Understanding My Birth Experience: Addressing C-Section Concerns
As a 30-year-old woman, I gave birth to my son only a few months back and faced an incident called shoulder dystocia during labor. My baby became lodged for a duration of three minutes, and after a series of maneuvers, he was finally delivered, although he required a stay in the NICU for a couple of weeks due to suspected hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) and seizures. When sharing my experience of childbirth, many people express sympathy and suggest that due to my small stature—I stand at 5'3”—and the baby’s weight of 8 pounds 6 ounces, I should have had a cesarean section. Up until the point of shoulder dystocia, my pregnancy and labor progressed typically. I was induced at 41 weeks; my water had already broken prior to the induction, but I hadn’t entered active labor yet. After being on Pitocin for around 14 hours, I began pushing—this followed a considerable amount of repositioning to help the baby find the best position for delivery. My dilation was slower than expected, but I did show progress with the medication. My midwife praised my efforts, noting that I only experienced a minor perineal tear and spent two hours in the pushing phase. She indicated that I have a smaller pelvis and strongly advised a cesarean for any future pregnancies, which I fully accept. Throughout this experience, I felt well-cared-for by my medical team and do not think they should have acted differently. From what I understand, the likelihood of shoulder dystocia occurring was relatively low given my baby's birth weight, and it seems unpredictable. I've heard some claims that it's possible to foresee this condition or to measure one’s pelvis to predict outcomes, but I’m left uncertain about the validity of those statements. With that in mind, I have some lingering questions: Is it possible to predict or prevent shoulder dystocia? Would a c-section have been the preferred course of action in my case, or would any other interventions have been more appropriate? When considering future pregnancies, is vaginal delivery still a feasible option for me? Additionally, how can I respond to those who question the quality of care I received?
Answers (1)
7/30/2025, 9:20:42 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to have lingering questions after a challenging birth experience, especially involving shoulder dystocia. Here, I'll address your concerns, providing clarity around the condition, your care, and future pregnancies.
Main Points:
- Predicting or preventing shoulder dystocia is complex and not always possible.
- Your care during labor was appropriate based on the circumstances.
- Future pregnancies can still include vaginal delivery, but with careful monitoring.
Explanation: Shoulder dystocia occurs when the baby's shoulder gets stuck behind the mother’s pelvic bone during delivery. It is difficult to predict, and while certain factors like a larger baby and maternal size may contribute, many cases arise unpredictably—even without obvious risk factors.
Regarding cesarean sections (C-sections), they are often considered if a baby is anticipated to be large or there are other complications, but in your case, labor was progressing. Your care team followed appropriate protocols, considering your situation and opting for a vaginal birth. Shoulder dystocia often cannot be predicted before labor begins, as no standardized measurements of pelvic dimensions can guarantee successful vaginal delivery outcomes.
Next Steps:
-
Plan for Future Pregnancies: Discuss your birth experience and concerns with your healthcare provider when planning future pregnancies. They will likely recommend scheduling a C-section based on your history, but ensure you understand all options and potential risks.
-
Education and Support: Consider joining support groups or forums for new parents who have experienced similar situations. Sharing your story and hearing others can provide invaluable comfort and guidance.
-
How to Respond to Others: When discussing your birth, assure those who question your care that shoulder dystocia is unpredictable and can happen to anyone. Emphasize the positive aspects of your care and your health, expressing confidence in the decisions made by your healthcare team.
It’s important to trust your experience and the care you received. Remember, every birth is unique, and what works for one person may not be the best for another. If you ever need more information or support, please feel free to reach out.
Related Questions
Shoulder Concerns After an Old Injury
I’m a 19-year-old male who experienced an unknown injury to my right shoulder around four years ago. Currently, I have a complete range of motion and do not face any issues with mobility. However, my shoulder has a tendency to dislocate during activities like throwing or lifting, and I also feel discomfort when I stretch it in particular ways. Additionally, it frequently pops and clicks. Lying on that shoulder for extended periods leads to pain, and occasionally, it feels as if it’s grinding against other bones. I consulted a physical therapist who suggested that I might have a labral tear, but unfortunately, I left the appointment without clear guidance on how to treat or recover from it. I would like to know if this indeed sounds like a torn labrum or if there might be another issue at play, and most importantly, what steps I can take to address it.
