Understanding the Hazards of Dialysis
Greetings, I would like to share a bit about my mother. She is 63 years old and received a kidney transplant nine years ago, in August 2016, from a donor who had passed away. Recently, 41 days ago, she faced a health crisis that led to her hospitalization due to breathing difficulties and confusion. The diagnosis revealed a series of serious conditions, including pleural effusion, congestive heart failure, acute kidney injury, pneumonia, and a urinary tract infection. She was quickly transferred to the intensive care unit. After undergoing a thoracentesis and treatment with Lasix, her condition improved, allowing her to leave the ICU. On May 15, doctors restarted her dialysis in an effort to alleviate the fluid buildup in her body. However, on May 22, the nephrologist decided to remove the dialysis line and halt the procedure. This decision was contested by her pulmonologist, who expressed worries about the potential reaccumulation of fluid around her lungs. By June 14, her condition worsened as the fluid returned, necessitating her readmission to intensive care. On June 16, after a period of waiting, she was placed on dialysis once more, and another thoracentesis was performed by the intensivist. Despite sedation, she experienced a significant decrease in her respiratory rate, which eventually led to intubation. As of June 18, she remains on a ventilator. On the 15th, I reached out for clarification regarding the delay in resuming dialysis and learned from a nurse that they aim to maximize kidney function for as long as possible since dialysis can be debilitating, prioritizing the longevity of the transplanted kidney. There appears to be a conflict between the pulmonologist and the nephrologist regarding her treatment. I am beginning to feel that the nephrologist may have been negligent, placing the preservation of my mother’s kidney above her overall health and safety. I am not seeking legal advice concerning malpractice; rather, I would appreciate insights from anyone familiar with the standards of care in nephrology. Should the nephrologist have opted to continue dialysis sooner? My mother was on dialysis for nine years prior to her transplant, and I find myself overwhelmed with anger and concern during this difficult time.
Answers (1)
6/18/2025, 11:10:53 AM
OpenHealth AI
I'm truly sorry to hear about your mother's health struggles; it’s understandable to feel overwhelmed and concerned during such a challenging time. It’s important to acknowledge the emotional weight of managing complex medical situations like this. Let’s address your questions regarding the treatment decisions surrounding her dialysis and offer some clarity.
Main Points:
- Dialysis is often necessary for maintaining health in patients with kidney issues, particularly post-transplant.
- The timing of reinitiating dialysis can depend on various factors including kidney function, fluid status, and overall health.
- Treatment plans can sometimes lead to conflicts among specialists based on differing priorities for a patient’s health.
Explanation: When someone with a kidney transplant begins to experience issues like acute kidney injury, especially following a serious condition, doctors may weigh the risks and benefits of restarting dialysis. Dialysis can indeed be taxing on the body, particularly for someone who has had a transplant, as it can affect kidney function long-term. Nephrologists often aim to preserve remaining kidney function, which can be critical for a transplanted kidney. This could explain the nephrologist's decision to delay dialysis when her condition was assessed.
The conflict between her pulmonologist and nephrologist is not uncommon, especially in complex cases involving multiple organ systems. Each specialist's focus—lung health versus kidney preservation—can shape their recommendations.
Next Steps:
-
Open Communication: If you haven’t already, ask to have a family meeting with her healthcare team to discuss all ongoing treatments and the reasoning behind them. Understanding the doctors' perspectives can help validate your feelings and guide you on the directions they believe are best.
-
Clarification of Priorities: Inquire how the treatment aligns with your mother's overall health needs versus just the kidney health. This might help ease your concerns about the priorities at play.
-
Advocate for Support: If possible, request the involvement of a palliative care specialist who can help balance care goals and navigate the emotional aspects of her treatment. They often provide insights when multiple specializations are involved.
-
Monitor and Document: Keep a record of her symptoms, treatment decisions, and any changes in her condition. This can be invaluable information when discussing her care with the team.
-
Seek Emotional Support: This situation is incredibly stressful. Consider accessing support groups for family members of patients with similar conditions, or reaching out to a mental health professional to discuss your feelings.
Your feelings of anger and concern are valid, and it’s important to allow yourself space to process them during this tough time. Please remember, you're not alone, and balancing the perspectives of her care team can lead to better outcomes.
Related Questions
Experiencing a Manic Episode Despite Medication: Is This Typical?
