Is Nissen Fundoplication Possible Without Motility Assessment?
A 20-year-old male, diagnosed with Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1), has been struggling with symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) for the past six years, though he has been actively managing it for the last two years. His primary complaint involves episodes of regurgitation, and there have been occasions where he has awoken during the night due to choking or gasping for breath. Recently, he underwent an endoscopy, which occurred two weeks ago. The findings included Los Angeles Grade B esophagitis, along with a 5 cm hiatal hernia, an inflammatory ulcer, and gastritis. Although he finds relief from proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy, the symptom relief is short-lived; generally, after around two weeks of PPI use, he begins experiencing diarrhea and abdominal cramping. The situation escalates if he continues the medication, ultimately forcing him to discontinue it. On the other hand, he has not experienced any reduction in symptoms when using H2 receptor antagonists. Given the intensity of his symptoms and his lack of response to conventional treatments, his gastroenterologist has recommended surgery. The doctor indicated that it is no longer common practice to conduct motility tests, such as esophageal manometry, when symptoms are as clear-cut and severe as his. However, the individual has come across information suggesting that obtaining insurance approval for surgery without these motility assessments could be challenging. Therefore, he seeks to understand if it is feasible to proceed with the Nissen fundoplication without undergoing additional testing.
Answers (1)
7/7/2025, 9:10:37 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel concerned about the complexity of your situation with GERD and the potential for surgery like Nissen fundoplication. Given your specific context, here’s what you need to know regarding proceeding with surgery without motility testing.
Main Points
- Surgery without Motility Assessment: It's possible to proceed with Nissen fundoplication without additional motility testing in certain cases, especially when your symptoms demonstrate significant reflux issues and structural problems like a hiatal hernia.
- Insurance Approval Considerations: While some insurance companies may request motility testing for surgery approval, your severe symptoms and clinical findings may allow for an exception.
- Symptom Management: It's crucial to manage your symptoms effectively during this process, particularly given your adverse reactions to both PPIs and H2 receptor antagonists.
Explanation
Nissen fundoplication is often recommended for patients with severe GERD, particularly when they experience serious complications, such as the ones you described, including esophagitis and a hiatal hernia. It can indeed be performed without esophageal motility studies if the clinical picture strongly indicates that surgical intervention is needed.
In many cases, when a patient shows clear signs of esophageal damage and has not responded well to medication, surgeons and gastroenterologists feel confident proceeding without motility tests, especially in younger patients. However, the requirement might vary according to the insurance policy, which may sometimes favor comprehensive testing before approving surgery.
Next Steps
- Discuss Options with Your Physician: Make sure to have a clear conversation with your gastroenterologist about your symptoms and the urgent need for surgery. Ask directly whether they can support the decision to proceed without motility testing based on your clinical history.
- Contact Your Insurance Company: Reach out to your insurance provider to clarify their policies on surgical approval for GERD treatments, specifically regarding the necessity of motility testing in your case. This can help you understand what documentation may be required.
- Symptom Management: While navigating these issues, maintain a focus on symptom management. Consider dietary adjustments, such as avoiding trigger foods (spicy, fatty, or acidic foods), eating smaller meals, and not lying down for at least 3 hours after eating to manage regurgitation and discomfort.
This approach will help you advocate effectively for your health needs while minimizing further complications from your condition. Please reach out if you have further questions or need additional guidance.
