Navigating Alternative Medicine Choices for My Mother With Lupus
My mother, aged 55, has been living with lupus for the past 15 years. Despite previous attempts at medication that resulted in allergic reactions, she currently takes no pharmaceutical treatments. Recently, she has decided to visit a naturopathic practitioner for a food sensitivity assessment, a test her general practitioner declined to conduct, and honestly, I can see why after discussing it with her further. I am seeking resources that might assist her as she ventures deeper into the realm of alternative medicine. To illustrate, she has recently taken to reading Dr. Gundry’s book about Leaky Gut for a second time and is an avid listener of his podcast. In the past, we even used colloidal silver as a nightly ritual during our childhood. My mother is convinced that lectins are worsening her lupus symptoms. While I understand her belief, I recognize that it stems from a perspective that may not rely on empirical evidence. Yet, I also have concerns about how her choices might affect her condition. She is certainly knowledgeable about nutrition and has made dietary adjustments in response to her lupus flare-ups. The challenge is that a multitude of foods seem to provoke her inflammation, leading to discomfort, irritation, and redness. Her past experiences with healthcare professionals have not been encouraging. I have witnessed how some doctors have dismissed her concerns, mistakenly believing that generalized advice like “eat more fruits and veggies” and “avoid nightshades” would be sufficient. In my exploration of her situation, I initially thought that mentioning the naturopath’s reliance on homeopathy would lead her to reconsider. Surprisingly, she argued against skepticism, urging me to “give him a chance” as she believed he employed other medicinal practices as well. The crux of the matter is that my mother struggles to differentiate between credible sources and those that should be disregarded. Is there a way for me to provide some guidance here? I wonder if there's a book or resource that could subtly encourage her to rethink her association with this homeopath without being too conspicuous about it.
Answers (1)
6/26/2025, 1:50:36 AM
OpenHealth AI
Navigating alternative medicine choices for someone with lupus can be challenging, especially when there is a mix of belief systems and medical backgrounds involved. Here’s a concise summary followed by a plain language explanation and actionable steps for supporting your mother.
Summary:
Your mother's interest in alternative medicine and diet may stem from her experiences with traditional healthcare, but it's important to approach these choices with critical thinking. Fostering her ability to discern credible sources is crucial. Encourage her to explore evidence-based resources about lupus management while also validating her experiences and concerns.
Explanation:
Your mother's lupus, an autoimmune condition, can indeed lead to a range of symptoms that may be exacerbated or alleviated by diet. However, while dietary changes can be helpful, it’s essential to ground these changes in scientifically supported practices. Books and sources that promote critical evaluations of treatments—especially those that lack strong scientific backing, like some claims around homeopathy—can provide balance.
Given her interest in alternative views, she might find the following points helpful:
-
Understanding Medical Claims:
- Help her recognize the difference between anecdotal evidence (personal stories) and scientific evidence (studies published in peer-reviewed journals).
-
Listening to Multiple Perspectives:
- Encourage her to read widely, including perspectives that both support and question alternative methods. This can deepen her understanding and help her make informed choices.
Actionable Steps:
-
Provide a Resource: Consider sharing "The Science and Fine Art of Food and Nutrition" by holistic health expert Arnold Ehret. This book discusses the relationship between diet and health while emphasizing the importance of scientific evidence. You could present it as a way to broaden the discussion around diet that complements her interests.
-
Suggest a Nutritionist with Lupus Expertise: Instead of a naturopathic practitioner, you might suggest she consult with a registered dietitian who specializes in autoimmune conditions. They can provide evidence-based dietary recommendations tailored for lupus management.
-
Discuss Evidence-Based Platforms: Introduce her to resources like the Lupus Foundation of America, which provides guidelines and evidence-based support concerning dietary changes and other lifestyle choices that may affect lupus.
-
Encourage Open Discussion: Have a candid conversation with your mother about her treatment choices, expressing your concerns gently and with empathy. Emphasize your desire for her to find what works best for her health while being supported by reliable medical advice.
-
Tracking Symptoms: Encourage her to maintain a food diary to track her symptoms alongside her diet. This might help her identify true triggers while providing data that could be discussed with healthcare professionals.
By offering support and reliable information, you can help your mother feel empowered and informed while navigating her health journey. Let me know if you need additional resources or specific examples!
