivacious person I used to be. Why would anyone choose to endure frequent doctor visits or live with debilitating limitations? I've continually faced accusations of possessing health anxiety, despite not having any imaging results to dismiss my symptoms. I desperately yearn to reclaim my former life. My condition reached a point where I had to resign from my job, as I could no longer manage the physical demands. Daily, I feel unwell, where even basic chores can leave me bedridden for days as I recover. I’ve grown weary of this endless cycle, depleted by the experience of being told I’m fine, even though I am the one living this reality. The flood of emotions and frustration is overwhelming. My ongoing symptoms include muscle and joint pain that worsens with activity, persistent daily headaches, severe fatigue, neck pain, mild fever, skin rashes, recurring infections, swollen lymph nodes, and pain in the right groin lymph node. Recently, I’ve noticed additional troubling symptoms like intermittent chest burning, increased neck swelling and tightness, a pulling sensation beneath the skin, and difficulty breathing with minimal exertion. These issues seem to flare up particularly at night. I suspect I might have developed a small bump on my collarbone, but I’m unsure. I would greatly appreciate any suggestions or insights on this matter; all are welcome as I seek answers and relief.
Understanding My MRI Results in Simple Terms
Could someone help clarify my MRI findings in a way that's easy to understand? I've been experiencing pain along with a small, pea-sized bump on my kneecap for the past three months. **Menisci:** There are irregular myxoid changes seen in both the medial and lateral menisci, and there's a possibility of fraying at the inner edge of the medial meniscus. However, there's no indication of a fluid-filled tear. **Articular Cartilage:** The cartilage in my patella shows mild irregularities, but there’s no significant loss of thickness. Both the medial and lateral compartments of the knee do not present any severe cartilage defects. **Patellofemoral Region:** The patellofemoral extensor mechanism appears intact, with only a slight lateral subluxation of the patella noted. The TT-TG distance is recorded at 13 mm. **Bone Structure:** There is slight edema in the bone below the patella, which may be due to contusion, degeneration, or could be a result of impingement. No fractures were found in this area. **Fluid Accumulation:** A small amount of fluid is present in the knee joint. **Additional Notes:** No other findings were reported. **Summary:** 1. Irregular myxoid changes in both medial and lateral menisci, with possible fraying at the medial meniscus and no fluid-filled tear present. 2. Slight lateral subluxation of the patella with a TT-TG distance of 13 mm. 3. Mild cartilage irregularities in the patella, but thickness is preserved. 4. Mild bone edema at the bottom of the patella, possibly due to contusion or degeneration, but no fractures found. 5. Presence of a small knee effusion. 6. No serious cartilage defects observed in the knee compartments.
Experiencing Blood During Wiping and Intense Cramping: Seeking Insights
I am a 22-year-old male, measuring 6 feet 1 inch tall and weighing 132 pounds. My medical history includes arrhythmia, which contributes to a range of perplexing symptoms. These symptoms include premature ventricular contractions (PVCs), episodes of dizziness, occasional shortness of breath, feelings of near-fainting, persistent fatigue, swollen lymph nodes, and discomfort in the jaw. Currently, I am prescribed acebutolol, taking a dose of 200mg once daily. I have recently arranged for a medical consultation in order to obtain a referral, but the waiting period in my city can stretch for several months. My primary concern is the intermittent bleeding that I experience, which occurs particularly after bowel movements. This bleeding can persist for several days, vanish for a couple of days, and then return. Sometimes, the blood is significant enough to soak the toilet paper, while other times, it only appears in minor amounts. The blood is bright red and is not mixed in with the stool; I have also noticed it present in the water of the toilet bowl. This troubling situation has been ongoing for about a year. The experience of passing a bowel movement can bring about sharp pain, and I often suffer from cramping that may manifest either before or after the event. This discomfort can radiate from the anal region throughout the abdomen and even into my testicles, creating a debilitating situation. I am eager to gather opinions or insights on what might be causing these symptoms.
