Exploring Alternatives to Fecal Transplants
Recently, a friend’s mother was turned down for a fecal transplant, prompting me to search for other possible options for her condition. Though I lack comprehensive details, here’s what I do know: - She's an elderly woman in her early 80s. - She has been suffering from persistent diarrhea for nearly a year, a situation that began after a surgery during which she contracted an infection that wasn’t MRSA but something similar. - As a result of this ongoing issue, she has been largely confined to her home for several months and has lost a considerable amount of weight. - The impact on her mental and physical wellbeing has clearly been severe. - Unfortunately, local healthcare providers appear to be dismissing her plight. - This is occurring in Northern California, not far from the San Francisco area. Given that her body has rejected the idea of a fecal transplant, are there alternative pathways to consider for treatment? What other therapies or lifestyle modifications might be beneficial? I welcome any insights or advice on this matter. Her daughter, who does not live nearby, is becoming increasingly frustrated with the lack of response from her medical team and is uncertain about what further actions to take.
Answers (1)
7/14/2025, 2:10:47 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable that you are concerned about your friend's mother and her ongoing struggles with persistent diarrhea. While fecal transplants can be effective for certain infections, they are not the only option. Given her age and medical history, it's essential to explore safe and appropriate alternatives that may help improve her situation.
Main Points
- Persistent diarrhea requires thorough evaluation to identify the underlying cause.
- Alternative treatments and lifestyle changes can support her health and manage symptoms.
- Close monitoring and nutritional support are critical in her recovery.
Explanation
Persistent diarrhea can have various causes, especially following an infection after surgery. These might include imbalances in gut bacteria, dietary factors, or complications from previous surgeries. In elderly patients, such prolonged gastrointestinal issues can lead to significant weight loss and affect overall health.
Given her situation, it’s important to approach this from both a medical and lifestyle perspective. If her current healthcare providers seem dismissive, it may be beneficial for her daughter to seek a second opinion or consult with a specialist, such as a gastroenterologist, who can provide a more detailed assessment.
Actionable Next Steps
- Nutritional Support: Focus on balanced meals that are easy to digest. Incorporate low-fiber foods initially (like white rice, bananas, applesauce, and toast) while avoiding rich, spicy, or fatty foods to help ease her digestive system.
- Hydration: Encourage regular fluid intake to prevent dehydration. Oral rehydration solutions or clear broths can be very helpful.
- Probiotic Supplements: Consider discussing probiotic supplements with a healthcare provider, as these may help restore gut health if her diarrhea is related to bacteria imbalance.
- Monitor Symptoms: Keep a daily diary of her dietary intake and symptoms. This can help identify triggers and patterns that worsen her condition.
- Explore Additional Treatments: Depending on her diagnosis, medications like anti-diarrheals (if appropriate) or medications to stabilize her gut microbiome might be options worth discussing. Discuss alternatives with a healthcare professional (like specialized dietary protocols or medications).
- Consider Complementary Therapies: Gentle physical activity, like short walks, and stress management techniques (such as mindfulness or breathing exercises) can also be beneficial for her psychological well-being.
If she is not seeing improvement or her condition worsens, it may be necessary for her daughter to advocate more vigorously for her care, possibly seeking out specialists in digestive health or looking into patient advocacy groups for elderly care in her area.
Remember, managing persistent diarrhea can take time, and it’s essential for her to receive support and encouragement throughout this process.