Related Questions
Persistent Rash: Seeking Answers
Age 24, assigned female at birth, weighing 98 pounds and standing 5'3" tall. I have a history of significant mental health struggles, including severe depression, anxiety, OCD, and tachycardia. Alongside this, I deal with chronic pain issues that remain without a clear diagnosis. I do not consume alcohol, occasionally smoke or vape, and abstain from cannabis and other recreational substances. My current medication regimen includes 450mg of Wellbutrin XL, 7.5mg of Buspar, and I take 50mg of Hydroxyzine for anxiety as needed. I do not take any vitamins regularly and frequently use Ibuprofen. Approximately one week ago, I noticed a rash emerging on my arms and face. Initially, I suspected it to be poison ivy due to my severe allergic reaction to it, especially since I mowed my lawn, which is infested with poison ivy. However, while one patch tends to improve, new ones appear continuously. The majority of these spots are very itchy, though some do not cause itching at all. There are two additional itchy regions: one beside my ear on my face and another on my abdomen. Last night, the patches on my arm resembled hives more than a conventional rash. I visited MinuteClinic for assistance, but the healthcare providers were puzzled. They ruled out poison ivy since the rash keeps reappearing and changing locations. Unfortunately, I cannot identify any allergens that might be causing this issue. There haven't been any alterations in my laundry detergents, dryer sheets, or personal care products. My diet remains consistent, as I prefer a routine, and nothing I eat appears to contribute to the rash. I live with two indoor cats, and I haven’t detected any fleas this season. The rash worsens at night, becoming itchier and more inflamed when I relax either at my desk or on the couch, but not when I’m in bed; I doubt it's bedbugs since the marks don’t resemble bites. Recently, I've noticed that I might be getting new spots shortly after walking on a nearby trail, although I am careful to avoid touching or disturbing anything while out. To manage the rash, I have been alternating between Benadryl cream and hydrocortisone, along with taking Claritin during the day when needed. I applied oral Benadryl one night when the rash appeared more hive-like, and I have been washing my clothing and bedding more frequently. The practitioner at MinuteClinic prescribed a steroid cream that I will begin using tomorrow; I cannot take oral steroids due to personal health reasons, although the physician initially aimed to prescribe those. I tend to have very sensitive skin—band-aids irritate me due to their adhesive, and many detergents and lotions can cause itchiness—however, none of my body care products have changed recently, neither in the past week nor in the past six months. It's essential to mention that my work involves exposure to various chemicals, including urethane plastic, platinum-cure silicone, acrylics, and liquid leaf metallic paint, which I believe contains copper. I initially thought that these substances could be the cause, but if they were, I would expect my entire body to be affected. The rash seems to avoid areas of my skin that are exposed to chemicals, and I haven't used urethane or silicone in the last week, yet new rashes continue to develop. Years ago, I experienced a similar rash that my doctor labeled a "stress rash," which I recall being quite itchy. It eventually subsided after a few weeks of oatmeal baths and a specific ointment. Currently, I find myself under extreme stress—I'm not able to share too many specifics, but I'm on the verge of a breakdown daily. The relentless challenges of life are taking a toll on my mental health. I’m trying hard to allocate time for relaxation, but I feel constantly anxious and overwhelmed. I’m attempting to keep my worries in check; nonetheless, I can't help but feel uneasy since the doctor was unable to definitively identify the rash. My propensity to overthink these matters has me concerned. Thank you in advance for any insights or advice you might have.
Could These Be Anal Warts?
At 24 years old, I've recently discovered an unusual bump near my rear end. To my surprise, I found there are actually two distinct lumps present. Given my sexual history — I engaged in receptive anal intercourse last year — I'm led to suspect they might be anal warts. I did ask my partner to use protection, but it's possible he may have removed the condom during intercourse. I’m curious if anyone else has different theories about this situation. Could these lumps simply be hemorrhoids, or is my mind just running wild?
Urgent Help Needed: Ruptured Cyst in Groin Area with Severe Bleeding and Discomfort
I’m a 21-year-old female who was diagnosed with pelvic inflammatory disease six months ago. After receiving antibiotic treatment, I subsequently noticed the formation of a cyst in my groin, along with several other cysts that may be located deeper within the pelvic region. At the time, I didn’t seek further evaluation since they were not painful. Recently, I’ve been experiencing a persistent dull ache in the area where the cysts are located. Late last night, following a workout session, I had a significant episode of heavy, watery bleeding along with an increase in discomfort. Given that my menstrual cycle occurred last week and I typically do not experience ovulation spotting, I suspect that one of the cysts may have ruptured. I’m uncertain if this is a typical development concerning the cysts or if I should reach out for immediate medical advice. Considering these cysts originated after my PID diagnosis, I am anxious about the possibility of an infection. Although I do not exhibit signs of sepsis, I am dealing with mild pelvic pain and vaginal bleeding that warrants concern.