Age: 38 Gender: Male Height: 6’5” Weight: 225 lbs Ethnicity: Caucasian Duration of Symptoms: I began experiencing manic symptoms in November. I have a bipolar diagnosis that dates back to when I was 16 years old. Location: Pennsylvania Pre-existing Health Conditions: Diagnosed with Bipolar 1, ADHD, anxiety, and an eating disorder. Current Medications: Currently prescribed include: Lurasidone HCl 60 mg tablets, Doxepin HCl 6 mg tablets, Lithium 300 mg, Lisdexamfetamine 70 mg, Zolpidem 12.5 mg controlled-release, Pregabalin 225 mg, Jardiance 10 mg, Lisinopril 10 mg, Naltrexone 50 mg, Mounjaro 15 mg/0.5 mL solution, and Topiramate ER 200 mg, along with Atorvastatin 20 mg. I hope I’ve followed the guidelines for this post. I’m currently enduring a manic episode. It began with symptoms such as restlessness, excessive irritability, racing thoughts, impulsive spending, and rapid speech. Now, I’m facing the aftermath with symptoms of profound depression, thoughts of self-harm, very low energy, and ongoing irritability. I'm quite disheartened as my medication regimen seems ineffective in preventing this episode. Should I reach out to my physician to discuss adjusting my medication or increasing the dosage? It feels like my lithium intake is relatively low at 300 mg taken three times daily. Is it frequent for someone to experience a manic episode while on multiple types of medication, particularly a combination like lithium, Lurasidone, and Doxepin? The Lisdexamfetamine I’m taking is aimed at managing ADHD and my eating issues. Any advice or insights would be immensely valuable. Thank you!
Seeking Guidance for Coping with Eating Disorder Triggers and Thoughts
I'm an 18-year-old female, weighing around 120 lbs and standing at 5 feet 4 inches tall. Over the past few months, I’ve been navigating the transition of living independently while pursuing my college education, making strides to establish healthier routines for myself. Having been a competitive athlete throughout my formative years, I grew up in an environment where maintaining a fit and slender physique was intensely stressed. However, upon entering college, my exercise regimen dwindled, leading me to gain about 5 to 7 pounds. This change was a source of anxiety for me, and following a somewhat offhand remark from my mother regarding my weight, I felt compelled to regain control. Regrettably, my response wasn't the healthiest. I started to severely limit my intake, sometimes going as long as 3 to 5 days subsisting on just gum, water, and the occasional energy drink. There was a sense of pride in my ability to endure such restrictions, and I experienced an unsettling exhilaration from the emptiness in my stomach. However, when I finally succumbed to the urge to eat, I would then purge. Initially, it was an isolated incident, but it soon regrettably escalated into a more frequent occurrence over the next month or so. I found myself meticulously tracking my calorie intake, and despite significant restrictions on certain days, I would often purge any small healthy meals I managed to consume because I despised the sensation of fullness. I began gravitating towards all-zero-sugar and low-calorie options, steering clear of foods I once cherished. To this day, I still experience apprehension surrounding specific dishes that used to bring me joy. After recognizing my behaviors, my roommate intervened, suggesting healthier methods to alter my weight, such as embracing regular workouts. Taking her advice to heart, I dedicated myself to making a change. I’ve done reasonably well since then, only reverting once or twice following that realization. I started engaging in exercise more frequently while prioritizing balanced meals and sufficient sleep, resulting in a notable improvement in my overall happiness. Upon returning to college after the winter break, I set new fitness objectives for myself. Despite never being overweight, my goal was to shed additional pounds and enhance muscle tone, prompting an increase in my workout frequency. Understanding the necessity of a caloric deficit for weight loss, I began eating less. My current practice involves loosely estimating my calorie intake from Monday to Thursday with an aim of keeping it below 1000. I also strive to burn over 1000 calories during those weekdays, reducing my expectations to at least 500 calories burned on weekends. My routine typically includes strength training 5 to 6 times a week, along with around two hours of incline walking on the treadmill and outdoor distance walks. On the weekends, I don’t track my calories explicitly; I try to eat mindfully but find myself skipping meals occasionally when I feel I’ve overindulged. I treat myself to sweets during the weekends, but I have developed a fear of certain foods I used to enjoy, such as pasta, avocados, peanut butter, and even whole bananas, opting instead for a third of a banana for breakfast throughout the weekdays. I've successfully lost a considerable amount of weight and feel pleased with my progress. Nevertheless, I frequently experience stomach discomfort and bloating, often leading me to believe I might feel better when I don’t eat rather than when I do. My current approach includes keeping my caloric intake lower for four days while designating the remaining three days as ‘refueling’ days to maintain a balance. Although this routine has yielded positive mental and physical results, I am now dealing with injuries and am concerned about needing to limit my walking routine to allow my ankle time to heal, as I want to avoid prolonged setbacks due to tendonitis. I recognize this regime has significantly aided my mental well-being and helped manage my anxiety regarding food. Last month, for instance, I logged 229 miles of walking and burned over 30,000 active calories according to my Apple Watch. While I appreciate the structure I’ve established, I’m uncertain about how to proceed with my injury and I am apprehensive about repeating the behaviors I experienced in the past. Does anyone have suggestions or alternatives I could incorporate during my recovery while still staying active? Any insights or advice would be greatly appreciated! Thank you!
