Inquiring About the Need for an MRI Regarding Possible Chiari Malformation
I am a 21-year-old female with asthma and hypothyroidism currently managed with levothyroxine, Wellbutrin, albuterol, and birth control. I’m reaching out for guidance on whether it would be sensible to request an MRI. **Quick summary: After experiencing two simultaneous concussions, I dealt with lingering issues for years. My symptoms have resurfaced strongly, including headaches, tremors, debilitating fatigue, brain fog, eye disturbances, and tingling in my fingers resulting in dropping items.** Four years ago, I sustained a concussion due to a careless incident. Sadly, a month later, while still recovering, I had another impact where I was struck on the nose and my neck jerked considerably. This began a challenging period of relentless headaches that lasted an astonishing two years, during which even prescription medications provided little relief. I also noticed a significant decline in cognitive function; tasks I once excelled at in mathematics became extremely difficult. * While my headaches had moments of respite, going from daily occurrences to several each week, they have recently returned with a vengeance. I now experience headaches 5 to 7 days a week, characterized as a dull ache primarily at the back and crown of my head, fluctuating between 2 out of 10 to an 8 out of 10 in severity. My sensitivity to odors, sounds, and bright lights has drastically increased, and I consistently suffer from neck discomfort akin to having slept awkwardly, accompanied by frequent nausea that makes eating challenging. Applying ice packs for about 40 minutes offers some temporary comfort, yet the relief is fleeting, necessitating my reliance on maximum dosages of Tylenol nearly every day. * Additional symptoms include hand tremors that particularly intensify after any physical exertion. Even a brief stroll causes shaking reminiscent of my uncle's experiences with Parkinson's disease. * An overwhelming fatigue engulfs me, described best as a complete lack of kinetic energy; although my heart beats, I feel utterly immobile. Routine activities, like walking through a mall, often leave me feeling lightheaded. * My memory has significantly deteriorated, resulting in a constant brain fog that makes classroom participation challenging. I often find myself struggling to write notes, as I can read one line then falter at writing even two words before needing to double-check the text again; this level of forgetfulness feels abnormal. * Furthermore, my eyes struggle to focus, particularly on small details or lines. I frequently experience involuntary twitching that disrupts my reading, almost mimicking a reflex called nystagmus, although I suspect it differs (I’ve posted about this previously). * I also often drop items that I am holding, including a hot cup of tea. I experience frequent numbness in my fingers and, at times, in my limbs. **Regarding my headaches:** they are characterized by a combination of pain and intense PRESSURE. At times, I fantasize about a dramatic solution like slicing open my skull to relieve it. Scenes in shows depicting burr holes trigger a visceral need within me, akin to craving food. While I recognize the dangers of self-diagnosing through online sources, Chiari malformation presents itself as the most coherent explanation for my symptoms. The only route to diagnosis is through an MRI. Previously, I underwent an MRI shortly after my second concussion, which indicated no issues; however, I am aware that Chiari can develop gradually following trauma. **Would it be prudent to consider requesting another MRI?** I can no longer access my MRI records, but I do have a brief video displaying some images if anyone is interested.
Answers (1)
7/3/2025, 12:02:09 AM
OpenHealth AI
Based on the detailed symptoms and history you provided, it sounds like you are experiencing significant distress related to your health. Given your concerns about Chiari malformation, it may be wise to consider requesting another MRI. Here’s a structured response to guide your next steps:
Main Points:
- Consider the possibility of Chiari malformation: Your symptoms and history warrant evaluation for this condition, especially after multiple concussions.
- Requesting an MRI may be prudent: A follow-up MRI can help assess any changes since your last scan and determine if Chiari malformation or other issues could be contributing to your symptoms.
Explanation:
Chiari malformation occurs when brain tissue extends into the spinal canal, and it can sometimes develop or worsen after head trauma. Your symptoms—including persistent headaches, cognitive difficulties, and hand tremors—can align with this condition, though they may also be related to other issues stemming from your concussions.
Since you previously had an MRI that showed no abnormalities but are now experiencing a resurgence of symptoms, another scan might be useful. Chiari malformation can evolve, and a new MRI could provide clearer insights.
