Uncommon Q&A: The Absence of Coughing During Illness
I find myself in a rather peculiar situation and I'm uncertain about how to approach my doctor regarding it. Whenever I fall ill, whether it’s something like COVID-19, strep throat, or bronchitis, I never experience a cough. At 31 years old and as a female, I can't recall the last instance where I coughed as a result of being sick—perhaps during my early teenage years? This has me somewhat worried because I wonder if it's concerning that my cough reflex isn't functioning properly. I would appreciate any thoughts or information on this matter.
Answers (1)
6/17/2025, 9:01:30 AM
OpenHealth AI
It's understandable to feel concerned about your unique experience of not coughing during illness, especially since coughing is a common symptom associated with many respiratory infections. Here's a concise outline on this topic.
Main Points
- Absence of Coughing: It is uncommon but not necessarily concerning that you don't cough when ill. This could be due to different factors such as your immune response, how your body reacts to infections, or even other underlying issues.
- Cough Reflex: The cough reflex can vary from person to person, and not everyone will exhibit all common symptoms of illness.
Explanation
Coughing is a natural reflex that helps clear the airways of irritants and mucus. The lack of a cough during illness can happen due to:
- Individual Variation: Some people's immune systems respond differently to infections. If your body effectively manages the illness without triggering a cough, it might simply reflect how your body works.
- Different Symptoms: Illnesses can manifest through various symptoms. You may experience other symptoms like sore throat, fever, fatigue, or body aches that are less noticeable than coughing.
- Cough Reflex Issues: In rare cases, there may be issues with the nerves or mechanisms responsible for triggering a cough, but these conditions typically present with other notable symptoms.
Next Steps
-
Self-Observation: Keep a record of your symptoms during future illnesses, noting any changes in how you feel and how your body responds. This can provide useful information for future discussions with your doctor.
-
Consult Your Doctor: When you feel ready, bring this observation to your healthcare provider's attention. They can assess if further evaluation of your cough reflex or respiratory health is necessary.
-
Priority Symptoms: Pay attention to other symptoms that may arise—like shortness of breath, chest pain, or changes in how you feel during an illness. If these occur, they would warrant more immediate attention.
Remember, it's okay to seek clarification on any health-related concerns, including your unique experiences with illness. You are not alone in this, and discussing it with a professional can offer peace of mind.
Related Questions
Seeking Guidance for Severe Food Aversion in 15-Month-Old on Propranolol
Greetings everyone, we're currently in a difficult situation with our 15-month-old daughter, and we’d like to connect with other parents or professionals who might have faced similar challenges. **Our Situation:** * Our daughter was born with a **medium-grade infantile hemangioma** at the nape of her neck. Although it’s not life-threatening, it is quite visible and slightly elevated. * Our pediatrician initiated a treatment plan with **Propranolol at 20 mg per day** about three months ago when she was around a year old. Apart from this condition, her health was generally good. * As of June 8, and under doctor guidance, we’ve decreased the dosage to **14 mg daily** (7 mg in the morning and 7 mg in the evening) to monitor any shifts in her behavior. **Observations Since Starting Propranolol:** 1. Our daughter has developed a **severe aversion to food**. Although she was somewhat picky prior, her eating habits have deteriorated significantly. 2. She now **completely rejects all solid foods and liquids**, refusing to be fed by anyone. 3. She relies solely on **breastmilk**, turning down water or juices offered by others. 4. During mealtime, she becomes **very irritable or upset**. Even gentle encouragement to try some cereal or soft foods leads to her total refusal and distress. 5. While she **plays with food** on her own, sometimes even bringing tiny bits to her mouth, any attempt by someone else to feed her results in her shutting down or crying. 6. We took a step back from forcing her to eat for over a week (following advice on rebuilding trust), continuing to offer food without pressure. Unfortunately, there’s been no improvement. 7. **Today, we attempted to reintroduce cereal**, and she rejected it just as she had previously. **Developmental Update:** * Born weighing **2.05 kg**, she is now approximately **7 kg** at 15 months, which is on the lighter side. * She is **not walking by herself yet**, but she can: * Stand alone * Walk with assistance (using a walker or while holding onto furniture) * Cognitively, she appears **alert and engaged**: she responds to her name, says Mama and Baba, laughs, and interacts with others, indicating no apparent cognitive delays. **Our Concerns:** * Could her food aversion be a **conditioned response**? Does she have a developed “fear” of being fed by anyone? * Is it possible that this behavior is a **side effect of Propranolol**? We know that appetite suppression and mood shifts can occur, but her response seems quite severe. * Are we in danger of her experiencing **nutritional deficiencies**, given her refusal of solid foods? * If so, what symptoms should we keep an eye on that might suggest underlying issues? * Should we seek the assistance of a **feeding therapist or child psychologist** at this point? * Is this issue something that improves over time, or do we risk entrenching the behavior the longer it continues? We are located in India and are looking for pediatric feeding specialists, although options are limited in our area. We would greatly appreciate: * Insights from parents who have encountered similar situations * Strategies for breaking this cycle of behavior * Any recommended resources or methods similar to Rowena Bennett’s "Bottle Aversion," even if it’s not directly applicable to our case * Guidance on when to consider **nutritional interventions or vitamin supplementation**. Thank you for taking the time to read this. It has been an incredibly stressful experience for us, and we welcome any advice or encouragement you can provide 🙏
