Comparing Barrow's and Burow's Solution for Chronic Ear Issues
Age: 35, Gender: Female, Height: 5'3", Weight: 150 lbs, Ethnicity: Caucasian, Condition: chronic swimmer's ear, Duration: intermittent for over 10 years, Current medications: none except for hydrocortisone/acetic acid otic drops, Alcohol use: no, Smoking: no, Recreational drug use: no. For over a decade, I've been dealing with persistent itching in my ears. This discomfort is not continuous; it fluctuates over time. Last year, I consulted with an ear, nose, and throat specialist who prescribed fluocinonide oil drops, which provided significant relief. In fact, it was the most effective treatment I've tried, allowing me the longest respite from itching episodes. However, after switching to a new health insurance plan, I was unable to return to that original specialist and instead saw a different ENT. This new doctor informed me that Debrox, an earwax removal aid I had been using upon a previous recommendation, was harmful, and he advised me to discontinue its use. Furthermore, he dismissed the fluocinonide oil as lacking credible scientific support. He introduced me to a concoction called Barrow's Solution, which he prepared himself. Strangely, it came without any accompanying ingredient information. The doctor claimed that this solution had previously been available through a pharmacy but became too costly for patients—while it only costs about $6 to make, pharmacies charged over $100 per bottle. So, he chose to create it himself, offering it for free to his patients, asserting it contained components similar to the hydrocortisone/acetic acid drops prescribed by my primary care doctor. Upon researching, I stumbled upon Burow's Solution, which, although it sounds similar, is not available for purchase or through a prescription. This raises questions about the authenticity and safety of Barrow's Solution. Should I have confidence in this unverified clear solution I received, labeled as "Barrow's Solution"? Given that this supposedly contains ingredients akin to the hydrocortisone/acetic acid solution, I have opted to continue using my pharmacy-purchased drops, as I have a substantial supply left. While the hydrocortisone/acetic acid drops still provide some relief, they take longer to work and can be painful. The fluocinonide drops were far superior, offering quick relief, and it's frustrating that my new ENT questions their efficacy despite them being previously prescribed by another specialist.
Answers (1)
7/29/2025, 4:20:41 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel frustrated and uncertain when navigating the treatment options for chronic ear issues, especially after trying multiple solutions. Given your long history of swimmer's ear and your experience with the fluocinonide drops, it's important to focus on effective and safe treatments.
Main Points:
- Fluocinonide oil drops were previously effective for you.
- Barrow's Solution has unclear safety and ingredient information.
- Burow's Solution may offer similar benefits but is not widely available or verified.
Explanation:
Chronic swimmer’s ear (otitis externa) can be bothersome, and it sounds like you've already tried a couple of treatments that provided varying levels of relief. Fluocinonide, a strong topical steroid, is typically used for inflammatory conditions and sometimes suggested for severe itching and irritation in the ear canal. Your ENT’s concerns about its efficacy may stem from specific guidelines or personal experience, but your positive response to this treatment is significant.
Barrow's Solution, being homemade and lacking detailed ingredient disclosure, raises valid concerns about both safety and effectiveness. The fact that it's not a commercially recognized product makes it harder to trust without clear composition and verification. Burow's Solution, while often used for similar conditions, is indeed not available as a commercial product, which adds to the confusion surrounding these treatments.
Next Steps:
- Continue using your hydrocortisone/acetic acid drops until your symptoms are better managed. Document how often you experience relief and any reactions.
- Consider reaching out to a pharmacist or another ENT specialist for clarity on both Barrow's Solution and potential alternatives. Sharing your positive experience with fluocinonide might prompt discussions about effective treatments.
- Stay clear of Debrox, especially given your ENT's advice against it. Earwax removal can sometimes exacerbate irritation, especially if you're prone to swimmer's ear.
- Maintain a symptom diary noting when symptoms occur and whether any specific activities (like swimming) trigger flare-ups, as it may help your next healthcare consultation.
If you want to better understand the ingredients in Barrow's Solution and explore evidence-based alternatives, this can empower you in discussions with any future healthcare providers you consult. Remember that it’s essential to advocate for your health and seek a second opinion if your concerns and treatment needs aren't being adequately addressed.
