Mystery of Joint Pain and Instability: Years of Normal Test Results
A 27-year-old Caucasian woman of average weight has been grappling with various joint issues for the last four to five years. Initially, she experienced discomfort predominantly in her fingers while attending college. Subsequently, she began to notice her hips would occasionally feel unstable and could unexpectedly give way during mundane activities, resulting in limping. This troubling pattern soon extended to her knees, where she encountered clicking noises and pain, particularly during exercise. These episodes would occasionally occur during her brief walk to work, again causing her to limp. The discomfort and instability persist in her hips and knees, while occasional symptoms manifest in her ankles, shoulders, and wrists. She has also experienced clicking in her temporomandibular joint (TMJ), which complicates her ability to perform everyday tasks. It's not merely the pain; there's an unsettling sense of physical instability that makes her feel as though some joints are misaligned, though not dislocated. An avid hiker and backpacker, she recalls one particularly painful experience from four years ago when her hip seemed to drift into an agonizing position. This caused her to struggle to lift her leg over obstacles like logs. In those moments, she would manually elevate her thigh to temporarily alleviate the pain, only for it to return shortly after. When hiking, her knees often ache, accompanied by a sensation of swelling and increased fluid. Her partner has noticed abnormalities in her joints, especially in her wrist, stating that it often feels off while they hold hands and her thumb moves. During weight lifting or even lifting moderate objects, she experiences acute discomfort as if her elbows might dislocate, while simple actions like closing a car door can cause similar feelings in her shoulder. Over the past five years, she has undergone multiple tests for autoimmune diseases, conducted by both her primary care physician and a rheumatologist, with all results returning negative. There were instances of elevated C-reactive protein (CRP) levels, but recently conducted X-rays for her hip, knee, and ankle revealed no abnormalities, adding to the perplexity of her condition. This cluster of issues has severely impacted her quality of life, hindering her from enjoying outdoor activities, hiking, and even performing routine tasks like opening jars. Her physician is genuinely interested in finding a solution but is puzzled since her symptoms suggest an autoimmune origin despite the absence of identifiable markers and normal imaging results. In an effort to understand her situation better, she shared additional health-related concerns, some of which may correlate: - A few joints show signs of minor hyperextension; however, hypermobility tests provided inconclusive results. Despite this, her new physical therapist has observed slight hyperextension in some joints. She doesn’t have notably flexible skin nor consider herself double-jointed; yet, she occasionally experiences stiffness and discomfort in her fingers and wrists after prolonged activities like playing the cello or using a phone. - She has a reputation for frequently falling ill, having faced numerous health challenges: pancreatitis at 17, shingles in two dermatome regions at 18, and mononucleosis during college that left her feeling unwell for an extended period. She contends with recurring colds lasting two weeks or longer, sometimes exacerbated by severe illnesses that have necessitated emergency visits, like a phlegmon in her throat and a suspected norovirus infection. - Additionally, she faces dental challenges, with weak enamel leading to frequent cavities, despite practicing good oral hygiene and minimal sugar intake. Prescription toothpaste has significantly improved her condition. - Menstrual issues comprise heavy periods and severe cramps, alleviated somewhat by hormone-regulating contraceptives, although continuous methods led to excessive bleeding. - IBS symptoms have been mitigated through psychiatric medications, yet she still experiences frequent heart palpitations and symptoms of Raynaud’s syndrome, indicating improper temperature regulation during stress. - Other notable health issues include ease of bruising, long-term headaches (not migraines), heightened susceptibility to motion sickness, and an overreaction of her skin to changes in water temperature, which triggers hives. - While she has no food allergies, she occasionally experiences coughing and a strange sensation in her throat after eating certain foods, particularly peanut-related candies. If anyone can provide insights or share similar experiences, it would be greatly appreciated as her healthcare team continues to search for answers. She lacks detailed knowledge of her family's medical history, with no known instances of comparable problems among relatives.
