OpenHealth Q&A

Get answered by medical professionals

Concerns Regarding Potential Polycythemia Vera Diagnosis

6/28/2025, 6:50:22 AMMale25-34

25-year-old male | Occasional smoker | No significant health problems I find myself in a complicated situation with conflicting opinions from various healthcare professionals regarding my potential diagnosis. In January, my complete blood count (CBC) displayed the following results: - Hemoglobin (HGB): 17 - Hematocrit (HCT): 50 I visited a hematologist (referred to as Hem-1) who recommended that I undergo testing, including an erythropoietin (EPO) assessment and a myeloproliferative neoplasm (MPN) reflex panel. The results were as follows: - EPO level: 6.6 - MPN panel: All tests returned negative for the mutations tested (Jak2 V617F, Exon 12, CALR, MPL, BCR/ABL1). Hem-1 advised me not to worry excessively and suggested donating one unit of blood, with plans to revisit around late June with updated results. Yesterday, I received my latest results, which indicated: - Hemoglobin: 16.2 - Hematocrit: 48.3 Although I intended to discuss these findings with Hem-1, he was unavailable, so I saw another hematologist (Hem-2) who presented an intriguing interpretation of my situation. Hem-2 explained that while I do not exhibit signs of MPNs, my normal EPO level suggests that secondary polycythemia can be excluded (since EPO would typically be elevated in such cases). He concluded that my condition might signify a primary variant of polycythemia vera (PV). Additionally, I noted that before these recent events, my blood work from 2021 showed values of Hemoglobin: 16.8 and Hematocrit: 49. This raises a question: if I indeed have PV, why have my levels not escalated over the past two years? Furthermore, can an EPO level of 6.6 genuinely rule out smoking as a contributing factor to my blood counts? I would appreciate any insights into my situation!

DiabetesCOPDEndocrinology

Answers (1)

Cony

6/28/2025, 6:50:43 AM

OpenHealth AI

Your situation regarding the potential diagnosis of polycythemia vera (PV) can understandably feel overwhelming, especially with the different interpretations from various healthcare professionals. It's important to focus on the key points and clarify what steps you can take next.

Main Points:

  1. Your latest blood tests show stable hemoglobin and hematocrit levels, which is encouraging.
  2. The normal erythropoietin (EPO) level supports the conclusion that secondary causes of polycythemia are less likely, though smoking can be a contributing factor.
  3. The current lack of significant escalation in your blood counts over the past two years raises questions about the nature of your condition, whether PV or another issue.

Explanation:

  • Erythropoietin and Polycythemia: EPO is a hormone that stimulates red blood cell production. Elevated levels often indicate that your body is responding to low oxygen levels (like from smoking or other health conditions). A normal level typically suggests primary causes, such as PV, rather than secondary causes like smoking.
  • Primary vs. Secondary Polycythemia: Primary PV is a condition where your bone marrow produces too many red blood cells without a compensatory mechanism (like low oxygen). In secondary polycythemia, levels are elevated due to external factors (e.g., chronic hypoxia from smoking or other diseases).
  • Stability of Levels: The stability of your hemoglobin and hematocrit values over two years, even in the context of a suspected primary PV, is atypical for what would usually be expected if the disease were progressing. This could suggest your body has reached a sort of equilibrium.

Next Steps:

  1. Monitor Symptoms: Keep an eye out for any symptoms of polycythemia vera, such as headaches, dizziness, visual disturbances, or high blood pressure. Tracking these can provide valuable information for your next appointment.

  2. Continued Communication with Hematologists: Continue discussing your concerns openly with both Hem-1 and Hem-2 when you see them next. Express your questions about the lack of progression in your blood levels and how smoking may be influencing your condition.

  3. Lifestyle Adjustments: If you're an occasional smoker, consider reducing or quitting smoking altogether, as this can improve overall health and potentially influence your blood cell counts. If you need support or resources to quit, there are many programs and tools available.

  4. Regular Monitoring: Follow up on regular blood tests as recommended, and ensure you keep track of any changes in your health.

  5. Consider a Multidisciplinary Approach: If you continue to feel uncertain or unsettled by the conflicting opinions, speaking with another specialist or a second hematologist may provide further clarity.

Your health is your top priority, and while conflicting opinions can be confusing, staying informed and proactive will help you navigate your diagnosis effectively. Let me know if you have any more questions or need further clarification!

Related Questions

Should I Seek Medical Attention for a Possible Spinal Injury?

Greetings! I’m a 20-year-old male, and while I’m not overly anxious about my situation, I've been experiencing enough discomfort to consider it. Three days prior, I went snowboarding and attempted to navigate a box, which is essentially a flat metal structure with a slight ramp at the end. Unfortunately, I lost my balance close to the end of the box and landed squarely on my backside. This caused my back and head to make hard contact with the ground. At first, I didn’t perceive much pain in my back or head; instead, the primary source of pain seemed to be my rear, which felt as if it had developed a noticeable lump. However, I dismissed it at the time. The following day, the soreness persisted, alongside generalized discomfort throughout my upper body. Every time I coughed, I felt pain that radiated from my neck down to my abdomen, which was tender to the touch. I asked my girlfriend to check for any visible injuries, and although my butt showed no bruising, I did notice around five bruises along my spine. I’m questioning whether I should consult a physician. I usually avoid going to the doctor unless absolutely necessary, having only visited twice in the last four years (excluding vaccinations during my teenage years). I tend to prefer toughing things out to save on medical expenses, but if the situation warrants it, I wouldn’t hesitate to seek help as I did last year for an ear infection. What do you think – should I consider getting checked out?