Seeking Medical Advice for Hormonal and Nervous System Symptoms Post-Medication
Greetings everyone, I'm reaching out on behalf of my wife, who doesn't participate in Reddit, to seek advice on what kind of medical professional she should consult regarding her health issues after halting her medications and supplements. Here are some details about her: - Age: 33 years - Gender: Female - Height: Approximately 5 feet 2 inches - Weight: Roughly 100 pounds - Country: United States - Tobacco Use: None - Alcohol Consumption: None - Recreational Drug Use: Discontinued THC gummies 12 weeks ago (used them 1-3 times a week for a year) - Current Medications: None - Past Medications/Supplements: - Concerta for ADHD (discontinued around 8 weeks ago after 15 years of use) - Vitex (chasteberry) at a dosage of 500–600 mg daily for about 1 year (stopped approximately 6 weeks ago) - "Adrenal support" supplements (adaptogenic/cortisol-focused, which have now been ceased) Her main concerns have arisen over recent weeks, displaying a range of physical symptoms that do not align perfectly with one specific issue: - Sleep disturbances, particularly waking up early feeling restless and with adrenaline surges - A sense of discomfort in her nervous system during the evening, without any accompanying anxious thoughts - Infrequent heart rate awareness and a jittery sensation - Periods of brain fog paired with challenges in focusing - Experiencing emotional numbness at times - Symptoms that vary in intensity with her menstrual cycle Regarding assessments conducted thus far: - Routine lab results from her primary care physician (including thyroid tests) came back normal - No known heart conditions - She has no history of anxiety disorders (these feelings do not seem to stem from thought processes) While she does not perceive a significant level of anxiety or stress mentally, she senses a physical imbalance—particularly in relation to sleep and hormonal issues. These symptoms seem to be rooted more in physiology than in psychological factors. We are trying to determine which type of specialist would be best suited for her next steps: - Endocrinologist (for possible hormonal imbalances?) - Psychiatrist (to address medication withdrawal versus potential physiological anxiety?) - Neurologist (to investigate autonomic functions or nervous system issues?) - Provider in functional or integrative medicine - Or perhaps a different specialty altogether I would appreciate insights from anyone, especially those who have dealt with similar health situations after stopping long-term stimulant use or hormone-affecting supplements. What type of medical professional should she consult first, and why? Thank you very much for any support or recommendations you can offer!
Help Needed: Hormonal and Anxiety Struggles
I’m a 36-year-old woman with a history of mental health issues. I smoke and am prescribed propranolol to manage my anxiety. Recently, I sought help for severe PMS symptoms and suspected perimenopause. Blood tests conducted on January 27, 2026, revealed slightly elevated DHEA-S levels and low estrogen. Just three days later, I began experiencing heightened anxiety along with frequent urination. I decided to stop taking Slynd, but this led to an escalation of my anxiety, resulting in constant panic attacks and a racing heart that reached 150 beats per minute. This abrupt change prompted me to discontinue Slynd on January 30, 2026. Despite managing my anxiety, my obsessive-compulsive tendencies worsened, leading to irrational fears about serious health issues like cancer. Five days after stopping Slynd (on February 5, 2026), I coped with tremors in my legs, a racing heart, extreme dryness in my mouth, and an overwhelming urge to urinate, compelling me to go to the emergency room. There, despite my heartbeat being at 150 and an intense panic that felt foreign, it turned out I only had a urinary tract infection. I was given propranolol, which significantly alleviated my symptoms. The EKG came back normal, but they did not perform blood tests. I needed to take propranolol four times to keep the tremors at bay. That night, my sleep was disturbed, and I woke up at 5 AM with the tremors returning along with anxiety. Strangely, I managed to cope without taking more propranolol. Today, I've been feeling some depersonalization and a general sense of unease, accompanied by minor paranoia. However, I managed to keep my panic under control without the medication. The antibiotics have helped reduce my frequent trips to the bathroom. Unfortunately, I woke up at 3 AM to find the tremors returning, along with increased anxiety and elevated heart rate. I can’t seem to control the shaking, which comes in two-second bursts. I’m left wondering if this chaos is a side effect of Slynd or if I am simply spiraling into madness. I have a doctor's appointment scheduled for Monday, but I worry the response will simply attribute everything to stress.
Struggling with Severe Anxiety and Its Consequences
At 24 years old, I face a multitude of mental health challenges, including Autism, ADHD, schizoaffective disorder (bipolar type), PTSD, and OCD. It certainly feels overwhelming at times. Whenever I encounter situations that provoke stress or require me to make choices, I experience an extreme level of anxiety. It’s a sensation that's almost beyond words, akin to a panic attack that stretches on for several days. For instance, after moving to a new apartment, I became exceedingly anxious about whether I could adapt to the sound of traffic. Although this concern seems trivial, it consumed me. For a period of 48 hours, I struggled to breathe and found myself hyperventilating. During this episode, my hallucinations intensified significantly. Each attempt to consume food or water resulted in vomiting, leaving me without any hydration for two days. My girlfriend, deeply worried about my condition, ended up taking me to the emergency room, where I received 2mg of Ativan to help ease my distress. These frightening episodes continue to occur. I often find myself in the grip of intense panic, unable to keep anything down. I've previously fainted due to severe dehydration. Coping with this situation feels almost impossible. Medical professionals hesitate to prescribe Ativan unless I visit the ER because of a past incident where I attempted suicide with the medication. I'm left questioning which of my diagnoses might be driving these acute panic episodes or if it's simply a disastrous combination of all my conditions. I would appreciate any thoughts or advice from those who might understand what I'm going through.