Answers (1)

7/20/2025, 4:20:45 PM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you are experiencing a complex array of joint issues and other systemic symptoms that have significantly impacted your quality of life. Here's a structured approach to help you navigate your situation further.
Key Points
- Joint pain and instability can be linked to various issues, including musculoskeletal disorders, hypermobility syndromes, or other underlying health conditions.
- Your symptoms suggest possible joint hypermobility, which may impact stability and lead to pain, despite normal test results.
- It's essential to focus on symptom management and explore supportive therapies for your quality of life.
Understanding Your Symptoms
- Joint Instability: The feeling of instability in your joints, especially during physical activities like hiking or lifting, might point toward a hypermobility syndrome or a connective tissue disorder. Hypermobile joints can lead to pain and difficulty in stabilizing them.
- Systemic Symptoms: Other symptoms, such as easy bruising, frequent illnesses, and gastrointestinal issues, may indicate a larger systemic condition, possibly affecting connective tissues.
- Dental Issues: Weak enamel and frequent cavities alongside your joint problems might suggest a systemic issue not identified by the standard tests.
Next Steps
-
Seek a Comprehensive Evaluation: Consider asking your healthcare providers about specialized consultations with a geneticist or a specialist in hypermobility syndromes (like Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome). These specialists can provide a more nuanced assessment of your symptoms, given their complexity.
-
Physical Therapy: Continue working with a physical therapist focused on joint stability and strengthening exercises tailored to your needs. Emphasize stability exercises that support your hip, knee, and shoulder joints to help manage instability symptoms.
-
Pain Management Strategies:
- Heat and Cold Therapy: Applying heat can help alleviate joint stiffness, while cold therapy can reduce swelling during flare-ups.
- Activity Modification: Gradually introduce low-impact exercises that may help maintain joint function without exacerbating pain. Activities like swimming or cycling may be beneficial.
- Assistive Devices: If joint instability is severe, consider using braces or supports to enhance stability during activities.
-
Diet and Nutrition: Keep a food diary to identify any potential triggers for your throat discomfort. Discuss with a nutritionist to ensure that your diet supports overall joint and digestive health, particularly considering your IBS.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Keep track of new or worsening symptoms, especially related to your menstrual cycle and gastrointestinal function. This could provide your healthcare team with valuable insights during follow-ups.
-
Mental Health Support: Given the chronic nature of your symptoms, you may benefit from support groups or discussions with mental health professionals familiar with chronic pain and health issues. They can help you develop coping strategies.
Conclusion
Your longstanding joint issues and associated symptoms have undoubtedly taken a toll on your life. Prioritizing a comprehensive evaluation, actively participating in physical therapy, and taking steps for symptom management are foundational next steps. If you have further questions or need clarifications about your situation, feel free to reach out. You’re not alone in this; advocating for yourself and seeking the right support can make a meaningful difference.
Related Questions
Experiencing Vertigo, Sweating, and Frequent Bowel Movements—Seeking Insight
Hello, everyone. I'm a 25-year-old female, of Caucasian descent, weighing 230 pounds and standing at 5 feet 8 inches. I do not consume alcohol, smoke, or use any recreational drugs. My prescribed medications include Zoloft (150 mg in the morning), Quetiapine (100 mg at night), and Amlodipine (5 mg in the morning). Below is a summary of my concerns. To start, I recognize that Reddit is not a substitute for medical advice. This is not an urgent situation, and I have consulted physicians without receiving useful explanations beyond reassurances that it is non-life-threatening. However, I am seeking some clarity. Occasionally, I experience episodes of reactive hypoglycemia, manifesting as shakiness and balance issues, often accompanied by sensations akin to a hot flash. In 2019, I dealt with a prolonged incident of vertigo due to labyrinthitis, which included vomiting yet resolved spontaneously (the doctor did not conduct any tests nor provide clarifications). Just today, while lying on my right side, I felt a wave of vertigo that quickly subsided upon standing. Subsequently, I experienced shakiness and had five bowel movements (all solid) within the span of about two hours. Consuming a meal and staying hydrated with Liquid IV seemed beneficial. Now, I’m left feeling anxious. Fortunately, I do not have a fever, and my blood pressure and heart rate have remained within normal ranges today. Additionally, I encounter sporadic symptoms that might connect to this situation, such as vagus nerve reactions during bowel movements. I also struggle with health anxiety. For approximately a week, I have been dealing with twitching in my right eye. Yesterday, I enjoyed some time swimming in the ocean. I have been cleared of thyroid issues as confirmed by blood tests, and my recent lab work including CBC and metabolic panels from a few months ago showed no abnormalities. A quick update: I previously dealt with post-orgasm migraines, but it has been two years since my last occurrence. Two unrelated MRIs of my brain have revealed no irregularities, with the most recent scan conducted in 2020.
