Conflicting Medical Opinions on Orthopedic Surgery for Elderly Patient
Hello, I’d like to gain insights from healthcare professionals regarding a situation concerning my father. Recently, my 77-year-old dad suffered a clavicle fracture near his left shoulder while visiting his hometown. Initially, he received treatment from a local physician who placed a bandage and sling on his injury and advised against surgery due to his advanced age. After returning home, he opted to consult with an orthopedic specialist, and I accompanied him for that visit. This new physician suggested surgical intervention involving the insertion of a plate and screws to facilitate the healing of the fracture. Unfortunately, the estimated cost for this procedure exceeded our financial capabilities, leading my father to revert to the first doctor’s recommendation of avoiding surgery. The orthopedic surgeon noted that without surgical intervention, my dad's chances of proper recovery were about 50/50, warning that he might lose the ability to raise his arms fully. I am curious as to why there were such stark differences in the doctors’ recommendations regarding my father’s treatment. What are the potential complications of surgery for someone in his age group? Ultimately, what would be the most advisable approach to take in his situation? I appreciate any guidance you can offer. Thank you.
Answers (1)
6/28/2025, 2:40:38 PM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel uncertain when confronted with conflicting medical opinions, especially regarding your father's health and the treatment of his clavicle fracture. The two doctors have different approaches based on their assessments, which can stem from various factors, including your father's overall health, the specifics of his fracture, and his age.
Key Points:
-
Differences in Treatment Recommendations: The first doctor believes that surgery might pose more risks than benefits given your father's age and offers a conservative treatment approach. In contrast, the orthopedic surgeon favors surgery to more effectively heal the fracture and prevent long-term mobility issues.
-
Potential Complications of Surgery: For elderly patients, possible complications from surgery include:
- Increased Risk of Infection: Surgery always carries a risk of infection, which can be more serious in older adults.
- Anesthesia Risks: Older patients may have a higher risk of adverse reactions to anesthesia.
- Longer Recovery Time: Recovery might take longer due to other health conditions that are more common with age, like heart disease or diabetes.
Recommended Approach:
To make an informed decision about your father's treatment, consider the following steps:
-
Gather More Information: Encourage open discussions with both doctors to clarify why they recommend their respective treatments. Ask specific questions about the risks and benefits of each option, especially concerning your father's health and lifestyle.
-
Consider a Third Opinion: If possible, seeking a third opinion from another orthopedic specialist may provide a broader perspective and help clarify the best course of action.
-
Evaluate Non-Surgical Options: Discuss alternative treatments with the doctors, such as physical therapy or pain management strategies that can promote healing without surgery.
-
Support and Comfort: It’s essential to involve your father in the decision-making process, allowing him to express his preferences and concerns about surgery and recovery.
-
Financial Concerns: If cost is an issue, ask the orthopedic surgeon if there are any options for payment plans or financial assistance, which might make surgery more feasible if it is the preferred route.
Conclusion:
Ultimately, the decision should weigh the potential benefits of surgery against the associated risks and your father's personal values and preferences. Ongoing communication with healthcare professionals will be key in navigating this decision.
Related Questions
Prolonged Miscarriage: Over Four Weeks In
A 35-year-old woman managing Type 1 diabetes with an insulin pump has been experiencing a challenging period marked by a recent miscarriage. This occurred just shy of ten weeks into the pregnancy, following an extremely positive pregnancy test, although medical confirmation had not yet been obtained. The physical symptoms were quite severe, with substantial bleeding that included large tissue clumps and blood clots observed during a shower. The size of these clots was rather alarming, comparable to a fist, causing blockage in the drain. Initially, for the first three to four days, there was heavy bleeding, requiring three pads daily. After that, the situation gradually improved, and around a week ago, she reached a point where only a pantyliner might suffice. Despite the reduction, bleeding persisted intermittently, mainly noticeable upon wiping, with instances of no blood at all, leading to inconsistencies in her experience. Recently, she has been feeling bloated and has noticed a resurgence in bleeding, necessitating the use of pads twice daily. Additionally, she has been experiencing light cramps and has developed acne. A subsequent pregnancy test revealed continued positive results. Now, with over four weeks of bleeding, she reached out to her physician’s office. However, the response was not one of concern, suggesting that she could schedule a visit at her convenience if she felt the need. The cost of visiting a doctor or urgent care deters her from seeking immediate professional help unless absolutely warranted. Overall, she reports feeling generally well, but is seeking advice from others. Is there cause for alarm, or is it feasible to let things unfold naturally? Could this miscarriage have evolved into her menstrual cycle instead? Additionally, it's worth noting that she occasionally finds small blood clots on the toilet paper after wiping. Since the onset of this situation, she has abstained from sexual intercourse.