Assessing the Reliability of BMI in Evaluating Anorexia Nervosa Risks
At 20 years of age and standing at a height of 163 cm, I currently weigh approximately 38 kg. After a recent visit to my general practitioner, she assessed my weight and height, calculating a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 14.3. She then communicated her findings in a letter to my psychiatrist, suggesting that hospitalization should be pursued urgently if I do not manage to stabilize my weight. My GP expressed concerns regarding the potential for cardiac arrest, which I find difficult to accept, especially since I feel okay. She measured my blood pressure but did not check my heart rate. Additionally, she ordered a blood test that I should complete unless I end up being hospitalized. I have regular menstrual cycles and am not experiencing any alarming symptoms. My lab results from a month ago, when my weight was 40 kg, were all normal. Currently, I'm taking 40 mg of fluoxetine for depression, and I've noticed an improvement in physical symptoms that I originally attributed to inadequate nutrition, such as chest pressure, fatigue, dizziness, and feeling cold; these have gradually improved alongside my mood. My psychiatrist believes that my GP may have overreacted, considering that my baseline BMI before the onset of my eating disorder was already on the lower end, typically around 17 to 18, with my peak weight being 49 kg. I have been advised that my psychiatrist mishandled the situation, and that I might benefit from switching to a different provider because she dismissed my GP’s concerns, referred to me as a "shrimp" to indicate that I am naturally thin, and did not inquire into my eating behavior. She also downplayed health risks due to my normal lab results. However, I still wonder if my psychiatrist might have a valid point regarding my GP's dramatic approach. So, is my psychiatrist correct that the reactions were exaggerated, or did she indeed handle the matter inappropriately, warranting a change in my medical provider?
Is it a Trapezius Contracture or Cervical Radiculopathy?
Hello! I recently experienced a rather troubling issue after my workout at the gym. I finished my bench press and noticed that I had developed a stiff neck, which made it painful to turn my head—there was a burning sensation that accompanied the movement. It felt like the strain had shifted from my lower back to my neck. I decided to take a break, but the following day, the discomfort had not subsided. I attempted to return to the gym yesterday, as the pain seemed to diminish significantly (except when I turned my head), but I discovered that I was unable to lift any weights due to a considerable weakness in my left arm, making it impossible to perform even basic curls. Today, I visited a doctor who was substituting for my regular physician. He diagnosed me with a trapezius contracture, but I have my doubts because he seemed hurried during the examination. When I researched online, I found little information linking contractures to a decrease in strength. Instead, I encountered references suggesting the possibility of cervical radiculopathy or a pinched nerve as more likely explanations. I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this matter. Can a muscle contracture lead to significant strength loss in just a few days? Thank you for your insights!
Elevated Testosterone Levels
Hello there! I recently underwent hormone testing and some additional evaluations as I'm a trans woman beginning hormone therapy. I have a follow-up appointment with my healthcare provider in approximately two and a half months, and I’m curious about how concerning my results might be in the interim. Here are the levels I received: | **Hormone** | **Level** | **Reference Range** | |--------------------|--------------------|-----------------------------------| | **Testosterone** | **39.0 nmol/L** | 8.64 – 29.0 nmol/L | | **DHEA-S** | **553 µg/dL** | ~80 – 560 µg/dL (varies by lab) | | **Prolactin** | **15.3 µg/L** | 4.0 – 15.2 µg/L | | **Progesterone** | **0.3 µg/L** | ≤ 0.2 µg/L (baseline for AMAB) | | **Estradiol (E2)** | **<25 ng/L** | ≤43 ng/L (baseline for AMAB) | | **LH** | **4.4 u/L** | 1.7 – 8.6 u/L | | **FSH** | **3.4 u/L** | 1.5 – 12.4 u/L | | **TSH** | **0.77 mU/L** | 0.27 – 4.20 mU/L | | **FT4 (Free T4)** | **18.6 pmol/L** | 11.0 – 24.0 pmol/L | | **FT3 (Free T3)** | **4.3–6.7 pmol/L** | | I'm eager to understand more about what these numbers may indicate for my health, especially concerning my testosterone levels. Thank you!
Understanding Low T4 with Normal Thyroid Function: Seeking Insights
Hello everyone, I hope you can help me understand my situation. My T4 levels are consistently low, typically falling between 0.5 and 0.6, while my TSH is on the lower side of normal at around 0.9. Despite these numbers, I experience a noticeably high heart rate, averaging about 99 beats per minute when at rest, alongside an elevated metabolism. Throughout my life, my body mass index has remained on the lower end, around 16 to 17, yet I maintain a high caloric intake of approximately 2,500 calories daily and rely solely on walking for physical activity. Additionally, I tend to have lower blood pressure readings. My healthcare provider reassures me that these readings are within the realm of normal, but it feels perplexing. Are there any specific evaluations I should consider or recommendations you might suggest? Currently, I don’t take any medications aside from a multivitamin. In the past, I've used antidepressants and birth control, but these did not seem to impact my lab results. I'm a non-smoker, and the combination of low BMI without dietary restrictions, low blood pressure, high heart rate, along with my low T4 and fairly low TSH levels have been constants in my life. Notably, all other hormonal tests—including those for sex hormones—return normal results, and I enjoy a regular menstrual cycle.