Understanding Treatment Options for a Complete Medial Meniscus Tear
A nearly 50-year-old woman, who is tall and slim, reports no significant health concerns aside from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and undifferentiated connective tissue disease (UMCTD), for which she takes medications including Plaquenil, Famotidine, and hormone replacement therapy (HRT). About three and a half months ago, she began experiencing discomfort and stiffness in her knee. Her flexibility, typically excellent, was compromised as she could only bend her knee beyond 90 degrees. Despite the pain, she continued taking Celebrex for a month or two and maintained her routine activities, which involve daily hiking and walking her dogs multiple times each day. Additionally, she incorporates stretching and yoga into her routine to enhance her strength during this period of recovery. Notably, she did not suffer a specific injury that triggered the pain. She has not reduced her physical activities; on the contrary, she has gradually increased strength training and stretching exercises. Recently, she jogged twice for around 20 minutes, primarily to evaluate her knee's condition. While she can observe improvements in her range of motion, she still experiences medial pain when attempting to sit in a frog position, and cannot bear weight when sitting on the floor from a heel-to-butt position. Moreover, after over three months of consistent activity, she continues to endure swelling, stiffness, and occasional pain over her kneecap or in the medial area. An attempt to tackle steep inclines made it clear that prolonged downhill walking could pose substantial challenges. Her situation appears to be plateauing. Two orthopedic specialists from the same practice have recommended a partial meniscectomy, noting that they will not be able to ascertain how much of the meniscus needs to be removed until they perform the procedure. They indicated that repairing the meniscus is not an option, especially since it has a high failure rate of about 20% even in younger patients. She acknowledges that recovery from such repairs can be quite challenging. However, she encountered information suggesting that the posterior root should not be excised but rather repaired, as removing it, along with performing a meniscectomy, is akin to doing nothing—potentially exacerbating her condition. Key questions arise: Will undergoing a meniscectomy or partial meniscectomy worsen her situation? Post-surgery, can she maintain or improve her level of activity? Does this procedure inevitably lead to the need for a total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in the future, or could avoiding surgery delay this requirement? Is it accurate that the extent of meniscus removal cannot be determined definitively beforehand? Additionally, she has noted an incidental plica on her MRI and wishes to ensure it remains undisturbed, as she has heard it should not be interfered with.
Answers (1)
3/28/2025, 8:40:48 PM
OpenHealth AI
Based on your detailed description, it seems you are facing significant challenges with a complete medial meniscus tear alongside other health conditions. Here are the key points regarding your situation and potential treatment options:
-
Understanding Meniscectomy: A partial meniscectomy involves removing the damaged part of the meniscus. While this procedure can provide relief from pain and swelling, it's not without risks. If the posterior root is part of the meniscus that gets removed, it may lead to further knee degeneration and might not alleviate long-term wear, potentially accelerating the need for total knee arthroplasty (TKA).
-
Impact on Activity Levels: Post-surgery, improvement in activity levels can vary. Some patients find relief and can return to their routines, while others may experience limitations. Factors such as the extent of the tear, your overall physical condition, and the presence of other joint problems can influence recovery.
-
Future Surgeries: While a meniscectomy does not automatically lead to a TKA, studies suggest that knee surgeries may increase the risk for future procedures, especially if the knee develops osteoarthritis. It's crucial to weigh the potential benefits and data about your specific case before deciding on surgery.
-
Pre-Operative Imaging: You mentioned that the extent of meniscus removal is uncertain until the procedure is underway. This is common; however, a detailed discussion with your orthopedic surgeon about your MRI findings and their implications on the surgery can help clarify expectations.
-
Plica Considerations: Incidental findings like a plica often do not require intervention unless they are symptomatic. Discuss with your surgeon your preference regarding its treatment during a surgical procedure and ensure your concerns are considered.
Next Steps for You:
-
Gather Detailed Information: Before making a decision, request a thorough explanation from your surgeons regarding the risks and benefits of both a partial meniscectomy and leaving the meniscus as is, including implications for future joint health.
-
Seek a Second Opinion: Since you have reservations about the proposed treatment, consider getting a second opinion from a knee specialist, especially one who focuses on sports medicine or has extensive experience with meniscus repairs.
-
Explore Non-Surgical Alternatives: Discuss with your healthcare provider about ongoing non-surgical options like physical therapy, bracing, or injections. These may help alleviate symptoms and improve function, possibly delaying the need for surgery.
-
Monitor Symptoms: Keep tracking your knee symptoms, such as pain levels, swelling, and changes in function, to identify patterns that may inform your decisions about treatment.
-
Prioritize Maintaining Activity: Continue engaging in activities that do not exacerbate your pain, such as low-impact exercises (swimming, cycling) and flexibility training, while avoiding high-impact movements that could worsen the tear.
Remember, this decision should align with your lifestyle, activity goals, and overall health condition. Taking time to consider your options can help you make an informed choice that supports your long-term well-being.
Related Questions
Understanding the Increased Pain in My Foot While Reclining
At 30 years old, I am nearing the five-week mark since undergoing surgery on my metatarsals. I've encountered a troubling issue: I can’t seem to find comfort when lying down, whether it’s with my foot raised or lying flat. My pain level escalates to a severe 10 out of 10, unless my foot is making contact with the floor or I dangle my leg off the side of the bed so that my toes touch the ground. Is this situation typical for someone in my circumstances? Are there any suggestions that might assist me in getting a better night's sleep?
