OpenHealth Q&A

Get answered by medical professionals

Seeking a Second Opinion on Left Shoulder Issues

7/28/2025, 4:10:25 PMMale25-34

I am a 36-year-old Caucasian male, standing at 5'9" and weighing 160 pounds. I smoked roughly a pack a day for ten years but quit two and a half years ago. Recently, I was prescribed Adderall XR about eight days ago, and I occasionally indulge in maybe two to three alcoholic beverages weekly. My shoulder troubles began approximately two weeks ago when I made a conscious effort to target my shoulders more during workouts. Initially, I experienced a peculiar sensation while reaching for objects, but it was not accompanied by any pain or restricted movement. After about ten days, I spent roughly two hours playing the drums, not continuously, and felt relatively fine. I usually maintain an active lifestyle, engaging in walking, gym sessions, and kayak fishing at least three times a week. I pushed through my workout routine despite the initial odd feeling, which evolved into mild discomfort but was not enough to disrupt my exercise regimen. However, after about ten days, I noticed a slightly worsening discomfort. While playing the drums, which lasted a couple of hours, I did not encounter any pain. Yet, upon finishing, I experienced excruciating pain when reaching for a drink on the counter, and my shoulder seemed unresponsive. Three days into this issue, I took Ibuprofen, which provided some relief, yet pain persisted with specific restrictions in movement. When I keep my elbow close to my body, there is no issue, but if I turn my thumb down, I can move my arm through a full range. On the other hand, if my hand is level with the ground or my thumb is positioned upwards, I can only lift my arm to about a 90° angle. I can extend my elbow fully, but rotating my arm upward is limited to about 5 to 10 degrees. The rapid development of these symptoms seems atypical for what is generally described as a frozen shoulder condition. My evaluation did not include any physical range of motion assessments; I was only asked questions which led to a diagnosis. I have a physical therapy appointment scheduled, but I'm questioning whether I should seek another opinion given the lack of physical examinations during my initial assessment. An X-ray has been requested as part of the investigation.

AsthmaArthritisInternal Medicine

Answers (1)

Cony

7/28/2025, 4:10:45 PM

OpenHealth AI

It sounds like you're experiencing complex shoulder issues that have developed quite rapidly, and it's understandable to want clarity on your condition, especially with the diagnosis you've received. Let’s break down the situation and discuss your options.

Main Points:

  1. Symptoms Description: Your symptoms include discomfort and restricted movement, particularly when your arm is raised in certain positions.
  2. Initial Assessment Concerns: You were not given a thorough physical examination, leading you to question the accuracy of the diagnosis.
  3. Upcoming Therapy: You have a physical therapy appointment scheduled, which may provide further insights or relief.

Explanation:

The symptoms you're describing—mild discomfort that worsened over time, along with limitations in your shoulder movement—could stem from a few different issues such as tendonitis, bursitis, or even a shoulder impingement. These conditions can develop rapidly, especially if there was increased physical activity targeting the shoulder muscles.

It's also important to consider the medical history you've shared, including your previous smoking habits and new medication (Adderall XR), both of which can influence your overall health but aren’t directly related to shoulder issues. The initial diagnosis appearing to lack a proper physical assessment is a valid concern and warrants further investigation if you're not satisfied with the explanation given.

Next Steps:

  1. Follow Through with Physical Therapy: Attend your scheduled physical therapy session. A physical therapist can perform specific assessments to determine the exact range and cause of your limitation, which is essential for your recovery.

  2. Track Your Symptoms: Keep a daily log of your shoulder pain, noting what activities worsen or alleviate your discomfort. This record will be valuable both for your therapy sessions and for any further evaluations.

  3. Consider a Second Opinion: If after therapy you are still unsatisfied with your progress or the diagnosis is unclear, seeking a second opinion is reasonable. Ensure this new evaluation includes appropriate physical examinations and possibly imaging studies like your scheduled X-ray.

  4. Modify Activities as Needed: Avoid any activities that exacerbate the pain in your shoulder until you understand the underlying problem better. Gentle stretching and mobility exercises, as advised by a therapist, can be beneficial without causing strain.

  5. Pain Management: Continue to use NSAIDs like ibuprofen for pain relief as needed, but be cautious with long-term use and always follow recommended dosages.

By taking these steps, you’ll be better equipped to understand your shoulder issue and work towards a solution. Remember, advocating for your health and seeking clarity in your diagnosis is important, and you are not alone in this process. Let me know if you need further information or guidance!

Related Questions

Blood in Urine: Seeking Guidance

A 20-year-old female weighing 140 pounds has not been taking any medications or supplements, and has no prior or current medical conditions. Her menstrual cycle last occurred two weeks ago. While at work, she observed blood in her urine, which appeared light red but darker than pink. Accompanying this symptom, she has experienced some abdominal discomfort. Notably, there was no evidence of blood on her underwear, only when she urinated. Additionally, she felt a moment of lightheadedness upon noticing the blood, which has since subsided; she attributes this feeling to her anxiety about the potential seriousness of the situation. Given these symptoms, what could be the likely cause? She is uncertain whether to visit the emergency room or to wait until urgent care is available tomorrow for a consultation. As she recently relocated and does not have a primary care physician yet, her anxiety is heightened.

LupusInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
32 minutes ago

Exploring Endolymphatic Hydrops: Could This Be My Condition?

34 years old / Female Current weight: 165 lbs Navigating the challenges of motherhood In early December 2025, I caught a cold. By mid-December, my right ear felt blocked, but I attributed it to the cold virus. As New Year approached, I experienced another cold, which coincided with an onset of ringing in my ears. Disturbingly, sounds started to seem altered from the affected ear, accompanied by a persistent fullness in that area. Additionally, I noticed twitching of my eye and swelling in the salivary gland on the same side. My primary care physician prescribed a decongestant and Flonase; however, because I am currently breastfeeding, I hesitated to take the medications as directed. On January 27, I was evaluated by an ear, nose, and throat specialist, who requested a hearing assessment the following day. The results indicated that I had sensorineural hearing loss affecting my low-frequency hearing range (250 Hz to 500 Hz). The doctor prescribed a steroid with the hope of addressing the issue promptly. Now on day 10 of steroid treatment, I have experienced significant relief. Remarkably, I've noticed a substantial amount of thick, putty-like mucus clearing from my nasal passages. The pressure in my ear has subsided, and sounds are returning to normal, though I still perceive a slight ringing — possibly just a touch of hearing loss remains. What concerns me is whether ongoing sinus congestion could be the root of these symptoms or if I might genuinely be dealing with endolymphatic hydrops. Notably, I have not experienced any episodes of dizziness. In the evenings, I tend to feel considerable pressure building on the right side of my head, almost as if my sinuses are becoming blocked once more. I would greatly appreciate any insights or advice on this matter, as I find myself in a state of uncertainty regarding my condition.

Thyroid DisordersInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
42 minutes ago

Gene Testing Outcomes Suggest Elevated Risk for MPN

A 27-year-old male of Irish heritage recently conducted a commercial gene analysis, and here are the findings: - **Rs12340895 (C;G)** Result Interpretation: "Doubles the likelihood of developing V617F-positive MPN." - **Rs3780374 (A;G)** Result Interpretation: "Significantly raises the probability of V617F-positive MPN manifestation." Based on my research, it appears that having these two genetic markers indicates a strong predisposition to this particular form of cancer. What steps should I consider taking to either prepare for or potentially postpone the onset of this condition? Should I discuss these findings with my healthcare provider? My studies suggest there isn’t a definitive cure for this condition.

Multiple SclerosisInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
42 minutes ago

Understanding Preseptal Cellulitis in Children

Hello everyone. I'm reaching out for assistance. My 6-year-old son recently experienced a concerning issue. He woke up on Friday with significant swelling around his eye, nearly closing it entirely. We quickly took him to the emergency room, where doctors diagnosed him with preseptal cellulitis. They prescribed antibiotics, specifically cephalosporin, as part of his treatment. However, after approximately 30 hours on the medication, I’ve noticed that his condition seems to have deteriorated. We’ve been applying warm compresses, which help reduce some swelling temporarily, but he now has a noticeable bump right in the center of the affected area. This morning, he woke up again with his eye completely shut. I’m uncertain whether I should return to the ER for further evaluation. I appreciate any advice or insights you can provide. Thank you!

Internal MedicineRheumatology
Male25-34
42 minutes ago

Unexpected Head Pain During Dance Moves

This may seem humorous, yet I'm genuinely interested in uncovering the cause of this peculiar experience. I’m a 34-year-old female. A few months back, hoping to elevate my mood and get my body moving away from the grip of depression, I decided to play some music and dance in my living room. In a moment of misguided enthusiasm, I attempted to twerk. It's worth noting that I have a long history of lower back discomfort, I've never attempted to twerk before, and I lack the rhythm, flexibility, or skills typical of proficient dancers. As I embarked on my very first serious twerk attempt, a sudden jolt of agony shot through my forehead, nearly causing me to lose consciousness. It felt like being struck with a hammer. I was momentarily blinded by the pain, convinced I might have suffered an aneurysm or something equally serious. This intense sensation only lasted for about a minute, during which I dramatically considered that I might be the first individual to perish from twerking. You might think it was just a case of me bumping my head while trying to dance away my sadness; however, I assure you that this wasn’t the case. Just as abruptly as the pain struck, it dissipated. In that moment, I promised myself to never attempt twerking again. Fast forward to today, and I experienced a similar incident again—not the twerking, but the sudden stabbing pain in my skull. I was engaged in some back stretches, particularly the cat-cow pose, and during the cow portion, I once more felt an intense sharp pain in the center of my forehead, just above my right eye. Stars filled my vision, and everything seemed slightly distorted. This sensation vanished within seconds, leaving me puzzled. What is causing this reaction? How do my forehead and lower back relate in this context? It's baffling! I genuinely seek any insights that might help explain this mysterious phenomenon.

ArthritisCrohn's DiseaseCOPD
Male25-34
52 minutes ago