Unexplained Itchy Blemishes on My Legs
At 15 years old, I experienced a troubling issue while vacationing in Spain. It began with a noticeable irritation on my right leg. To manage it, I applied a disinfectant spray and covered the area with a bandage to prevent further contact with my clothing, which seemed to exacerbate the itchiness. This initial spot emerged nearly a week ago and has since transformed into a brown mark resembling post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. Just today, I discovered three more itchy patches on my other leg; the largest one bears a striking resemblance to the original. What could these be?
Are My Ear Infection Symptoms Intensifying After Treatment?
As a 42-year-old woman, I visited urgent care yesterday and was diagnosed with an ear infection accompanied by a perforation. I’ve been prescribed Amoxicillin 875 mg, which I take twice daily, along with Ofloxacin drops. After applying the drops, I’ve been experiencing intermittent sharp pains, and it feels like my ears are becoming even more clogged. I apply the drops once daily, using 10 drops in the affected ear, and then I lie down for about 15 minutes to let them absorb. Should I wait until tomorrow to assess my condition, or is this an indication that my infection is worsening?
Should I Visit the ER? A Dilemma with Urgent Care Guidance
I’m a 26-year-old female and today I sought care at an urgent care facility. Before my scheduled appointment, the staff reached out to inquire about my symptoms. They recommended that I head to the emergency room, yet I question whether my condition is severe enough for such action, which is why I initially opted for urgent care. For the past week, I’ve been dealing with a persistent headache at the base of my skull on the right side, radiating towards my neck and ear. Initially, this discomfort was a sharp, stabbing sensation, reminiscent of a pinched nerve. Now, however, it has transformed into a continuous pressure feeling while still causing tightness in my neck. Moreover, my neck has been incredibly stiff for the entire week, disrupting my sleep patterns. I assumed these symptoms were due to muscle tension, and although it feels somewhat better today, there's still discomfort and limited mobility. I don’t have a fever, but my appetite has vanished and I’m experiencing considerable fatigue, evidenced by a two-hour nap I just took. Recently, I noticed another concerning symptom: a firm lump in my left armpit that developed yesterday. The skin around this lump appears slightly discolored and the area is raised. It feels somewhat swollen, but only causes pain when I apply pressure. The lump doesn’t shift around, leaving me uncertain if it’s a cyst or a swollen lymph node. I’m caught in a dilemma about whether to wait and consult my primary care physician or to heed the urgent care nurse’s advice and go to the ER. I would prefer to avoid an emergency visit if possible. The nurse mentioned imaging might be necessary, yet since I’m experiencing slight improvements, I’m unsure of the best course of action. Thank you for any insights you might have!