Feeling Lost and Overwhelmed: Seeking Guidance
I want to start by saying sorry for the disorganized nature of this message. I’m an 18-year-old female who has been struggling with health issues for approximately two years, and things seem to be getting worse. Despite my efforts, my doctors appear unresponsive, repeatedly sending me for blood tests that consistently show mild anemia. I’ve dealt with this mild anemia for as long as I can remember, and while it has improved somewhat over the years, I still face numerous challenges. I also carry some mental health diagnoses, including borderline personality disorder, depression, anxiety, and PTSD, but thankfully, those conditions have been getting better since their initial diagnosis. I’m currently on birth control and sometimes take Omeprazole, which helps with my nausea. Now, onto my main concern… I struggle to work more than 10 hours each week. The instant I stop being active, I drift off to sleep, regardless of whether I'm reading or gaming. Right now, I estimate that I sleep between 12 and 18 hours a day and can’t seem to reduce it. I’m perpetually fatigued, to the point where I fail to take proper care of myself; on many days, I can barely get out of bed except when I need to use the bathroom. When I finally manage to get up and move around, I often experience nausea (along with occasional dizziness) and heart palpitations. I feel lightheaded frequently, even in a seated or lying position. I react more strongly to temperature changes compared to others, whether hot or cold. Stretching can trigger cramps, primarily in my back and calves, and I frequently suffer severe pain in the left side of my chest and abdomen, along with some mild migraines. My joints and lower back are consistently aching, and I tend to wake up in a sweat, even if I started the night feeling chilly. I’m at a loss for what to do next, as I’ve seen numerous doctors who just don’t seem to understand. My health issues are impacting my work, relationships, social life, overall happiness, and even my personal hygiene. I feel like I’m losing my sanity while my doctors remain unconcerned about my condition. At this point, I find myself hoping that something catastrophic happens just to get someone to pay attention. Should I continue fighting for answers, or is this all in my head?
Experiencing New Symptoms After Kidney Stone Issues
Hello, I'm a 29-year-old male reaching out for your valuable insights regarding some concerning health issues I’ve been facing. I realize I might be sharing quite a lot here, but any advice would be immensely appreciated. A few months back, I visited the emergency room due to a kidney stone. I was informed that it should easily pass; however, I don’t believe it has, and it might just be lodged in my bladder, which I understand can happen. Since that time, the initial symptoms of the kidney stone have subsided, but I've noticed that I'm urinating significantly more often. This incident occurred in April, but ever since, I've been plagued by an array of new symptoms that I can't help but think are related. Throughout June, I began to experience some odd, intermittent pains in various spots across my abdomen. On a couple of occasions, I noticed blood in my stool as well. For years, I've struggled with inconsistent bowel movements and probably should have sought help for that before now. In addition, I've found myself grappling with heightened anxiety—or at least, that’s what it feels like. I've had moments of almost drifting off to sleep, only to be abruptly jolted awake for no clear reason. This sensation isn’t limited to brief episodes; I’ve felt this way for several consecutive days. I consulted my primary care physician about these experiences, and he suggested that I might be lactose intolerant or could have irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). He prescribed medication for my anxiety. Additionally, just last week, I noticed a painful sore on my leg that stings during showers, and the hair in that area has fallen out. Today, the sore appears much more inflamed and noticeable. Altogether, these issues seem too numerous to be a mere coincidence. I voiced my concerns to my doctor, expressing that I feel like my body may be signaling something deeper, beyond just lactose intolerance or anxiety. More recently, I’ve been experiencing sharp pains and discomfort in my back near the shoulder blades, as well as in my wrists and knees. Accompanying this is a significant level of fatigue, which has persisted for the past couple of years. This situation has brought me immense worry, and it's affecting my daily life in a major way. I genuinely seek your insights or opinions on what I might be dealing with. It’s been several months, and all I want is to return to a sense of normalcy!