Actionable Next Steps:
-
Document Your Symptoms: Continue to keep a detailed record of your symptoms, including their frequency, duration, and any triggers. This information can support your request for an MRI and help clinicians understand your condition better.
-
Consult with Your Healthcare Provider: Reach out to your primary care physician or a neurologist to discuss your symptoms comprehensively. Clearly express your concerns regarding Chiari malformation and request a new MRI based on your symptom history and current issues.
-
Explore Symptom Management: In the meantime, consider employing management strategies for your headaches, such as:
- Staying hydrated and maintaining a consistent sleep schedule.
- Using relaxation techniques or mindfulness to help reduce sensitivity and anxiety.
- Identifying and avoiding known headache triggers, including certain foods, stress, or prolonged screen time.
-
Stay Informed: Be proactive in discussing your treatment options with your doctor. Share any relevant research you have found about Chiari malformation, and ask about referrals to specialists if needed.
-
Consider Support Networks: Engaging with support groups or communities online may provide emotional support and coping strategies as you navigate your symptoms and seek a diagnosis.
Please remember that while self-advocacy is important, maintaining communication with healthcare professionals is crucial for proper diagnosis and care. You're taking a proactive step in seeking clarity about your health, and that is commendable.
Related Questions
Expectorated Large Tissue with Blood
At 28 years old, I experienced a fever the previous night, after which I had no other cold symptoms. To my surprise, today I coughed just once and expelled a significant piece of tissue mixed with blood. Following this alarming incident, I sought medical attention at an urgent care facility because I developed a headache immediately afterward and felt a peculiar "butterfly" sensation in my chest. The healthcare professionals did not conduct any laboratory tests or imaging studies, instead opting to prescribe antibiotics for what they suspected might be an infection. Is this an appropriate response to my situation? This is quite concerning.
Understanding Kidney Pain: Should You Be Concerned?
As a 15-year-old assigned female at birth (AFAB), I've been dealing with acid reflux, although I've been neglecting to take any supplements. I also have scoliosis, which I doubt is linked to my current issue. Recently, I have been experiencing pain in my kidney area, specifically in my back, where my kidneys are situated. My mother suggested that this discomfort might indeed stem from my kidneys. For several months now, I haven't pinpointed the cause. I typically consume about 1 to 1.5 liters of water daily, and occasionally I drink cola, though I've reduced that due to my reflux. I sometimes have peach juice or plain tea, but those drinks have become quite infrequent. Despite my fluid intake, it seems my pain level remains consistent regardless of what I drink. The pain primarily affects my right kidney, but during more intense episodes, I also feel discomfort in my left kidney. I've tried lying down and applying gentle pressure to the area, which provides a bit of relief. Aside from occasional bladder discomfort today, I haven't experienced any additional pain that relates to my kidneys, aside from the persistent back pain from scoliosis and the usual stomach and chest pains from my reflux. Is it necessary for me to consult a doctor about this concern? 🥺 I am hesitant to go unless it's truly serious because I was hospitalized last summer due to undiagnosed tics and twitches—likely anxiety-related—and I spent the entire winter seeing doctors for this issue and my scoliosis. I’m also worried about missing school due to more medical appointments, especially since my doctor has a packed schedule, and I'm uncertain if she would prioritize my concern if it doesn't seem urgent. When I was hospitalized last summer, tests including urine and blood analysis showed no significant issues, so I'm unsure whether this warrants another visit now.
Persistent Shin Discomfort
For the past year, I have been grappling with ongoing discomfort in my shins. Despite consulting multiple physiotherapists and doctors, I have yet to find a solution to my problem. My routine has included extensive strength training targeting my hips, glutes, calves, and lower leg muscles. I've also taken steps to improve my running form and have experimented with various recovery techniques, such as foam rolling and using massage devices. No matter what I try, the pain persists, specifically on the inner side of my lower legs. Initially, I suspected that I was suffering from shin splints. However, given my varied attempts at treatment and the lack of improvement, I am starting to believe that the issue might be something different. Even mundane activities, like walking around at home, have become increasingly uncomfortable, not to mention my inability to ride a stationary bike without experiencing pain. If anyone has any insights or recommendations that could assist me in alleviating this issue, I would be extremely grateful. Thank you for your help! I'm a 20-year-old male, standing at 5 feet 8 inches and weighing 70 kilograms.