Concerns About Pancreatic Cancer in a Young Man
Greetings, everyone. I typically observe from the sidelines here as I struggle with significant health anxiety. This issue has plagued me for as long as I can remember, though it hasn't always revolved around health. I realize this might be driven by my anxiety, but I'm reaching out in hopes of getting some insights, even if it feels a little embarrassing to share. My troubles began about three years ago. In 2022, I was quite overweight, tipping the scales at 310 pounds while standing 6'2". My diet was poor, consisting mainly of fast food, which I consumed frequently, sometimes two to three times a day. Subsequently, I began experiencing sudden shortness of breath, where it felt like I couldn't quite inhale fully. At the time, I shrugged it off due to my careless attitude. Fast forward to 2023, after indulging in an excessive meal of ribs, I felt significant pressure in my upper abdomen, which was quite unsettling. Concerned about the shortness of breath alongside this discomfort, I consulted a telehealth service. They suggested this could indicate a heart issue and advised me to visit the emergency room. At the ER, I underwent an EKG, which confirmed that my heart health was normal. Instead, they diagnosed me with GERD, which made sense since I occasionally experienced heartburn, though I never paid much attention. They prescribed me Omeprazole and sulfurcote for a month. By March 2023, during a follow-up appointment with my primary care physician, she inquired whether any blood work had been conducted, noting the ER hadn’t done so. She ordered a complete blood count and metabolic panel. Anxiety welled up as I awaited the results, but she reassured me that if anything seemed off, we'd investigate further. When the results came in, I discovered that everything appeared normal, except my triglycerides and platelet count, the latter being at 471. The doctor informed me of my obesity and stressed the need for weight loss. However, it was this elevated platelet count that plunged me into an intense fear of pancreatic cancer. She noted my platelet count was concerning and suggested retesting. While everything else checked out, the elevated platelet levels gnawed at me. As I began to research, I stumbled upon information linking high platelet counts to cancer, and it sent my anxiety spiraling—pancreatic cancer, in particular, caught my attention. After discontinuing my medication for a week, I started to feel pain beneath both my right and left ribs and noticed I was burping frequently. This led me to believe the worst: cancer. At my next appointment, I explained my symptoms, but they attributed them to my recent cessation of medication. I asked if pancreatic cancer was a possibility, and although they assured me it wasn’t, my mind still raced. Another CBC test showed my platelet count still at 470, and they scheduled a follow-up for the next month. Yet, the discomfort persisted, and I felt dismissed when I expressed my concerns. I opted not to resume the GERD medication, as I wasn’t experiencing heartburn anymore. I managed to lose weight, dropping to 264 pounds from 310 by avoiding fast food and entirely cutting out soda. While the weight loss should have been encouraging, it also alarmed me. Reflecting on my previous eating habits, it struck me how unhealthy my choices had been. This brought me to a subsequent blood test that showed my platelets had risen to 475. My doctor referred me to a hematologist about two months later, and my weight had fallen to 259 by that point. Despite still experiencing pain, medical professionals insisted my symptoms weren’t concerning and hadn’t recommended any imaging of my pancreas or stomach. During my visit with the hematologist, I recounted everything, but again, they expressed no concern regarding pancreatic cancer, instead focusing on the possibility of blood cancer, which only escalated my anxiety. If my tests indicated high levels, they would conduct an ultrasound of my liver and spleen. They performed numerous blood tests, and while my C-reactive protein levels appeared normal, my ESR was slightly elevated—but still nothing alarming. Miraculously, my platelet count dropped to 421 without much explanation. The hematologist decided an ultrasound was unnecessary and advised me to follow up with my primary care provider. The pain had lessened by this point; what I experienced was more like minor flare-ups when my diet slipped. In conclusion, I find myself still obsessively checking the color of my stool, concerned when it appears lighter. Although flare-ups have become much less frequent, my weight remains a constant focus, currently at 244 pounds. My intense fear of pancreatic cancer continues to haunt me despite what I’ve learned and the reassurance I've received from my healthcare providers, who attribute it to anxiety. Nonetheless, the variations in my stool, my weight loss, and persistent pain trigger anxiety attacks that are hard to manage. While I understand that pancreatic cancer is quite rare at my age, I struggle to shake this fear no matter what efforts I make. I'm here looking for understanding and possibly insights that can offer me clarity beyond what my current situation provides. Notably, I lack any family history of cancer, abstain from drinking alcohol, and have never smoked, leaving me with minimal risk factors aside from my previous obesity.