Understanding My Shoulder Dislocations: MRI Results Are Confusing
User M20 89KG 183CM Smoker Since May of last year, I have experienced six dislocations in my right shoulder, with the latest incident occurring just two weeks ago. I am an MMA fighter and practice Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. During my most recent dislocation, the physician who reset my shoulder had trouble because it repeatedly popped out as he attempted to put it back in place – this happened several times. He harshly remarked that I was 'subhuman,' indicating that my shoulder condition was dire. He recommended that I undergo an MRI scan after the inflammation subsided, so I had the procedure done today. However, the results are perplexing, and here's what they show: MRI Findings: - There is bone marrow edema and contusion in the subchondral area of the right humeral head. - The glenohumeral joint and labrum appear normal. - Tendons of the supraspinatus, subscapularis, infraspinatus, and teres minor muscles are all normal. - The biceps tendon shows no abnormal intensity. - Bone marrow and the humeral head are also normal. I was expecting a recommendation for either a Laterjet or Bankart surgical procedure, yet these results indicate that everything is normal, even though I struggle with basic shoulder movements. To those who might suggest physiotherapy or rehabilitation, I previously committed eight months to physical rehab with the best specialist in my country, but my shoulder dislocated as soon as I resumed training for MMA. Can anyone help me understand how the MRI results appear normal while I am unable to perform simple overhead movements and my shoulder dislocates with minimal effort? It has been disheartening to watch my friends compete and thrive while I deal with this persistent shoulder injury.
Answers (1)
7/15/2025, 1:50:45 PM
OpenHealth AI
I'm sorry to hear about the difficulties you're experiencing with your shoulder. It’s clear this situation is both frustrating and impacting your training and daily activities significantly. Let’s break down the MRI results and your concerns together.
Main Points:
- Your MRI results indicate some bone marrow edema but no significant abnormalities in the surrounding structures.
- Persistent dislocations, despite rehabilitation, suggest issues beyond what the MRI shows, possibly related to instability or muscular control.
Explanation: The MRI findings reveal bone marrow edema, which indicates some level of inflammation or stress in the area, but the structures that usually contribute to dislocations, like the labrum and rotator cuff tendons, appear normal. This can be confusing, especially when your symptoms don’t align with these findings.
It's possible that your shoulder instability may stem from functional issues, such as muscular control or proprioception (awareness of where your shoulder is in space), rather than from structural damage that an MRI might typically reveal. Dislocations in athletes, particularly in contact sports like MMA and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, can occur from a combination of hypermobility, weakness in stabilizing muscles, or neurological factors influencing joint stability.
Next Steps:
-
Focus on Stability Training: Since your previous rehabilitation didn’t yield the desired results, consider seeking a specialist in shoulder instability who can focus on a tailored rehabilitation program. Look for one that combines specific stability exercises, proprioceptive training, and possibly neuromuscular re-education.
-
Soft-Tissue Assessment: It's beneficial to have an assessment by a physiotherapist or sports medicine specialist who specializes in functional movement. They may identify underlying issues that could contribute to instability beyond what the MRI shows.
-
Alternative Therapies: Explore adjunct therapies such as sports massage, acupuncture, or electrical stimulation, which may improve your shoulder's sensitivity and overall stability.
-
Consider a Second Opinion: Given the complexity and ongoing nature of your injury, seeking opinions from another orthopedic specialist might provide alternative insights or recommendations regarding potential surgical options tailored specifically to your case.
Remember, you're not alone in this; many athletes face similar struggles, and finding the right approach may take time and patience. Stay strong, and let me know if you have more questions or need further assistance.
Related Questions
Seeking Guidance on Ice Treatment Post-Surgery
I’m a 34-year-old male, weighing 158 pounds and standing 5 feet 6 inches tall. I lead a non-smoking lifestyle, consume three alcoholic drinks weekly, and do not have any known allergies. I'm currently recovering from right hand and wrist surgery, which took place five weeks ago. I need some advice regarding the use of ice for my treatment, as my wrist remains quite swollen. While I understand the advantages of icing, I find the experience quite intolerable. I attempt to immerse my hand and wrist in ice water completely, but the pain is so intense that I can barely last more than 15 seconds. Is this a challenge of mental resilience where I need to push through the discomfort for the sake of a proper 10-minute soak? In the past, I worked with racehorses, and we would apply ice to their legs for 30-minute sessions, significantly accelerating their recovery. I recognize the effectiveness of this method, yet the pain from the cold is unbearable. Should I endure this discomfort for longer periods?
Rash on My Arm: Should I Be Concerned?