Experiencing Uncertainty: Possible Ischemic Attack?
Greetings, everyone, including healthcare professionals. For the past year, I've been managing high blood pressure, and I'm currently prescribed a regimen that includes Amlodipine at 10 mg and Bisoprolol at 5 mg. At 44 years old, I’m a woman who is classified as overweight and also deals with hypothyroidism, low ferritin levels, liver issues, and slightly elevated cholesterol levels. Typically, my medications maintain my blood pressure within a range of 110/70 to 140/80. However, two days ago, I experienced a stressful episode, causing my systolic pressure to spike to 155/95. Upon standing, I sensed weakness in my left arm, which felt as if it were slightly twisting. A wave of panic hit me, and I feared I might be incapacitated or having a stroke. Despite my anxiety, I was still able to grasp a glass and tightly close my fist. Briefly, my right arm felt a mild sensation that lasted only a second. This peculiar feeling persisted for roughly a minute. I then consumed some mint tincture mixed with alcohol and engaged in deep breathing exercises, which remarkably alleviated my symptoms and brought my blood pressure back to a stable level. I contacted my physician, who inquired about my symptoms and their duration. Aside from the discomfort in my arm, I wasn't experiencing any additional issues. A second doctor relieved me of any immediate concerns regarding the necessity for an MRI, and since I underwent one a month prior that showed no abnormalities in my cranial blood vessels, I felt some reassurance. Now, back home and with lingering fears of having experienced an ischemic attack, I wonder if an ultrasound of the neck arteries is warranted. Do my symptoms indicate a potential attack? What steps should I take next? Has anyone faced a similar situation? Thank you all for your insights.
Concerns About Potential Misdiagnosis
Hello everyone, I recently stumbled upon this subreddit and felt it would be the ideal platform to share my experience. I initially posted something similar under r/Asthma but soon realized that this community might be more appropriate for my concerns. To provide some context, I’m a 25-year-old woman with no personal history of smoking, although I have been heavily exposed to secondhand smoke throughout my life. There is a family history of asthma and COPD on my side. I was diagnosed with asthma during childhood but seemed to outgrow it as I got older. Throughout my younger years, I frequently battled respiratory and sinus infections, and in my teenage years, I suffered a severe case of walking pneumonia. Following that episode, my breathing worsened significantly, prompting my doctor to reinstate the asthma diagnosis and prescribe albuterol inhalers without performing any additional tests except for an X-ray to confirm the pneumonia had resolved. Over the years, I’ve noticed a gradual worsening of my symptoms. Each primary care physician I've consulted has prescribed various inhalers and medications, but the relief they provide has been minimal. For years, I have dealt with a persistent dry cough described as that of a seasoned smoker, yet my doctors continuously assured me it was merely asthma, claiming that my inhalers would alleviate it. When a coughing fit does occur, it can be so intense that I end up gagging, losing control of my bladder, and feeling dizzy. Fast forward to two weeks ago: my cough intensifies with physical activity, and I have a physically demanding job. Typically, my inhaler assists me with breathing, but in this instance, it was ineffective, and emergency services were called to administer oxygen. My oxygen saturation dropped to 93% until the oxygen and my rescue inhaler were applied. I declined hospitalization after feeling better with the oxygen. I took a day off work to recuperate. I managed to see my primary care doctor afterward. Having been on Advair and albuterol for years, I was also prescribed Singulair last year due to flare-ups. In my recent visit, my doctor substituted my Ventolin (albuterol) with Airsupra and introduced Spiriva, along with short courses of Mucinex and Prednisone. At the appointment, my lungs sounded clear, and my oxygen levels were between 99-100%. There was no wheezing, just persistent coughing. Returning to work the following Thursday proved challenging; within three hours, I experienced another severe coughing episode that felt as if my throat might rupture. I was gagging, tearing up, and struggling to remain upright, feeling dizzy and breathless. Several doses of my rescue inhaler provided little relief, and emergency services were contacted again; I was subsequently transported to the emergency room. My oxygen saturation was stable at 97-100%, yet I continued to feel breathless and my painful coughing persisted. Respiratory treatments seemed to exacerbate the coughing, and magnesium failed to provide