Related Questions
Mysterious Health Decline
My uncle, a 64-year-old man, is experiencing a steep decline in health, yet the physicians he has consulted seem baffled by his condition. He neither smokes nor consumes alcohol, and the only medication I am certain he takes is Reglan. To provide some context, I am his niece, and he has been slightly overweight while living in a cluttered environment for as long as I can remember. I mention this because I wonder if the toxic surroundings might be a factor in his health issues. Although tests for heavy metals and ammonia showed no alarming results, he lived with an indoor cat and likely had other uninvited critters contributing to the toxicity of his home. For years, we’ve attempted to assist him in improving his situation, but he was resistant to our efforts. In September 2025, he underwent gallbladder removal surgery. Prior to this, he was capable of functioning independently. Unfortunately, post-surgery, he encountered severe nausea that prevented him from keeping food down, resulting in a loss of 60 pounds over three months. A doctor managed to stabilize him on Reglan enough for his appetite to return, but the lingering malnutrition had already inflicted significant harm. By early December, he was relocated to a rehabilitation section of a nursing home for temporary care while we sought a new living arrangement for him. Since that time, he has lost all mobility in his legs and his left arm. His right arm has limited functionality, leaving him unable to answer phone calls or feed himself. Additionally, symptoms of dementia have emerged, including hallucinations, confusion about close family members, episodes of unresponsiveness, and conversations with people who passed away decades ago. Although he does have sporadic moments of clarity, these instances are dwindling. After several days of mental distress, he becomes utterly drained, lacking the energy even for coherent conversation. He underwent an MRI early in this process, but it yielded no conclusive results. Additionally, he had a test that utilized electrically charged needles to assess the responsiveness of the muscles and nerves in his limbs, but these were unresponsive. Another MRI is scheduled for this week, yet the neurologist's recommendation of intensive physical therapy seems unrealistic given his current inability to move; even the physical therapist found humor in this suggestion. Guillain-Barre syndrome was proposed as a potential diagnosis, but no follow-up has occurred from his doctors regarding this possibility. Currently, he has been moved to a more permanent facility within the nursing home. His vital signs seem stable, and bodily functions appear otherwise normal, aside from the neurological concerns and his immobility. Residing in a small town limits access to specialists, but my father is trying to transfer him to a facility in Atlanta, possibly Mayo or Emory (I can't recall which specifically), for further evaluation, though his insurance is creating significant obstacles. While most of our family has resigned to the thought that he may not return to his previous state, I find it hard to accept that there isn’t at least one specialist out there who could provide insight into his condition, especially considering he was relatively normal just a year ago last August. Any thoughts or suggestions for additional testing would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for taking the time to read this lengthy message.
ENT Inquiry: Can Nasal or Sinus Cancer Develop in 3 Months Post-Normal Endoscopy?
Subject: 62 Years Old Gender: Female Background: Long-standing nasal and sinus issues My mother has grappled with persistent nasal blockages, sinus discomfort, and ear pressure for a considerable period. Approximately three months prior, she underwent a flexible fiberoptic nasal endoscopy, which revealed signs indicative of chronic rhinitis and sinusitis. The examination showcased features such as inflamed and discolored mucosa, enlarged nasal turbinates, and the presence of clear mucus. Importantly, no masses or concerning lesions were identified during this evaluation. Additionally, her oropharyngeal examination yielded normal results. However, during a recent ENT consultation, a “suspicious lesion above the middle turbinate” was identified via endoscopy, which prompted a referral for an “urgent” CT scan (scheduled for three weeks from now, as we reside in Croatia). Currently, she does not exhibit any worsening symptoms such as facial swelling, altered vision, or recurring nosebleeds (two notable nosebleeds occurred around a year ago, but she has not experienced any since then). I have a few inquiries: 1. Is it feasible for a malignant tumor in the nasal or sinus region to arise or become significant within a mere three months, given that a fiberoptic endoscopy conducted three months earlier revealed no alarming findings? 2. Considering this clinical scenario, how much more likely could this be a nasal polyp or chronic inflammatory reaction as opposed to a cancerous growth? 3. Is there a possibility that such a lesion existed three months prior but eluded detection during the fiberoptic endoscopy? I greatly appreciate any guidance you can provide regarding these concerns.