Related Questions
Struggling with Diagnosis: Potential Muscle Myopathy
Profile: 30-year-old male, weighing 190 pounds, originally from Turkey and currently residing in the Netherlands. Main Concern: Persistent muscular fatigue and profound discomfort in the legs. Duration: Symptoms have been notable since June 2025. Health History: No previous medical conditions reported. The individual does not smoke and abstains from alcohol and recreational drugs. There is no familial history of muscular issues. **Background and Progression** The journey began with the adoption of a ketogenic diet alongside rigorous physical training about a year ago, resulting in a rapid weight loss of approximately 10 kilograms. Shortly thereafter, the individual began experiencing constant, bilateral deep muscle discomfort in the legs. Initially attributing this to the body’s adjustment period, the keto diet continued for an additional three months before being halted. Additionally, there was a notable delay in recovery for the upper body after even mild exercise, often requiring one to two weeks for relief. The training regimen was completely abandoned ten months ago. While the upper body fatigue resolved, the leg soreness has persisted. **Symptom Overview** The pain is characterized by its symmetrical nature, alternating locations among muscle groups such as hamstrings, calves, behind the knees, and quadriceps. Symptoms intensify with extended periods of standing or walking, and substantial soreness is present even during rest periods. The upper body feels generally healthy unless subjected to vigorous strength training, where push-ups serve as a self-assessment tool. Completing ten push-ups does not lead to subsequent day issues, but executing more than twenty in a single session results in significant muscle fatigue lasting from seven to ten days. This reaction suggests a difficulty in muscle restoration and recovery. **Medical Evaluations and Findings** - Creatine Kinase (CK) levels: within normal range - Kidney function (eGFR, creatinine): normal - Vitamin D level: at the low end of normal (55 nmol/L) - Thyroid function: normal - Vitamin B12 (holo-transcobalamin): normal - Vascular examination: no signs of peripheral artery disease - Neurological assessment: both muscle strength and sensation were normal, but muscle stiffness was observed. **Current Hypothesis** There is a possibility of a metabolic myopathy contributing to these ongoing symptoms. **Community Inquiry** - Has anyone encountered similar symptoms, particularly following a ketogenic diet or exercise routine? - How did you reach a diagnosis? - What strategies proved effective in managing symptoms or enhancing your overall quality of life?
Update on Severe Anal Bleeding: One Year Later
I am a 29-year-old female, weighing 80 kg and standing 5 feet 7 inches tall. I am diagnosed with Stage 4 Endometriosis, Hypermobility Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hEDS), and Fibromyalgia. After receiving numerous requests for updates from my previous post, I felt it was time to provide one. In my initial post, I discussed my severe issues with hemorrhoids and an anal tear. To clarify, I believe the hemorrhoids developed after experiencing significant bleeding and clotting, potentially exacerbated by the tear. It appears these two conditions have been hindering one another’s healing process. Now, I'm five days post-surgery and the discomfort is quite intense. The procedure involved the removal of four notably large internal hemorrhoids, banding the remaining ones, and a nerve block behind the tear to help alleviate muscle tension and promote healing. My surgeon mentioned that additional hemorrhoids are present, and it’s likely I will need another operation in the future; I have a follow-up scheduled in eight days. Additionally, I received a substantial iron infusion right after the surgery. At this moment, I am still dealing with some bleeding, considerable swelling and bruising, pain, and a degree of prolapse. I'm adhering to a structured pain management regimen where I take my medication at specific intervals. I am also attempting to take as many saltwater baths as possible throughout the day to aid recovery. Any advice or strategies to help me navigate the first couple of weeks during this challenging time would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!
Struggling with Ongoing Abdominal Issues
I’m 37 years old, standing 5 feet 5 inches tall and weighing 205 pounds. In June 2023, I underwent gallbladder removal due to complications, and I have a Mallory Weiss tear. I don’t smoke and have maintained sobriety for approximately five years. The only medications I take are famotidine for occasional heartburn and Excedrin for migraines. My health struggles have persisted for about three years now. My ordeal began in May 2022, and no, I am not expecting a child. I experienced severe vomiting, unable to retain anything in my stomach for more than a few minutes. In that month alone, I lost nearly 70 pounds. After spending four days in the hospital, I was informed that sludge in my gallbladder was inconsequential, and they assured me I was fine—suggesting it was all psychological. After such dismissals, I felt hopeless for a time. Eventually, I began experiencing severe, sharp pain on my side. I underwent two HIDA scans and even participated in a test where I consumed oatmeal and laid still in a scanner for an entire hour, but I ended up vomiting into a basin during the process. Nevertheless, the doctors insisted that everything appeared normal. After a few months of enduring persistent pain, I could no longer tolerate it and had to have my gallbladder surgically removed in June 2023. The gallbladder was swollen and filled with stones, and it was affecting my liver. I had hoped this would finally provide a solution. However, just two months later, I found myself dealing with unexpected vomiting once again. Now, I am facing alarming new discomfort in my right abdomen and can't keep food down at all. Last Friday, I visited the emergency room, only to hear once more that all my tests returned normal. I am at my wits' end—financially and mentally, I can’t keep enduring this cycle. It feels as if food is getting stuck somewhere and never properly digested. At times, even if I manage to keep something down for a couple of hours, it doesn't seem to make it further; I have no forewarning of nausea, and often find myself bolting mid-bite towards a sink or bathroom because it’s already rising. I’ve attempted eliminating dairy and gluten from my diet for a month each, but nothing has improved. The Mallory Weiss tear adds to the frustration, as frequent vomiting aggravates it, resulting in a cycle that seems impossible to break due to the bleeding. I am reaching out in hopes that someone might have insight or suggestions on how to move forward from here.