relief. Both the paramedics and ER staff expressed concern when I mentioned my chronic cough that had persisted for years without improvement. Initially, emergency responders detected only a faint wheeze and diminished lung sounds on one side, although they later reported normal findings. No fluid or wheezing was noted, just continued coughing. CT scans and X-rays of my throat and chest returned normal results. After three days in the hospital, my lactic acid and CO2 levels returned to normal. Despite being treated with steroids and cough suppressants, I found no alleviation of my symptoms. I have now received urgent referrals to a pulmonologist, an ENT specialist, and an allergist, and I recently followed up with my primary care physician. Her only recommendation was cough drops and to wait for my upcoming Pulmonary Function Test (PFT). Additionally, the hospital prescribed Pantoprazole for potential GERD, which hasn't significantly helped. My follow-up blood tests revealed that while my CO2 levels improved, they still remain low, and there are no current indications of an autoimmune disorder, though I am awaiting several results. After undergoing the Pulmonary Function Test, the findings were unusual. Though I await an appointment with the pulmonologist, I reviewed the notes from my test. They indicated, "Spirometry is normal. Lung volumes demonstrate hyperinflation and air trapping. Diffusing capacity is normal. No substantial bronchodilator response observed." When I inquired with the technician who administered the test, she mentioned two possibilities: either my lungs weren't inflamed enough to demonstrate a response, which seemed unlikely considering my extensive coughing fits, or the underlying issue might be irreparable with medications. This situation has left me anxious that I may be dealing with more than just severe asthma. For years, I communicated to my doctors that my condition seems to deteriorate, and that none of the prescribed medications eased my cough, yet they continuously reassured me that it was manageable. Now, after being hospitalized, I recognize the critical need to take this seriously. I rarely experience wheezing or fluid but instead contend with a persistent cough similar to that of a long-term smoker. My cough worsens with movement, eating, drinking, taking deep breaths, lying down, waking up, laughing, excessive talking, exposure to extreme temperatures, dry or humid air, stress, and irritants such as dust, smoke, and potent odors. It feels like merely existing prompts my coughing. Although I always have a cough, the triggers mentioned intensify it. I frequently feel congestion in my throat and chest, accompanied by a tight and painful sensation. I have the incessant urge to clear out whatever feels obstructive, but nothing ever emerges. My coughing often leads to dizziness and incontinence. If I'm not actively coughing, I seem to be clearing my throat repeatedly to manage the mucus. During any illness, my cough tends to worsen, resulting in the need for prednisone. Antihistamines provide partial relief solely for nasal symptoms, without helping my throat and chest. When my rescue inhaler does work, its effectiveness lasts only for a short time before I revert to my previous condition. My lungs may feel momentarily unobstructed thanks to the albuterol, but the coughing inevitably returns until my chest aches again. An ER doctor suggested possible diagnoses of Chronic Rhinosinusitis, Post-Nasal Drip, or GERD; however, medications for allergies and acid reflux have not meaningfully addressed my coughing or breathlessness. It does not seem connected to my sinuses but rather feels like my airways are obstructed, hindering deep breaths. Until I meet with the pulmonologist, my best hypothesis has been Cough-Variant Asthma, but given the lack of response to bronchodilators in my PFT, my confidence in that is wavering. In reviewing my results, I cannot help but consider the early stages of COPD or emphysema, especially since my breathing seems to worsen over time, although my age typically mitigates those concerns given my extensive exposure. I've ordered a test for Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency from AlphaID to discuss with my pulmonologist just in case. I am certain I have asthma, but I’m beginning to suspect that there may be additional complications involved. For years, my primary care provider dismissed my concerns, despite my insistence that something felt off. It wasn’t until I required EMS intervention that she finally began the referral process to specialists. I find myself in a state of confusion and unease. Has anyone here experienced anything resembling my situation? I'm looking forward to consulting with the pulmonologist about my test results in the coming week or two, but I’m apprehensive that they will simply dismiss my concerns like previous practitioners have done.