Hi there! I’m a 65-year-old female, and for the past four days, I’ve been dealing with a strange rash on my arm. Unfortunately, I can’t visit a healthcare professional until Monday, so I’m hoping to get some clarity in the meantime. I’ll share some images. If they don’t upload here, I’ll post them in the comments instead. The first image, taken last night, is a bit out of focus, but this morning, the rash has appeared even redder. Although it doesn’t itch now, I did experience some itching during the initial two days. As for my health history, I generally don’t have major health concerns apart from elevated cholesterol levels and a recent A1C reading of 5.9, but I do not have diabetes. I keep fairly active for my age group. During the first couple of days, there was some pus, and I managed to clean it with an alcohol wipe, which helped remove it. Could this be related to a spider bite? I noticed some small spiders (specifically daddy long legs) in my bedroom, especially near the balcony door, and I eliminated a few of them today, so that could be a possibility. Should I be wary of any serious complications from this rash? Any advice would be immensely appreciated! My ER co-payment is quite steep, and there’s no urgent care facility nearby. My only option is to request an appointment with my primary care physician next week, but I’m uncertain if it’s something that warrants immediate attention.
Micronodules Detected in Lung
Hello, I recently underwent a coronary artery calcium (CAC) scan to assess arterial plaque, and I was pleased to receive a favorable score of 7.75. However, the report highlighted the presence of several clustered micronodules located in the right upper lung, accompanied by adjacent ground-glass opacities. I am a 60-year-old male, 6 feet tall and weigh 190 pounds. I do not currently take any medications and generally enjoy excellent health. There is a family history of heart disease on my father's side. Additionally, I am a non-smoker, apart from occasional use of cannabis, and consume alcohol very infrequently. Thank you in advance for any insights you can provide!
Liver Mass Assessment
Patient Profile: - Age: 61 years - Height: 5'9" - Weight: 240 lbs - Gender: Female - Lifestyle: Non-drinker, non-smoker, no illicit drugs Current Medications: - Atenolol 10mg (morning and evening) - Rosuvastatin 40mg (evening) - Duloxetine 60mg (evening) - Spironolactone 25mg (recently added) - Jardiance 10mg (recently added) Medical History: The patient has a notable history of multiple pheochromocytomas and paragangliomas, having undergone surgery on eight occasions. According to scans performed three years ago, two subcentimeter retroperitoneal masses were identified, suggestive of potential paraganglioma. Additionally, she suffers from secondary polycythemia and possesses the PHD1 gene mutation. Previously, she received treatment at a prominent research institution in the United States. However, her endocrinologist has since retired and returned to their home country. Current Condition: At present, she is mostly asymptomatic. However, in January 2026, she experienced a concerning event requiring an ambulance transport to a local emergency room, where her oxygen levels registered at 88-89%. This incident was unsettling, given her extensive medical history. The emergency physician initially diagnosed her with congestive heart failure (CHF), but upon discharge, her family medicine doctor suggested pneumonia. During her hospital stay, a cardiologist—who has never managed a pheochromocytoma patient—recommended a chemical stress test. A CT scan performed on her chest revealed a 3.2 x 2.5 cm mass located in the left lobe of her liver. Her blood tests typically show elevated levels related to pheochromocytomas; however, the laboratory does not conduct resting catecholamine testing, which leads to unreliable results, despite them being consistent over time. Furthermore, she has received care at major hospitals in Minnesota and both leading hospitals in Cleveland, Ohio. Unfortunately, when she required her last surgery, the tumor board declined her case, citing an unfavorable risk-benefit ratio. This leaves her without a specialist in pheochromocytomas. Request for Guidance: The patient is seeking advice or recommendations for her current health situation and management of her conditions.
Concerns About My Daughter's Morning Health Issues
My 17-year-old daughter experiences troubling symptoms each morning, particularly on days when she needs to rise early for school or work. She often wakes up feeling dizzy and nauseated, accompanied by a rapid heartbeat exceeding 100 beats per minute. This situation prevents her from being able to eat and may persist for several hours, or in some cases, throughout the entire day. Standing at 5 feet 8 inches tall (172 cm) and weighing 121 pounds (55 kg), her physical health otherwise seems fine. I have a personal history of inappropriate sinus tachycardia (IST), which is why I take beta-blockers for management. A few years ago, she consulted a cardiologist regarding her frequent episodes of near-fainting, who recommended increasing her water intake and adding more salt to her meals. Given the persistent nature of her symptoms, I am contemplating whether a follow-up appointment with the cardiologist is warranted, especially since all previous tests, including ECG and ultrasound, came back normal. This situation significantly affects her daily life, restricting her ability to engage fully in school and work. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!