Struggling with Diagnosis: Possible Metabolic Myopathy
30-year-old male, weighing 190 pounds, originally from Turkey but currently residing in the Netherlands. My primary concern is persistent muscle fatigue in my legs, which I have endured consistently since June 2025. **Medical Background:** I have no prior health issues; I do not smoke, drink alcohol, or use drugs. Furthermore, there is no familial history of muscle disorders. **Background and Progression:** - About a year ago, I adopted a ketogenic diet alongside an intense workout regimen, resulting in a weight loss of approximately 10 kg in a short time. - Shortly after this lifestyle change, I began experiencing continuous and symmetrical pain, as well as deep muscle soreness in both of my legs. - Initially, I thought these symptoms were part of the adjustment to the keto diet and continued with it for three additional months before discontinuing. - Additionally, I found my recovery from upper body workouts to be unusually slow, often taking 1–2 weeks for my muscles to feel normal again. - I completely ceased training 10 months ago. - Since then, while the fatigue in my upper body has improved, the deep soreness in my legs has remained a constant issue. **Summary of Symptoms:** The pain I experience is always symmetrical and concentrated in particular areas. For instance, while my hamstrings ache currently, I find that when I lie down, the discomfort can shift to my calves, the area behind my knees, or my quadriceps. Only when I stand for extended periods do I feel discomfort across all leg muscles at once. The pain intensifies with extended use of the muscles, such as through walking or standing. In contrast, my upper body remains unaffected as long as I avoid heavy strength-based exercises. I sometimes assess my strength through push-ups: - I can perform 10 push-ups without experiencing fatigue the following day. - However, if I attempt 25 push-ups in a single set, I usually suffer from fatigue that lasts between 7 to 10 days afterward, indicating difficulty in muscle recovery. **Additional Insights:** - After stopping the keto diet, I regained approximately 10 kg, but the muscle pain persists. - I have no record of trauma or vascular conditions. **Medical Examination and Findings:** - Creatine Kinase (CK) levels: Normal, indicating no muscle breakdown. - Kidney function (eGFR, creatinine): Normal. - Vitamin D: Low-normal levels (55 nmol/L). - Thyroid function: Normal. - Vitamin B12 (holo-transcobalamin): Normal. - Vascular examination: No signs of peripheral artery disease. - Neurological examination: Muscle strength and sensation were normal, though some stiffness was noted. **Current Hypothesis:** I suspect metabolic myopathy, feeling as if my muscles struggle to regenerate fuel for recovery. However, I remain open to the possibility of an entirely different underlying issue. **Seeking Community Input:** - Has anyone else experienced similar symptoms after starting a ketogenic diet or during extensive training? - What approach led to your diagnosis? - What methods have you found beneficial in managing your symptoms or enhancing your overall well-being?
Desperate Search for Answers in an Unidentified Infection
Basic Details: Male, 27 years old, 6’4”, 138 lbs. Greetings, medical professionals. For the past ten years, my life has drastically deteriorated. Despite consulting numerous physicians and visiting some of Europe's top hospitals, I find myself with limited choices. The only concrete information we have is the discovery of an infectious disease, which was detected through microscopic blood analysis and confirmed by two separate laboratories. Unfortunately, they were unable to specify the pathogen involved and merely concluded their investigations. Determined to pursue answers, I delved into the fundamentals of microscopy and acquired my own microscope. To my surprise, I was able to observe the same organism referenced in the laboratory reports. I have since presented my findings to every medical expert and facility I've consulted. Although they concur that something is amiss, they ultimately declare there’s nothing they can do because subsequent blood tests aimed at identifying the organism have returned negative results. I am eager to try various antimicrobial treatments in the hope that they may provide some relief, yet no physician seems willing to authorize such prescriptions. I continue to be referred to new specialists, but the journey yields no progress. I would greatly appreciate any advice on how to navigate this challenging circumstance. Thank you for taking the time to read my message. In summary: Long-term illness with an unidentified organism found in my blood, unsuccessful identification efforts, and a general reluctance from doctors to pursue treatment options have left me feeling hopeless and out of alternatives.