Comparing Barrow's and Burow's Solution for Chronic Ear Issues
Age: 35, Gender: Female, Height: 5'3", Weight: 150 lbs, Ethnicity: Caucasian, Condition: chronic swimmer's ear, Duration: intermittent for over 10 years, Current medications: none except for hydrocortisone/acetic acid otic drops, Alcohol use: no, Smoking: no, Recreational drug use: no. For over a decade, I've been dealing with persistent itching in my ears. This discomfort is not continuous; it fluctuates over time. Last year, I consulted with an ear, nose, and throat specialist who prescribed fluocinonide oil drops, which provided significant relief. In fact, it was the most effective treatment I've tried, allowing me the longest respite from itching episodes. However, after switching to a new health insurance plan, I was unable to return to that original specialist and instead saw a different ENT. This new doctor informed me that Debrox, an earwax removal aid I had been using upon a previous recommendation, was harmful, and he advised me to discontinue its use. Furthermore, he dismissed the fluocinonide oil as lacking credible scientific support. He introduced me to a concoction called Barrow's Solution, which he prepared himself. Strangely, it came without any accompanying ingredient information. The doctor claimed that this solution had previously been available through a pharmacy but became too costly for patients—while it only costs about $6 to make, pharmacies charged over $100 per bottle. So, he chose to create it himself, offering it for free to his patients, asserting it contained components similar to the hydrocortisone/acetic acid drops prescribed by my primary care doctor. Upon researching, I stumbled upon Burow's Solution, which, although it sounds similar, is not available for purchase or through a prescription. This raises questions about the authenticity and safety of Barrow's Solution. Should I have confidence in this unverified clear solution I received, labeled as "Barrow's Solution"? Given that this supposedly contains ingredients akin to the hydrocortisone/acetic acid solution, I have opted to continue using my pharmacy-purchased drops, as I have a substantial supply left. While the hydrocortisone/acetic acid drops still provide some relief, they take longer to work and can be painful. The fluocinonide drops were far superior, offering quick relief, and it's frustrating that my new ENT questions their efficacy despite them being previously prescribed by another specialist.
Answers (1)
7/29/2025, 4:20:41 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel frustrated and uncertain when navigating the treatment options for chronic ear issues, especially after trying multiple solutions. Given your long history of swimmer's ear and your experience with the fluocinonide drops, it's important to focus on effective and safe treatments.
Main Points:
- Fluocinonide oil drops were previously effective for you.
- Barrow's Solution has unclear safety and ingredient information.
- Burow's Solution may offer similar benefits but is not widely available or verified.
Explanation:
Chronic swimmer’s ear (otitis externa) can be bothersome, and it sounds like you've already tried a couple of treatments that provided varying levels of relief. Fluocinonide, a strong topical steroid, is typically used for inflammatory conditions and sometimes suggested for severe itching and irritation in the ear canal. Your ENT’s concerns about its efficacy may stem from specific guidelines or personal experience, but your positive response to this treatment is significant.
Barrow's Solution, being homemade and lacking detailed ingredient disclosure, raises valid concerns about both safety and effectiveness. The fact that it's not a commercially recognized product makes it harder to trust without clear composition and verification. Burow's Solution, while often used for similar conditions, is indeed not available as a commercial product, which adds to the confusion surrounding these treatments.
Next Steps:
- Continue using your hydrocortisone/acetic acid drops until your symptoms are better managed. Document how often you experience relief and any reactions.
- Consider reaching out to a pharmacist or another ENT specialist for clarity on both Barrow's Solution and potential alternatives. Sharing your positive experience with fluocinonide might prompt discussions about effective treatments.
- Stay clear of Debrox, especially given your ENT's advice against it. Earwax removal can sometimes exacerbate irritation, especially if you're prone to swimmer's ear.
- Maintain a symptom diary noting when symptoms occur and whether any specific activities (like swimming) trigger flare-ups, as it may help your next healthcare consultation.
If you want to better understand the ingredients in Barrow's Solution and explore evidence-based alternatives, this can empower you in discussions with any future healthcare providers you consult. Remember that it’s essential to advocate for your health and seek a second opinion if your concerns and treatment needs aren't being adequately addressed.