In Need of Support
Greetings, I'm a 23-year-old male who actively participates in sports. It was around April that I started experiencing persistent pain in my shoulder and sacroiliac joint. By July, after taking finasteride for a period of three weeks, my joint discomfort intensified significantly and began affecting almost every joint in my body. Additionally, I noticed that my joints became unusually loose, leading to my shoulders partially dislocating from their sockets. This also brought on severe cognitive fog and a sensation of pressure in my head. I am losing my sense of optimism. If anyone has insights or assistance to offer, I would greatly appreciate it. To highlight, I have never had hypermobility nor have I been particularly flexible before this issue arose.
Unexplained Bruises and Welts on My Daughter's Skin
Four nights ago, my daughter developed two noticeable welts on her thighs, which showed no signs of pain or itching. She insisted vigorously that nothing occurred to cause them, and nobody had harmed her. The following day, I noticed that the welts had vanished, leaving behind bruises. This left me quite anxious, fearing she might have sustained an injury. However, since that initial incident, it seems she has developed one or two more welts every evening right before bedtime, which then disappear overnight, only to be replaced by bruises in the morning. Most of these welts have appeared on her legs, ankles, and feet, with the exception of one on her palm that did not result in a bruise. Oddly, none of the welts are itchy, but she mentions that they can be painful when pressure is applied. There's a bit of swelling as well, consistently occurring in the evenings just before she goes to bed. We plan to consult a doctor on Monday, but it's currently the weekend, and I'm curious if anyone has encountered something similar or could have insights on what might be happening.
Navigating Acoustic Neuroma Treatment Options
**Profile: 45-year-old Male, 6'0", 220 lbs, No Regular Medications** My husband maintains a relatively healthy lifestyle despite experiencing some service-related disabilities. About a year and a half ago, he underwent knee replacement surgery, and he utilizes a CPAP machine due to sleep apnea—an issue linked to a jaw surgery performed many years ago. Additionally, he has a history of appendectomy. For the past three years, he has been prescribed hearing aids due to bilateral hearing loss, although he rarely uses them. About eight months ago, he experienced what he described as the "worst headache of his life." Given that he seldom suffers from headaches, we decided to visit the emergency room. A CT scan showed no abnormalities, and he was diagnosed with a migraine. Since then, he has grappled with weekly migraines. He has a triptan medication, but it offers limited relief. Additionally, he has been reporting non-migraine headaches every few days. Before this incident, he reported headaches perhaps twice a year, typically after consuming alcohol, which he does occasionally and in moderation. He also frequently mentions a sensation of pressure or fullness in his head, though he is uncertain if he would categorize it as a headache. Given the stressors our family has faced over the past couple of years, I hoped this might subside as we return to a more typical routine. Two weeks ago, my husband’s boss alerted us that an ambulance was called after he fainted while walking down the hall at work. After regaining consciousness, he attempted to sit up but felt intense dizziness, forcing him to lie back down. Although his fall wasn't witnessed, he was found roughly two minutes later. At the ER, tests including a CT scan and EKG returned normal results. He was then referred back to his primary care manager (PCM), who ordered an MRI with and without contrast. The MRI revealed the presence of an acoustic neuroma. Through my investigation, it appears that many of his symptoms—headaches, pressure sensations, dizziness, and cognitive fog—could be linked to this condition. We are currently awaiting a follow-up appointment with his PCM for a specialist referral. I want to ensure that he is equipped to advocate for himself during this process. Considering his MRI results and associated symptoms, should we seek the expertise of a specialist familiar with acoustic neuroma? I am concerned that our small-town ENT may not have extensive experience with this issue, and I want to avoid a mere monitoring approach if more proactive treatment is advisable. With a busy family and an active lifestyle, his symptoms over these past months have certainly impacted him, as well as our family dynamics and his professional duties. I would greatly appreciate any insights regarding treatment options or specialist locations you might be able to share. Thank you!