Seeking Expertise: An Insight Into My Ongoing Health Struggles
Hello everyone, I am a 21-year-old woman and for the past three years, I've endured persistent abdominal pain. Numerous tests have been conducted across various medical specializations, revealing that my condition has led to significant deficiencies in copper, vitamin B6, vitamin D, and magnesium. As a result, I now face several complications affecting my nerves, heart, and digestive system. A few months ago, I underwent a pelvic MRI due to my nerve-related issues. The report primarily pointed out inflammation in the nerves of both legs. However, upon reviewing the images, I noticed several sections of my intestines that appeared unusually highlighted, catching my attention rather dramatically. I can't shake the feeling that the MRI might have missed critical information because the focus was predominantly on nerve conditions. Unfortunately, I lack the resources to seek a second opinion, but I do have all the imaging from that MRI on hand. I would greatly appreciate it if someone could lend their insight into these images. I will share the specific pictures I’m concerned about in the comments, and I am open to sending the complete report along with the images for anyone willing to help. Thank you so much for your time and assistance!
Experiencing Selenium Overconsumption
I was unaware that Brazil nuts contain elevated levels of selenium, leading me to consume an excessive amount. During my travels three weeks ago, I nearly finished a 200g bag within two days, and after returning home, I've consumed at least one more 200g bag, possibly even two. This intake was done in a short timeframe and without any breaks in between. A couple of days following these larger servings, I experienced stomach discomfort, which I initially attributed to a potential illness contracted while I was traveling. However, since that time, I have been dealing with fatigue, muscle weakness, joint discomfort, and general malaise. Today, I had my blood drawn for testing, but the results may not be ready until later next week. In the interim, I am seeking guidance on how to prevent any severe repercussions from this situation. Has anyone dealt with selenium toxicity and can share their insights? If my toxicity levels were significant, would I have already noticed severe symptoms? Furthermore, what signs should compel me to seek immediate medical attention? Even though I know I should simply wait for the test results, I find myself feeling anxious and would greatly appreciate any thoughtful advice to help me remain calm. Thank you for your time and support.
Could Rapid Healing Indicate an Underlying Issue?
It's commonly advised to inform your physician if your healing process seems slower than expected, as that may indicate a potential health concern. But is it possible to heal at an accelerated pace, and could this be a cause for alarm? To illustrate, about a month prior, I experienced a significant tumble down some stairs, resulting in a severe bruise on my leg. By that evening, the bruise had expanded to a size larger than my palm and had taken on a deep purple hue. The following morning, it appeared nearly black—definitely the most intense bruise I'd ever encountered. Yet, remarkably, just four days later, it had almost vanished entirely, leaving only a few yellow spots smaller than my fingernail. Although I’ve always been a relatively fast healer, I typically expect bruises to linger for a minimum of two weeks. I’ve been struggling with debilitating fatigue, frequent nausea, vomiting, night sweats, and hip discomfort for some time. Recently, my nausea has intensified to the point where I can barely manage to consume more than a couple of crackers, which has unfortunately led to some weight loss. After some investigation, including an MRI of my hip—which appeared normal—I was advised by an orthopedic specialist to pursue physical therapy since the hip pain, my first symptom, has persisted since January (and the MRI took place in April). I have a scheduled appointment with my general practitioner, and I am hopeful to receive clarity on my situation. When my partner made a light-hearted comment about my rapid bruise recovery as a good sign, suggesting it ruled out leukaemia, it sparked my curiosity about whether accelerated healing could be linked to any underlying health issues that might be contributing to my current ailments.
Experiencing Persistent Nerve Pain After ABG Procedure
Age: 22, Weight: 61 kg, Height: 165 cm Greetings, fellow Redditors, particularly those in the medical field. I'm feeling quite distressed as I struggle with an inability to fully extend my left arm due to ongoing nerve pain, which presents itself like an electric shock each time I try to move it. This issue arose after I was hospitalized for dehydration, during which a nurse inadvertently impacted a nerve while performing an arterial blood gas (ABG) test. The sensation was excruciating and left me quite shaken. I’m deeply concerned about the possibility of lasting damage, as it has significantly hindered my daily activities. Being a nurse myself, this raises worries about my ability to perform my job effectively. Is this experience common? How long is the recovery period? Am I at risk of never returning to normal function? Any guidance would be greatly appreciated. 🥺