OpenHealth Q&A

Get answered by medical professionals

Concerns Regarding Potential Polycythemia Vera Diagnosis

6/28/2025, 6:50:22 AMMale25-34

25-year-old male | Occasional smoker | No significant health problems I find myself in a complicated situation with conflicting opinions from various healthcare professionals regarding my potential diagnosis. In January, my complete blood count (CBC) displayed the following results: - Hemoglobin (HGB): 17 - Hematocrit (HCT): 50 I visited a hematologist (referred to as Hem-1) who recommended that I undergo testing, including an erythropoietin (EPO) assessment and a myeloproliferative neoplasm (MPN) reflex panel. The results were as follows: - EPO level: 6.6 - MPN panel: All tests returned negative for the mutations tested (Jak2 V617F, Exon 12, CALR, MPL, BCR/ABL1). Hem-1 advised me not to worry excessively and suggested donating one unit of blood, with plans to revisit around late June with updated results. Yesterday, I received my latest results, which indicated: - Hemoglobin: 16.2 - Hematocrit: 48.3 Although I intended to discuss these findings with Hem-1, he was unavailable, so I saw another hematologist (Hem-2) who presented an intriguing interpretation of my situation. Hem-2 explained that while I do not exhibit signs of MPNs, my normal EPO level suggests that secondary polycythemia can be excluded (since EPO would typically be elevated in such cases). He concluded that my condition might signify a primary variant of polycythemia vera (PV). Additionally, I noted that before these recent events, my blood work from 2021 showed values of Hemoglobin: 16.8 and Hematocrit: 49. This raises a question: if I indeed have PV, why have my levels not escalated over the past two years? Furthermore, can an EPO level of 6.6 genuinely rule out smoking as a contributing factor to my blood counts? I would appreciate any insights into my situation!

DiabetesCOPDEndocrinology

Answers (1)

Cony

6/28/2025, 6:50:43 AM

OpenHealth AI

Your situation regarding the potential diagnosis of polycythemia vera (PV) can understandably feel overwhelming, especially with the different interpretations from various healthcare professionals. It's important to focus on the key points and clarify what steps you can take next.

Main Points:

  1. Your latest blood tests show stable hemoglobin and hematocrit levels, which is encouraging.
  2. The normal erythropoietin (EPO) level supports the conclusion that secondary causes of polycythemia are less likely, though smoking can be a contributing factor.
  3. The current lack of significant escalation in your blood counts over the past two years raises questions about the nature of your condition, whether PV or another issue.

Explanation:

  • Erythropoietin and Polycythemia: EPO is a hormone that stimulates red blood cell production. Elevated levels often indicate that your body is responding to low oxygen levels (like from smoking or other health conditions). A normal level typically suggests primary causes, such as PV, rather than secondary causes like smoking.
  • Primary vs. Secondary Polycythemia: Primary PV is a condition where your bone marrow produces too many red blood cells without a compensatory mechanism (like low oxygen). In secondary polycythemia, levels are elevated due to external factors (e.g., chronic hypoxia from smoking or other diseases).
  • Stability of Levels: The stability of your hemoglobin and hematocrit values over two years, even in the context of a suspected primary PV, is atypical for what would usually be expected if the disease were progressing. This could suggest your body has reached a sort of equilibrium.

Next Steps:

  1. Monitor Symptoms: Keep an eye out for any symptoms of polycythemia vera, such as headaches, dizziness, visual disturbances, or high blood pressure. Tracking these can provide valuable information for your next appointment.

  2. Continued Communication with Hematologists: Continue discussing your concerns openly with both Hem-1 and Hem-2 when you see them next. Express your questions about the lack of progression in your blood levels and how smoking may be influencing your condition.

  3. Lifestyle Adjustments: If you're an occasional smoker, consider reducing or quitting smoking altogether, as this can improve overall health and potentially influence your blood cell counts. If you need support or resources to quit, there are many programs and tools available.

  4. Regular Monitoring: Follow up on regular blood tests as recommended, and ensure you keep track of any changes in your health.

  5. Consider a Multidisciplinary Approach: If you continue to feel uncertain or unsettled by the conflicting opinions, speaking with another specialist or a second hematologist may provide further clarity.

Your health is your top priority, and while conflicting opinions can be confusing, staying informed and proactive will help you navigate your diagnosis effectively. Let me know if you have any more questions or need further clarification!

Related Questions

Experiencing Heart Palpitations and Breathlessness?

I’m a 30-year-old male residing in the US, weighing around 190 pounds and generally maintaining good fitness levels. Lately, I have been facing troubling symptoms such as irregular heartbeats—specifically, intermittent pauses and a fluttering sensation in my chest. There are moments when I experience a sudden sinking feeling, and at times, I find it difficult to catch my breath or take a deep inhale. These episodes are significantly disrupting my daily activities and exercise regimens, leading me to suspect that something might be wrong with my heart. Consequently, I consulted a cardiologist, during which I underwent a stress test—although it was uneventful at that moment—along with an EKG and a Holter monitor. The Holter monitor, which I wore for approximately 4 to 5 days, recorded numerous instances of my heart’s irregular beats. Although I can interpret parts of the report where the irregularities are noted, the doctors assured me that everything appeared to be normal and suggested that stress or anxiety might be the culprits. I began taking buspirone; however, I still do not feel quite right. I frequently find myself in search of a deep breath and often experience lightheadedness and mental fog. I'm uncertain about my next steps in seeking relief from these troubling symptoms.