Related Questions
Discomfort Three Months After Top Surgery
I am 25 years old, weigh 250 pounds, and identify as nonbinary. I occasionally use cannabis edibles and consume alcohol. My only medication is omeprazole, which I take as necessary; otherwise, I’m not on any other prescriptions. I have been diagnosed with POTS and PCOS. I underwent top surgery at the end of April, marking three months since the procedure. Lately, I have been experiencing intermittent sharp pains during my recovery process. However, today I awoke feeling discomfort predominantly on my left side. Despite trying to massage the area, it hasn’t provided relief, and there is no pain when I apply pressure anywhere specific. I do notice strain when I lift items or engage my left arm, and there's a dull ache felt in the middle of my left back, corresponding with the anterior pain. Occasionally, I also feel lightheaded, which I often experience when my sodium intake is low—and I admit I haven’t been mindful of my diet in that regard. Am I experiencing symptoms that could potentially relate to the surgery, or should I seek medical attention at the hospital?
Eye Discomfort from Catarrh
I am a 19-year-old female weighing 92 pounds. Over the past few days, I've been suffering from flu-like symptoms, although feels so severe that I suspect it might be COVID-19 instead. My nasal passages are completely congested, and despite taking medication to alleviate the symptoms, my condition hasn’t improved. In fact, the congestion has led to catarrh oozing from my right eye, which is quite distressing. Each morning, I find my eyelashes stuck together due to the discharge, and I can't seem to halt this issue. The catarrh has caused considerable swelling and reddening of my eye, both internally and on the surrounding skin. It appears as if I’ve sustained a blow to the face. At this point, the soreness is so intense that I struggle to move my eyeball without discomfort.
Experiencing Leg Sensitivity and Tension - Seeking Similar Stories
Hello everyone, I find myself in a troubling situation that’s leaving me feeling quite hopeless. Despite numerous visits to doctors, I still don’t have a diagnosis, yet I endure constant suffering. Has anyone else gone through anything like this? My troubles began roughly two and a half years ago, starting with a peculiar numbness in the last three toes of my right foot. Gradually, this sensation escalated, transforming into significant tightness throughout my entire lower leg. Initially, I likened it to the onset of cramping, although it never fully developed into one. This phase lasted about three weeks, during which I was prescribed medications, including Ketoprofen and Sirdalud, which ultimately brought some relief. For quite some time after that, I would experience episodes of tension and unusual sensitivity that would typically last about a week. The only consistent treatment during this period was a daily dose of Amitriptyline, 10 mg. However, earlier this year, things took a drastic turn for the worse. I began to notice the sensitivity in my leg once more, which was manageable at first. Then, one day at work, everything changed abruptly. I felt as if my body had shut down completely; there was an overwhelming tension, making it impossible for me to sit, stand, or walk comfortably for several hours. Eventually, the tension subsided, allowing me to return home, but it lingered throughout the evening. The following day, while the overall tension eased, the tightness in my right leg remained prominent, particularly below the knee. I resumed taking Sirdalud on a regular basis. Falling asleep has become a challenge as well; finding a comfortable position to ease my legs feels nearly impossible. Yet, after finally drifting off, nighttime seems to provide a welcome relief for my body. Some additional symptoms I’ve been experiencing: - My foot occasionally has a peculiar sensitivity, leading to strange sensations upon contact. - I also feel a pulsating sensation on the inside of my foot that lasts for about an hour. - There are sporadic muscle twitches occurring in various areas of the foot, sometimes near the big toe or the inner side. - I’ve noticed that my leg muscles are weak and tire easily. This episode persisted for around a month before it lessened, allowing me to work for three weeks before I went on vacation. Unfortunately, during my trip, the symptoms returned and have now plagued me for six weeks. Additionally, this time, I am also experiencing issues in my left leg. Walking has become increasingly difficult; even minor activity leaves my legs feeling utterly fatigued. I’ve also noticed a slight fever during both recovery phases. Interestingly, I've observed that my emotions and room temperature (whether too hot or too cold) seem to affect my symptoms. Moreover, I frequently experience numbness in my hands, though I can’t determine if it’s linked to my leg