Evaluating a PCL Injury in a 26-Year-Old: Complete Rupture or High-Grade Partial Tear?
Hello everyone! I’m a 26-year-old male, standing at approximately 180 cm tall and weighing around 78 kg. I do not smoke, take any medications, and have no notable medical history. Four weeks ago, I sustained an injury to my left knee during a motorcycle accident, where there was a direct impact that likely resulted in posterior tibial translation. An MRI was performed a week following the incident. The radiologist’s interpretation indicated a complete rupture of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), but I remain skeptical about this conclusion. Currently, I experience very little discomfort and haven’t noticed any instability while using a dynamic PCL brace for the last three weeks. My ability to walk appears unaffected. Upon reviewing the MRI images, the ligament still seems intact and properly aligned, with no significant retraction visible. Is it possible that what I have is a high-grade partial tear instead of a complete rupture? I would greatly value any insights you might have regarding the MRI findings. Thank you!
Answers (1)
6/18/2025, 11:30:58 PM
OpenHealth AI
It sounds like you're in a challenging situation with your knee injury, and it's completely understandable to seek clarity on your diagnosis. Let's break down the information regarding your PCL injury and the implications of the MRI findings.
Main Points:
- Your MRI indicated a complete PCL rupture, but your symptoms do not seem to align with this conclusion.
- There is a chance that you could have a high-grade partial tear instead.
Explanation:
The posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) plays a crucial role in stabilizing the knee. A complete rupture usually leads to significant instability, which often correlates with pain and changes in mobility. Since you're able to walk without issues and have limited discomfort, it raises valid questions about the severity of your injury.
MRI interpretation can sometimes be nuanced, and the evaluation of the ligament's integrity can vary between observers. A high-grade partial tear might exhibit some abnormality on MRI, but not the complete disruption seen with a full rupture. Variability in MRI findings can stem from the quality of the imaging, the technique used, and the radiologist's experience.
Next Steps:
-
Continue Using Your Brace: Keep using the dynamic PCL brace as it provides support and can help manage any potential instability while you recover.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Pay attention to any changes in your knee, including increases in pain, swelling, or instability. If things change, take note of the specific circumstances.
-
Seek a Second Opinion: If you're still uncertain about the diagnosis, consider asking another orthopedic specialist for their interpretation of your MRI and symptoms. They might provide further insight or suggest additional imaging or tests.
-
Rehabilitation Exercises: Engage in knee-strengthening exercises recommended for PCL injuries to maintain range of motion and strength, unless specifically advised against by a healthcare provider.
-
Follow-Up MRI: If indicated by a specialist, a follow-up MRI after a few months might help to evaluate any changes in the ligament as you heal.
Taking these steps can help assure that your knee healing is on track. It's great that you're actively participating in your recovery process. Please keep track of your progress and don't hesitate to seek further help if you need it.
Related Questions
Understanding Vestibular Paroxysmia
An ear, nose, and throat specialist has labeled my condition as vestibular migraine; however, I’m uncertain if that truly captures what I’m experiencing. My situation lacks the typical headache associated with migraines, and the bouts of dizziness are incredibly brief—lasting only a second or two, yet they occur multiple times each hour. I underwent an MRI due to experiencing pulsatile tinnitus and was informed that an artery is situated near my eardrum. Interestingly, I managed to lose 95 pounds, which coincided with the disappearance of both the pulsatile tinnitus and dizziness, though not necessarily at the same time. Unfortunately, over the past week, I have started to notice a return of the fleeting dizziness (or a feeling of imbalance), and for several weeks now, the pulsatile tinnitus has also resurfaced. What are your thoughts on this situation?
Is Leg Swelling Typical for a 22-Year-Old Male?
I've observed that my legs tend to swell significantly after I've been on my feet for extended stretches during work. The swelling appears to diminish once I remove my socks, yet it still strikes me as unusual.
Unexplained Illness or Just Weight Gain?
At the age of 41, I have been grappling with numerous health issues that seem to have intensified following the birth of my first child when I was 38. Over the past three weeks, I've noticed significant swelling in my lymph nodes, not only in my neck and beneath my collarbone but also at the back and sides of my head, in both armpits, and in my groin. These areas have become notably enlarged and hard, accompanied by discomfort. I often wake up in a sweat nearly every night, and my joints ache persistently. Additionally, I experience sharp, stabbing sensations in my breasts, as well as discomfort resembling pain in both kidneys. An imaging scan conducted last year revealed that I have cysts on my left kidney and a stone in my right. Specifically, one of the cysts on the left measured 3.8 x 4.6 cm. Furthermore, I have been diagnosed with mild fatty liver disease. Just last week, I underwent non-fasting blood tests and received the results, which I would appreciate any insights on. I am aware of my obesity, weighing between 210 to 220 pounds at a height of 5'3". I do not consume alcohol, vape moderately, and do not use any illegal substances. The only medication I take is Effexor; otherwise, my medications consist primarily of over-the-counter allergy treatments and a substantial amount of Advil and Aleve.
Unexpected Onset of Madelung Deformity: A Personal Account
About four years ago, I unexpectedly developed Madelung deformity in both of my wrists. Now, at 30 years old, I reflect on the series of events leading up to this. Initially, I was struggling with bone pain, primarily around the thoracic region of my spine, accompanied by intermittent ulnar numbness in my arms. In my quest for answers, I consulted various specialists regarding my thoracic spine issues. Ultimately, I was diagnosed with epidural lipomatosis and arthritis in that area. Unfortunately, amid my frustrations, I neglected to mention my wrist issues. As a dedicated gym enthusiast, the diagnosis has been particularly challenging, as I can no longer engage in bench pressing or any activities that place pressure on my wrists. Interestingly, I did not experience any wrist deformities or pain during my childhood, even while participating in various sports such as football and Brazilian jiu-jitsu. Recently, however, I have noticed an increase in discomfort; shifting my wrists has become a necessity for relief. I’m curious to know what might have led to the emergence of these symptoms in an adult like me. Any insights would be greatly appreciated!
Persistent Nasal Discomfort and Ear Pain Concerns
I am a 26-year-old female, weighing 120 lbs and standing 5 feet 1 inch tall. I do not consume drugs or alcohol and am a former smoker. Currently, I am taking 40 mg of Strattera for attention-related issues. Last summer, I experienced a sinus infection and was prescribed antibiotics, which alleviated the immediate symptoms; however, the problem seems to have lingered. I now frequently suffer from a runny nose that is accompanied by an unpleasant odor, sinus-related headaches, and persistent tinnitus. During my visit to the doctor, we tried nasal steroid treatments alongside a prednisone regimen, but I had to discontinue the latter midway due to experiencing chest pains. Despite being on the nasal steroids for six weeks, I saw no improvement. I was referred to an ear, nose, and throat specialist, but later they contacted me saying that my primary physician could manage my condition. Currently, I feel perplexed because it has been over a year since these issues began, and my ear pain has intensified recently. I have just completed another round of amoxicillin due to noticeable redness in my ear. I am seeking advice on what this could indicate or what steps I should take next, especially since the ENT turned down my referral from my primary care doctor. My doctor mentioned that they would likely just restart the steroid treatment if I were seen by the ENT anyway.