Understanding Possible Seizure Triggers and Recurrence Risks
Health Background: I am a 21-year-old female, standing at 169 cm and weighing 65 kg. Over the past three years, I have been using oral contraceptives. As of this morning, I started taking 25 mcg of levothyroxine along with a weekly vitamin D supplement of 0.266 mg. Recently, I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism and found to have a vitamin D deficiency that I suspect has existed for the last three years. I do not consume alcohol or smoke, and I can confirm I am not pregnant. Two years ago, I experienced a mild concussion. I currently reside in Spain. A couple of months back, in mid-December, I blacked out twice. The second occurrence took place while I was at the doctor’s office after seeking urgent medical care for the initial incident. Following the second episode, I underwent a CT scan and an EKG, both of which returned normal results. Further tests, as directed by my physician, revealed a critical vitamin D deficiency and hypothyroidism; however, he expressed doubt that either of these conditions led to my loss of consciousness. I was then referred to a neurologist, and I am presently awaiting an appointment. Although the waiting period is lengthy, my doctor indicated that I should receive priority for scheduling, although the exact timeframe remains uncertain. The referral document summarized my events, labeling the second episode (which the physician witnessed) as a potential seizure devoid of tonic-clonic movements—a revelation that took me by surprise. After regaining consciousness, I felt extremely disoriented and terrified, struggling to process what was happening. I have no prior history of seizures, epilepsy, or any related conditions, and there is no known family history of these issues. If this indeed was a seizure, what might have triggered it? Additionally, what is the likelihood of experiencing another one? Since that time, I have not had any further incidents, but I have experienced moments where I felt a sense of impending doom, which I managed to overcome. I intend to wait for the neurologist's evaluation, but the uncertainty surrounding a possible neurological condition is quite distressing. Thank you for any insight you can provide!
Persistent Pain in Right Shoulder and Arm After Lifting
Hello, everyone! I’m a 23-year-old male and have been engaged in weightlifting for several years now. Recently, I’ve been struggling with ongoing discomfort in my right shoulder and arm, which I haven’t been able to accurately identify. The pain manifests during particular movements, especially with lateral raises or when my arm is raised to shoulder level while rotating my wrist. Certain pressing and pulling activities can also provoke this discomfort. Rather than feeling sharp, it’s a deep, nagging sensation that sometimes seems localized in the front area of the shoulder or at the biceps tendon, and at other times it feels more like it’s situated between the shoulder and upper arm. Fortunately, there’s no numbness or tingling involved. This issue began while I was working out. I decided to take a break for around two months, but when I returned, the pain persisted. After consulting a physician, I was diagnosed with bicipital tendinitis. Since then, I’ve reduced my upper-body workouts, completely steering clear of shoulder exercises and heavy lifting, and have begun a gentle rehabilitation regimen focusing on external rotations, pendulum movements, and scapular exercises. Despite adhering to this routine for about a week, I haven’t experienced any noticeable improvement. Is it typical for this type of tendon injury to require an extended period for recovery? At what point should I consider diagnostic imaging, such as an ultrasound or MRI? Additionally, are there frequent rehabilitation errors that might impede the healing process? I appreciate your insights in advance!
Understanding EEG Results for My 22-Month-Old Son: Insights Needed
Could someone help clarify this for me? My son, who is just 22 months old, hasn’t started walking yet, becomes tired easily, and has been experiencing behavioral outbursts. He had a febrile seizure in February 2025, followed by another unexplained seizure in April 2025, which led us to consult a neurologist. Since he was 3 months old, he has been receiving therapy from a physical therapist for torticollis. At birth, he spent five days in the NICU due to issues with meconium aspiration. A recent MRI showed normal results, and he also had a follow-up EEG after one conducted in July 2025. The results from this recent EEG were abnormal for a pediatric patient in awake, drowsy, and sleeping states. Notably, there were brief episodes of left frontotemporal delta slowing, which occurred mainly when he was awake and drowsy. There were no signs of epileptiform activity detected. In contrast, the EEG performed back on July 3, 2025, was deemed normal for both awake and drowsy states, again with no evidence of epileptiform irregularities, although it did not capture any sleep data. This examination was prompted by the child's existing history of febrile seizures. Importantly, he is not currently on any anti-seizure medications. The EEG procedure used standard electrode placements per the 10-20 system, conducted a single-lead EKG, and included continuous video monitoring. During the analysis, the background activity was symmetric, indicating some anterior-posterior (AP) organization, with a dominant rhythm of 50-80 microvolts at 7 Hz. His drowsy state was marked by a reduced amount of eye blink activity, less breathing motion interference, and a generalized slowing in theta/delta frequencies. Stage II sleep exhibited spindles and vertex waves patterns. Additionally, there were intermittent bursts of 250-300 microvolts in the left frontotemporal region with semi-rhythmic activity of 2-4 Hz, mostly observed during wakefulness and drowsiness. No definitive epileptiform discharge was noted. Photic stimulation during the test did not elicit a strong response, and hyperventilation was not conducted during this session.
INTENSE Spine Discomfort, Breathing Difficulties, Muscle Twitches, and Sweating
To elaborate on the situation mentioned in the title, I’ve been experiencing unusual muscle twitches and spasms for the past few days, along with some discomfort in my back. However, today, I felt an unexpected sharp pain shoot through my spine, which has left my legs feeling numb and made it impossible for me to sit up straight. Additionally, I’ve been dealing with cold sweats for the last hour and struggling to breathe properly. Perhaps I’m just overanalyzing things and it’s a common occurrence, but the intensity of the pain is overwhelming—it's truly unbearable. I’m shaking quite a bit, and unfortunately, my parents aren’t responding to my attempts to reach them for help. I have a history of a chronic heart condition and arthritis, yet I’ve never experienced pain this severe, especially in my spine. For context, I am nearly 15 years old and female. My current medications include pain relievers, anxiety medication, beta blockers, and some vitamins, though those specifics may not be particularly relevant. I don’t smoke; however, I have tried vaping a few times, which might not matter much, but I thought it was worth mentioning as it was requested.