Concerns After Gallbladder Surgery (Three Weeks Post-Op) - Is It an Infection?
Profile: - Age: 35 - Gender: Female - Height: 5 feet 4 inches - Weight: 160 pounds - Ethnicity: Asian Duration of Symptoms: Last Three Weeks Location: United States Recent Medical History: Nearly three weeks have passed since my gallbladder removal surgery. Over the last few days, I've noticed a small amount of unclear fluid coming from the incision. I just observed what seems to be pus oozing from the surgical site. Although there is slight tenderness when I move or touch the area, it isn't painful. Thankfully, I haven’t experienced any fever or chills, and there’s no unpleasant odor emanating from the wound. Should I continue to clean it with soap and water, or is it necessary for me to visit the emergency room for further evaluation?
Navigating Ear Infections While Traveling in Thailand
**Age:** 23 **Height:** 6'3" **Weight:** 88 kg **Medication Taken:** 1000mg Bactoclav - Amoxicillin with Potassium Clavulanate, along with pain relief and antihistamines. **Summary:** I’m hesitant to consult a doctor overseas only to receive a prescription for the same antibiotics available at a local pharmacy for a fraction of the price. What strategies can I employ to effectively manage this persistent ear infection? Am I being too hasty in my expectations? I have a long history of ear infections, often triggered by exposure to water or any activity impacting my ears. I regularly use a specialized oil before showering to prevent water from entering my ears. While backpacking in Thailand, I've developed a particularly severe ear infection over the last several days. Initially, a course of 500mg amoxicillin seemed effective, but significantly, just yesterday my condition took a downturn, shifting from nearly healed to painfully inflamed. Now, my ear is not only swollen but also incredibly sore. In an attempt to combat this, I’ve been taking 1000mg Bactoclav - Amoxicillin and Potassium Clavulanate, having consumed seven tablets in the last two days; unfortunately, there's been no noticeable improvement. I’m reluctant to seek medical attention, fearing I would be prescribed the same medication I could acquire from a pharmacy, albeit at a much higher cost. Yet, I’m also starting to question the efficacy of the pharmacy’s medication. I’ve only recently begun the stronger treatment since my symptoms returned. Any advice would be greatly valued! In addition, I’d like to share that just a week into my four-month journey, I feel as though my ongoing ear issues are gradually dominating my life. I am incredibly grateful for this travel opportunity, and while my health isn’t at risk in a serious way, these ear complications are becoming quite overwhelming. Could there be surgical options available? Might there be an underlying health concern that I’m unaware of? It doesn’t seem normal to be plagued by constant ringing, popping sounds, and wax buildup in my ears. Moreover, it feels excessive to have to apply products in my ears every time I shower.
Injury to the Sciatic Nerve
At 25 years old and weighing 135 pounds, I am currently taking naproxen and Lyrica to manage my sciatic nerve injury. The pain in my right leg has made it incredibly difficult for me to remain upright. It’s been two weeks since I first sought treatment; I consulted a physician who advised medication and attended a physiotherapy session. Initially, I experienced some relief after the appointment, but unfortunately, the pain returned the following day—even the prescribed home exercises exacerbated my discomfort. Just yesterday, I attempted the cobra pose, along with the flossing technique, which only heightened my pain. I find it nearly impossible to stand for more than a few seconds before the discomfort becomes intolerable. Additionally, I have an appointment with an osteopath on Tuesday, but I can't shake off my worries— is it normal to still struggle with walking after two weeks? Although I am experiencing some numbness in my toes, I haven’t encountered any loss of bladder or bowel control, worsening numbness, or weakness in my legs, so I feel stable in that regard. Nonetheless, I fear the possibility of never fully recovering and being left with a lasting disability. The pain is overwhelming, adding to my anxiety about the future.
Inquiry Regarding Metronidazole Use for Recurrent Bacterial Vaginosis
I am a 32-year-old female, measuring 5 feet 5 inches tall and weighing 248 pounds. My current medications include Vyvanse at a dosage of 40mg, a medication for asthma, vitamin D, a 325mg iron supplement, and as of now, I am also taking amoxicillin to treat strep throat. I am about to begin using Metronidazole 0.75% Vaginal Gel, with a total of 70 grams available. The instructions indicate that I should administer 5 grams vaginally twice a day for seven days, followed by twice a week for a period of two months. During the initial treatment phase when I will apply the gel twice daily, I anticipate abstaining from sexual activity. However, once I transition to the twice-weekly application, is it permissible to engage in sexual intercourse? I would normally consult my physician about this matter, but she is currently unavailable, and the nurse is also out of the office, which is quite frustrating.