problems. That sums up everything regarding my symptoms. I’d greatly appreciate any insights or similar experiences you might wish to share! Regarding my medical evaluations: - I’ve undergone five MRIs, revealing syringomyelia that has remained unchanged over time. A notable finding was a cyst-like area on the central spinal cord at levels Th7 to Th10, measuring up to 3 mm in the anteroposterior direction and 4 mm laterally; however, no other useful information was provided. - I’ve had three EMGs/ENMGs with consistent results showing no neuropathy, although there’s some suggestion of underlying myopathy. The nerve evaluations consistently appeared normal. - All tests for motor and sensory nerves in my legs were normal. Muscle tests showed shortened duration potentials indicative of slight muscle damage. Notably, no dystonic postures were observed, and voluntary movement ceased rapidly after inducing provocative maneuvers. - A recent muscle biopsy returned normal, revealing no myopathic changes. Some COX-negative muscle fibers were present but at a very low percentage. - Advanced imaging showed no signs of tick-borne encephalitis. Additionally, my ANA IgG test returned positive at a titer of 1:100. - For the last several years, my CRP levels have been elevated, consistently ranging between 15-30, while the normal range is up to 5. I also have had elevated uric acid levels for years. - For about 15 years, I managed autoimmune thyroiditis, recently progressing to hypothyroidism, which is currently under control with treatment. - CT imaging revealed enlargement in my liver and spleen, though a PET/CT ruled out any tumors. The metabolic activity in these organs was initially high but appears normal now. - Genetic testing is also underway with results anticipated this autumn. Despite extensive testing, I remain without a diagnosis, and my despair is growing as these sensations are incredibly distressing. Without a diagnosis, there is no specific treatment available. At present, my Amitriptyline has been replaced with Nortriptyline, and I remain uncertain about its efficacy. I share my story in hopes of connecting with others who might be facing similar challenges. How have your doctors approached your cases? What diagnoses have they considered? Any treatments that brought you relief? My life feels consumed by this issue, and I’ve been struggling with dark thoughts. Thank you for reading! 🫶
Navigating Conflicting Medical Opinions: Should I Discuss a Second Opinion with My Orthopedist?
As a 25-year-old woman, measuring 5’5” and weighing 108 pounds, I recently experienced an unfortunate incident that resulted in a fracture of my middle finger. Approximately three weeks ago, I was diagnosed with a non-displaced fracture in the head of my third metacarpal, leading to my concern regarding the future functionality of my grip. To address this issue, I opted for a titanium implant to stabilize the fracture. However, despite ongoing treatment, including oral antibiotics, I continue to notice concerning symptoms such as yellow discharge, indicating a potential infection. I've been diligent about attending weekly follow-up appointments with my primary physician, but my condition doesn't seem to improve; it feels as though my hand remains in the same state. My doctor mentioned that if the situation does not improve, the next step might involve IV antibiotics. Seeking additional perspectives, I consulted another orthopedic specialist, who proposed a different course of action: removing the implant to allow for natural healing. This alternate recommendation has left me feeling uncertain about which path to pursue. In light of this contrasting advice, would it be advisable for me to communicate with my orthopedic surgeon about the second opinion I obtained and the differing suggestions I received?
Jaw Discomfort and Muscle Tightness
While my issue may not be as severe as others described in this forum, it has been quite bothersome, and I'm eager to understand its origin and potential remedies. I'm a 15-year-old male weighing around 75 kilograms. One day, while using the restroom, I absentmindedly cracked my jaw, moving it from side to side as I often do. Suddenly, I experienced an unusual twitching sensation on the left side of my jaw, just below the ramus bone. Although there was no pain, I noticed a slight swelling, which made the left side of my jaw appear noticeably less defined than the right. At the time, I didn’t think much of it, but after several months, I’ve come to realize that the condition has remained unchanged. Now, when I place my finger in that area and attempt to position it just behind the jaw—as I can easily do on the right side—I encounter something obstructing the movement. It feels like a tight muscle, akin to a small rope with a somewhat flattened texture. This sensation is quite frustrating, and I’m determined to learn what it is and how to alleviate it.