Related Questions
Experiencing Dizziness
Greetings, I’m a 49-year-old Caucasian female, measuring 165 cm and weighing 66 kg. I don’t engage in smoking or consuming alcoholic beverages. Currently, I'm prescribed thyroid medication at doses of 0.85/0.88, as well as 2.5 mg of bisoprolol. Occasionally, I take antacids or pantoprazole for my digestive health. I have been diagnosed with Hashimoto's thyroiditis and GERD, and I have white matter hyperintensities noted in my recent MRI, likely stemming from migraines. Right now, I’m feeling anxious as I await the results from my latest MRI scan. Recently, I completed cardiology assessments, including a treadmill stress test and an echocardiogram, both of which returned normal results. I do have mitral valve prolapse accompanied by mild regurgitation, and I continue to take levothyroxine along with bisoprolol. Earlier today, while I was drinking decaf coffee, I stood up abruptly and was suddenly hit by a wave of dizziness, which made me feel as if I might faint. I quickly sat back down, and the sensation subsided. My daughter mentioned that my face flushed during the incident, but the color returned once I was seated again. I’m curious to hear any insights or suggestions about what could be happening.
Concerns About My Tonsils
I'm a 26-year-old male, standing at 6'5" and weighing 200 lbs. Around six weeks prior, I was diagnosed with strep throat and completed a ten-day regimen of penicillin. Shortly after recovering, I developed a mild cough that persisted for about two weeks. For the past month, however, I've noticed that my tonsils seem to show signs of a minor infection. Having dealt with tonsil stones before, I'm aware of the distinct differences in appearance. A week ago, I visited urgent care where they performed a strep test that returned negative results. The healthcare professionals indicated it was probably a viral infection. Aside from the appearance of my tonsils, I don't experience any additional symptoms. Occasionally, I feel a dryness in my throat while swallowing, which could be more accurately described as a mild irritation in my tonsils. I do not have a fever, cough, or any other issues. What troubles me is that my tonsils have appeared this way for an entire month. How long might this condition take to resolve? Should I consider seeking another round of antibiotics?
Curious Condition with No Odor
I am a 54-year-old male residing in Australia, weighing 95 kilograms and standing at 6 feet tall. For approximately a year, I have been experiencing a recurring issue that has recently intensified. Daily, I notice a crumbly, cheese-like substance accumulating beneath the glans of my penis. Despite maintaining a consistent cleaning routine, the situation does not improve. Notably, there is no unpleasant odor associated with this substance, which appears white in color. To provide some context, my penis is relatively small when flaccid but exceeds average size when erect, resulting in considerable loose skin. I'm seeking advice on what this might indicate.
Could My H. pylori Infection Be Returning?
Greetings! I'm a 17-year-old female, standing at 5'4" and weighing 113 pounds. I come from a Mexican family that has an aversion to seeking medical help for reasons that escape me. Back in November 2024, after losing 10 pounds and experiencing daily vomiting and persistent nausea for five months, my parents reluctantly agreed to take me to the doctor for evaluation. I was diagnosed with H. pylori infection and gastritis. Following this, I underwent treatment with antibiotics and adhered to a specific diet, which effectively resolved the infection, as confirmed by a negative test in March. However, I continued to deal with gastritis symptoms. Fast forward to May 2025; after a trip to Mexico where the food hygiene was questionable, I returned home on May 20th only to find myself suffering from diarrhea that lasted for ten days. Now, a month later, I’m plagued by severe abdominal pain, bloating, intermittent vomiting, constant nausea, and a significant loss of appetite. Could it be that my H. pylori has returned?
Elevated AST Levels in My Son
Subject: Male, aged 4.5 years, weight 16.5 kg, height 105 cm, typically healthy but experiencing elevated AST levels. In April, I took my son for a blood test due to his fatigue. The results indicated anemia with low iron levels, and his AST was slightly elevated at 40 (the normal upper limit is 35). At the time, he was recovering from a virus and had been coughing persistently for several weeks, which I attributed to the elevated enzyme. Fortunately, the other liver function tests and blood counts appeared normal (aside from the anticipated low iron). This week, I had him tested again and the AST level has risen to 44. Interestingly, he was very active just the day prior, participating in a soccer match and trampoline activities. While I have some concerns, my general practitioner doesn't seem overly alarmed. My son appears to be healthy overall, although he does have a minor issue with a slightly inward-turned femur that is being managed with physical therapy. I'm scheduled to see a pediatric specialist in a couple of weeks. Has anyone else dealt with similar AST level concerns in their children?