Clarification Requested on MRI Findings Regarding Brain and Cervical Spine
Age: 34 Gender: Female For the past couple of months, I have been facing symptoms that resemble those of multiple sclerosis. My medical history includes a diagnosis of Sjögren's syndrome, osteoporosis, and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. I recently underwent MRIs of my brain and cervical spine, but my neurologist is not available to discuss the results until September 10. I would greatly appreciate any insights into my findings, particularly regarding possible Chiari malformation and the presence of unusual white matter regions. **MRI of the Brain with Contrast** **History:** Weakness and tingling sensations. **Comparative studies:** None available. **Technique:** A comprehensive MRI was conducted in multiple planes and sequences, both before and after the administration of 10 cc of MultiHance contrast via IV. **Results:** - A notable posterior angulation of the odontoid bone with an associated angulation at the cervicomedullary junction. - The paranasal sinuses and mastoid air cells appear clear. - The orbits show no abnormal findings. - Key intracranial arterial flow voids remain intact. - No signs of diffusion limitation, bleeding within the brain tissue, or extra-axial accumulation were observed. - The cerebellar tonsils are located ectopically and extend up to 6 mm. - No T2 hyperintense lesions in the white matter are detected. - The ventricles are adequately decompressed. **Conclusions:** 1. The presence of cerebellar tonsillar ectopia of 6 mm raises concerns for a potential Chiari I malformation. There is significant posterior angulation of the odontoid and anterior angulation at the cervicomedullary junction. 2. No T2 hyperintense white matter lesions or signs indicative of recent ischemia were found. **MRI of the Cervical Spine with Contrast** **History:** Symptoms include weakness and numbness in the upper limbs. **Comparative analyses:** None available. **Technique:** A cervical spine MRI in multiple planes and sequences was conducted before and after administering 10 cc of MultiHance contrast intravenously. **Findings:** - There is evidence of degenerative changes in the bone marrow at various levels. - Chronic posterior angulation of the odontoid is noted again, alongside the cerebellar tonsillar ectopia. - The assessment of the spinal cord signal is impacted by imaging artifacts. A localized area of T2 hyperintensity measuring 5 x 4 mm appears in the anteromedial section of the cervical cord between C4 and C5. - At C2-C3, there are no significant degenerative alterations. The spinal canal remains unremarkable, and there is no significant foraminal narrowing at this level. - C3-C4 shows no notable degenerative changes. The spinal canal and foramina are clear of significant narrowing. - At C4-C5, there are also no significant degenerative changes present. The spinal canal remains unremarkable with no significant narrowing of the foramina. - At C5-C6, there is a posterior disc osteophyte complex and mild bilateral uncovertebral joint enlargement, leading to mild right foraminal narrowing and some flattening of the ventral cord, indicating mild to moderate stenosis. - At C6-C7, similar degenerative findings include a posterior disc osteophyte complex and bilateral uncovertebral joint hypertrophy, along with moderate stenosis in the spinal canal and mild bilateral foraminal narrowing. - C7-T1 shows posterior disc osteophyte formation and bilateral uncovertebral joint changes, resulting in mild to moderate stenosis in the spinal canal, with no significant narrowing of the foramina. **Conclusions:** 1. The evaluation of cord signal is limited by artifacts. The localized area of T2 hyperintensity in the right anteromedial cervical cord measures 5 x 4 mm as seen on image 15, spanning from C4 to C5, though no associated enhancement is noted. 2. There are findings of ectopia of the cerebellar tonsils and posterior angulation of the odontoid as identified on the brain MRI. 3. Mild degenerative changes are observed at multiple levels, as described above.
Concerns Regarding Military Enlistment Records
I am a 19-year-old male with no medications and a current diagnosis of a depressive mood disorder. I am feeling overwhelmed and uncertain about how to navigate a challenging situation I find myself in. Regrettably, I must admit that I unintentionally provided incorrect information on my enlistment application. I didn’t anticipate facing any complications with my military enlistment, but the health screening process uncovered details that I was previously unaware of. Upon discovering this information, I was extremely distressed, as I had no knowledge of these issues until now. My concerns include a: - Mood Dysregulation Disorder - Unspecified Bipolar Disorder These conditions are serious disqualifications for military service. Despite undergoing two psychological evaluations, which resulted in a determination of mental stability for service, my attempts to enlist in branches such as the Marine Corps, Army, Army National Guard, and Navy have all been unsuccessful. Is there a possibility to correct or even access these records? Unfortunately, I lack the information needed to make amendments, and they appear on my medical chart, complicating my situation further.