COPDInternal MedicineRheumatology
Male25-34
30 minutes ago

Light Pink Discharge After Urination

Just yesterday, after using the restroom, I spotted a faint pink hue on the toilet paper. Initially, I thought it might indicate the start of my menstrual cycle, especially since I didn’t have my period last month during the last week of January. However, today I haven't noticed any blood, and I don't anticipate any appearing this week or even the next. Additionally, I observed small traces of blood in my urine during the week my period was supposed to arrive. While I do experience some hormonal symptoms, I’m uncertain about their meaning. Thankfully, I haven’t felt any burning sensations, but I find myself feeling confused and, to be honest, a bit anxious about the situation. I maintain an average weight, I’m not on any medications, and I do not smoke.

Thyroid DisordersEndocrinologyRheumatology
Male25-34
40 minutes ago

Factors Influencing Rapid Advancement of Leprosy

I'm an 18-year-old assigned female at birth, standing at 5'11" and weighing 150 pounds. I've ceased taking any antibiotics or other prescribed medications, with the exception of haloperidol. I smoke and drink, but I don't engage in drug use. My ethnicity is Caucasian. Additionally, I have several other health issues, including anemia, scoliosis, endometriosis, and ovarian complications. I find myself unwilling to endure this condition for the next two decades. Currently, my health feels precarious. My wounds take an excruciatingly long time to heal or sometimes don't heal at all. I experience numbness or a tingling sensation in my hands, where the skin resembles that of a reptile, likely due to my fingers being either broken or oddly bent, possibly infected as well. My arms, legs, and face are covered in lesions, primarily due to these unhealed wounds. Furthermore, I deal with mild muscle weakness, a condition that began during my time playing football as a lineman, accompanied by numerous injuries that still haven’t fully recovered. I find myself wishing for a more rapid progression of this disease so that I can reach a point of resolution, as I feel irreparably damaged and have turned down treatment out of deep-seated self-loathing. Is there any way to accelerate this? I should mention, though it may not be directly related: my scars have a purplish hue, and I've noticed small visible 'holes' near these scars on my left arm—at least four that I've identified—while my left hand seems to be in the worst condition. Thank you for listening. Goodbye.

ArthritisLupusEndocrinology
Male25-34
40 minutes ago

Understanding Prednisone Usage and Withdrawal

A 38-year-old woman, measuring 5’10 and weighing 125 pounds, with no smoking or drinking habits and a background of autoimmune disease, encountered a viral infection in December. In response to her condition, a specialist recommended a tapering regimen starting with a 40mg dose of prednisone for five days, followed by a gradual reduction through 30mg, 20mg, and 10mg over a total period of 20 days. After completing the course and halting the medication, she experienced severe symptoms approximately 36 hours later, including intense vomiting, debilitating headaches, and widespread pain throughout her body. Any physical contact provoked discomfort, leaving her in distress. Unable to reach her original provider, she consulted another physician who prescribed a lower dosage of 4mg of prednisone, instructing her to decrease the amount by 1mg every three days. Remarkably, she felt relief upon returning to the 4mg dose. However, she expressed concern regarding the potential effects when she ultimately weans off the medication entirely. She is seeking guidance on whether this method of tapering is typical and which specialist might be best suited to manage her prednisone treatment moving forward.

ArthritisLupusEndocrinology
Male25-34
1 hour ago

Recurring Mysterious Rash Every Year, All Tests Negative

Hello everyone! I'm an 18-year-old female, and I don't consume alcohol, smoke, or engage in any recreational drug use. Around the middle of January last year, I noticed a gradual appearance of a rash across my body that escalated into a severe illness after approximately a week and a half of its onset. Currently, I find myself in a similar situation, suggesting that this might be a yearly recurring issue. At the moment, the rash isn't itchy, although I've recently had a mild sore throat. Thankfully, I don't have any other signs of illness right now. Last year, when I was unwell, it was an incredibly challenging experience; I felt extremely weak, had a runny nose, persistent cough, sore throat, and even experienced moments of confusion due to fever. The rash did become itchy once I fell ill. During last year's episode, I sought medical advice and underwent several tests while dealing with the rash. All results came back negative, including tests for mononucleosis. The only positive result was for a common cold. Having received vaccinations for measles, mumps, and rubella during my childhood (despite having had those diseases), I'm fairly certain this isn't related to any of them, and I believe I tested negative for those as well last year. Any insights or advice would be greatly appreciated! Thank you from a financially struggling college student!

ArthritisLupusCOPD
Male25-34
1 hour ago