COPDInternal MedicineEndocrinology
Male25-34
21 minutes ago

What are the odds of my father recovering from hospitalization?

My father, a 70-year-old male weighing 210 pounds and standing 5'9" tall, has a complex medical history that includes a heart attack, diabetes, acute kidney issues, and Stage 4 prostate cancer. Additionally, he has suffered multiple fractures since his youth, largely due to his involvement in motocross. Today, he was admitted to the hospital because he experienced an overwhelming urge to urinate but couldn't do so. Despite undergoing multiple ultrasounds of his bladder, the results showed nothing. He continues to express kidney discomfort along with the persistent need to relieve himself. Upon his arrival at the emergency room, his blood pressure was alarmingly low at 54/37. Currently, he is being treated in the intensive care unit. Earlier today, his blood sugar levels soared above 500 but have since fluctuated between 150 and 250. To manage his severe blood pressure, they are administering a central catheter with potent medication. However, my primary concern lies with his Troponin levels. I reviewed his medical charts, and it indicates that his Troponin level stands at a distressing 4,300. Understanding that any figure above 1,000 signals a critical situation, I am left wondering how likely it is that my father will recover from this condition. The medical team is still conducting numerous tests, but the elevated Troponin levels diminish my hope significantly.

DiabetesCOPDEndocrinology
Male25-34
1 hour ago

Could It Be a Sinus or Ear Infection?

For the past 11 days, I've been feeling under the weather. While most of my symptoms have diminished and my energy levels have returned to what they usually are, I still find myself somewhat congested. My right ear has been feeling blocked for the past 9 days, whereas my left ear keeps experiencing a popping sensation, followed by moments of muffled hearing. My nasal discharge is clear, but I'm experiencing discomfort in my right sinus area and the upper region of my teeth—exactly where my ear is persistently blocked. I’ve never dealt with this level of ear congestion due to a cold, so I'm uncertain about how long it will linger. Having encountered sinus infections before, the pain is causing me some concern. I’m feeling quite anxious for this to resolve quickly as I am in the process of moving and plan to embark on a cross-country drive next week. The thought of my condition worsening is distressing. I'm at a loss regarding what steps to take next.

AsthmaCOPDInternal Medicine
Male25-34
1 hour ago

Pain in the Tongue: Seeking Advice

A 25-year-old woman, standing at 5 feet 6 to 7 inches and weighing 242 pounds, is currently on a medication regimen that includes Zoloft (200mg), guanfacine (2mg), and Adderall (20mg) taken only on weekdays. She also uses hydroxyzine (1-10mg) as needed for anxiety, but has only taken it a couple of times over the last six months. In addition, she vapes and abstains from cigarettes, although her alcohol consumption is significant. She has not been using any pain relief medications for her current complaints. Due to her previous dental problems, it’s noteworthy that she has a menthol allergy. Previously, she had two chipped teeth that would irritate her tongue, leading to discomfort. After removing those teeth back in April, the associated bump on her tongue disappeared. However, she recently experienced increased pain, which she described as feeling like a small section of her tongue is absent. The discomfort has a burning sensation, particularly when she touches the roof of her mouth, and has intensified since returning home from work. Currently, she rates her pain level at a 6 out of 10, yet it surged to an 8 after consuming a mild meal (chili dogs, made sure nothing was spicy or hard) and chewing carefully, which made eating and speaking difficult. She finds it hard to sleep due to the pain, which she likens to the sensation of pressing or poking a bruise. Having the opportunity to consult with a third-year medical resident at her workplace—a doctor's office—she was told that her tongue appears to be in a healing state but to monitor any worsening of the condition. She feels that the situation has actually deteriorated. Now, she is contemplating whether to visit urgent care or wait until her doctor’s appointment on Monday, on her day off. Appreciating any advice, she wishes everyone a great weekend!

Multiple SclerosisCOPDInternal Medicine
Male25-34
2 hours ago

Assistance Needed to Diagnose Knee Infection

I am seeking advice regarding a condition affecting my knee. Initially, I suspected it might be an ingrown hair, but I’m uncertain. Lately, when I stand up after sitting for a while, I experience a throbbing sensation. Just two days ago, I was training despite the discomfort, but yesterday I found myself unable to participate in my game. At this point, running is out of the question; I can only manage to limp. Currently, I have applied magnoplasm to the area, but the swelling is noticeably greater compared to my right knee. I will respond to any feedback as quickly as possible.

ArthritisCOPDInternal Medicine
Male25-34
2 hours ago